Lovely news for once! Oxfam £100k
Lovely news for once! Oxfam £100k
Author
Discussion

vescaegg

Original Poster:

30,635 posts

198 months

Oakey

27,984 posts

247 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
That won't even cover the CEO's annual salary.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Oakey said:
That won't even cover the CEO's annual salary.
Are the source for that?

http://society.guardian.co.uk/salarysurvey/table/0...

scenario8

8,008 posts

210 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
I don't understand people's often kneejerk reaction to the concept of professional management of charities (often at rates significantly lower than the open market might suggest is achievable).

My wife works at a professional level for a well known charity. She is paid a good third less than she might command at a plc. Her workplace contains many capable and necessary professionals, none of whom (I am aware) work for free. The third sector would disappear up its own backside very quickly indeed if it couldn't/wasn't allowed by the court of PH to pay for professional management, accountancy, legals, IT support, media...

wormburner

34,587 posts

284 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
scenario8 said:
I don't understand people's often kneejerk reaction to the concept of professional management of charities (often at rates significantly lower than the open market might suggest is achievable).

My wife works at a professional level for a well known charity. She is paid a good third less than she might command at a plc. Her workplace contains many capable and necessary professionals, none of whom (I am aware) work for free. The third sector would disappear up its own backside very quickly indeed if it couldn't/wasn't allowed by the court of PH to pay for professional management, accountancy, legals, IT support, media...
What proportion of the charity money is spent on the goal of the charity? Over 90% good. Under 50% bad. That is the issue.

scenario8

8,008 posts

210 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
There are so many subjective elements to what is part of achieving the goal, aren't there? One could very easily manipulate the "good" and "bad" elements of expenditure to move the proportion far in excess of the arbitrary 10% one might think acceptable.

wormburner

34,587 posts

284 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
scenario8 said:
There are so many subjective elements to what is part of achieving the goal, aren't there? One could very easily manipulate the "good" and "bad" elements of expenditure to move the proportion far in excess of the arbitrary 10% one might think acceptable.
Ok, lets say the goal is feeding orphans. Good spend might be on food, ground workers, collection centres and shipping. Bad spend might be on accountants, nice offices in the SE,marketing agencies, subsidised canteens and company Mercedes'. Just as an example.


TheDiplomat

72 posts

175 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Agree with the dismissive posts above.

Small, local charities often do a valuable job, but large Oxfan-sized charities I just cannot trust.

From the chuggers on the street (who often work for fundraising companies and take the first two years of charitable donations) to the CEOs at the top - I don't trust them, and don't feel they're accountable.

I would never donate to such charities for these reasons. I prefer to volunteer my time (albeit not that often) and make a difference myself.

scenario8

8,008 posts

210 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Ok, since we're using a made up example, if that specific charity had a turnover of £100m, I wouldn't be upset with it's CEO earning £100k. Or probably even £200k if I could see the CEO was enhancing the performance of the charity. I wouldn't mind him/her driving a Mercedes on the charity's account. I would also expect a charity of that size to acrue expensive accountancy bills. It might be fortunate to negotiate pro rata work from the Big 4 - but it might not and face big bills. I wouldn't be upset to read a DM type headline stating that company spent £200k pa on accountancy.

I inferred a previous poster as being troubled by a CEO of Oxfam earning £100k pa. As a headline that doesn't bother me in the slightest. Oxfam turnsover £300m pa. I'd want someone capable running an organisation with that amount of money floowing around and I'd probably have to find a decent wedge to recruit them. You might be able to find a management team capable of running an efficient organisation of that size who'd do it for nothing. I bet people try.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
TheDiplomat said:
I would never donate to such charities for these reasons. I prefer to volunteer my time (albeit not that often) and make a difference myself.
You do donate - over half of charities total income comes from the Government. Government support overtook individual donations a few years ago and cutbacks now could well wipe out thousands of charities.

Oakey

27,984 posts

247 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
The Telegraph

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/religion/7229874/T...

Telegraph said:
Oxfam's Chief Executive Barbara Stocking earns £109,100. Oxfam employs 5,000 staff and has an annual turnover of £300 million.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Oakey said:
That won't even cover the CEO's annual salary.
Are the source for that?

http://society.guardian.co.uk/salarysurvey/table/0...
I'm guessing you didn't look at the date - why else would you post up 9yr old information?

Oakey

27,984 posts

247 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2011/jan/04/what...

Guardian said:
Most will dump their bag of surplus goods and won't think any more about them. They focus instead on how Oxfam spends the money made from these donations (around £60m a year, or roughly a fifth of the charity's total £318m turnover) or how, in some critics' eyes, it wastes it.

wormburner

34,587 posts

284 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
scenario8 said:
Ok, since we're using a made up example, if that specific charity had a turnover of £100m, I wouldn't be upset with it's CEO earning £100k. Or probably even £200k if I could see the CEO was enhancing the performance of the charity. I wouldn't mind him/her driving a Mercedes on the charity's account. I would also expect a charity of that size to acrue expensive accountancy bills. It might be fortunate to negotiate pro rata work from the Big 4 - but it might not and face big bills. I wouldn't be upset to read a DM type headline stating that company spent £200k pa on accountancy.

I inferred a previous poster as being troubled by a CEO of Oxfam earning £100k pa. As a headline that doesn't bother me in the slightest. Oxfam turnsover £300m pa. I'd want someone capable running an organisation with that amount of money floowing around and I'd probably have to find a decent wedge to recruit them. You might be able to find a management team capable of running an efficient organisation of that size who'd do it for nothing. I bet people try.
You haven't commented on proportions.

The issue is that big charities compete with each other for the limited charitable money available. Advertising generates returns, but at a cost to other charities, so all big charities are committed to big spending on awareness and advertising, just to take money from each other. Inefficient.

Small charities are more efficient, and yet smothered by the powerful advertising efforts of the big charities. Inefficient again.

scenario8

8,008 posts

210 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
wormburner said:
You haven't commented on proportions.
I think I commented above that people would have their own interpretations of what is good spend and what is bad. I was, after all, reacting to a poster's seeming upset that a large nominal sum was being used in a specific position in management pay. Obviously I would like to see any individual "charity" to use its funds efficiently but the third sector is huge and diverse so it might be a little too simplistic to have a fixed opinion on what is an acceptable proportion of funding spent on "good" and "bad", let alone nominal sums in individual organisations.

People often get upset by money they give to charity being spent on wages. Often, in my opinion wages are a very worthy use of that charitable giving. My company gives a six figure sum to a charity that provides healthcare. A huge proportion of that money goes on wages. I'm happy to support it.

wormburner

34,587 posts

284 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
scenario8 said:
wormburner said:
You haven't commented on proportions.
I think I commented above that people would have their own interpretations of what is good spend and what is bad. I was, after all, reacting to a poster's seeming upset that a large nominal sum was being used in a specific position in management pay. Obviously I would like to see any individual "charity" to use its funds efficiently but the third sector is huge and diverse so it might be a little too simplistic to have a fixed opinion on what is an acceptable proportion of funding spent on "good" and "bad", let alone nominal sums in individual organisations.

People often get upset by money they give to charity being spent on wages. Often, in my opinion wages are a very worthy use of that charitable giving. My company gives a six figure sum to a charity that provides healthcare. A huge proportion of that money goes on wages. I'm happy to support it.
You still haven't commented on proportions. Your partner works for a famous charity so you are close to this issue. Why is it famous? Probably largely because it spends a lot of donors' money on advertising competing against the other big charities.

If charities were restricted on size or lost their charitable status, you'd see more focus on the goal and less on 'making payroll this month'. I exaggerate for the sake of illustration.


scenario8

8,008 posts

210 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
wormburner said:
You still haven't commented on proportions. Your partner works for a famous charity so you are close to this issue. Why is it famous? Probably largely because it spends a lot of donors' money on advertising competing against the other big charities.

If charities were restricted on size or lost their charitable status, you'd see more focus on the goal and less on 'making payroll this month'. I exaggerate for the sake of illustration.
I think I don't have a better answer for you than the ones I've given above. I'm not a forensic accountant so would probably find it hard to determine what was good and bad spending even if I had a pretty good idea of what I thought would slip into those two categories. I doubt there would be consensus amongst the country as to what would be good and bad spending either once you got into the nitty gritty.

I'd also suggest each and any organisation within the third sector would have very different goals and structures. If you won't rest without me committing a made up figure to apply to all organisation then on the basis that I'm not an accountant or a corportate lawyer and have no idea what I'm talking about - but it's the internet so that's par for the course I suppose - how about I wholeheartedly agree with your 90% and 50% figures? On first examination and as headline figures they look alright. That good enough?

I can't comment on my wife's employer's advertising spend. Again, I'd imagine agreeing what was and what was not "advertising spend" would be a bit tricky but I don't think it spends a great deal on print or new media advertising that generically one might call advertising in that way. It doesn't rely in any great measure on general public donations, by the way. High Net Worth Individual donations are significant, as are corporate donations. Both those groups' income streams can be structred in various complex ways so not easy to categorise simplistically. A degree of their "income" is from the State sector, too, which might be considered contentious. It would need to be understood, however, that the organisation implements government policy so it might be a bit simplistic to state our tax is being "given to charity".

(I'd rather not bang on in any more detail about my wife's charity as I'd like to maintain anonymity).

I'm not sure I have a supporting opinion that all charities must not exist above a certain size (measured by turnover?). I would imagine there would be an optimum size for different organisations and different sectors. I've not put too much thought to it.

I'm still not upset with a specific employee within an organisation in the third sector with a turnover of £300m receiving £100k pa, though, as was my original intended comment.

Randy Winkman

22,804 posts

220 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Some people just want an excuse not to give money to charity.

whoami

13,201 posts

271 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Oakey said:
That won't even cover the CEO's annual salary.
Ah well, they should just throw it in the bin then.

jontymo

853 posts

181 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Good on the now deceased gent to put on a bet of the amount he did in hope to give something better to charity.