Discussion
I watched about 10 minutes of this when I was 7, before my Dad decided it probably wasn't something I should be watching. That was still enough to give me nightmares.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_War_Game
27 years later and aged 33 it's not much different, although the threat of nuclear war has subsided it retains it's power to chill my spine.
Worse still though is the utter contempt the government had and still has for it's people. I know PH is full of right wing nuts who think Senator McCarthy was on the right track, and sometimes I'm one of them. But this movie, based on the actual plans for a nuclear strike, shows that ultimately the rulers see the ruled as farm animals, expendable as individuals, and categorised into classes according to how worthy of saving they are on their usefulness to the rulers of a ruined world. It made no difference then if it was a Tory or Labour government in power, as I'm sure it makes none now.
Definitely worth watching.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_War_Game
27 years later and aged 33 it's not much different, although the threat of nuclear war has subsided it retains it's power to chill my spine.
Worse still though is the utter contempt the government had and still has for it's people. I know PH is full of right wing nuts who think Senator McCarthy was on the right track, and sometimes I'm one of them. But this movie, based on the actual plans for a nuclear strike, shows that ultimately the rulers see the ruled as farm animals, expendable as individuals, and categorised into classes according to how worthy of saving they are on their usefulness to the rulers of a ruined world. It made no difference then if it was a Tory or Labour government in power, as I'm sure it makes none now.
Definitely worth watching.
AJS- said:
I watched about 10 minutes of this when I was 7, before my Dad decided it probably wasn't something I should be watching. That was still enough to give me nightmares.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_War_Game
27 years later and aged 33 it's not much different, although the threat of nuclear war has subsided it retains it's power to chill my spine.
Worse still though is the utter contempt the government had and still has for it's people. I know PH is full of right wing nuts who think Senator McCarthy was on the right track, and sometimes I'm one of them. But this movie, based on the actual plans for a nuclear strike, shows that ultimately the rulers see the ruled as farm animals, expendable as individuals, and categorised into classes according to how worthy of saving they are on their usefulness to the rulers of a ruined world. It made no difference then if it was a Tory or Labour government in power, as I'm sure it makes none now.
Definitely worth watching.
Those in power have always had relative contempt for those not in power.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_War_Game
27 years later and aged 33 it's not much different, although the threat of nuclear war has subsided it retains it's power to chill my spine.
Worse still though is the utter contempt the government had and still has for it's people. I know PH is full of right wing nuts who think Senator McCarthy was on the right track, and sometimes I'm one of them. But this movie, based on the actual plans for a nuclear strike, shows that ultimately the rulers see the ruled as farm animals, expendable as individuals, and categorised into classes according to how worthy of saving they are on their usefulness to the rulers of a ruined world. It made no difference then if it was a Tory or Labour government in power, as I'm sure it makes none now.
Definitely worth watching.
I am actually a fan of the films depicting the armageddon scenario, Threads being my favourite, it actually makes you feel sick after watching it, even now,i also own the day after tommorrow, twighlights last gleaming and have seen when the wind blows on you tube.
The films do show how bad an idea nuclear war is.
is the war game the black n white film with harvey keitel and robert duval? as it is excelent.
The films do show how bad an idea nuclear war is.
is the war game the black n white film with harvey keitel and robert duval? as it is excelent.
It is funny how quickly people forget all of this.
The Cold War only ended twenty years ago and kids today have no idea of the weird background 'threat' that was always there, films like this and 'Threads', having the 'Protect and Survive' leaflets posted through your letterbox, anti-nuclear protesters at Greenham Common. I suppose it is all another world away.
At least in those days the world was probably more stable as we knew who had the bombs and what they could do. Today, after the collapse of the Soviet Union, rogue states, the further proliferation of nuclear weapons is making the world all the more dangerous.
The Cold War only ended twenty years ago and kids today have no idea of the weird background 'threat' that was always there, films like this and 'Threads', having the 'Protect and Survive' leaflets posted through your letterbox, anti-nuclear protesters at Greenham Common. I suppose it is all another world away.
At least in those days the world was probably more stable as we knew who had the bombs and what they could do. Today, after the collapse of the Soviet Union, rogue states, the further proliferation of nuclear weapons is making the world all the more dangerous.
bob1179 said:
It is funny how quickly people forget all of this.
The Cold War only ended twenty years ago and kids today have no idea of the weird background 'threat' that was always there, films like this and 'Threads', having the 'Protect and Survive' leaflets posted through your letterbox, anti-nuclear protesters at Greenham Common. I suppose it is all another world away.
At least in those days the world was probably more stable as we knew who had the bombs and what they could do. Today, after the collapse of the Soviet Union, rogue states, the further proliferation of nuclear weapons is making the world all the more dangerous.
At least we had the SLR then.The Cold War only ended twenty years ago and kids today have no idea of the weird background 'threat' that was always there, films like this and 'Threads', having the 'Protect and Survive' leaflets posted through your letterbox, anti-nuclear protesters at Greenham Common. I suppose it is all another world away.
At least in those days the world was probably more stable as we knew who had the bombs and what they could do. Today, after the collapse of the Soviet Union, rogue states, the further proliferation of nuclear weapons is making the world all the more dangerous.
bob1179 said:
It is funny how quickly people forget all of this.
The Cold War only ended twenty years ago and kids today have no idea of the weird background 'threat' that was always there, films like this and 'Threads', having the 'Protect and Survive' leaflets posted through your letterbox, anti-nuclear protesters at Greenham Common. I suppose it is all another world away.
At least in those days the world was probably more stable as we knew who had the bombs and what they could do. Today, after the collapse of the Soviet Union, rogue states, the further proliferation of nuclear weapons is making the world all the more dangerous.
I'm not sure I believe that.The Cold War only ended twenty years ago and kids today have no idea of the weird background 'threat' that was always there, films like this and 'Threads', having the 'Protect and Survive' leaflets posted through your letterbox, anti-nuclear protesters at Greenham Common. I suppose it is all another world away.
At least in those days the world was probably more stable as we knew who had the bombs and what they could do. Today, after the collapse of the Soviet Union, rogue states, the further proliferation of nuclear weapons is making the world all the more dangerous.
As mentioned above nuclear weapons now are many times more powerful than in 1965 when the film was made, and even then the predictions made in the film were quite conservative.
Even if a terror group were willing and able to let off a dirty bomb (and I suspect they would have done by now if that was the case) then it still couldn't compare to the horrors of an all out nuclear war with Soviet Russia, who actually had enough fire power to kill everyone in the country (and probably the world) several times over if they needed to. Some small bombs on buses, or even a hijacked plane can't compare to the all out horror if nuclear war.
And that's not to mention the horrors of a conventional ground war in Europe, which is nearly inconceivable now but would have been likely been a prelude to a nuclear war. Soviet tanks rolling into Berlin and then West Germany.
There has always been rogue states and terrorists, they just get more headlines when we need a common enemy, and no-one else is blowing stuff up.
AJS- said:
I'm not sure I believe that.
As mentioned above nuclear weapons now are many times more powerful than in 1965 when the film was made, and even then the predictions made in the film were quite conservative.
Even if a terror group were willing and able to let off a dirty bomb (and I suspect they would have done by now if that was the case) then it still couldn't compare to the horrors of an all out nuclear war with Soviet Russia, who actually had enough fire power to kill everyone in the country (and probably the world) several times over if they needed to. Some small bombs on buses, or even a hijacked plane can't compare to the all out horror if nuclear war.
And that's not to mention the horrors of a conventional ground war in Europe, which is nearly inconceivable now but would have been likely been a prelude to a nuclear war. Soviet tanks rolling into Berlin and then West Germany.
There has always been rogue states and terrorists, they just get more headlines when we need a common enemy, and no-one else is blowing stuff up.
I think the comparative yield of a modern nuclear weapon is irrelevant to be honest. One thing to remember is that todays nuclear weapons have a selectable yield and probably wouldn't be used to anywhere near their maximum potential. Also, the NATO forces also had large stockpiles of weapons (although not as much as the USSR), I think both sides peaked around 1986 with enough firepower to destroy mankind repeatedly.As mentioned above nuclear weapons now are many times more powerful than in 1965 when the film was made, and even then the predictions made in the film were quite conservative.
Even if a terror group were willing and able to let off a dirty bomb (and I suspect they would have done by now if that was the case) then it still couldn't compare to the horrors of an all out nuclear war with Soviet Russia, who actually had enough fire power to kill everyone in the country (and probably the world) several times over if they needed to. Some small bombs on buses, or even a hijacked plane can't compare to the all out horror if nuclear war.
And that's not to mention the horrors of a conventional ground war in Europe, which is nearly inconceivable now but would have been likely been a prelude to a nuclear war. Soviet tanks rolling into Berlin and then West Germany.
There has always been rogue states and terrorists, they just get more headlines when we need a common enemy, and no-one else is blowing stuff up.
I think what I was trying to say is that if one rogue state (North Korea, Pakistan, Iran, etc.) could get a weapon into a western city, even a small one it would completely overwhelm the emergency services of that country. You are quite right in saying that all out nuclear war would be a horror beyond comprehension, but it didn't happen purely for that reason. The people involved had sense, something that the leaders of some countries don't have because they use their imaginary sky hero as justification for hating us, or whoever else they don't like. This is what I meant by the relative stability that MAD gave us, now that it is gone, it leaves the world a little bit more jittery.
Reading that back, I know what I'm trying to say, I don't know if I'm saying it very well!

croyde said:
American school kids even practiced 'Duck and Cover' emergency drills.
Not just Americans. At school in Gibraltar I vividly remember air raid drills. Looking back, I doubt my desk would have been much defence against the nuclear missile(s) that the Russians would have lobbed onto the navy base.One of the Duck and Cover films suggests hiding under a picnic blanket if you are outdoors when someone drops an A-bomb on your head.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detail...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detail...
I'm 33 too and can remember vividly the threat that hung over us. I grew up in Hackney so was all the more aware of what little chance anyone in that area would have stood had it happened (nearly did in 84(?) due to Able Archer).
I can remember being fearfull of the word "Nuclear" and that heart in your mouth moment when a newsflash would appear mid program, even now the sound of an air raid siren gives me the willies.
The thing is I don't think anyone ever knew for sure what the signal would be, I think the best outcome would be to just not tell us.
Dark, dark days. Hope its the last we see of them.
I can remember being fearfull of the word "Nuclear" and that heart in your mouth moment when a newsflash would appear mid program, even now the sound of an air raid siren gives me the willies.
The thing is I don't think anyone ever knew for sure what the signal would be, I think the best outcome would be to just not tell us.
Dark, dark days. Hope its the last we see of them.
bob1179 said:
AJS- said:
I'm not sure I believe that.
As mentioned above nuclear weapons now are many times more powerful than in 1965 when the film was made, and even then the predictions made in the film were quite conservative.
Even if a terror group were willing and able to let off a dirty bomb (and I suspect they would have done by now if that was the case) then it still couldn't compare to the horrors of an all out nuclear war with Soviet Russia, who actually had enough fire power to kill everyone in the country (and probably the world) several times over if they needed to. Some small bombs on buses, or even a hijacked plane can't compare to the all out horror if nuclear war.
And that's not to mention the horrors of a conventional ground war in Europe, which is nearly inconceivable now but would have been likely been a prelude to a nuclear war. Soviet tanks rolling into Berlin and then West Germany.
There has always been rogue states and terrorists, they just get more headlines when we need a common enemy, and no-one else is blowing stuff up.
I think the comparative yield of a modern nuclear weapon is irrelevant to be honest. One thing to remember is that todays nuclear weapons have a selectable yield and probably wouldn't be used to anywhere near their maximum potential. Also, the NATO forces also had large stockpiles of weapons (although not as much as the USSR), I think both sides peaked around 1986 with enough firepower to destroy mankind repeatedly.As mentioned above nuclear weapons now are many times more powerful than in 1965 when the film was made, and even then the predictions made in the film were quite conservative.
Even if a terror group were willing and able to let off a dirty bomb (and I suspect they would have done by now if that was the case) then it still couldn't compare to the horrors of an all out nuclear war with Soviet Russia, who actually had enough fire power to kill everyone in the country (and probably the world) several times over if they needed to. Some small bombs on buses, or even a hijacked plane can't compare to the all out horror if nuclear war.
And that's not to mention the horrors of a conventional ground war in Europe, which is nearly inconceivable now but would have been likely been a prelude to a nuclear war. Soviet tanks rolling into Berlin and then West Germany.
There has always been rogue states and terrorists, they just get more headlines when we need a common enemy, and no-one else is blowing stuff up.
I think what I was trying to say is that if one rogue state (North Korea, Pakistan, Iran, etc.) could get a weapon into a western city, even a small one it would completely overwhelm the emergency services of that country. You are quite right in saying that all out nuclear war would be a horror beyond comprehension, but it didn't happen purely for that reason. The people involved had sense, something that the leaders of some countries don't have because they use their imaginary sky hero as justification for hating us, or whoever else they don't like. This is what I meant by the relative stability that MAD gave us, now that it is gone, it leaves the world a little bit more jittery.
Reading that back, I know what I'm trying to say, I don't know if I'm saying it very well!

Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



