Cloud seeding for the Olympics - should we
Discussion
My view is yes, it's a once in a lifetime event but the tree huggers will be up in arms...
an interest article from the times today
We have the technology to stop these damaging downpours. We should dare to use it
Living through this wretched summer is like being a stoic with a persistent ear infection. At first we think it will only last a short while, so we don’t worry about it. But the pain just gets worse. Finally, shivering, we reach guiltily for the medicine cabinet.
Yes, there really is a pot of pills that might possibly help us with the weather. And as, one by one, parts of the country succumb to deep floodwaters it is only a matter of time before we start asking, do we want to keep ourselves environmentally pure, or do we want to try to stop it raining?
The pills in this case are labelled “silver iodide”. When sprayed from an aeroplane — a process called cloud-seeding — tiny silver iodide particles provide a nucleus around which raindrops can form, causing precipitation earlier than it would otherwise have occurred. Although the effectiveness of the technology remains a matter of debate, those who have tried it have often claimed success, either by making it rain in areas afflicted by drought or by diverting rainfall from a place that has suffered too much.
The Chinese Government is a big advocate. Clouds were seeded to empty them of rain before they passed over the stadium during the opening and closing ceremonies of the Beijing Olympics. Cloud-seeding was used to end months of drought around Beijing in 2009, resulting in a heavy snowfall. You don’t have to be an authoritarian state to use it, however. US ski resorts have used it to improve the slopes. Gulf states have used it to bring rain to desert areas. France has reduced hail damage to crops. Australia has increased rainfall in dry areas.
In Britain, too, we once used it but experiments ceased in the mid-1950s. While the Ministry of Defence was disappointed with the results, conspiracy theorists believed it was only too successful: it has been blamed — wrongly — for the devastating Lynmouth flood of 1952, when parts of the Devon town were washed away after exceptional rainfall. The MoD had been trying to seed clouds the day before, but on an east-bound cloud formation in Bedfordshire.
Could we make cloud-seeding work on the successive depressions that have raced across the Atlantic this summer before decelerating off Ireland and dumping their rain over the British Isles? We will have no idea unless we have a go. All I do know is that if we could persuade the clouds to dump at least some of their rain harmlessly 500 miles out into the Atlantic we could save an awful lot of damage to property, crops and our tourist industry.
Admittedly, spraying the Western Approaches with silver iodide particles isn’t quite with the environmental spirit of the times. We don’t like the idea of meddling with nature. We like to see foul weather and climate change as punishment for our environmental sins; any proposal to engineer our way out of storms would cause a thunderous eruption in the green lobby.
But just a question: if there were potentially catastrophic rain clouds heading for Britain and we knew we could do something to disperse them before they did their damage, would not a refusal to act be a failure in our duty of care to the people whose lives and livelihoods are under threat?
an interest article from the times today
We have the technology to stop these damaging downpours. We should dare to use it
Living through this wretched summer is like being a stoic with a persistent ear infection. At first we think it will only last a short while, so we don’t worry about it. But the pain just gets worse. Finally, shivering, we reach guiltily for the medicine cabinet.
Yes, there really is a pot of pills that might possibly help us with the weather. And as, one by one, parts of the country succumb to deep floodwaters it is only a matter of time before we start asking, do we want to keep ourselves environmentally pure, or do we want to try to stop it raining?
The pills in this case are labelled “silver iodide”. When sprayed from an aeroplane — a process called cloud-seeding — tiny silver iodide particles provide a nucleus around which raindrops can form, causing precipitation earlier than it would otherwise have occurred. Although the effectiveness of the technology remains a matter of debate, those who have tried it have often claimed success, either by making it rain in areas afflicted by drought or by diverting rainfall from a place that has suffered too much.
The Chinese Government is a big advocate. Clouds were seeded to empty them of rain before they passed over the stadium during the opening and closing ceremonies of the Beijing Olympics. Cloud-seeding was used to end months of drought around Beijing in 2009, resulting in a heavy snowfall. You don’t have to be an authoritarian state to use it, however. US ski resorts have used it to improve the slopes. Gulf states have used it to bring rain to desert areas. France has reduced hail damage to crops. Australia has increased rainfall in dry areas.
In Britain, too, we once used it but experiments ceased in the mid-1950s. While the Ministry of Defence was disappointed with the results, conspiracy theorists believed it was only too successful: it has been blamed — wrongly — for the devastating Lynmouth flood of 1952, when parts of the Devon town were washed away after exceptional rainfall. The MoD had been trying to seed clouds the day before, but on an east-bound cloud formation in Bedfordshire.
Could we make cloud-seeding work on the successive depressions that have raced across the Atlantic this summer before decelerating off Ireland and dumping their rain over the British Isles? We will have no idea unless we have a go. All I do know is that if we could persuade the clouds to dump at least some of their rain harmlessly 500 miles out into the Atlantic we could save an awful lot of damage to property, crops and our tourist industry.
Admittedly, spraying the Western Approaches with silver iodide particles isn’t quite with the environmental spirit of the times. We don’t like the idea of meddling with nature. We like to see foul weather and climate change as punishment for our environmental sins; any proposal to engineer our way out of storms would cause a thunderous eruption in the green lobby.
But just a question: if there were potentially catastrophic rain clouds heading for Britain and we knew we could do something to disperse them before they did their damage, would not a refusal to act be a failure in our duty of care to the people whose lives and livelihoods are under threat?
Seeding clouds in specific areas to do specific things, to subtly influence behavior in stable areas is one thing. Trying to do it over the UK which is a geographical meeting point for 4 different weather systems is another thing entirely.
And seed a Depression over the Atlantic so it rains a few hundred miles out to see instead of over Ireland or the UK? What the hell does the author think the weather is *already* doing a few hundred miles out into the Atlantic???? Or is this a different Atlantic Ocean to the one that is notoriously a storm filled, pissing it down b
h?
And seed a Depression over the Atlantic so it rains a few hundred miles out to see instead of over Ireland or the UK? What the hell does the author think the weather is *already* doing a few hundred miles out into the Atlantic???? Or is this a different Atlantic Ocean to the one that is notoriously a storm filled, pissing it down b
h?Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



