BBC4 last night - the le Man tragedy
BBC4 last night - the le Man tragedy
Author
Discussion

pidsy

Original Poster:

8,715 posts

188 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
anyone else watch this?

a really interesting look at the crash that led to so many deaths in 1955, when a mercedes broke up along the pit straight and took out a lot of the crowd. 84 dead and over 100 injured.

the fact they didnt stop the race astounded me.

well worth a look on iplayer!

StevieBee

15,512 posts

286 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
Been on before but still compulsive viewing.

It was an accident waiting to happen sadly. Flick through any motor racing history book and you'll see people standing less than a few yards from cars separated only by a length of rope or a hay bale. There used to be a picture hanging in the Kentagon at Brands of a mechanic loading fuel into a race car with a fag dangling from his lips!!!


The Don of Croy

6,469 posts

190 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
StevieBee said:
Been on before but still compulsive viewing.

It was an accident waiting to happen sadly. Flick through any motor racing history book and you'll see people standing less than a few yards from cars separated only by a length of rope or a hay bale. There used to be a picture hanging in the Kentagon at Brands of a mechanic loading fuel into a race car with a fag dangling from his lips!!!
See you tube for the replay of Senna in the rain at Donnington (European GP). Marvel at the pit stops - men in street clothes, anoraks etc moddling about as F1 cars skid in and out, camera crews getting in the way...could have been 1955 not the 1980's.

Nicholas Blair

4,111 posts

315 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
The Don of Croy said:
See you tube for the replay of Senna in the rain at Donnington (European GP). Marvel at the pit stops - men in street clothes, anoraks etc moddling about as F1 cars skid in and out, camera crews getting in the way...could have been 1955 not the 1980's.
Or even 1993 wink

The Don of Croy

6,469 posts

190 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
Nicholas Blair said:
The Don of Croy said:
See you tube for the replay of Senna in the rain at Donnington (European GP). Marvel at the pit stops - men in street clothes, anoraks etc moddling about as F1 cars skid in and out, camera crews getting in the way...could have been 1955 not the 1980's.
Or even 1993 wink
Was it really less than 20 years ago? Everything was different then, esp the weather...

Nicholas Blair

4,111 posts

315 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
hehe

skeggysteve

5,724 posts

248 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
pidsy said:
the fact they didnt stop the race astounded me.
I seem to remember reading/hearing somewhere that they didn't stop the race because the crowd would have tried to leave and they wanted to keep the roads clear for the ambulances etc.

pidsy

Original Poster:

8,715 posts

188 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
skeggysteve said:
I seem to remember reading/hearing somewhere that they didn't stop the race because the crowd would have tried to leave and they wanted to keep the roads clear for the ambulances etc.
That was the original reason, but once the ambulances etc gad gone - it still carried on. Mercedes dropped out to avoid a PR nightmare. They invited jaguar on to do the same but they said no.

Simpo Two

93,092 posts

296 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
They may have taken the view that stopping the race wouldn't bring the 84 people back to life, so they carried on. Still a bit of wartime pragmatism in those days.

Eric Mc

125,934 posts

296 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
pidsy said:
skeggysteve said:
I seem to remember reading/hearing somewhere that they didn't stop the race because the crowd would have tried to leave and they wanted to keep the roads clear for the ambulances etc.
That was the original reason, but once the ambulances etc gad gone - it still carried on. Mercedes dropped out to avoid a PR nightmare. They invited jaguar on to do the same but they said no.
Different world.

Different mores.

Logically - what would stopping the race have achieved?

Ten years earlier German machinery had been deliberately killing French people.

Races were hardly ever stopped by accidents in those days - unless the road was blocked.

Three drivers died at Dundrod that year too - and the race wasn't stopped at any point.

pidsy

Original Poster:

8,715 posts

188 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
Very true. I guess i was just judging it by todays standards.

Eric Mc

125,934 posts

296 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
pidsy said:
Very true. I guess i was just judging it by todays standards.
Always a rash thing to do. "The past is a different country - they do things differently there" - someone once said.

pidsy

Original Poster:

8,715 posts

188 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
Indeed.

I didnt really think about the change in morals over the 60 years since then.

Simpo Two

93,092 posts

296 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
I'm not sure it's morals, we just seem to be over-sensitive about death now.

And yet the masses love to tune in and watch people dying in interminable hospital dramas and violent films. Funny isn't it.

pidsy

Original Poster:

8,715 posts

188 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
I think that if it is "real life" we are morally obliged to stop races, cut to an ad break or look away.

You are spot on about people loving a bit of murder or a good accident - as long as its on TV.

Eric Mc

125,934 posts

296 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
pidsy said:
Indeed.

I didnt really think about the change in morals over the 60 years since then.
I didn't use the word "morals". I used the word "mores" - which means something quite different.

I suppose a more modern expression would be "mind set".

Europe in the mid 1950s was emerging from the most devastating war in its history. The bulk of the people alive at the time had clear and sharp memories of what they had been through.
Look on their approach to "health and safety" as a form of "release" from the oppression and extreme dangers of the war. In WW2, a person usually died because of what someone did to them - usually through deliberate agressive action. Being killed because of a motor racing accident wasd looked on as an improvement in that situation. As one driver said, "At least no one was TRYING to kill us".

pidsy

Original Poster:

8,715 posts

188 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
Yes- and i used the word morals.

hehe anyway, great programme - interesting to read more about it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
Velocity channel here in the states showed a BBC documentary recently called "Grand Prix, The Killer Years".

It was fascinating and horrific, especially in the apparent ambivalence of teams and circuits to the deaths. Some of the scenes, especially the deaths of Roger Williamson and Piers Courage were very difficult to watch, especially given how relatively recent they were.

Pothole

34,367 posts

313 months

Saturday 14th July 2012
quotequote all
unrepentant said:
Velocity channel here in the states showed a BBC documentary recently called "Grand Prix, The Killer Years".

It was fascinating and horrific, especially in the apparent ambivalence of teams and circuits to the deaths. Some of the scenes, especially the deaths of Roger Williamson and Piers Courage were very difficult to watch, especially given how relatively recent they were.
Relative to Cugnot's fardier à vapeur?

Eric Mc

125,934 posts

296 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
unrepentant said:
Velocity channel here in the states showed a BBC documentary recently called "Grand Prix, The Killer Years".

It was fascinating and horrific, especially in the apparent ambivalence of teams and circuits to the deaths. Some of the scenes, especially the deaths of Roger Williamson and Piers Courage were very difficult to watch, especially given how relatively recent they were.
They were the accidents that made people in motor sport think a bit more about how the image of guys dying played out on front of a TV audience - and how it affected sponsors. The commercialisation of motor sport was one of the factors involved in the advent of increased safety awareness.