X3 - Help please!
X3 - Help please!
Author
Discussion

Trellis

Original Poster:

590 posts

270 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
A friend of mine has a X3 320d and has the following symptoms:

Quote: "When pulling off there is sometimes a knocking noise (from towards the rear of the vehicle) as if the exhaust is knocking. Sometimes it seems that I can ‘feel’ it through the gear stick. Also when accelerating at low speeds, there is a slight ‘jerk’ (almost like an automatic changing up a gear, but not as severe). Thought it might be the prop shaft donut but apparently not...!"

hes had it into a 'specialist' who was unable to diagnose it......rolleyes

has anyone got any pointers/ideas?

thanks!

ANOpax

1,094 posts

197 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
Probably drivetrain issues caused by non-matching tyres. Are all the tyres of the same make, tread pattern and wear?

A google search on this issue will reveal far more than I can cram into a single post but I'd suggest looking at your friend's tyres first. I have run a sport model X3 without star rated tyres but have ensured that they're all of the same type and that I replace them in sets of 4.

Good luck!

Vee

3,109 posts

265 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
My sisters one is doing exactly this (although she has a 3.0sd auto, 2006).

BMW Holland Park managed to rack up £1,500 worth of warranty work on it last week and didn't sort the problem.
They claim it is down to the tyres not being the standard size (my bro in law has saved money and not put the recommended staggered set up on).
To me it feels like a mechanical problem.
Problem is BMW won't look at it further without the correct tyre sizes on. Please post back if you get a solution.

essexplumber

7,756 posts

204 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
I have a 2.0d manual 56 plate X3 with 82K on the clock, bought it 3 weeks ago and I get that knock sound too. Its a sort of clunk, when pulling away or manuvering. Mine has 4 star rated Pirrellis on it that look recent although I don't know what it had been run with prior to that.

I'm going back to the dealer (indie) this weekend to get a PDS replaced so I'll get him to check it out.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
Vee said:
They claim it is down to the tyres not being the standard size (my bro in law has saved money and not put the recommended staggered set up on).
There's your answer smile

Trellis

Original Poster:

590 posts

270 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
thanks for suggestions so far - will pass on.....

Vee

3,109 posts

265 months

Wednesday 11th July 2012
quotequote all
St John Smythe said:
Vee said:
They claim it is down to the tyres not being the standard size (my bro in law has saved money and not put the recommended staggered set up on).
There's your answer smile
I'm surprised that this can cause such an obvious problem. I did some calcs on the rolling radius is only around 1% out.

I'll suggest they put the right sizes on

essexplumber

7,756 posts

204 months

Thursday 12th July 2012
quotequote all
So if you had run incorrect tyre sizes what actually makes the noise, is it the diff or prop shaft or a bush?


AndyM31

817 posts

236 months

Thursday 12th July 2012
quotequote all
I think it is a drive shaft issue where something is either worn or cracked. I had similar symptoms with a similar vehicle.

I'd want to jack it up and see if there is any movement with the diffs and drive shafts.

Trellis

Original Poster:

590 posts

270 months

Thursday 12th July 2012
quotequote all
both he and I are dubious that non-matching or incorrectly sized tyres can really cause such a driveline shunt on a 4x4??

A problem with the driveline itself seems much more logical to us, as you say. But his garage could find no fault.

Seems foolish to spend £700 on a good set of tyres to find the issue remains........

Any more takers?

ANOpax

1,094 posts

197 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Trellis said:
both he and I are dubious that non-matching or incorrectly sized tyres can really cause such a driveline shunt on a 4x4??

A problem with the driveline itself seems much more logical to us, as you say. But his garage could find no fault.

Seems foolish to spend £700 on a good set of tyres to find the issue remains........

Any more takers?
This is a commonly reported issue which seems to defy logic. There are reports of driveline problems being solved by changing the tyres. But if the driveline is significantly knackered already, then you need a new transfer box. The problem only affects sport models with the staggered wheel sizes (and hence different rolling circumferences) or standard models with identical wheel sizes but where different makes of tyre or tread pattern have been used. It seems that the X-drive system is very sensitive to differences in grip and rolling coefficients although no-one has plausibly explained why...

Vee

3,109 posts

265 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
I think there are enough people who've had this problem go away with the correct tyre sizes put on to convince me.

At least then, if it still persists, BMW can replace the Transfer Box under warranty.

Trellis

Original Poster:

590 posts

270 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
thanks again - I have no idea what model it is and what the tyre sizes should be - I'll leave that to my mate!!


Trellis

Original Poster:

590 posts

270 months

Friday 20th July 2012
quotequote all
To all those who responded - thanks again - new matching tyres were fitted and yes it totally cured the knocking....

so there you have it.

I never realised BMW X3's were so precious and fussy about their boots!!! smile

Vee

3,109 posts

265 months

Saturday 11th August 2012
quotequote all
Vee said:
My sisters one is doing exactly this (although she has a 3.0sd auto, 2006).

BMW Holland Park managed to rack up £1,500 worth of warranty work on it last week and didn't sort the problem.
They claim it is down to the tyres not being the standard size (my bro in law has saved money and not put the recommended staggered set up on).
To me it feels like a mechanical problem.
Problem is BMW won't look at it further without the correct tyre sizes on. Please post back if you get a solution.
Well St John Smythe was spot on.

The cheap option taken was Kumho Excstas in the correct size on the back and incorrect size on the front. It seems only the premium brands make a front 235/45/19 (these cost more than the 255/40/19 rears).
Tyre dealer was given an ear bashing for suggesting they'd be ok and eventually agreed to swap them for Bridgstone D Sports in the correct size at no extra cost.
Noise has reportedly gone. Correct sizes on but mismatched brands front to rear.