When did Bangle get involved?
When did Bangle get involved?
Author
Discussion

AB

Original Poster:

20,671 posts

226 months

Thursday 12th July 2012
quotequote all


We have a 2002 330Ci and a 1999 840Ci Sport.

Given that both cars are over 10 years old, was Bangle involved with either of them?

Don't they still look great in 2012?

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Thursday 12th July 2012
quotequote all
From wiki, for what it's worth,

"BMW

He became the first American chief of design of BMW on October 1, 1992, where he designed the Z9 Gran Turismo concept car. His styling themes have generated intense controversy among automotive designers, and have had a polarizing effect with respect to their visual cues.

On February 3, 2009, Bangle announced that he was to quit both his position at BMW and the auto industry altogether, to focus on his own design-related endeavours.[3] He was replaced by Adrian van Hooydonk.[4][5] Bangle now works for his own firm called Chris Bangle Associates based in Turin, Italy. [6]
Design philosophy

Bangle's designs are incorporated in the entire BMW lineup, including the 1, 3, 5, 6 and 7 series as well as the X3, X5, and X6 the newest design SUVs, and the concept car Gina. These span the automotive platforms E81 / E82 / E87 / E88, E90 / E91 / E92 / E93, E60 / E61, E63 / E64, E65 / E66 and E53. Bangle himself did not (as is commonly believed) coin the phrase "flame surfacing" to describe his work; this can be attributed to a motoring journalist, and is probably the first time Deconstructivism has been adapted to automotive design. The reason for this design was to use BMW's new technology of 3D panel pressing allowing a single press for compound curves, which had previously needed multiple pressings unless the panel was shaped by hand. This is further evidenced by the fact that Bangle has often pointed out architect Frank Gehry's work as a major influence.

The most controversial of his work was the E65 7 Series, a sharp contrast to the preceding E38 generation which was conservatively styled. Time magazine named it as one of the 50 Worst Cars of All Time for its rear end styling and iDrive functionality, and while the sales for the 2002 and 2003 models years were off 60% from the 2001, the E65 7 series became the best-selling 7 Series of all time.[7][8]

During the Bangle era, BMW overtook Mercedes as the global leader in premium car sales.

Bangle aggressively defended his designs against criticism. He was supported by the BMW board of directors, who wanted to move BMW's image into the future.[7] He said it was necessary for product lines to follow a cycle of a revolutionary generation followed by an evolutionary generation followed by another revolutionary generation and so on. Indeed, he oversaw the conservative evolution of BMW designs with the redesign of the BMW 3-Series and the introduction of the BMW X5. For Bangle this marked the end of the evolution of BMW design and the revolution was witnessed with the 2002 introduction of the BMW E65. Bangle acknowledges that his designs do not look good in photographs, suggesting to critics that they should see the cars in real life before judging them on their looks. He introduced a new BMW concept car, called GINA on June 10, 2008."

Paul M

367 posts

235 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
I wasn't a big fan of everything that Bangle did. He certainly divided opinion, took BMW in a different direction - whether liked or not and got people talking BMW.

Esseesse

9,027 posts

239 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
It's interesting how that he thinks products should be evolutionary/revolutionary. Completely different market I know but this is the opposite to Apple's approach to design which tends to be evolutionary to the point that the design is 'done'.

I suppose Bangle is more form over function and Apple, although they have nice forms, put function first.

The MacBook Pro has recently been tweaked (minor appearance changes) but at any one time their designs are 'finished' given technical constraints. I feel as though the E38/E39/E46 followed the Apple style philosophy much more (and the older E34's etc etc now I think about it). I think I prefer that approach, forcing revolution/evolution cycles seems to have only happened with/since Bangle. Also I think change for change's sake is a bad thing.

Esseesse

9,027 posts

239 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
AB said:
Don't they still look great in 2012?
Yes and the 3 series looks better than the current new one. I can see what they're trying to do with the new one, it frowns a bit at the front but it's not as balanced a thing as an E46.

il sole

287 posts

175 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
I don't think Bangle ever gets the credit he deserved. His ideas totally transformed and modernised the appearance of BMWs so much so that people were not keen on the F10 5er after the ultra modern E60. Let's not forget too that he also penned the still amazing Fiat coupe from the mid ninties - and that design, like the E60 and the LCI E90 and the Z4 (never good with Z code numbers!!) still look fresh today.
With regards to the comments about the E46 - yes, it does still look good, but, at the same time, very old. In fact when the E90 came out, like the E60 with regards to the E39, they made the previous generations look very dated...whether that is a good or bad thing is open to discussion!
But i think the best thing he can be remembered for is preventing BMW from falling into the Audi 'one design suits all' approach. Before the Bangle era, the 3,5,7 looked broadly similar, but since him, the models have diversified more and become more stand alone. (although the caveat there is that the new F31 looks just the same as an F11 in side profile, which is a shame). But at least BMWs do not all copy each others' design like audis. You see one on the road and the only thing that sets them apart are the twinkly light design! you could just as well be in a poverty spec A4 as a monster S8 costing 4 times as much...

Mermaid

21,492 posts

202 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
I doubt any Bangle design will be a future classic.

RVVUNM

1,913 posts

240 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Mermaid said:
I doubt any Bangle design will be a future classic.
Bang on, dreadful looking cars.

il sole

287 posts

175 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
RVVUNM said:
Mermaid said:
I doubt any Bangle design will be a future classic.
Bang on, dreadful looking cars.
ah well you can't please everyone!! but BMW sales figures for the Bangle era would argue otherwise!

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
RVVUNM said:
Mermaid said:
I doubt any Bangle design will be a future classic.
Bang on, dreadful looking cars.
E60 looks alright still?

Mermaid

21,492 posts

202 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
mrmr96 said:
E60 looks alright still?
Not better than the E39, E34, E28. smile But probably better than the rest.

RVVUNM

1,913 posts

240 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Chaps, you could plant a BMW badge on a dog turd and someone will buy it.

Esseesse

9,027 posts

239 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
il sole said:
RVVUNM said:
Mermaid said:
I doubt any Bangle design will be a future classic.
Bang on, dreadful looking cars.
ah well you can't please everyone!! but BMW sales figures for the Bangle era would argue otherwise!
Massive credit bubble through his period at BMW though?

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
RVVUNM said:
Chaps, you could plant a BMW badge on a dog turd and someone will buy it.
You've seen the Ferrari thread then?

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
RVVUNM said:
Mermaid said:
I doubt any Bangle design will be a future classic.
Bang on, dreadful looking cars.
It's all subjective, but you are wrong. Design needed a radical jump and Bangle produced it. The cars that looked odd when new look mostly normal now. The E65 looked particularly awkward at first and still does in some ways, but the more radical elements of its design have been widely copied. The current S Class copies the "Bangle Butt" bootlid and the shape of the dashboard.

Mermaid

21,492 posts

202 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Zod said:
RVVUNM said:
Mermaid said:
I doubt any Bangle design will be a future classic.
Bang on, dreadful looking cars.
It's all subjective, but you are wrong. Design needed a radical jump and Bangle produced it. The cars that looked odd when new look mostly normal now. The E65 looked particularly awkward at first and still does in some ways, but the more radical elements of its design have been widely copied. The current S Class copies the "Bangle Butt" bootlid and the shape of the dashboard.
It's all subjective, and you are wrong. smile You have owned Bangle cars - was it because of the design or because of the driving experience?

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Mermaid said:
Zod said:
RVVUNM said:
Mermaid said:
I doubt any Bangle design will be a future classic.
Bang on, dreadful looking cars.
It's all subjective, but you are wrong. Design needed a radical jump and Bangle produced it. The cars that looked odd when new look mostly normal now. The E65 looked particularly awkward at first and still does in some ways, but the more radical elements of its design have been widely copied. The current S Class copies the "Bangle Butt" bootlid and the shape of the dashboard.
It's all subjective, and you are wrong. smile You have owned Bangle cars - was it because of the design or because of the driving experience?
Mainly the latter, but I liked the looks of the E60 M5. I still don't really like the E63 6 Series (the front is weirdly droopy and the bootlid is just wrong), but the E90 3 Series and the E60 5 Series are good designs. The E70 X5 is a good-looking car (for an SUV).

Cheib

25,484 posts

206 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
il sole said:
RVVUNM said:
Mermaid said:
I doubt any Bangle design will be a future classic.
Bang on, dreadful looking cars.
ah well you can't please everyone!! but BMW sales figures for the Bangle era would argue otherwise!
I think BMW's success has been driven by the brilliance of their driveline and especially their engines in today's eco sensitive world. They are simply head and shoulders clear of the opposition when it comes to engine tech and emissions in my opinion.

I've always been a BMW man but when it came to buy my X5 I just didn't even consider any other car because of the emissions. I live in London and the Red Ken was about to bring in the 225 g/km congestion charge threshold (Boris saved us from that). The X5 was the only one below it, it was amazing the difference at the time.

il sole

287 posts

175 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Cheib said:
I think BMW's success has been driven by the brilliance of their driveline and especially their engines in today's eco sensitive world. They are simply head and shoulders clear of the opposition when it comes to engine tech and emissions in my opinion.

I've always been a BMW man but when it came to buy my X5 I just didn't even consider any other car because of the emissions. I live in London and the Red Ken was about to bring in the 225 g/km congestion charge threshold (Boris saved us from that). The X5 was the only one below it, it was amazing the difference at the time.
you could have always bought a G wizz wink

but you are right in that the engines and driving characteristics are a major factor in BMW's sales rise. However, it can't all be down to this otherwise how could you explain Audi's sales??!!!
Seriously though, i reckon it was a combination of many factors - design being avantgarde and cutting edge, superior engines, better handling, and badge cache. All together that was quite a package!

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Mermaid said:
I doubt any Bangle design will be a future classic.
Z4M will be, IMO. i think that was bangle?

i thought he also played a key role in the E46, E39 and E38 era too?

one thing is for sure, whilst most of them are certainly not pretty, they've aged well. despite the hideous boot, i really like the 6 series. the E60 hasn't really done it for me, however and the normal E90 saloon really is yawn-inducing. the Z4 isn't just (IMO) a lovely looking thing, it's one of the best BMW designs ever, especially the coupe.