Coalition death is nigh?
Author
Discussion

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

274 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
Tory backbenchers now very restless and some outspoken tantrums. Cameron and Clegg show joint strength with confidence and commitment to see the five years through. It has to be serious for the two Party leaders having to publicly announce that the Coalition is united. Another six months? I cannot see a minority Government surviving. How do you see it?

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
The tories did not win the last election, no matter how much some of their backbenchers think they did. There is no guarantee that they would do any better now if the coalition ended and that resulted in a new election in the not-too-distant future.

The Lib dems want an election at the moment about as much as the bloke in front of a firing squad wants to hear the first bang. Unless something changes for them in the not-too-distant future, they'll be holding their parliamentary party meetings in a telephone box for the foreseeable future.

Don't expect anything monumental to happen in the next couple of years wink

turbobloke

117,562 posts

291 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
Nothing will happen unless the Tories take a substantial lead over Labour in the polls. Libdems are in single figures a month or so ago at 8% so a general election would be a wipeout for them.

This thread should have a free placard and guaranteed spot in a town centre local to the OP (for the OP) opposite the mandatory religious nutter.

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

274 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
rs1952 said:
The tories did not win the last election, no matter how much some of their backbenchers think they did. There is no guarantee that they would do any better now if the coalition ended and that resulted in a new election in the not-too-distant future.

The Lib dems want an election at the moment about as much as the bloke in front of a firing squad wants to hear the first bang. Unless something changes for them in the not-too-distant future, they'll be holding their parliamentary party meetings in a telephone box for the foreseeable future.

Don't expect anything monumental to happen in the next couple of years wink
As a Lib-Dem myself, we are in a couple of years now and the polls, as expected, look rather bleak eek
As much as I try and convince myself all will be OK even I am now having doubts on our survival as the third Party. This makes life difficult politically speaking, never voted Conservative in my life and don't intend starting now (no disrespect) Labour is not for me and the prospect of decades in the wilderness unpalatable. Can't understand why the importance of Lords reform is taking near centre stage, most people don't care about that at the moment. Just more damage to the Party AFIK.
I cannot see any Party forming a majority Government for a couple of decades, perhaps thats a lib-dem lifeline.

king arthur

7,904 posts

292 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
On This Week last week (confused) when asked whether the coalition or Nick Clegg would survive until 2015, Michael Portillo thought the coalition would, wasn't so sure about Clegg. Andrew Neil thought Clegg is 50/50 to survive and the coalition parties will go their separate ways by 2014. Wonder who will be right?

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

274 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
Nothing will happen unless the Tories take a substantial lead over Labour in the polls. Libdems are in single figures a month or so ago at 8% so a general election would be a wipeout for them.

This thread should have a free placard and guaranteed spot in a town centre local to the OP (for the OP) opposite the mandatory religious nutter.
So you don't see the backbench growing anger will put pressure on Cameron by way of a vote of no confidence. Hopefully you have a deeper understanding of Politics then demonstrated with your apparent lacking of depth of knowledge regarding previous threads. Somehow I very much doubt it.


Jasandjules

72,688 posts

260 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
The country is f***ed whichever way you look at it. Now it is simply a matter of which person leads us to doom...

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

274 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
king arthur said:
On This Week last week (confused) when asked whether the coalition or Nick Clegg would survive until 2015, Michael Portillo thought the coalition would, wasn't so sure about Clegg. Andrew Neil thought Clegg is 50/50 to survive and the coalition parties will go their separate ways by 2014. Wonder who will be right?
Blast it, I missed it. I would imagine that if the Lib-Dems and Conservatives can sit tight they would want to separate and ready themselves for electioneering as separate Parties.

ukwill

10,289 posts

238 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all

Personally I couldn't give a toss. Whoever is in Govt for the next several years is going to suffer.

Wouldn't it be great if, for once, Labour were made o stick around and clear up the mess it left behind?

Only problem with that, is they have no idea of how to turn the money taps off.


or


I'd like to see an election tomorrow and Labour to win. Might sound perverse, but CIF would be bloody hilarious 3 months in.

Actually no, scrap that. I just couldn't wish that on the country, no matter how much I detest the likes of Harmann, Balls, Miliband et al.

king arthur

7,904 posts

292 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
crankedup said:
Blast it, I missed it. I would imagine that if the Lib-Dems and Conservatives can sit tight they would want to separate and ready themselves for electioneering as separate Parties.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01kwlkl/This...

I must say I do like Neil as a political presenter.

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
crankedup said:
As a Lib-Dem myself ....
Shhhhh!!! You don't want to go admitting that around here biggrin I used to be an active party member myself but I never mention it. Oh bugger ......

I think the difficulty for the Lib Dems has been primarily the fact that they have tried to be (and generally succeeded in being) all things to all men as a party of permanent opposition on the national stage. They could be pro-this and ant-that to their hearts content, safe in the knowledge that they would never form a majority parliamentary government, so they wouldn't have to implement their policies.

Then the wishy-washy electorate put them in the position of having to share power and a lot of their, perhaps, more ill-thought-out policies have to go out of the window, followed closely by all those people who have been attracted to the party by its moves to the left of Labour under Paddy Ashdown.

If the party goes back to pre-1964 parliamentary numbers, true "centrist" liberals would continue to vote for them or find a home at the Ken Clarke end of the Tory party or, if there still is one, the right wing end of Labour.

But on a more positive note, there are vast swathes of this country (notably the south west where I am) where voting Labour never really caught on away from the major cities, and the choice has always been between Tories and Liberals. That will continue, and the Tories won't win all of those seats.

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
crankedup said:
Tory backbenchers now very restless and some outspoken tantrums. Cameron and Clegg show joint strength with confidence and commitment to see the five years through. It has to be serious for the two Party leaders having to publicly announce that the Coalition is united. Another six months? I cannot see a minority Government surviving. How do you see it?
They will easily run another 2 years.

Personally I can see 2014 as a year of turmoil. There will not really b anything to pass through by then of any major standing.

Conservatives can then be a minority Government. It would bring some of the 2010 intake into more prominent roles and they can use this as their election platform.

Clegg is unlikely to remain as leader for the 2015 election. Tim Farron likes to think he would be the next leader, if he is then that would be a faster demise of the Lib Dems.

rover 623gsi

5,230 posts

192 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
I am confident – that for better or worse – the Coalition will run a full term as I don’t think that either of the three main parties want a general election at the moment.

I predict that whoever wins the next election there will be no landslide and, it is even possible that although they will undoubtedly lose seats, the Lib Dems could still end up holding the balance of power.

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
Quote edited to remove the potential slanging match content smile

crankedup said:
turbobloke said:
Nothing will happen unless the Tories take a substantial lead over Labour in the polls. Libdems are in single figures a month or so ago at 8% so a general election would be a wipeout for them.
So you don't see the backbench growing anger will put pressure on Cameron by way of a vote of no confidence.
Tory backbenchers can be as unhappy as they like, but they'll be even more unhappy if they find themselves being kicked out by the electorate at a snap early election.

A back bench revolt leading to an election would risk the very same people who engineered it shooting themselves in the foot.

So my vote is with tb on this one.

0a

24,160 posts

225 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
Anyone prepared to put some cash on PaddyPower then?

Year of Coalition Break Up Odds
2012 - 13/2
2013 - 7/2
2014 - 2/1
2015 or later - 5/4

They will last until 2015 in my opinion; both parties will see big losses if there is an election any time soon. They are both hoping something will come around - particularly the Lib Dems.

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
rover 623gsi said:
I am confident – that for better or worse – the Coalition will run a full term as I don’t think that either of the three main parties want a general election at the moment.

I predict that whoever wins the next election there will be no landslide and, it is even possible that although they will undoubtedly lose seats, the Lib Dems could still end up holding the balance of power.
Indeed it will be. I can foresee at present if the Government carry on as they are a Lab/Lib Coalition.

I could see Lib Dems losing in the 2015 election quite badly, but if they end up being the keystone to most governments. Then they may find themselves having a constantly conflicting viewpoint.

turbobloke

117,562 posts

291 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
crankedup said:
turbobloke said:
This thread should have a free placard and guaranteed spot in a town centre local to the OP (for the OP) opposite the mandatory religious nutter.
So you don't see the backbench growing anger will put pressure on Cameron by way of a vote of no confidence. Hopefully you have a deeper understanding of Politics then demonstrated with your apparent lacking of depth of knowledge regarding previous threads. Somehow I very much doubt it.
What's apparent to you is often a mystery, and your view of others is always surpassed by your opinion of yourself so nothing new there.

As to my original comment, with death in the thread title and resurrection of the Libdims needing a miracle it was entirely appropriate.

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

274 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
rs1952 said:
crankedup said:
As a Lib-Dem myself ....
Shhhhh!!! You don't want to go admitting that around here biggrin I used to be an active party member myself but I never mention it. Oh bugger ......

I think the difficulty for the Lib Dems has been primarily the fact that they have tried to be (and generally succeeded in being) all things to all men as a party of permanent opposition on the national stage. They could be pro-this and ant-that to their hearts content, safe in the knowledge that they would never form a majority parliamentary government, so they wouldn't have to implement their policies.

Then the wishy-washy electorate put them in the position of having to share power and a lot of their, perhaps, more ill-thought-out policies have to go out of the window, followed closely by all those people who have been attracted to the party by its moves to the left of Labour under Paddy Ashdown.

If the party goes back to pre-1964 parliamentary numbers, true "centrist" liberals would continue to vote for them or find a home at the Ken Clarke end of the Tory party or, if there still is one, the right wing end of Labour.

But on a more positive note, there are vast swathes of this country (notably the south west where I am) where voting Labour never really caught on away from the major cities, and the choice has always been between Tories and Liberals. That will continue, and the Tories won't win all of those seats.
Yup, I 'came out' some months back, interestingly some of the 'baiter's' have switched from Labour to Lib-Dems in a lost cause to annoy me.
Agree with your summary of the current state of play for the Party, fairly spot on. Unfortunately my patch is total Tory, still keep plugging away smile

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

274 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
crankedup said:
turbobloke said:
This thread should have a free placard and guaranteed spot in a town centre local to the OP (for the OP) opposite the mandatory religious nutter.
So you don't see the backbench growing anger will put pressure on Cameron by way of a vote of no confidence. Hopefully you have a deeper understanding of Politics then demonstrated with your apparent lacking of depth of knowledge regarding previous threads. Somehow I very much doubt it.
What's apparent to you is often a mystery, and your view of others is always surpassed by your opinion of yourself so nothing new there.

As to my original comment, with death in the thread title and resurrection of the Libdims needing a miracle it was entirely appropriate.
And yet you see it as your place to bring forth your unpleasant manner simply because you dislike my political and moral instincts. Like a child throwing the dummy out. Please make an effort to accept that not everyone is greedy, self serving, morally bankrupt and shallow with a distinct hint of bitterness. Oh look now I've gone and been rude to you.

andymadmak

15,729 posts

301 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
I think the problem for the Lib Dems has been that the reality of being in power and actually having to clean up the mess that New Labour left them has bitten hard into the fluffy clouds that so many Lib Dem supporters had taken residence upon in the years leading up to the election. I'm not being disprespectful by saying that. There is no doubt that many Lib Dem supporters heard what they wanted to hear when Clegg said " No Student fees" , "Fair votes" and such like.
The fact that the country cannot afford the former and is not fussed about the latter, and that so much of what the Lib Dems want to do is being swamped by the hostile economic situation has left a lot of Lib Dem supporters feeling utterly betrayed, both by their leaders and by the country as a whole.

I suppose it's one thing to campaign for something whilst secretly knowing you've got F all chance of getting it, and quite another to have your hands (finally) on some levers of power and STILL not get what you want.
As it happens I think that Clegg and Co went into Government for the right reasons. I think they did believe they could make a difference, and that the public would recognise their sacrifice. I also think Cameron and co have tried to make it work.

But the underlying problems of a super debt ridden economy, bloated wasteful public sector and a Eurozone in crisis have been ignored by many voters, who, after the Labour years of "free money" are already (and amazingly) listening to Milliband, Balls, Harman and co and their siren calls of "more free money to come", and "it was all everyone elses fault".

Maybe the Tory vote is holding up better because Tory supporters always knew it would be tough? Whatever the reason I think Lib Dems should take some pride in what they have tried to do with personal tax allowances for example. However it's meltdown for them as a party. Their own young idealogues won't forgive them for student fees and losing the vote on PR, whilst supporters of the main parties will simply become more partisan. Maybe in ten years, a new Lib Dem party will emerge. More likely is that Labour will try to absorb dissaffected Lib Dem voters by offering them the moon on a stick.
Coaltion politics, however worthy the motives, has been a lesson for Clegg & co. To paraphrase "Il est brave, mais ce n'est pas la politique"