Couple buried in tunnel
Discussion
So sad....seems they were just unable to escape their car
No idea why it took so long to find them
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/topics/weather/9405659/...
R.I.P
No idea why it took so long to find them
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/topics/weather/9405659/...
R.I.P
The Don of Croy said:
Just seen this on the DT website - how very tragic.
And how does a car get buried in the (massively over populated) UK for days on end with no-one checking?
If the car was completely buried under 700 tons of mud - I don't think it would be that obvious that there was a car there.And how does a car get buried in the (massively over populated) UK for days on end with no-one checking?
Riley Blue said:
I know that road fairly well and can see how there might be a landslip, but big enough to bury a car? I wouldn't have thought so - very sad.
Very sad indeed.Just cannot understand how they were undiscovered for a week. Granted it's not a major A road but anyone from the Yeovil, Crewkerne, Chard area would use that road to get to Bridport or some of the pretty resorts on the popular Dorset coast (West Bay, Charmouth, Chideock).
I used to use that tunnel all the time when much younger. Friends told me that they always tooted their horn going through it as a mark of respect for a young man killed during the construction of the tunnel.
Very sad news but something isn't adding up here.
Edited: It is an A road.
Also, the date on that video is 10th July so those people taking a look at the landslide are just feet away from the car.... :

Edited by Smart Mart on Tuesday 17th July 16:25
I know this might be 'ghoulish' speculating - but having wathced the news etc. they're all saying how it was a 'million to one' chance that the poor buggers drove under the entrance at exactly the time of the landslip...
I'm wondering if maybe *some* earth had already come down, causing them to stop the car, and then once stopped there, in that time the rest came down?
I mean - what are the chances of *all* the landslip coming down at *exactly* the time that they were at the entrance? Thinking about that - if it had come down at exactly that time, wouldn't the momentum of the vehicle have ensured that they would have at least been moving at that time, and hence the nose of the car got into the tunnel a little bit - and once the weight of it had stopped the car, the nose of the car would have at least been poking out of the front of the landlslip?
As I say - don't want to speculate too much, and it's horrific - but just thinking scientifically about the incident for a moment?
Which yes, I know, doesn't help or bring the poor buggers back. RIP
Horrible.
I'm wondering if maybe *some* earth had already come down, causing them to stop the car, and then once stopped there, in that time the rest came down?
I mean - what are the chances of *all* the landslip coming down at *exactly* the time that they were at the entrance? Thinking about that - if it had come down at exactly that time, wouldn't the momentum of the vehicle have ensured that they would have at least been moving at that time, and hence the nose of the car got into the tunnel a little bit - and once the weight of it had stopped the car, the nose of the car would have at least been poking out of the front of the landlslip?
As I say - don't want to speculate too much, and it's horrific - but just thinking scientifically about the incident for a moment?
Which yes, I know, doesn't help or bring the poor buggers back. RIP

Horrible.
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
I know this might be 'ghoulish' speculating - but having wathced the news etc. they're all saying how it was a 'million to one' chance that the poor buggers drove under the entrance at exactly the time of the landslip...
I'm wondering if maybe *some* earth had already come down, causing them to stop the car, and then once stopped there, in that time the rest came down?
I mean - what are the chances of *all* the landslip coming down at *exactly* the time that they were at the entrance? Thinking about that - if it had come down at exactly that time, wouldn't the momentum of the vehicle have ensured that they would have at least been moving at that time, and hence the nose of the car got into the tunnel a little bit - and once the weight of it had stopped the car, the nose of the car would have at least been poking out of the front of the landlslip?
As I say - don't want to speculate too much, and it's horrific - but just thinking scientifically about the incident for a moment?
Which yes, I know, doesn't help or bring the poor buggers back. RIP
Horrible.
Could well be that the car was stuck in the conditions that immidiatly precursored the main land slide, as you said, doesnt help then...I'm wondering if maybe *some* earth had already come down, causing them to stop the car, and then once stopped there, in that time the rest came down?
I mean - what are the chances of *all* the landslip coming down at *exactly* the time that they were at the entrance? Thinking about that - if it had come down at exactly that time, wouldn't the momentum of the vehicle have ensured that they would have at least been moving at that time, and hence the nose of the car got into the tunnel a little bit - and once the weight of it had stopped the car, the nose of the car would have at least been poking out of the front of the landlslip?
As I say - don't want to speculate too much, and it's horrific - but just thinking scientifically about the incident for a moment?
Which yes, I know, doesn't help or bring the poor buggers back. RIP

Horrible.
TTmonkey said:
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
I know this might be 'ghoulish' speculating - but having wathced the news etc. they're all saying how it was a 'million to one' chance that the poor buggers drove under the entrance at exactly the time of the landslip...
I'm wondering if maybe *some* earth had already come down, causing them to stop the car, and then once stopped there, in that time the rest came down?
I mean - what are the chances of *all* the landslip coming down at *exactly* the time that they were at the entrance? Thinking about that - if it had come down at exactly that time, wouldn't the momentum of the vehicle have ensured that they would have at least been moving at that time, and hence the nose of the car got into the tunnel a little bit - and once the weight of it had stopped the car, the nose of the car would have at least been poking out of the front of the landlslip?
As I say - don't want to speculate too much, and it's horrific - but just thinking scientifically about the incident for a moment?
Which yes, I know, doesn't help or bring the poor buggers back. RIP
Horrible.
Could well be that the car was stuck in the conditions that immidiatly precursored the main land slide, as you said, doesnt help then...I'm wondering if maybe *some* earth had already come down, causing them to stop the car, and then once stopped there, in that time the rest came down?
I mean - what are the chances of *all* the landslip coming down at *exactly* the time that they were at the entrance? Thinking about that - if it had come down at exactly that time, wouldn't the momentum of the vehicle have ensured that they would have at least been moving at that time, and hence the nose of the car got into the tunnel a little bit - and once the weight of it had stopped the car, the nose of the car would have at least been poking out of the front of the landlslip?
As I say - don't want to speculate too much, and it's horrific - but just thinking scientifically about the incident for a moment?
Which yes, I know, doesn't help or bring the poor buggers back. RIP

Horrible.
Given the amount of material that came dowen and how flattened the car was, it's not surprising that no-one found it until they started digging...
I think for me the most surprising thing is that they just left the road alone for ten days. As I said earlier, this is a popular road down to the Dorset coast for people living in the Yeovil & Crewkerne areas.... just can't see why they didn't just try to clear the road earlier.
Although having said that, they found some cracks in the tunnel apparently so might have just marked it down as a long term closure rather than an A road that needed sorting out ASAP.
Although having said that, they found some cracks in the tunnel apparently so might have just marked it down as a long term closure rather than an A road that needed sorting out ASAP.
Smart Mart said:
I think for me the most surprising thing is that they just left the road alone for ten days. As I said earlier, this is a popular road down to the Dorset coast for people living in the Yeovil & Crewkerne areas.... just can't see why they didn't just try to clear the road earlier.
Although having said that, they found some cracks in the tunnel apparently so might have just marked it down as a long term closure rather than an A road that needed sorting out ASAP.
I think that may well prove to be the case. There would need to be a complete structural examination of a such a tunnel before reopening. A landslip of this size that close to a tunnel would require detailed confirmation that the actual tunnel itself was safe before reopeningAlthough having said that, they found some cracks in the tunnel apparently so might have just marked it down as a long term closure rather than an A road that needed sorting out ASAP.
Around the same time a road started cracking outside Seaton in Devon from the dreadful rain. Within two days it had fallen away and collapsed into a fair sized crater and remains closed currently.
Very very sad and most unusual. Tragically on this occasion the consequences to a passing car went unnoticed. Our thoughts must be with the two people killed and the bereaved. Very sad case but I do think that the decisions made were reasonable given the circumstances.
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
I know this might be 'ghoulish' speculating - but having wathced the news etc. they're all saying how it was a 'million to one' chance that the poor buggers drove under the entrance at exactly the time of the landslip...
It's a million-to-one chance that they were there, but not really a million to one that a car would be there.Looking at the photos, you would sort of expect to see a car if it had been caught up: (apparently the masonry crushed it)
http://www.thisissomerset.co.uk/bodies-discovered-...
... and apparently fire crews did examine the scene as best they could, and used thermal imaging:
http://www.dorsetecho.co.uk/news/localnews/9822483...
Seems some enterprising person thought she would not miss her silver.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-somerset-1896...
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-somerset-1896...
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


