MP4's looking good value?
MP4's looking good value?
Author
Discussion

kbf1981

Original Poster:

2,351 posts

231 months

toppstuff

13,698 posts

278 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
kbf1981 said:
Yes, I spotted that car and found myself looking in the back of the sofa for the money...

I wonder if that could be a good buy.

The MP4 12 C has come down a bit, but Mclaren have done well in selling over a 1000 of them in just a year. Given that the focus now is on the Spider, costing over £200k, and with new prices going nowhere but up, I can see a used MP4 12 C getting down to the 120-150k level and then looking like good value compared to a new one. Perhaps at these levels the car's value might show some resistance to more falls?

New Mclarens ( including a SuperMac hyper car) are going to be launched and that is only going to boost the brand. That, in turn, could support the value of used ones once they fall to a sensible level.

Of course, there could be a further number hitting the market as early adopters switch to the Spider, in which case prices could fall further. MInd you, this view could all be bks. smile

I have long given up trying to second guess depreciation...

andrew

10,368 posts

223 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
imho, they'll drop from £200k spec'ed new to half that in three to four years, just like any mass-produced competitor

15HN

420 posts

258 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
I was told that the bid on them are 140k.

kbf1981

Original Poster:

2,351 posts

231 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
15HN said:
I was told that the bid on them are 140k.
That makes it look good value vs. a 458:

1000 miles 458 = £190?
1000 miles MP4 = £160?

DMC2

2,005 posts

242 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
It looks good value until you try and sell it in a years time and get bids of £120k.

JazzyO

1,125 posts

212 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
kbf1981 said:
That makes it look good value vs. a 458:

1000 miles 458 = £190?
1000 miles MP4 = £160?
So you add 3000 miles and try to sell it in a year.

4000 miles 458 = £160?
4000 miles MP4 = £110?

What is good value? What you pay for it, or what you lose on it?


Onno

matc

4,738 posts

238 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
JazzyO said:
kbf1981 said:
That makes it look good value vs. a 458:

1000 miles 458 = £190?
1000 miles MP4 = £160?
So you add 3000 miles and try to sell it in a year.

4000 miles 458 = £160?
4000 miles MP4 = £110?

What is good value? What you pay for it, or what you lose on it?


Onno
I can't see there being a £50k difference between a 458 and an MP4 - the Mac is starting to get some better reviews after the initial trepidation; it's getting a free power hike and Iris should be coming by the end of the year. Plus as has been posted a price hike is also due, so this would make the second hand ones look a bargain in comparison to new.

I think they're a bit of a bargain at the moment.

kbf1981

Original Poster:

2,351 posts

231 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
I can't see one at £110k as what would that put LP's at? And if LP's were £80k....what would that mean for 430's? A good one at £60k? And a 360....good one at £35k?

I think at £120k the MP4 would be crazy value - that's new 997 Turbo money, and less than the 991 Turbo will come out at. The 997 / 991 Turbo is, in a way, the most direct competitor as they're both turbo's, ultra fast cars, that are less "showy" than what's typical of this end of the market imo.

TP321

1,522 posts

229 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
What you are seing now is a lot of cars coming on to the market from speculators. Coupe production is all but stopping in october as production switches to the spider. There is also a £12k price increase in october making even a povety spec car £190k plus. So the existing cars, with their upgraded power and working Iris will look great value at £150k

Sir Snaz

571 posts

217 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
A view from the 'scummy' side of the tracks .....

I have owned some nice cars (couple of porsches, TVRs, AMGs etc etc), and I have driven, but have not yet owned a super/hyper car. IT IS something I will do.....but only when I can really afford it - hence my commenting on this thread.

My view on the MP4 is that it is just not 'WOW' enough to tempt me to spend my hard earned on one. Now I am not talking technical prowess, as I know that technologicaly, it knocks spots off the competition. I am also aware that, at the limit, it probably drives better than anything else out there.......but lets face it, 99% of hypercars are bought as a 'statement' and will only be driven on highdays/holidays and the very occasional track day. For me the MP4 is just too dull....for example I saw one parked next to and Alfa 8C the other day ......guess which car poeple were looking at.

I cant be the only potential hypercar owner that thinks this way...and that is why I think you will see the price of MP4s continue to plummet when compared to, say, the 458 or the equivalent lambo (is that the superleggera or the aventador by the way??)

just my two penneth

snaz

jdw1234

6,021 posts

246 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
kbf1981 said:
I can't see one at £110k as what would that put LP's at? And if LP's were £80k....what would that mean for 430's? A good one at £60k? And a 360....good one at £35k?

I think at £120k the MP4 would be crazy value - that's new 997 Turbo money, and less than the 991 Turbo will come out at. The 997 / 991 Turbo is, in a way, the most direct competitor as they're both turbo's, ultra fast cars, that are less "showy" than what's typical of this end of the market imo.
I see no reason why those prices won't happen.


ditomaso

241 posts

253 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
A Ferrari is a complete package, whereas an MP4 isn't, ie it just doesn't have the soul. Ferrari have managed to take their racing pedigree and apply it to their road cars quite successfully, whereas Mclaren have just created a technical tour de force, great performance & package, but at the moment, it just doesn't have the presence of even a 355/360.

If Mclaren were somehow to able to blend in their racing pedigree, ie the Marlborough Honda branding years etc (something other than boring silver/grey), then I think it would help that special feeling of owning one, but until then, their prices will take a bigger hit than comparative cars like a 458. And as someone has pointed out, a Porsche 991 looks fantastic value in comparison. Just my two penneth, great car but a few years to bed in.

detomaso

1,354 posts

279 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
ditomaso said:
detomaso said:
close but no cigar wink
kbf1891 said:
I can't see one at £110k as what would that put LP's at? And if LP's were £80k....what would that mean for 430's? A good one at £60k? And a 360....good one at £35k?

I think at £120k the MP4 would be crazy value - that's new 997 Turbo money, and less than the 991 Turbo will come out at. The 997 / 991 Turbo is, in a way, the most direct competitor as they're both turbo's, ultra fast cars, that are less "showy" than what's typical of this end of the market imo.
I agree, IMO the MP4 sort of straddles the gap; not quite exotic enough in some minds yet more interesting than an 'every city has a dealer' Porsche, I can't see them dropping down to that level.

andrew

10,368 posts

223 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
ditomaso said:
A Ferrari is a complete package, whereas an MP4 isn't, ie it just doesn't have the soul. Ferrari have managed to take their racing pedigree and apply it to their road cars quite successfully, whereas Mclaren have just created a technical tour de force, great performance & package, but at the moment, it just doesn't have the presence of even a 355/360.

If Mclaren were somehow to able to blend in their racing pedigree, ie the Marlborough Honda branding years etc (something other than boring silver/grey), then I think it would help that special feeling of owning one, but until then, their prices will take a bigger hit than comparative cars like a 458. And as someone has pointed out, a Porsche 991 looks fantastic value in comparison. Just my two penneth, great car but a few years to bed in.
i often see ideas like these and they intrigue me

if * a car is compromised/unappealing/crap in some way, then surely that would apply equally to new car sales, so restricting the supply of used cars and bringing the depreciation curve back to average ?

ime, the only cars that depreciate less than average are those with limited new supply, those maintained regardless of cost over a long period, or, very occasionally, those that become fashionable with time

( * fwiw i quite like the mclaren biggrin )

toppstuff

13,698 posts

278 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
ditomaso said:
A Ferrari is a complete package, whereas an MP4 isn't, ie it just doesn't have the soul. Ferrari have managed to take their racing pedigree and apply it to their road cars quite successfully, whereas Mclaren have just created a technical tour de force, great performance & package, but at the moment, it just doesn't have the presence of even a 355/360.

If Mclaren were somehow to able to blend in their racing pedigree, ie the Marlborough Honda branding years etc (something other than boring silver/grey), then I think it would help that special feeling of owning one, but until then, their prices will take a bigger hit than comparative cars like a 458. And as someone has pointed out, a Porsche 991 looks fantastic value in comparison. Just my two penneth, great car but a few years to bed in.
With the greatest of respect, all this talk about "soul" and "presence" is just guff and bks IMO.

Ferrari's are the equivalent to running around shouting your head off while wearing a mankini. Sometimes thats cool, sometimes it , well, isn't.

I think McLaren are doing well ( sold nearly as many 12C's in their first year as Ferrari sold 458's in their first year, from a standing start with no major dealer network ) and they are are doing well because there are people that like them precisely because they don't make such a fuss. The 12 C is wonderful precisely because it does not have the image of the Ferrari. This is A Good Thing.

I am personally turned off by the "bella-machina-buy-a-scuderia-baseball-cap-and-matching-aftershave-Felipe baby-tifosi-Forza Ferrari!- pasta carbonara-bronzed gigolo-Rod Stewart-Christiano Ronaldo-rosso corsa-don't put too many miles on the clock cos it hurts residuals" bks that goes with Ferrari.

I want a proper car. Made by blokes called Martin, Dave and Steve, in a factory in the UK, without any fuss or nonsense.

In this respect I see the 12C more as a competitor to Porsche 911 Turbos.

Personally, Italians do my head in. Give me some reserved Brits every time.


Edited by toppstuff on Thursday 19th July 12:12

jshell

12,117 posts

236 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
ditomaso said:
A Ferrari is a complete package, .
In what way? Coz if you went to look at an expensive end German rep-mobile and saw the same build quality, you'd walk away.

ditomaso

241 posts

253 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
toppstuff said:
With the greatest of respect, all this talk about "soul" and "presence" is just guff and bks IMO.

Ferrari's are the equivalent to running around shouting your head off while wearing a mankini. Sometimes thats cool, sometimes it , well, isn't.

I think McLaren are doing well ( sold nearly as many 12C's in their first year as Ferrari sold 458's in their first year, from a standing start with no major dealer network ) and they are are doing well because there are people that like them precisely because they don't make such a fuss. The 12 C is wonderful precisely because it does not have the image of the Ferrari. This is A Good Thing.

I am personally turned off by the "bella-machina-buy-a-scuderia-baseball-cap-and-matching-aftershave-Felipe baby-tifosi-Forza Ferrari!- pasta carbonara-bronzed gigolo-Rod Stewart-Christiano Ronaldo-rosso corsa-don't put too many miles on the clock cos it hurts residuals" bks that goes with Ferrari.

I want a proper car. Made by blokes called Martin, Dave and Steve, in a factory in the UK, without any fuss or nonsense.

In this respect I see the 12C more as a competitor to Porsche 911 Turbos.

Personally, Italians do my head in. Give me some reserved Brits every time.


Edited by toppstuff on Thursday 19th July 12:12
Granted the Mclaren attracted a lot of buyers, but I would wager a number of them couldn't get a 458 fast enough & wanted something different, also - I'm guessing a good proportion are Ferrari owners who wanted the latest toy.

As for Ferrari being 'in your face', well lets face it, they are, after all they are stunning cars with performance to match. I agree with the mileage issue, the cars can be driven for thousands of miles, I've put thousands on mine and couldn't give a damn, actually it runs far better.

Only time will tell with the MP4, but its way too clinical, maybe thats the Mclaren way



mattdaniels

7,362 posts

313 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all

Maff

612 posts

298 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
My white MP4 is going on SOR next week with the dealer (due to arrival of 458) and I have been advised to advertise it for £149,995. Bit of a drop from its £206k purchase price, but that's what the market is dictating.