E36 M3 - what are they like, things to look for
E36 M3 - what are they like, things to look for
Author
Discussion

fatherted

Original Poster:

14 posts

208 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
Hi everybody
I looking to purchase a E36 M3, my first M car biggrin. I have been looking at cars around the £4-4.5k mark which would seem to get me a 97ish EVO with less than 100k on the clock

Would there be anything specific i would need to look for with these cars, I found a buyers guide that mentioned about the bushes possibly needing replaced and the rusty rear arches but no mention of potential issues with the engine or gearbox

what are they like to live with day to day, i would be using mine as a 2nd car with a derv dream machine for the work slog
however I will probably use it everyday anyway, will the fuel costs cripple me within a week?

thanks in advance

Edited by fatherted on Wednesday 18th July 19:39

MitchT

17,166 posts

240 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
I looked long and hard at these and have done much digging for info. My findings were as follows...

  • Unmolested cars are hard to find - most have been messed with
  • They love destroying bushes and coil springs, as most BMWs do (but it's not a big deal as they're not a massive cost)
  • Rust is an issue, especially rear arches
  • The bi-vanos on the 3.2 Evo is a weak spot and can be costly to fix. A massive debate is constantly raging as to whether the issue is over-hyped or not, but the fact remains that if you have to fork out more than half a car's value to have one part replaced then you certainly won't think it's over-hyped, so at least be aware of it.
  • The SMG version is best avoided. It's not as good as a manual, is more fragile and costs a hell of a lot more to fix.
  • Insurance is inexplicably expensive and is the sole reason I could never justify buying one. I was quoted £1,500 to insure an E36 M3 worth £5k, compared with half that to insure a 425bhp, 195mph Ferrari 512TR worth £90k. Go figure!

fatherted

Original Poster:

14 posts

208 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
MitchT said:
I looked long and hard at these and have done much digging for info. My findings were as follows...

  • Unmolested cars are hard to find - most have been messed with
  • They love destroying bushes and coil springs, as most BMWs do (but it's not a big deal as they're not a massive cost)
  • Rust is an issue, especially rear arches
  • The bi-vanos on the 3.2 Evo is a weak spot and can be costly to fix. A massive debate is constantly raging as to whether the issue is over-hyped or not, but the fact remains that if you have to fork out more than half a car's value to have one part replaced then you certainly won't think it's over-hyped, so at least be aware of it.
  • The SMG version is best avoided. It's not as good as a manual, is more fragile and costs a hell of a lot more to fix.
  • Insurance is inexplicably expensive and is the sole reason I could never justify buying one. I was quoted £1,500 to insure an E36 M3 worth £5k, compared with half that to insure a 425bhp, 195mph Ferrari 512TR worth £90k. Go figure!
thanks for the info
I am looking for a unmolested example so I can molest it slightly, nothing that cant be removed :P
the insurance is one of the things that is attracting me to it
I had a quote from compare the market for £750 fully comp on a EVO convertible which isn't too shabby and I can probably get it down yet with a bit of shopping around

I have heard about the SMG 'boxes and to be honest I'd prefer the manual anyway.
I will need to delve deeper into this vanos issue.
on other thing i heard was the 3.2s have a habit of spinning con rod shells if they have been thrashed, has anyone heard of this or is it an over hyped issue like the vanos problems mentioned above


MitchT

17,166 posts

240 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
fatherted said:
on other thing i heard was the 3.2s have a habit of spinning con rod shells if they have been thrashed...
It was the E46 that had a regular habit of doing this, to the extent that BMW 'upgraded' the engines which they believed to be affected rather than wait and have to replace the whole unit under warranty if it did fail. As far as the E36 is concerned, I once heard a vague suggestion that this can happen with the 3.2, but it's not a common issue that I am aware of.

Output Flange

17,053 posts

242 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
E46s are known for snapping coil springs, it's not something common on E36s.

Buy the nicest 3.2 you can find. It's a better car than the 3.0. Vanos issues ARE overhyped, there's now a sub-£500 fix for it, and even if it does die you can continue to use the car until you fix it, so it's not the end of the world.

As said, rear arches rust and they're the most obvious part, but check the whole car thoroughly.

Things you want to see have been done:

- braided clutch hose
- bushes, particularly RTABs
- check gearbox doesn't jump out of gear
- no knocks, bangs or strange noises
- exhaust manifold flexi joint isn't cracked and leaking

Some parts for them are expensive compared to standard E36 parts - brake discs are dealer only, for example.

Otherwise just go out, buy one and enjoy it - they're great cars.

MitchT

17,166 posts

240 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
Output Flange said:
E46s are known for snapping coil springs, it's not something common on E36s.
I've owned a 318is from three months old (July '99) and still have it now. It loves coil springs. Nom, nom, nom.

Crackie

6,386 posts

273 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
Output Flange said:
E46s are known for snapping coil springs, it's not something common on E36s.

Buy the nicest 3.2 you can find. It's a better car than the 3.0. Vanos issues ARE overhyped, there's now a sub-£500 fix for it, and even if it does die you can continue to use the car until you fix it, so it's not the end of the world.

As said, rear arches rust and they're the most obvious part, but check the whole car thoroughly.

Things you want to see have been done:

- braided clutch hose
- bushes, particularly RTABs
- check gearbox doesn't jump out of gear
- no knocks, bangs or strange noises
- exhaust manifold flexi joint isn't cracked and leaking

Some parts for them are expensive compared to standard E36 parts - brake discs are dealer only, for example.

Otherwise just go out, buy one and enjoy it - they're great cars.
All good advice there yes. I would add.....

- Drive as many as possible to get a feel for shocks / damping on a good one. A '97 90k mile EVO on original shocks is not likely to impress.
- Ditto the above but for steering rack rather than shocks.
- If possible try and find an owner who can prove they've used a reputable Indie like CPC, Bexley's or similar to service the car.

Some good PH advice on this thread E36 EVO

fatherted

Original Poster:

14 posts

208 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
thanks for the advice guys
I'll have to put my intended purchase on hold for the moment but it will give me more time to look over any info i can find and search for the right car
I was also considering an EVO 5 but the insurance is not far off the 1k mark where as the M3 will be about £750, so that rules the lancer out

Crackie

6,386 posts

273 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
Hi fatherted - I forgot to say what they're like. Hold out for a good one and you won't regret it. thumbup. Great engine, easily as quick as an E46, great noise, sensible running costs/mpg. Assuming you're OK with the relatively dated interior, a good EVO, with uprated shocks or coilovers with fresh steering / quicker rack, can easily hold its own against new machines.

Treat the VANOS with care while warming the car up; if you're unlucky enough to have an issue then http://www.mrvanos.com/ can sort for sensible money.

Edited by Crackie on Thursday 19th July 22:35

fatherted

Original Poster:

14 posts

208 months

Thursday 19th July 2012
quotequote all
Crackie said:
Hi fatherted - I forgot to say what they're like. Hold out for a good one and you won't regret it. thumbup. Great engine, easily as quick as an E46, great noise, sensible running costs/mpg. Assuming you're OK with the relatively dated interior, a good EVO, with uprated shocks or coilovers with fresh steering / quicker rack, can easily hold its own against new machines.

Treat the VANOS with care while warming the car up; if you're unlucky enough to have an issue then http://www.mrvanos.com/ can sort for sensible money.

Edited by Crackie on Thursday 19th July 22:35
the interior doesn't really bother me too much, a mate has a 328 that got written off last weekend and I've always like the way the dash gives the impression that its wrapped around the driver
if i do get a hold of one then i will be making a few changes over time but nothing that can't be reversed and my mate was saying that i could have a couple of tasty bits from his 328i as apparently they will bolt on no bother

cheers

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Friday 20th July 2012
quotequote all
fatherted said:
I was also considering an EVO 5 but the insurance is not far off the 1k mark where as the M3 will be about £750, so that rules the lancer out
If a £250 additional insurance premium is a deal breaker are you sure you are looking at the right sort of car?

fatherted

Original Poster:

14 posts

208 months

Friday 20th July 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
If a £250 additional insurance premium is a deal breaker are you sure you are looking at the right sort of car?
I could happily run the M3 or the EVO no bother, I have a rule about insurance which is to never pay more for any one car than what i did for my first car which was a 1.1 fiesta that cost me £860 for the year
I've managed to stay under it so far and its the way I intend to keep it unless it's something pretty special


Edited by fatherted on Friday 20th July 13:28

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Friday 20th July 2012
quotequote all
Output Flange said:
Some parts for them are expensive compared to standard E36 parts - brake discs are dealer only, for example.
Not so. You can get Mintex Evo discs for less than £100 the pair.

As above really. You may struggle to find a good one for £4500. Lots of shiny ones, but good cars that haven't been ragged, rechipped and pissed about with are more money. I'd be looking to spend 6K plus on a proper one with proper history and few owners. Four doors are sometimes cheaper.

Output Flange

17,053 posts

242 months

Friday 20th July 2012
quotequote all
Are the Mintex proper floating OEM equivalent discs?

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Friday 20th July 2012
quotequote all
Output Flange said:
Are the Mintex proper floating OEM equivalent discs?
Yup, they're identical. A mate bought a pair last week - for £120 with pads you can't moan. Even if they were solid, you'd think twice about paying £400 for BMW boxed discs.