Greek examples of taking the michael
Greek examples of taking the michael
Author
Discussion

rogerthefish

Original Poster:

2,399 posts

262 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
Once again the Greeks are trying to defer payments of the EMF bailout by saying the cuts are too much but as a person currently in Greece for a 7 day hol they appear to be taking the pxxs royally.

We've seen media reports of no medicines because of lack of funds by the government, yet a packet of English cigarettes is 3.80€ (£3) and they have Europes highest amount of smokers (40%). Can the price be doubled/tripled.

Alcohol, away from the tourist area's the price of pint is €1.

Cars, no parking charges on town streets/no traffic wardens/so people park literally anywhere.

Counterfeit goods displayed in shops without worries.

Three times I've hired a car from different places-always to be told the card machine is not working-can I pay cash.

So clearly they are having a laugh at the EU's expense!

Anyone else have examples of Greeks waste or abuse?.

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
The Black economy rules, just like Spain

baz1985

3,685 posts

276 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
The ability of Western powers to preach about anti-corruption measures to developing nations can no longer tantamount to anything beyond sanctimonious hogwash.

rogerthefish

Original Poster:

2,399 posts

262 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
So just doing a bit of a fag packet calculation.

So cigarettes go up tommorrow €4 a packet
10 mil population = 4 mil smokers
So say on average I pack a day = 16 mil x 365
Equals 5.8€ billion, which buys a lot of medical care
or helps towards emf loan, and that just cigarettes !

They really are laughing at Europe

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
You don't seem to be delineating between individual action and that of 'the Greeks'.

Individual motivation is simple - self preservation. Those people taking cash instead of using the machine are making sure they have cash to survive - as would you if you needed to make sure your family had food and a roof.

The other stuff - prices of fags and booze - is different. But what would happen if the Greek 'government' massively increased duty on fags and booze? Do you think they would see a windfall in revenues? Who would be buying the fags and booze at these new prices?

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
rogerthefish said:
So just doing a bit of a fag packet calculation.

So cigarettes go up tommorrow €4 a packet
10 mil population = 4 mil smokers
So say on average I pack a day = 16 mil x 365
Equals 5.8€ billion, which buys a lot of medical care
or helps towards emf loan, and that just cigarettes !

They really are laughing at Europe
Why single out cigarettes for a bizarre extreme tax-gaining excercise?
SImply doubling the price of cigarettes overnight is as unrealistic as putting the tax rate up to 70%. It's pointless saying it.

Dogwatch

6,387 posts

253 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
True we haven't had a bailout from Brussels - in fact they keep demanding more from us frown - but our home grown black economy is probably quite healthy if HMRC could get their hands on it.

Like the Greeks we know that our taxes will be spent on the overpaid and underworked.

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
rogerthefish said:
So just doing a bit of a fag packet calculation.

So cigarettes go up tommorrow €4 a packet
10 mil population = 4 mil smokers
So say on average I pack a day = 16 mil x 365
Equals 5.8€ billion, which buys a lot of medical care
or helps towards emf loan, and that just cigarettes !

They really are laughing at Europe
Roger

Do you think every smoker in the UK pays the full price for cigs and buys them at the local shop?

I think there is a large grey/black market in things like cigs, CDs, sky tv cards etc which means that the only mugs that pay full price for theings are the law abiders, who pay their way anyway.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
johnfm said:
Roger

Do you think every smoker in the UK pays the full price for cigs and buys them at the local shop?

I think there is a large grey/black market in things like cigs, CDs, sky tv cards etc which means that the only mugs that pay full price for theings are the law abiders, who pay their way anyway.
True enough. We have a massive problem with black market cigarettes in this country, and we only have a land border with Ireland.



Check out some of the lovely places Greece borders and figure out what would happen if they started jacking up the duty on fags and booze when they have no money to pay the border guards.

rogerthefish

Original Poster:

2,399 posts

262 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
And counterfeit goods in shops, are the Greeks just allowed to do want they want and expect everyone else to fund they're lazy lifestyle...I guess so then

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
rogerthefish said:
And counterfeit goods in shops, are the Greeks just allowed to do want they want and expect everyone else to fund they're lazy lifestyle...I guess so then
Where do you get the money to fund the police or trading standards officers from?

don4l

10,058 posts

207 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
rogerthefish said:
So just doing a bit of a fag packet calculation.

So cigarettes go up tommorrow €4 a packet
10 mil population = 4 mil smokers
So say on average I pack a day = 16 mil x 365
Equals 5.8€ billion, which buys a lot of medical care
or helps towards emf loan, and that just cigarettes !

They really are laughing at Europe
Cigarettes in Greece are already twice as expensive as in most of its neighbours. A packet of Marlborough is only €1.81 in Albania. Putting the price up to €7.95 would produce such an increase in smuggling that tobacco duty receipts would collapse.


Don
--

Getragdogleg

10,318 posts

214 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
Speaking as someone who goes to Greece regularly I think we are the ones who have it wrong. We have loads of tax that pays for bone idle tts to laze about, oh, and a huge public sector full of non productive paper shufflers, a road network that is suffering from underinvestment, you cant park anywhere near a town, you cant' nip to the shop for some fags if you are in a car and we pay through the nose for all the stuff we buy, we are "stable" and largely pay our taxes yet we are miserable, life here is filled with parking fines, speed cameras, regulations and control and yet we are not happy, the Greeks are happier, they don't give a st about silly rules some paper pushers in another country have made up and they have a simpler day to day life, their roads are bad but then, so are ours.


blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
don4l said:
Cigarettes in Greece are already twice as expensive as in most of its neighbours. A packet of Marlborough is only €1.81 in Albania. Putting the price up to €7.95 would produce such an increase in smuggling that tobacco duty receipts would collapse.


Don
--
Exactly. GIven that it seems they are more than willing to operate with a black market then sales would fall to zero overnight.
THere is no quick-fix. It's too extreme. However irritating all these things are to hear, it is not realistic to suddenly say to people "Oh, IM doubling the price of X,Y or Z". People don't tolerate this. The only way to do this is slowly-slowly austerity measures: small cuts everywhere and slight tax increases everywhere.
Look how much rebellion they are having doing that?

philthy

4,697 posts

271 months

Tuesday 24th July 2012
quotequote all
Hike the the tax on booze and fags in Greece, and they will simply pop over the border to their nearest EU neighbour (Bulgaria). That's if they can't be bothered to take the risk of Albania, or Turkey.

Digga

48,613 posts

314 months

Tuesday 24th July 2012
quotequote all
Part of the problem - and we are beginning to see it here - is legitimacy of law. If the establishment - government and large institutions - are seen to be taking the piss;duck houses, Libor fixing etc. etc., then the disenfranchisement manifests itself in a very strong counter-culture.

We are not a million miles from the feeling prevalent in France, immediately prior to the revolution. I'm not suggesting the UK or EU will see similar bloodshed, but nevertheless something has to give and, to an extent in the UK, with LIbor and phone tapping cases and the like, this is happening. In Greece, cronyism is still rife amongst the government and rightly or wrongly this does ned a certain legitimacy to the black economy.

muffinmenace

1,100 posts

219 months

Tuesday 24th July 2012
quotequote all
So the consensus over the last few posts is that what they really need is a common fiscal policy scratchchin

Getragdogleg

10,318 posts

214 months

Tuesday 24th July 2012
quotequote all
muffinmenace said:
So the consensus over the last few posts is that what they really need is a common fiscal policy scratchchin
My point is that while the people are happy and the state does not interfere with their daily lives too much then they will tolerate the excesses and general piss taking of the ruling class, duck houses and expense fiddles are part of daily life the same as dodgy fags and the black market is to the proles.

If the politicians continue to make it hard for the people to go about their daily lives or indulge in fiddles and perks but still go on troughing themselves all the while telling the people they must face "cuts" or "austerity" then the people will revolt or ignore.

Greece is largly in the "ignore" camp unless they are not getting paid, then they move to the revolt camp unless it is too hot to bother.

Lady Muck

1,184 posts

240 months

Tuesday 24th July 2012
quotequote all
Getragdogleg said:
Speaking as someone who goes to Greece regularly I think we are the ones who have it wrong. We have loads of tax that pays for bone idle tts to laze about, oh, and a huge public sector full of non productive paper shufflers, a road network that is suffering from underinvestment, you cant park anywhere near a town, you cant' nip to the shop for some fags if you are in a car and we pay through the nose for all the stuff we buy, we are "stable" and largely pay our taxes yet we are miserable, life here is filled with parking fines, speed cameras, regulations and control and yet we are not happy, the Greeks are happier, they don't give a st about silly rules some paper pushers in another country have made up and they have a simpler day to day life, their roads are bad but then, so are ours.
Spot on.

And that is why I am saving to leave for Cyprus and build a simple home there.

Digga

48,613 posts

314 months

Tuesday 24th July 2012
quotequote all
Lady Muck said:
Getragdogleg said:
Speaking as someone who goes to Greece regularly I think we are the ones who have it wrong. We have loads of tax that pays for bone idle tts to laze about, oh, and a huge public sector full of non productive paper shufflers, a road network that is suffering from underinvestment, you cant park anywhere near a town, you cant' nip to the shop for some fags if you are in a car and we pay through the nose for all the stuff we buy, we are "stable" and largely pay our taxes yet we are miserable, life here is filled with parking fines, speed cameras, regulations and control and yet we are not happy, the Greeks are happier, they don't give a st about silly rules some paper pushers in another country have made up and they have a simpler day to day life, their roads are bad but then, so are ours.
Spot on.

And that is why I am saving to leave for Cyprus and build a simple home there.
Do a bit of homework first if either of you beleive Greece is free of an overgrown public sector or bureaucracy! I have family out there and can assure you that even though the black econmoy is alive and kicking, the clunking fist of the state still makes itself felt in many areas.