Gay marriage to be introduced in Scotland
Discussion
OK, firstly, I'm not posting this as anything to do with the independence debate - please try and not take it in that direction.
But the Scottish Government's decision to allow gay marriage - a good thing?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-pol...
An irrelevent thing. Just as it was in the rest of the country. All that has happened is that it has allowed gay cpls to get gay married and then gay divorced. Hurrah for social advancement.
(All of our gay friends who have got married, have got divorced, in most cases having previously been happily together for several yrs)
(All of our gay friends who have got married, have got divorced, in most cases having previously been happily together for several yrs)
Definitely a good thing. Why have two pieces of legislation (Marriage and Civil Partnership) for one thing?
I have no doubt some militants will try to force an "anti" church to perform a gay marriage but I can't see why the vast majority of people would want to be part of or married by an institution that doesn't treat all it's members equally.
I have no doubt some militants will try to force an "anti" church to perform a gay marriage but I can't see why the vast majority of people would want to be part of or married by an institution that doesn't treat all it's members equally.
Caulkhead said:
I can't see what difference this makes - Scottish law already gives same sex 'unions' the same legal rights as married people and they claim no religious types will be forced to marry anyone they don't want to so what's the change?
It's called the same thing now (important distinction to many) and the civil partnership legislation can be thrown away.Caulkhead said:
I can't see what difference this makes - Scottish law already gives same sex 'unions' the same legal rights as married people and they claim no religious types will be forced to marry anyone they don't want to so what's the change?
Ask that question to a gay couple! I think the key word in all this is 'equality'.b
hstewie said:
hstewie said: Does anyone actually care? Maybe because I'm not gay I'm insensitive and it is a big deal?
I can see why people care because it's about equality but most str8 people I know actually prefer the civil partnership now because they are not religious but at the same time want to celebrate their feelings for eachotherduckers26 said:
I can see why people care because it's about equality but most str8 people I know actually prefer the civil partnership now because they are not religious but at the same time want to celebrate their feelings for eachother
Personally I'm not religious either.I do find it a little odd though when a law decided in a relatively short amount of time trumps hundreds of years of religious teaching.
duckers26 said:
I can see why people care because it's about equality but most str8 people I know actually prefer the civil partnership now because they are not religious but at the same time want to celebrate their feelings for eachother
Straight people can't legally have a "civil partnership". I attach no religious meaning to marriage, as I'm not religious, and it is a societal, legal construct not a religious one.b
hstewie said:
hstewie said: Personally I'm not religious either.
I do find it a little odd though when a law decided in a relatively short amount of time trumps hundreds of years of religious teaching.
I think it's a good thing, shows how fast society and attitudes are improving. Out with the old, in with the new!I do find it a little odd though when a law decided in a relatively short amount of time trumps hundreds of years of religious teaching.
b
hstewie said:
hstewie said:duckers26 said:
I can see why people care because it's about equality but most str8 people I know actually prefer the civil partnership now because they are not religious but at the same time want to celebrate their feelings for eachother
Personally I'm not religious either.I do find it a little odd though when a law decided in a relatively short amount of time trumps hundreds of years of religious teaching.
Efbe said:
the only people that won't like this are the stupid
I personally think that both gay and straight people should have the choice of marriage or civil partnership to suit whether they are religious or not. I am hopefully going into CP after 11yrs together but am horrified at the cost of it which would buy a nice car!duckers26 said:
Efbe said:
the only people that won't like this are the stupid
I personally think that both gay and straight people should have the choice of marriage or civil partnership to suit whether they are religious or not. I am hopefully going into CP after 11yrs together but am horrified at the cost of it which would buy a nice car!
I wasn't meaning you being stupid, just those that oppose gay marriage, because they don't like gays!I got married to the mrs despite being anti-religious, though not in a church. For me I couldn't give two s
ts about the religious side of it, The concept of a marriage/coupling/wedding was around long before all this b
ks christianity rubbish, and will be around long after it.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriage#History_of_m...
vonuber said:
I think the main reason people want church weddings is because the buildings are a pretty good setting.
They do look nice in the photos. When I was best man two years ago me, the groom and the bride had to go three time before he'd take our cash! Didn't dare take my boyfriend!ViperPict said:
Caulkhead said:
I can't see what difference this makes - Scottish law already gives same sex 'unions' the same legal rights as married people and they claim no religious types will be forced to marry anyone they don't want to so what's the change?
Ask that question to a gay couple! I think the key word in all this is 'equality'.Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


