Treat me like an idiot... Diesel (not Beemer) remap
Treat me like an idiot... Diesel (not Beemer) remap
Author
Discussion

Dibble

Original Poster:

13,292 posts

271 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
I've just bought a 2008 Saab 9-3 1.9 TiD with quoted BHP of 150.

Frankly, having come from a 2.5 Turbo petrol Volvo, the Saab is a bit... Pedestrian.

A quick Google shows plenty of places that will do an engine remap via the ODB port and increase the BHP to around 175-180 and also the Nm jobby (whatever that is). The websites all claim that this won't reduce miles per gallon, but will in fact increase it.

So how successful is this type of mod? Is it worth doing? Will I notice the improvement? Does anyone have any recommendations of software to request?

I'm a mechanical moron, so this is all just shy of necromancy for me. As a result, any explanations should be VERY dumbed down. Aim for a four year old and we'll do fine.

SomeMinorTrouble

378 posts

173 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
Where I work we do viezu remaps.
We always get good feedback and the general opinion is its good VFM at £299
It usually takes around 3 hours to install.(usually takes alot less than this when the workshop is empty)
http://www.viezu.com/Your-Vehicle/Saab/9-3/9-3-1.9...
thats the stats for your car, the improved mpg through extra power is because you get more power at less revs=less revs used=less fuel used.
hope this helps.

TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
It'll take about an hour or so, and you'll end up with a car that's completely different to before.
You'll get faster acceleration when accelerating, and better MPGs when cruising, so provided you don't have terrible MPGs at the moment, you should see an average increase.

What will be done is increases in the amount of fuel injected, increased turbo boost, and raised limiters for various things.
You might also get changed injection timing and fuel pressures in some cases, so all in all, there may be 15-20 or so data tables altered in the ECU.

reaper668

495 posts

240 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
I've just fitted a Diesel Express tuning box to my 08 1.9cdti Vectra which I'm led to believe is the same engine as your Saab and it feels like a completely different car now. It seems much smoother and the acceleration has really improved. I am getting more MPG too.

http://www.dieselexpress.co.uk/

Colonial

13,553 posts

236 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
SomeMinorTrouble said:
Where I work we do viezu remaps.
We always get good feedback and the general opinion is its good VFM at £299
It usually takes around 3 hours to install.(usually takes alot less than this when the workshop is empty)
http://www.viezu.com/Your-Vehicle/Saab/9-3/9-3-1.9...
thats the stats for your car, the improved mpg through extra power is because you get more power at less revs=less revs used=less fuel used.
hope this helps.
I run a viezu remap on my Golf. Not a diesel, but still.

Good tune. Real good tune. Very happy with it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
Dibble said:
I'm a mechanical moron, so this is all just shy of necromancy for me. As a result, any explanations should be VERY dumbed down. Aim for a four year old and we'll do fine.
That made me laugh - brilliantly put sir!

redtwin

7,518 posts

213 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
I have used emaps before. Simon (I think it's a one man operation) comes to you and does it on your drive or wherever. Takes about an hour, he reads the original map on your car, sends a copy to a tuner in Germany who twiddles it, e-mails it back to Simon who uploads it to your car.

His prices depends on how far will have to travel to you (he is based in Walsall).

This is what his website quotes for your car:

http://www.e-maps.co.uk/products/Saab/9-3/

I did rolling road tests before and after and found that the increase on my car (yes, a BMW) was actually greater than quoted.

I hear a lot of warnings regarding tuning boxes as they only alter fuelling whereas a remap changes many other parameters and can limit excessive torque which could damage your engine /gearbox.

GenePoolReject13

1,970 posts

220 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
I had a company called Celtic tuning remap my old Focus TDCI. Stats stated power went from 115bhp to around 150bhp. It certainly felt like the quoted figures and the 1.8 TDCI has a flat spot from 3100-3500rpm which disappeared. After the map was done it pulled all the way through the revs. It changed how the car drove, it was much more usable afterwards.
As for fuel consumption, I cant say there was much of an increase but I never got any less than before the remap was done, there might have been a slight increase but any difference was marginal. I wouldn't bother if fuel consumption was your primary reason for having it done.
As for Celtic tuning, the remap cost me £400 but this was 3-4 years ago so prices may have changed. They were very pleasant to work with with and they came and mapped the car on my driveway, once done the techie bloke came on a test drive with me to make sure I was happy with the results and it took about 90 minutes from start to finish. They were recommended to me and I would happily recommended them to anyone else.

Oh and no I don't work for them.

900T-R

20,406 posts

288 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
There's a big difference between a 'tuning box' and a remap.

A tuning box intercepts the signals from the various engine sensors and changes them so the ECU, for instance, sees a lower engine temperature and then starts to inject more fuel than in would have otherwise. This, of course, is a rather crude way to do things and can wreak havoc with things like diesel particle filter regeneration.

The reason 'tuning boxes' get sold is that car manufacturers are using increasingly sophisticated methotds to protect their ECU software from being 'hacked' by a third party (the tuner). Where the code of a certain ECU has not (yet) been cracked, a tuning box will neatly circumvent the security measures.

As it takes the electronics wizards a lot more time to actually gain access and decipher the ECU data to the point that they can change all the relevant parameters than to actually tune the car, there are few companies who actually do the programming. Most tuning outfits download their maps from a third party - if they're serious, acting as an official distributor and paying for their downloads, if they're cowboys they might just download something of unknown origin they found on the web.

Also, there might still be the odd chancers out there who just increase fueling all across the board and slap an abitrary hp/torque figure on their sales material, instead of developing their maps on an actual car, using a rolling road and making sure that certain parameters don't cause any problems in the lnoger term (for instance, if you make an engine more efficient to the point that combustion temps are lowered under normal driving conditions, you might end up with a choked diesel particulate filter and a hefty bill a few thousand miles down the road because the regeneration process only starts at a certain temperature).

There will be less of them than before, as gaining access to the ECU data in itself has become so much more difficult and time consuming, but you still may run into one of them especially if you have an older car with a less sophisticated management system. Forewarned is forearmed.

All in all, reputation is everything in this field. If your local mobile ECU tuning geezer is doing the job, it's important to know where the maps originate from. In this case, either a large outfit like Superchips or BBR or BSR (Sweden), would be fine as would reputable Saab/Vauxhall tuning specialists.


ch427

12,038 posts

264 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
had both my passat petrol turbo and transporter diesel done, very happy with the results. mpg went up slightly in both and performance difference was like night and day.
used angel tuning on the passat and a local guy on the transporter

Andy_sx

2,410 posts

237 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
Had an 08 Astra 1.9cdti remapped a few years ago by Angel Tuning, have known them through the Fiat forums from their inception, so trusted them. Power went from circa 150 - 180 bhp and torque was increased aswell. Took the tech a coupe of hours all told. Driving difference was night and day, you could feel the extra power and torque from low down, and the engine would rev alot more freely. MPG improved by around 5mpg.

It is worth it if you are after a combination of more poke, better driveability and more mpg, but if you are chasing just mpg, the outlay will take a fair old while to re coup.

jatinder

1,667 posts

244 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
I would avoid superchip style maps (upload onto ECU and forget) and would rather go go for someone who will tailor each map to an individual car.

My Thorney map was quite frankly rubbish, lean at the bottom and over fuelling at the top of the rev range, which has now caused some problems further down the line!

I went to Courtenay's and they they put there own on and tweaked it, the car is completely different to drive!

Remaps are great but make sure you get a good one and do you research thoroughly and enjoy.

Edited by jatinder on Wednesday 1st August 09:09

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

187 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
900T-R said:
There's a big difference between a 'tuning box' and a remap.

A tuning box intercepts the signals from the various engine sensors and changes them so the ECU, for instance, sees a lower engine temperature and then starts to inject more fuel than in would have otherwise. This, of course, is a rather crude way to do things and can wreak havoc with things like diesel particle filter regeneration.

The reason 'tuning boxes' get sold is that car manufacturers are using increasingly sophisticated methotds to protect their ECU software from being 'hacked' by a third party (the tuner). Where the code of a certain ECU has not (yet) been cracked, a tuning box will neatly circumvent the security measures.

As it takes the electronics wizards a lot more time to actually gain access and decipher the ECU data to the point that they can change all the relevant parameters than to actually tune the car, there are few companies who actually do the programming. Most tuning outfits download their maps from a third party - if they're serious, acting as an official distributor and paying for their downloads, if they're cowboys they might just download something of unknown origin they found on the web.

Also, there might still be the odd chancers out there who just increase fueling all across the board and slap an abitrary hp/torque figure on their sales material, instead of developing their maps on an actual car, using a rolling road and making sure that certain parameters don't cause any problems in the lnoger term (for instance, if you make an engine more efficient to the point that combustion temps are lowered under normal driving conditions, you might end up with a choked diesel particulate filter and a hefty bill a few thousand miles down the road because the regeneration process only starts at a certain temperature).

There will be less of them than before, as gaining access to the ECU data in itself has become so much more difficult and time consuming, but you still may run into one of them especially if you have an older car with a less sophisticated management system. Forewarned is forearmed.

All in all, reputation is everything in this field. If your local mobile ECU tuning geezer is doing the job, it's important to know where the maps originate from. In this case, either a large outfit like Superchips or BBR or BSR (Sweden), would be fine as would reputable Saab/Vauxhall tuning specialists.
Agreed. If you're just using a piggy-back device that alters turbo-boost levels or fueling then you can end up with a knackered DPF, CAT or a melted turbo. Take it to someone who is actually changing the map on the ECU.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
jatinder said:
My Thorney map was quite frankly rubbish
Yes, I can see the problem with it right there hehe

FoundOnRoadside

436 posts

175 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
jatinder said:
My Thorney map was quite frankly rubbish
Yes, I can see the problem with it right there hehe
Yeah, them of the blame shift. "Oh, don't use Tesco 99, it'll pop your engine". No, that'll be your st remaps popping the engines... laugh

Ranger 6

7,736 posts

280 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
redtwin said:
I have used emaps before. Simon (I think it's a one man operation) comes to you and does it on your drive or wherever....

http://www.e-maps.co.uk/products/Saab/9-3/
Simon has an excellent reputation for quality work. He's the one I'd use.

I heard Viezu evolved out of the old Chipped UK - don't know how true that is but older PHers may remember some funny threads?


TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
All the funny threads have been deleted now I think, some were borderline "Epic"!

Hub

7,172 posts

229 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
Manufacturer and/or model specific forums always have a wealth of information on tuneable cars. Find yourself a popular UK Saab forum and there will be loads of info - in particular what is recommended for that model, and whether there are any weak points i.e. is your clutch going to slip and ultimately fail as a result of too much torque, or will the turbo explode etc.

Colonial

13,553 posts

236 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
TheEnd said:
All the funny threads have been deleted now I think, some were borderline "Epic"!
Missed them all.

I'm happy with the tune and has seen strong gains.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
Tuning boxes are a bit st IMO. I've heard they sometimes do things like intercept the fuel rail pressure signal, dial it down, and then pass it to the ECU. So the ECU will then open the injectors longer to get the fuel it needs at the lower pressure. However in reality the pressure is just fine and the extra duration causes it to overfuel.

A lot of indy's seem to be offering remaps nowadays. Which is better than a tuning box but not as good as a rolling road remap; since what a lot of these guys are doing is buying the hardware required to upload maps, which they purchase under license from the big players. It's therefore not customised to your car.

A rolling road remap by someone who knows what they are doing is the best option.