Looking for a nice E28
Looking for a nice E28
Author
Discussion

Embryonic

Original Poster:

4,485 posts

206 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
I've been really tempted by E28s recently (well either that or a Porsche 924, but the BMW is sneaking ahead now). I'm thinking that a tidy 525i or 528i auto would be a very nice thing to smoke about in.

Any tips on what I should be looking out for? Obviously they're getting on a bit so rust is clearly going to be a potential danger area, but where in particular should I be looking for it?

Are there any other major issues to pay attention to?


And finally, prices - there are a couple of nice ones around but they seem rather expensive (the 4-Star 528i being a prime example), but it often seems that the tidy examples are 520s or 518s. Is it worth saving a few quid, buying one of these instead and fitting a larger engine to it? Prices seem to be a bit all over the place really.



Any opinions on this car? It looks nice, although I'd much rather have a bit more grunt: http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/4048546.htm


E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all
That car looks nice enough, although being a 525e it has a M20 2.7 litres 'high efficency' engine about 121bhp and 170lb/ft of torque.

Being a M20 it will have cambelt not a chain like the M30 fitted to all othe I6 E28's, so check when this was last changed, anything more than 4+ years and it'll need a new one.

Embryonic

Original Poster:

4,485 posts

206 months

Wednesday 1st August 2012
quotequote all


Yeah, that's what I mean about ideally wanting a bit more power, although the car itself is pretty much what I'd be looking for, aside from the fact that I'd want some nice OEM or aftermarket BBS alloys fitting.

Thanks for the M20 cam belt tip too, I didn't know that. I'm not sure whether to go for a lesser engine and see how I get on or hold out for a "proper" 525/528, which will doubtless a cost a chunk more in similar condition.

Embryonic

Original Poster:

4,485 posts

206 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
V8 TEJ said:
I recently had an urge to buy an E28 too and bought this one about a month ago...
Thanks for your reply, and your E28 looks lovely. The exterior/interior colour combo really works for me, and the wheels are ace. I'm guessing you don't have any photos of it lowered? I'd be in two minds on whether to leave it at standard height or just give it a slight drop, and you might convince me one way or the other.

I'd only be intending to use it as something to pootle about in at weekends and nice days, so I'm not entirely convinced I need the power of a 525 or 528 - but I do keep thinking that in an automatic example it would be nice to have that extra urge for over-takes and motorway use.


Where did you find your example? Aside from the usual places (PH, Car and Classic, Classic Cars For Sale, ebay, BMW5.co.uk), is there anywhere else I should be looking?

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
The Four Star one is too much money. Really, £3500 should be plenty for a nice E28 although an M535i will be more. The 525i is alright but with 150bhp they're not that great. UK 525e's are all automatics which is a pity as the manual version was so much better.
Choosing which model to buy is the wrong way to go about it - buy on condition. You'd be much better off with a mint 520i than an overheating stbox of a 528i that you're constantly fixing. These cars are about wafting along rather than racing folk. The 518i was better than you'd think but with the four cylinder engine they do lack sparkle and feel ordinary.
There have been a few low mileage minters on Ebay of late, mainly the more prosaic models but still worth having.

bmthnick1981

5,320 posts

247 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
V8 TEJ said:
I recently had an urge to buy an E28 too and bought this one about a month ago. It had a fortune spent on it by the previous owner so is immaculate inside/outside/underneath. Also has lovely leather interior which made this more appealing to me than others out there. It's only a 520i and I usually drive something 2.5 litre and upwards but the condition and spec made it too good to pass up. Certainly lacks oomph compared to the V8 Jaguar I used to cover the daily 60 mile commute in, but doesn't feel underpowered and returns about 34 mpg average even though it gets driven pretty hard. It still has the nice old school BMW 6 pot noise and is a nice drive. There seems to be less love out there for the 520 and 525 and upwards seem to be favoured. Not an issue for me as 130 bhp pulling about 1250 kg is perfectly acceptable in my book.

The ride is lovely. Over potholes/speedbumps it's actually better than my XJ8 was while still giving a good feedback to the driver. I have lowered it slightly since the photos (not a lot only 35mm) which has sharpened up the handling whilst still retaining the comfort.

The prices for these do vary a lot but I think it's worth paying the extra for the best you can afford as then like me, you just get in and drive it with no worries. Rust is a problem of course, jacking points being the first to go so make sure these areas are strong and that the level of repair is good.

So far I'm really happy I found this car and can't wait to drive it home from work...:-)











Edited by V8 TEJ on Wednesday 8th August 16:55
That is lovely, love the wheels. Excellent purchase!

Output Flange

17,053 posts

242 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
That 525e does look nice. You can put an "i" head on that engine to give it more oomph, and you can also swap the diff to a slightly shorter one to improve acceleration too, without affecting usability or refinement.

A 528i is a reasonably pokey machine, even with an auto box.

Doing an auto -> manual swap is pretty straightforward too, so don't worry too much about what's fitted currently (in any model).

Oh, and you have mail incoming about that E23...

Embryonic

Original Poster:

4,485 posts

206 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
iSore said:
Choosing which model to buy is the wrong way to go about it - buy on condition.
Yeah, deep down I know that. It would just be nice to find a minty fresh 528 auto that's the best of both worlds.

And the 4-Star one is undoubtedly nice, but silly money.

Output Flange said:
That 525e does look nice. You can put an "i" head on that engine to give it more oomph, and you can also swap the diff to a slightly shorter one to improve acceleration too, without affecting usability or refinement.

A 528i is a reasonably pokey machine, even with an auto box.

Doing an auto -> manual swap is pretty straightforward too, so don't worry too much about what's fitted currently (in any model).

Oh, and you have mail incoming about that E23...
Good info, thanks. If anything, I'd actually prefer an auto to slink around in.

Replied to your mail. I guess I need to look at a few cars and decide whether I want an E23 or an E28. I'm also drawn to W123s, but I still think the E28 is winning so far...

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
You don't need to do anything to the 525e to increase oomph -they're great just as they are with remarkable around town acceleration thanks to the big wadge of torque at around 1500-2500 rpm. Start messing around with i heads and you basically turn it into a half arsed 528i only not as good. I drove a manual version in Germany and it was superb to drive.
E23's are nice but there are so few nice ones left. W123's are great - the 230CE Coupe with the later engine (late 1980 on) and power steering plus the 4 speed auto is a very nice thing. There was a 1979 250 saloon on Ebay not long back in that bright Citrus yellow with brown interior.........

Embryonic

Original Poster:

4,485 posts

206 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
iSore said:
You don't need to do anything to the 525e to increase oomph...
Thanks for your thoughts.

There's a fairly tidy looking green E23 on C&C which sounds quite nice having spoken to the owner, but you're right, they're very thin on the ground. I think I saw that yellow 250 saloon (was it also on C&C?) on PH, there have been a couple posted on the Smoker Barge Thread lately and they seem to be reasonably priced for a nice one.

I like this: http://www.carandclassic.co.uk/car/C322884# but then I also like this: http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3919286.htm

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
Both very good choices - of the two I'd go for the 230E though - it looks like a superb car for not a lot of money. The 280 engine was a bit of an old growler really- they slapped a twin cam head on the old single cam 280 bottom end and whilst it was quite powerful at 185 bhp, they were nowhere near as nice as the BMW 2.8. They can strip the flats off the oil pump drive spindle as well. They're also bloody thirsty. The 230E though will surprise you at how quietly it will cruise at 80-90 and it'll average 25 ish MPG.

The CE is the prettier car though, but the time to buy a good W123 is now because they will start to command proper money.

Embryonic

Original Poster:

4,485 posts

206 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
You really seem to know about these cars, that's interesting, thanks. I agree that the CE is a very pretty thing, but the 230E does look lovely - there's just something about an old German 4-door saloon that I really like.

V8 TEJ

375 posts

192 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Embryonic said:
Thanks for your reply, and your E28 looks lovely. The exterior/interior colour combo really works for me, and the wheels are ace. I'm guessing you don't have any photos of it lowered? I'd be in two minds on whether to leave it at standard height or just give it a slight drop, and you might convince me one way or the other.

I'd only be intending to use it as something to pootle about in at weekends and nice days, so I'm not entirely convinced I need the power of a 525 or 528 - but I do keep thinking that in an automatic example it would be nice to have that extra urge for over-takes and motorway use.


Where did you find your example? Aside from the usual places (PH, Car and Classic, Classic Cars For Sale, ebay, BMW5.co.uk), is there anywhere else I should be looking?
Thanks for the compliments :-)

I took this pic this morning before leaving for work. The original springs were very soft and it actually feels nicer to ride in now as it's not so high and floaty.



They are really nice cruisers and I also like the W123 Mercs a lot. My Dad used to have a lot of them in the '80s and my brother has had about 6 of them over the years. He has a 250 limo now, this is it being used as brides maids transport at a wedding.



He's generally favoured the old 2.8 lump in these as the first one he bought in 1994 was a 280E manual 5 speed, which had previously been owned by my Dad a few years earlier. This car was a beast at the time and had the 16" Penta wheels on (which brother still has and keeps locked away) as was that champagne colour. I think it was this car that got him hooked on to the 2.8 lump. I agree that the 2.8 is a guzzler, the 2.3 isn't exactly eco for it's size/power either but it's easier to live with.

I was looking to buy a W123 or an E28 just like you. I went all the frickin way to Yorkshire (from Berkshire) to buy a 1982 230CE which was on CarandClassic and the bloke selling was an utter tt. He made all sorts of claims about how mint it was etc. and the photos looked quite good. When I got there I saw it had been sprayed with spray cans in various areas, the interior was covered in mould, underside was corroded, brakes didn't work (obviously a dodgy MOT) and engine didn't sound healthy. What a c0ck.

So as I had a wad burning a hole in the pocket I trawled CarandClassic and saw a 528i in Kent, Blue, 62'000 miles (still for sale) which didn't 'do it' for me personally but I was desperate to get a car as Jag was involved in a crash. My persistent searching paid off as the Ad stated at the bottom "Also got 520, manual, resprayed, beige leather etc" but there were no pics of it. I had some pics e-mailed over and a few days later it was sitting on my drive. Sounded too good to be true at first and has been a nice experience so far. Only bit a grief I've had was a rusty core plug towards rear of engine (RH side behind exhaust) but I now know how to remove/refit the whole exhaust as a result :-)

Good luck with the search which ever you do end up buying. These '80s German saloons certainly have increased appeal these days. I get many admiring looks/thumbs up from other drivers when cruising on the M25 among all the modern cars.

ETA: I had a 1 previous (deceased) owner Silver 525e 12 years ago and they do drive really nice with loads of torque. It feels weird that you are generally under 2k rpm most of the time (like a truck) but smooth and refined. The problem for me was that something was wrong with the one I had as it only did 15 mpg max. Nothing obvious was amiss. I had just finished Uni so wasn't exactly flush either so it wasn't fun! Water pump sprang a leak, overheated and Head cracked. Sold it for spares/repair for about £350 iirc, A701 UFM was the reg.

Edited by V8 TEJ on Friday 10th August 10:14

Embryonic

Original Poster:

4,485 posts

206 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the thorough reply and photos. Your car does look great and not too low by any means.

I can't seem to find the blue 528 on C&C, I don't suppose you have a link to it? Sounds like you've done well with your find, especially as it wasn't really advertised properly.

The 525e is beginning to sound more appealing - I know they were tuned for torque, but actually hearing people who've driven them say that they go well enough is starting to convince me that it would suit me just fine...



g3org3y

22,529 posts

222 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
V8 TEJ said:
So far I'm really happy I found this car and can't wait to drive it home from work...:-)

Very very nice! BUT needs BMW roundels. smile

V8 TEJ

375 posts

192 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Embryonic said:
Thanks for the thorough reply and photos. Your car does look great and not too low by any means.

I can't seem to find the blue 528 on C&C, I don't suppose you have a link to it? Sounds like you've done well with your find, especially as it wasn't really advertised properly.

The 525e is beginning to sound more appealing - I know they were tuned for torque, but actually hearing people who've driven them say that they go well enough is starting to convince me that it would suit me just fine...

Bloody typical, the Ad has been removed now! It was there a couple of days ago and has been for months!! It was up for 3k, nice car, I can send you the chaps details if you want and he can e-mail you some pics. It looks to be a genuine 62k miler, has had money spent on it just like the 520 I bought off him. :-)

JohnAdmin

25 posts

192 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
It looks very nice.

V8 TEJ

375 posts

192 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
g3org3y said:
Very very nice! BUT needs BMW roundels. smile
I see your point :-) But I like it as is. People who don't know about old cars wonder what it is! :-)

Embryonic

Original Poster:

4,485 posts

206 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
V8 TEJ said:
Bloody typical, the Ad has been removed now! It was there a couple of days ago and has been for months!! It was up for 3k, nice car, I can send you the chaps details if you want and he can e-mail you some pics. It looks to be a genuine 62k miler, has had money spent on it just like the 520 I bought off him. :-)
Wondered if I was just blind hehe

I'll email you in a moment, ta.

V8 TEJ

375 posts

192 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Embryonic said:
The 525e is beginning to sound more appealing - I know they were tuned for torque, but actually hearing people who've driven them say that they go well enough is starting to convince me that it would suit me just fine...

I forgot to expand on this point. The 525e is no slouch. I'd say the Auto 525e is a fair bit quicker than the the 520i manual. What I hadn't realised at first when I had the 525e is that there is a stop under the throttle pedal which pushes down like a button, and so engages kick-down mode in the gearbox. It growls and flies along then :-)

They are meant to be as eco as the 520 but with more usable power. If that is the case I'd like to replace the 520 I have. It's just I had a bad experience with the 1 525e I did own.

A good 6 cyl example is a lovely driving machine. Do some test drives first and see how you feel. I told most of friends/family about my fond memories of that 525e (whilst Jag XJ8 ownership) and always said it was the best riding car I had ever owned. I have been reminded of this fact recently. E28s are really nice all round machines :-)