The S&S top ten films
Author
Discussion

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,027 posts

279 months

Thursday 2nd August 2012
quotequote all
It's a strange list to me.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/film/film-news/...

Everyone must have had friends around where the discussion gets onto the best films of all time. How many get anywhere near the S&S list?

A little while ago some friends set up 'rules' for nominations: at least five years old to elminate the recency effect (and to exclude Twilight probably), you have bought the video, have viewed it at least 3 times and at least once a year.

There were arguments regarding other rules, such as nothing including Liam Neesom, but we thought such films would be excluded anyway under the other rules.

One strange thing was that for best comedy the only one that everyone could agree should be in the top ten was Kind Hearts and Coronets. As soon as it was mentioned everyone sort of said 'Yes, that's in'. However, it never got top.

Vertigo often got a mention (if only for improper use of the English language) but there was always one or two who thought it rubbish.

The shock in our group was when Lord of the Rings beat Godfather (both trilogies being counted as one film). In a controversial decision (i.e. I disagreed with it) TV series could be included if a film had also been made about it and this has meant that mostly the overall winner, without regard to genre, has been the BBC 1995 version of Pride and Prejudice. Not totally uncontroversial but as one woman pointed out, it was shorter in air time than the Rings.

I don't go to parties anymore. Its just eat and talk nowadays.

SirSamuelBuca

1,353 posts

188 months

Thursday 2nd August 2012
quotequote all
Personally I prefer Rear Window to Vertigo.

I havent seen half of the old films so cannot comment, but there are plenty of modern thought provoking and wonderfully written/acted films that could easily be in the top 10.

Pride and Prejudice has dated quite badly. ( i have watched in 3 times ;'() I do not think its quite as thought out as it should of been to match the book imo.

Edited by SirSamuelBuca on Thursday 2nd August 08:42

obob

4,193 posts

225 months

Friday 3rd August 2012
quotequote all
These kind of lists are stupid. People just choose old stuff that no one has heard of so they can show what a film buff they are. Vertigo is an Ok film, Citit
zen Kane is a snoozefest. There are much better films but they would be too mainstream for people to vote for because they wouldn't feel all elitist and look at me I watch black and white movies.

longshot

3,286 posts

229 months

Friday 3rd August 2012
quotequote all
Never heard of most of them but Citizen Kane belongs there.
I remember watching it for the first time to see what all the fuss was about and was blown away.

Fiddler On The Roof should be in there.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Friday 3rd August 2012
quotequote all
SirSamuelBuca said:
Personally I prefer Rear Window to Vertigo.

I havent seen half of the old films so cannot comment, but there are plenty of modern thought provoking and wonderfully written/acted films that could easily be in the top 10.

Pride and Prejudice has dated quite badly. ( i have watched in 3 times ;'() I do not think its quite as thought out as it should of been to match the book imo.

Edited by SirSamuelBuca on Thursday 2nd August 08:42
How can a period piece like Pride and Prejudice have dated?

Bullett

11,194 posts

215 months

Friday 3rd August 2012
quotequote all
Sci-fi can look very dated, and that's made up.

The colours the costumes, the language all date a film. It will have the period it was made in stamped on it, especially from the early days of cinema.

That list is very film buff geeky.

For a comedy I'd go with Monty Python (Brian or Grail) or Blues Brothers. I can watch all 3 of those time after time.

My list would exclude anything based on a book or tv series, it would have to be original material.

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Friday 3rd August 2012
quotequote all
I remember watching Pride and Prejudice film from the 30s, it was horrible compared to the 90s series.

Films lists by critics tend to be a little geeky.

Kind Hearts and Cornets, great choice! Hope I'm not considered elitist for loving a film that is B&W!biggrin
Thing is with KH&C, one cannot consider that without Ladykillers, Passport to Pimlico and the rest.biggrin

I love film, and could create a top ten list of around 200 films.

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,027 posts

279 months

Friday 3rd August 2012
quotequote all
Halb said:
I love film, and could create a top ten list of around 200 films.
So true.

My wife once mentioned Chocolat at a party and every woman agreed.

I once lost someone close to me and saw Truly, Madly, Deeply, very much a chick flick, within a couple of months and it really got to me. It showed the emotion of someone who experiences the loss of somebody close but not in the way you normally see in film, with a tear wiped from the eye and a head hung down, but with the resentment against the person who had so selfishly died, the snot, the unfairness of it all and the horror of the fact that you will never, ever see them again. The going slightly mad bit was too close for comfort. Really a tremendous film but I only saw it the once so couldn't nominate it. I bought the DVD when it came out but it still has the cellophane around it.

Don't watch it with a rope around you neck. No way I would put it in the top 10, or even 200, but I've never been so affected by a film. Even typing about it brings back some of the emotion.

I'm a big fan of Alan Rickman but I'll never forgive him for T,M,D.

kiteless

12,599 posts

235 months

Friday 3rd August 2012
quotequote all
longshot said:
Fiddler On The Roof should be in there.
I know it's not one of the greats, but I love that film.

Hackney

7,442 posts

239 months

Friday 3rd August 2012
quotequote all
It's so subjective.

I could also pick a top ten list of 200 films.
But would always include Some Like It Hot in a top ten

Japveesix

4,576 posts

199 months

Saturday 4th August 2012
quotequote all
Halb said:
I love film, and could create a top ten list of around 200 films.
Hackney said:
I could also pick a top ten list of 200 films.
I could do a top ten of 401 films because I like films more than both of you put together.

EDLT

15,421 posts

237 months

Saturday 4th August 2012
quotequote all
obob said:
These kind of lists are stupid. People just choose old stuff that no one has heard of so they can show what a film buff they are. Vertigo is an Ok film, Citit
zen Kane is a snoozefest. There are much better films but they would be too mainstream for people to vote for because they wouldn't feel all elitist and look at me I watch black and white movies.
This.

Also under the OP's rules I'm banned from making a list because I don't own any videos.

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Saturday 4th August 2012
quotequote all
Japveesix said:
I could do a top ten of 401 films because I like films more than both of you put together.
I doubt it.biggrin