Diesels - sacrificing our health for climate change?
Discussion
Radio 4 program talking about the health risks posed by emissions from diesel engined vehicles, including the observation that the drive to diesel pushed by the requirement to reduce CO2 emissions has resulted in poorer local air quality and bad health outcomes.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01lhgyn/File...
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01lhgyn/File...
TheHeretic said:
I've always been under the impression that the particles are worse for you, but they tend to fall to ground, and are not airborne for as long. Never really investigated much though, so it could be an old wives tale.
Not sure but aparenty carbon and rubber from tyres and brakes is very bad too not to mention domestic heating gas/oil petrols also emit PMs so maybe its something we can expect some more taxes on 
TheHeretic said:
I've always been under the impression that the particles are worse for you, but they tend to fall to ground, and are not airborne for as long. Never really investigated much though, so it could be an old wives tale.
Good old PM10s (Particulate Matter 10 micron). One of the Diesel mags used to go on about this some years back IIRC. Their point was that petrol cars produced smaller particles (PM2.5s) which were more likely to hang around in the air for longer and get breathed deeper into lungs. Then it went all quiet. Sounds plausible but what do I know...The biggest threat to health arises from vehicles with large diesel engines that are put under load frequently, stopping and starting. As such the dastardly duo are buses pulling into and away from bus stops, and HGVs negotiating traffic calming particularly speed bumps.
Large diesel engines under load produce the two most genotoxic carcinogens known to science, 3-nitrobenzanthrone and 1,8-dinitropyrene. These pollutants are implicated in lung and liver cancers. However TPTB see fit to regulate harmless lemonade fizz while busising town and city centres. Bright bunch.
Large diesel engines under load produce the two most genotoxic carcinogens known to science, 3-nitrobenzanthrone and 1,8-dinitropyrene. These pollutants are implicated in lung and liver cancers. However TPTB see fit to regulate harmless lemonade fizz while busising town and city centres. Bright bunch.
turbobloke said:
The biggest threat to health arises from vehicles with large diesel engines that are put under load frequently, stopping and starting. As such the dastardly duo are buses pulling into and away from bus stops, and HGVs negotiating traffic calming particularly speed bumps.
Large diesel engines under load produce the two most genotoxic carcinogens known to science, 3-nitrobenzanthrone and 1,8-dinitropyrene. These pollutants are implicated in lung and liver cancers. However TPTB see fit to regulate harmless lemonade fizz while busising town and city centres. Bright bunch.
Tsk, didn't you know, public transport can do no evil.Large diesel engines under load produce the two most genotoxic carcinogens known to science, 3-nitrobenzanthrone and 1,8-dinitropyrene. These pollutants are implicated in lung and liver cancers. However TPTB see fit to regulate harmless lemonade fizz while busising town and city centres. Bright bunch.
Article in the Mail ( sorry) about this in June:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-2158574/...
And IRRC EUReferendum blog covered this a few weeks ago too, with some high figures of deaths across the EU caused by the OP' s very point.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-2158574/...
And IRRC EUReferendum blog covered this a few weeks ago too, with some high figures of deaths across the EU caused by the OP' s very point.
How do they determine that diesel fumes caused it? Surely they would have to show that diesel fumes are either remaining airborne, and getting into the human body, and then causing these cancers? As I said previously, I haven't read this stuff for some time, but as far as I know, diesel exhaust does not remain airborne, unlike petrol exhausts.
Do you have that blog link at all?
Do you have that blog link at all?
I would think that the particles being discussed are easily aerialised by air movement. If you listen to the radio programme, there is some discussion of attempts to reduce the airborne concentrations in London by spraying hotspots with something that will capture and bind them (along with some accusations that this is only being done near to monitoring stations in order to conceal the extent of the problem).
Being a solid particulate does not seem to have stopped asbestos being a health risk, and I believe the particles in question are much smaller than asbestos fibres.
Being a solid particulate does not seem to have stopped asbestos being a health risk, and I believe the particles in question are much smaller than asbestos fibres.
otolith said:
I would think that the particles being discussed are easily aerialised by air movement. If you listen to the radio programme, there is some discussion of attempts to reduce the airborne concentrations in London by spraying hotspots with something that will capture and bind them (along with some accusations that this is only being done near to monitoring stations in order to conceal the extent of the problem).
3-NBA heads off into rainwater as it is. Paper here (pdf file).It's not nice anywhere...from Huaijian et al "The mutagenicity and genotoxicity of 3-nitrobenzanthrone by biological assays both in vivo and in vitro are very high, comparable to 1,8-dinitropyrene, which is the direct mutagen of strongest activity so far reported in the literature."
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




