BBC - doing a good job?
Author
Discussion

shed driver

Original Poster:

3,103 posts

191 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
I've been enjoying the Olympics coverage on the BBC, TV, radio and the sublime BBC sport web site. There have been some pretty poor presenters at times, but on the whole I think they've done a magnificent job.

Would other companies have done such a good job, or is the BBC uniquely placed to provide blanket coverage of major home events like this?

SD.

UF

7,018 posts

214 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
It's all done by the Olympic broadcasting service. Commentators have been been poor imo.

3d highlights show shouldn't just be an hour each night, they should have a 3d channel running all day.

Eric Mc

125,941 posts

296 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Curate's Egg.

Technical presentation has been excellent (and it isn't only the IOC feed that we are seeing).
The sheer volume of coverage has been unsurpassed.

Commentary and presentation has been varied.

PS - there are at least two other threads on this topic - one in the TV forum and one in the Sport's forum.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
No. Wall to wall left wing bias.


(I imagine, haven't actually watched any of it on the BBC)

Eric Mc

125,941 posts

296 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
No. Wall to wall left wing bias.


(I imagine, haven't actually watched any of it on the BBC)
Not noticed much in the way of politics at all - apart from Boris getting in on the act whenever he can - usually on BBC London.

Morningside

24,147 posts

260 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
AJS- said:
No. Wall to wall left wing bias.


(I imagine, haven't actually watched any of it on the BBC)
Not noticed much in the way of politics at all - apart from Boris getting in on the act whenever he can - usually on BBC London.
Boris? that lefty(!) Strange how the BBC seems to love him.

I am even more impressed by the huge technical stuff going on behind the cameras. Instant replay, red button, cameras everywhere all working seamlessly.

whoami

13,201 posts

271 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
No. Wall to wall left wing bias.


(I imagine, haven't actually watched any of it on the BBC)
confused

Stu R

21,701 posts

246 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
I think it's been brilliant for the large part. Commentary has been pretty good on most of the events I've watched, some of the presenters have been a bit wide of the mark but there's a few like Claire Balding who've done a sterling job.

Certainly couldn't envisage a scenario where any other broadcaster in the UK could do a better job.

andymadmak

15,730 posts

301 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Technically brilliant
Commentaries a bit varied - some excellent, some less so.
Trevor Nelson an utter disaster

Twincam16

27,647 posts

289 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
It's been excellent, and the use of BBC3 was inspired too. Means they can still run serious, non-sporty usual BBC output on 2 and 4 while not missing out on any of the action.

Olympic sports don't work well with advert breaks, and I'd far rather have former athletes chatting in the lulls between sports than various products finding desperately tenuous links with Olympic sports to flog products in an embarassing way.

Eric Mc

125,941 posts

296 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
It will be interesting how the BBC coverage compares to Channel 4.

Last time Channel 4 covered a major athletics event it was a bit of a disaster. Hopefully, they've learned from that.

singlecoil

35,889 posts

277 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
It would be fine if they remembered that not everybody is fascinated by finding out who can run around a track the fastest on any particular day. They've got a 24hour news channel, perhaps they should have actual news on that, so that those who don't want to watch sports have a choice?

Twincam16

27,647 posts

289 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
It will be interesting how the BBC coverage compares to Channel 4.

Last time Channel 4 covered a major athletics event it was a bit of a disaster. Hopefully, they've learned from that.
Although their cricket coverage during the 2005 Ashes season was superb. Channel 5's highlights package isn't a patch on it.

extraT

1,876 posts

181 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
I used to practise Tae Kwon Do- was pretty good at it too. Unfortunately I didnt get my Blackbelt as I moved to Austria- I was two belts away.

Watching the Tae Kwon Do this morning, I was dismayed to hear the commentator refer to one of the fighters as a "Tae Kwon Do Player"- somehow it almost seemed as if he were belittling their efforts. Infact, the commentary was so bad, I had to turn the sound off.

For the amount of money these Olympics are costing, surely the BBC/Government could have spent a little bit more on providing retired sports professionals to aid the commentators?

Oh and watching the 5000m heat with Mo Farah, the Northern commentator would not stop saying "we are watching Olympic Gold Meadlist Mo Farah" It was so annoying at one point his co-commentator just said "when will you stop!" - very awkward.

Blue62

10,587 posts

183 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
I reckon the 'technical' commentary and explanations have been a real hit this time around. I was fascinated to hear Colin Jackson explaining how high jumpers achieve the lift, it's really added to my enjoyment, but then I am one of those odd people who happens to think the licence fee is a steal.

GetCarter

31,335 posts

310 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Took them 11 days to fix that 'opus' they keep playing. It was driving me mad. Whoever composed it must have been spitting feathers.

It is now glorious 4/4, as it was supposed to be all along.

UF

7,018 posts

214 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
It will be interesting how the BBC coverage compares to Channel 4.

Last time Channel 4 covered a major athletics event it was a bit of a disaster. Hopefully, they've learned from that.
How much do you think is the BBC and how much the IOC broadcasting service? I assume the IOC will do provide the same service that will be used by channel four.


Twincam16

27,647 posts

289 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Blue62 said:
I reckon the 'technical' commentary and explanations have been a real hit this time around. I was fascinated to hear Colin Jackson explaining how high jumpers achieve the lift, it's really added to my enjoyment, but then I am one of those odd people who happens to think the licence fee is a steal.
I don't have a problem with the licence fee either. I actually have Sky (Landlady pays for it), which would be considerably more expensive, but the only Sky channel I watch that I can't also get on Freeview is Motors TV.

Eric Mc

125,941 posts

296 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
UF said:
Eric Mc said:
It will be interesting how the BBC coverage compares to Channel 4.

Last time Channel 4 covered a major athletics event it was a bit of a disaster. Hopefully, they've learned from that.
How much do you think is the BBC and how much the IOC broadcasting service? I assume the IOC will do provide the same service that will be used by channel four.
There's more to TV than just relaying camera shots. Channel 4's coverage of the World Championships in 2011 was awful, completely down to the inadequacy of their studio anchor.

iphonedyou

10,425 posts

188 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
extraT said:
I used to practise Tae Kwon Do- was pretty good at it too. Unfortunately I didnt get my Blackbelt as I moved to Austria- I was two belts away.

Watching the Tae Kwon Do this morning, I was dismayed to hear the commentator refer to one of the fighters as a "Tae Kwon Do Player"- somehow it almost seemed as if he were belittling their efforts. Infact, the commentary was so bad, I had to turn the sound off.

For the amount of money these Olympics are costing, surely the BBC/Government could have spent a little bit more on providing retired sports professionals to aid the commentators?

Oh and watching the 5000m heat with Mo Farah, the Northern commentator would not stop saying "we are watching Olympic Gold Meadlist Mo Farah" It was so annoying at one point his co-commentator just said "when will you stop!" - very awkward.
In fairness, it's Tae Kwon Do. Aren't there discussions to drop it from the Olympics anyway? tongue out