Insurance question.
Insurance question.
Author
Discussion

bingybongy

Original Poster:

4,153 posts

177 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
I recently managed to put a 25 year old Tag watch through the washing machine, which filled the watch with water.

The insurance company have had a quote to repair the watch, and are happy to go ahead, however the dial and hands will be different.

I have received today a photo of said items and am not sure that I like them.

As The claim is already made am I right to reject the franken-watch or do I let them repair it and get a virtually brand new watch.

The replacement cover will not pay enough to get a new one, but I could buy something I like rather than have a watch I didn't buy. (If you see what I mean).

Animal

5,670 posts

299 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
Are the original parts not usable? If they are, and you want to keep some originality why not say this to your insurers?

ShortShift811

650 posts

173 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
Read your policy wording and see if it's on a 'new for old' basis (most household policies are).

If so, whilst your insurers seem to have been co-operative and amenable to a repair, they should also be willing to offer a replacement item (or vouchers) to the equivalent new value of your watch. All you need to do is explain you're not happy with the idea of non-original parts.

Let us know how you get on.

ETA: The onus may well be on you to prove the value if seeking a replacement - check the policy. The devil's in the detail. HTH.

Edited by ShortShift811 on Thursday 9th August 07:24

bingybongy

Original Poster:

4,153 posts

177 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
I have told the insurers I am not happy with the watch being cobbled together with bits from a parts bin, so they are forwarding a voucher for an agreed amount. Well done to Allianz.