Newsnight argument about the Olympics being elitist.
Newsnight argument about the Olympics being elitist.
Author
Discussion

Omshanti

Original Poster:

58 posts

172 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
Ok, another topic for which I am not sure if this is the right forum but here it goes again.
I rarely watch TV, but have been watching it for the Olympics and the other night ended up watching Newsnight which was discussing whether the Olympic games were elitist.
I personally thought the argument was very weak, but was curious what other people thought about it.

TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
Well, I guess you need to have a bit of money behind you if you are planning to spend your life training for something with no income.

RacerMDR

5,582 posts

241 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
of course the olympics is elitist - it should be!! Only the best should get to be there.

Then everyone else gets to watch.

So it isn't elitist from a viewing perspective, but it is from a performing perspective and right bloody so!

I presuming they are saying that only kids get to train and be successful if they come from successful families. Well, again, that is just the way of the world.

You don't see many racing drivers, tennis players, golfers etc coming from under privelidged backgrounds.......as they need to not have a job whilst they get good enough to be there. They also need expensive kit etc

Does my head in all this liberal bks. Money breeds success - always has and always will.



TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
Erm... Best in the world... The very top athletes in their categories... Surely that is the definition of elite? The whole point is that it is elite.

RacerMDR

5,582 posts

241 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
quite - can you imagine the namby pamby liberals saying "ah yes, but it isn't fair on the rest - so we have to have races for the losers and the fat and slow that got 5 A levels grade A because we decided to make them really easy so that we didn't hurt anyones feelings"


Northern Munkee

5,354 posts

231 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
This'll be off Moynihan comments about 50% of the medals are won by private school kids who represent 7% of the population, typically guardinista

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-19109724

Rather than discuss what's wrong with state school sport and his calls for better funding of competitive school sports, newsnight instead engage in the typical leftie middle class dinner party conversation about how terrible & damaging it is that all the poor prol children must be made to feel like a loser when they'll never have to deal with winning and losing in adult life....

There was a phone in on R5 start of the week one woman rang in to complain that although they do do athletics at school the children are not permitted to race against each other.?!

Subsequently the child had joined an athletic club, and initially been completely unable to cope with "racing". Challenged why the school had such a policy, she said she was buggered if she knew but had not challenged the school about it. Too many socialists in teaching, still believing that "sport" is training impressionable minds for being soldiers of capitalism.

Unbelievable.

Probably been discussed already N, P & E, OP.btw

Omshanti

Original Poster:

58 posts

172 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
What I felt was that they were ignoring the difference in nature of different sports. Some sports will always be more specialised by nature. It's hard to do horse riding, rowing, sailing ..etc if you live in a city, and they will require a lot of money as well so it is obvious that wealth comes into play, but then if wealth is the issue then the problem is much much bigger than the Olympics or sports. It's the same in all walks of life. Countless amont of aspects/elements come into play in people's lives and result in the paths they choose, and it's impossible to control everything.

However, coming from Japan, I do get the impression that specialised sports are much more popular here in the UK, which I guess is related to the historical development of the British and western European society.

It also felt a little racially orientated as they called the athletics inclusive and not elitist which was so obviously based on the racial demographics represented in that field. I think athletics is just as elitist as any other field of sports in many aspects. Sporting excellence, when it comes to collective outcomes has a lot to do with the culture surrounding each sport in each community. A sport has to be popular, has to have good experience handed down each generation...etc. So if somebody who wants to excel in a certain sport but is not in a community with a culture of supporting that sport they will always have a hard time.

Also what felt a bit unfair was that they were mentioning that sports like Sepak takraw and kabadi are not included in the Olympics despite having millions of people playing them. It made me wonder if Baseball or American football are in the Olympics. Does anybody know? I don't think I have seen them. But then they are not mentioned in the argument because they are played in wealthier countries?





Edited by Omshanti on Thursday 9th August 23:13

Northern Munkee

5,354 posts

231 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
GentleFellow said:
Northern Munkee said:
Newsnight instead engage in the typical leftie middle class dinner party conversation about how terrible & damaging it is that all the poor prol children must be made to feel like a loser when they'll never have to deal with winning and losing in adult life.... Too many socialists in teaching, still believing that "sport" is training impressionable minds for being soldiers of capitalism.

Unbelievable.

Probably been discussed already N, P & E, OP.btw
So for you, it's brutal honesty in PE lessons for Olympic success,  and silencing people like me for brutal honesty on the PH forums.

Sport is elitist. The reason you all think this elitism is fair is because you hate people who think it isn't. That's it. :-) 
Silence you? hate you? Never crossed you around here. So get over yourself.

Brutal honesty? You lose, you shake hands, and either accept it, & learn to lose with dignity, &/or work harder come back and try again. And as a consequence sport is elitist, of course it is, precisely as it should be, it rewards hard work & excellence, rather than mediocrity, as life, then again I'm a Yorkshireman. As to your other tosh, perhaps you ought to try another profession as your sensitivity will ultimately be your undoing.