BBC Report on Injured Veteran Care
BBC Report on Injured Veteran Care
Author
Discussion

pointedstarman

Original Poster:

554 posts

177 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01lvfh4/News...

Anyone see this? The related article is:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19112550

Was astonished to see what appears to happen to many injured ex- Army Veterans and even more astonished at the money spend to refurbish an MoD building at Tidworth. Who in thier right mind decides that the best place for a recovery centre is a run down grade 1 stately home they don't own and goes on to spend £20M doing it up? Surely a new facitly for half the money would be better leaving the remainder to spend on long term care which, going on this report, needs sorting.

My astonishment turned to anger a the condecending and patronising way the squaddie was treated in the post article discussion with Bryn Parry, Lord Dannet and Eddie Mair. Was I being too sensitive or did they take a guy who was understandably inarticulate given the situation (Ben McBean) and pretty much humiliate him on national tv?

Carfiend

3,186 posts

240 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Money should be spent on after care for veterans. £20m on an old stately home while killing two birds with one stone does not provide best value for money for those who have been badly injured in the line of duty.

Digga

48,629 posts

314 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
It raises some worrying points.

Granted the job of the soldier is, was and always will be to put life and limb on the line, but surely with what we have learned from our collective and (sadly) extensive experience of modern warfare is that those returning from battle need to be cared for. Aside from debilitating physical injuries, we now know enough about post-traumatic effects to realise that even 'healthy' individuals may be in critical need of care.

Certainly expecting people to come out of combat situations straight back into civvy street has proven to be an idiotic and, frankly, dangerous idea. Many and varied are the stories of otherwise good soliders going off the rails once they leave the forces.

The income vs expenditure of H4H (a charity I have personally supported) is also, potentially worrying.

Laughingman21

590 posts

242 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Digga said:
It raises some worrying points.

The income vs expenditure of H4H (a charity I have personally supported) is also, potentially worrying.
What do you find worrying about it?

Digga

48,629 posts

314 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Laughingman21 said:
Digga said:
It raises some worrying points.

The income vs expenditure of H4H (a charity I have personally supported) is also, potentially worrying.
What do you find worrying about it?
the article said:
Raised £141m, spent £121m
Only that like any large organisation, it's easy to add overhead. Secondly that it says they intend to spend "£153m on constructing and servicing five regional MoD Personnel Recovery Centres".

Leithen

14,167 posts

298 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Help for Heroes has focused on helping injured servicemen and women who are still serving. Speak to those working for ex-servicemen related charities (Poppy Factories etc) and you'll discover that there is a big problem with housing, jobs etc for those who have left the forces.

Perhaps the biggest problem that few are speaking about is the delayed PSTD (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder) or Combat Stress consequences from recent and current operations in Iraq/Afghanistan. This can take 5-10+ years to manifest itself, is truly awful for the individuals involved and those close to them. It's a ticking time bomb and needs as much attention as the very good H4H work done at the moment.

steveatesh

5,387 posts

195 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
What's sad is that we, as a nation, have to have charities such as H4H in the first place because such help and assistance should be part of the planned in military costs.

I wonder how much of the current state of affairs is a hang over of our history, when officer positions went to the upper classes or those who could buy a commission, while the soldiers we viewed as canon fodder?

How do other countries approach it? The Americans appear to place a much higher value on their military as people, than we do here.

Laughingman21

590 posts

242 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Digga said:
Laughingman21 said:
Digga said:
It raises some worrying points.

The income vs expenditure of H4H (a charity I have personally supported) is also, potentially worrying.
What do you find worrying about it?
the article said:
Raised £141m, spent £121m
Only that like any large organisation, it's easy to add overhead. Secondly that it says they intend to spend "£153m on constructing and servicing five regional MoD Personnel Recovery Centres".
One of H4H's main goals was to spend the money they raise, not put it into investments/save it for a rainy day. IMHO, raising £141m in 5 years is impressive, but then actually using the majority of that cash is where the real success of H4H lies.

As for the £153m, the article doesn't give any indication of the period of time the expenditure is for so it's hard to say whether they've made a tough promise to keep. (e.g. if it was in the next 2 years, I'd be worried, but over 20 years, at their current rate of fund raising that should be easy).

CatJ

9,586 posts

274 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
H4H have put out a statement in response to last nights programme. Worth a read.

http://www.helpforheroes.org.uk/

It pops up when you go onto the above website.

eccles

14,415 posts

253 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
CatJ said:
H4H have put out a statement in response to last nights programme. Worth a read.

http://www.helpforheroes.org.uk/

It pops up when you go onto the above website.
Not exactly the most robust defence.

Mr_B

10,480 posts

274 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Quite a shame that the heros feel let down by this. I really like the work they do, but if the guys who it is aimed at feel the they are stating to miss the target, the aim needs to shift.

ninja-lewis

5,507 posts

221 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Guam said:
I have kicked into H4H over the last couple of years along with many folks. I did not envisage that money would be used for subsidising MOD. I believed <alomg with most I would suspect>, it would go directly to those impacted to assist in their lives post Injury.
That is what Help for Heroes have had to do from Day 1. It was set up to raise money to build a swimming pool at DMRC Headley Court, which the Governmentt was refusing to fund.

It's nothing new either. The Royal British Legion and Erskine were effectively set up to meet needs that the Government of the day should've been meeting.

The main difference between H4H and other service charities is that H4H usually isn't directly involved in the delivery. They primarily raise funds for large capital projects (Headley Court, Personnel Recovery Centres etc) and give grants to other service charities (Combat Stress etc). They have a fund to support individuals but it is administrated by other charities on their behalf (SSAFA, ABF, RAFBF and so on).

It's a disgrace the way the media have gone after the charities here. The ones they should be going after are the MOD, NHS and Treasury for not providing support to both service personnel and veterans that they should be - especially once personnel leave the forces. That's the real scandal.

Mark Benson

8,264 posts

300 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
pointedstarman said:
My astonishment turned to anger a the condecending and patronising way the squaddie was treated in the post article discussion with Bryn Parry, Lord Dannet and Eddie Mair. Was I being too sensitive or did they take a guy who was understandably inarticulate given the situation (Ben McBean) and pretty much humiliate him on national tv?
I saw it last night, unfortunately Ben appeared unprepared and muddled in what he seemed to be saying (at one point he seemed to be saying that the views weren't his own and that he was just the spokesperson, the next he seemed to be saying they were) and his inexperience showed when in a round table discussion with people more comfortable and better prepared than he was.
I don't think he was too badly treated, he was given chance to speak.

As for the news about the Tidworth building - as I understood it, H4H are saying that they are helping mostly serving soldiers currently, but the facilities will be open for veterans in due course - unfortunately they can't help everyone and they won't please some. It's sad that they can't give everyone some help immediately, but they have a limited resource and have decided that there is a need for these recovery centres (with the support of many, serving and veterans alike). It's going to take time though, and I do think that the article and subsequent discussion focused too much on what they haven't done, rather than what they have.

I do have to say though, I wondered how long it would take the media to lay into Help For Heroes, given the phenomenal success they've had and the wide support they get and I wasn't surprised it was the BBC who did so.

Digga

48,629 posts

314 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Mark Benson said:
I do have to say though, I wondered how long it would take the media to lay into Help For Heroes, given the phenomenal success they've had and the wide support they get and I wasn't surprised it was the BBC who did so.
True. I imagine looking after 'people who go to war' is not near the top of the agenda for a good number of Guardian readers.

If the programe provided constructive scrutiny then in the broader view of 'checks and balances' it might help H4H. As you say though, the one certainty is that niether they nor the MOD can please everyone.

pointedstarman

Original Poster:

554 posts

177 months

Saturday 11th August 2012
quotequote all
I can't say I buy in to the 'media going after H4H' thing. If they do something wrong then they should be open for criticism the same as any other institution.

I simply do not understand the logic of using the monies they have been given by a sympathetic public to refurbish a grade 1, MoD owned building. The cost of meeting the demands of English Heritage when taking on the refurbishment of a grade 1 building are astronomical. I do not believe there are not equally impressive, unlisted, building out there that would have done the job just as well and cost a fraction of the £20M needed for Tidworth.

On the subject of the BBC discussion, how many young squaddies are out there that would hold there own in a televised formal discussion with two media savvy ex senior army officers? Ben was stitched up in my opinion. At the very least there should have been a fourth person there, sympathetic to Bens' position, with more experience of such situations, either that or EM should have supported him more.

Dixie68

3,091 posts

218 months

Saturday 11th August 2012
quotequote all
There have been some whispers of discontent about H4H among my ex-colleagues in the Army and RAF for quite a while, more so recently. I however reserve judgement and believe that SOME help is better than none. For that reason I donate to H4H (I'm wearing a H4H wristband right now), but I also donate to the British Legion who I believe do more for servicemen/women than H4H.
My donations are 25% to H4H, 75% to RBL.

dandarez

14,042 posts

314 months

Saturday 11th August 2012
quotequote all
Military charities across England, Wales and Scotland -
across the board they raise just under £700m a year and have more than £1.1 billion in the bank.


The MoD issued a statement in which it said:
"Those who put their lives on the line and make sacrifices for this country deserve all the financial support and medical care we can give them."

It said £226 million would be spent over the next 10 years on assistance for recovering troops.


Assuming 'assistance' means everything these troops need, there seems to be an incredible amount of money not being used or am I reading it wrong?

eccles

14,415 posts

253 months

Saturday 11th August 2012
quotequote all
dandarez said:
Military charities across England, Wales and Scotland -
across the board they raise just under £700m a year and have more than £1.1 billion in the bank.


The MoD issued a statement in which it said:
"Those who put their lives on the line and make sacrifices for this country deserve all the financial support and medical care we can give them."

It said £226 million would be spent over the next 10 years on assistance for recovering troops.


Assuming 'assistance' means everything these troops need, there seems to be an incredible amount of money not being used or am I reading it wrong?
When they say £226 million will be spent on them, does that mean by the MOD or by the various charities, or a total between the two?

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 11th August 2012
quotequote all
The trouble is that when HFH gets bad press, the mud sticks for years. People hate the idea that their donations are going to the MOD and its infrastructure and not the soldiers themselves. The lack of support for ex service personnel is also disappointing.

I know loads of people who don't give to charities because the think their donations are going to charity directors or corrupt African leaders.

eccles

14,415 posts

253 months

Saturday 11th August 2012
quotequote all
el stovey said:
The trouble is that when HFH gets bad press, the mud sticks for years. People hate the idea that their donations are going to the MOD and its infrastructure and not the soldiers themselves. The lack of support for ex service personnel is also disappointing.

I know loads of people who don't give to charities because the think their donations are going to charity directors or corrupt African leaders.
There have been many reports over the years on the amount given to charities that gets used on 'overheads' and 'admin fees'. I remember some of the tables published giving the percentage per pound given that actually got used on the intended recipients and some of it was incredibly low.