Couple of questions about the Scottish Independence
Discussion
Just had a couple of questions hurled at me about said topic.
Firstly, If Scotland get independence, will the UK still be in the EU? Surely it should not be, as without Scotland, we would no long be united. It appears Scotland would have to apply a fresh, so wouldn't we?
and secondly, if we do remain in the EU, will our contributions change? Surely it should drop, as we will lose all the people, assets and liabilities that Scotland would take off our hands.
Firstly, If Scotland get independence, will the UK still be in the EU? Surely it should not be, as without Scotland, we would no long be united. It appears Scotland would have to apply a fresh, so wouldn't we?
and secondly, if we do remain in the EU, will our contributions change? Surely it should drop, as we will lose all the people, assets and liabilities that Scotland would take off our hands.
Westminster would still be in the EU. That would not change. The calculations for pay,ends would change somewhat though, I would imagine. Scotland and it being in the EU is a different issue. There are lots of economic issues arising that would need to be sorted, such as currency, currency control, interest, and inflation control, and so on, and so forth. Membership of the EU would be easy I would imagine.
[viperpictmodeon] the EU will beg scotland to join and scotland will but negotiate excellnet terms because they are now independent and not ruled by english w
kers. They will then choose to donate billions of their surplus oil revenue cash because it will now be loose change to them. England will now be destitute and broke without scotland supporting them so the eu will kick them out[viperpictmodeoff]
kers. They will then choose to donate billions of their surplus oil revenue cash because it will now be loose change to them. England will now be destitute and broke without scotland supporting them so the eu will kick them out[viperpictmodeoff]Actually the truth of it as the law stands at present if Scotland were to gain full independence they would no longer be part of the EU.
To become a member state they would have to join the Euro, or all other member states would have to agree unanimously to change the Treaty.
Back to reality though, this is not an issue as Scotland will not win a referendum on full Independence.
To become a member state they would have to join the Euro, or all other member states would have to agree unanimously to change the Treaty.
Back to reality though, this is not an issue as Scotland will not win a referendum on full Independence.
voyds9 said:
Radio 4 summed it this morning quite well.
Both sides can make the figures say what they want, so it will really be a vote from the heart.
The figures aren't really the issue. The important things are the economy, and how much an independent Scotland will be 'independent'. Like any other cou try it has to set out its objectives. Voting without k owing what on earth is at least vaguely going to occurr is a dangerous, I think. Both sides can make the figures say what they want, so it will really be a vote from the heart.
TheHeretic said:
The figures aren't really the issue. The important things are the economy, and how much an independent Scotland will be 'independent'. Like any other cou try it has to set out its objectives. Voting without k owing what on earth is at least vaguely going to occurr is a dangerous, I think.
Your 'n' is not working 
Pesty said:
(viperpictmodeon) the EU will beg scotland to join and scotland will but negotiate excellnet terms because they are now independent and not ruled by english w
kers. They will then choose to donate billions of their surplus oil revenue cash because it will now be loose change to them. England will now be destitute and broke without scotland supporting them so the eu will kick them out(viperpictmodeoff)
Au contraire - ViperPict mode is sticking your fingers in your ears and shouting, "lalala I'm not listening".
kers. They will then choose to donate billions of their surplus oil revenue cash because it will now be loose change to them. England will now be destitute and broke without scotland supporting them so the eu will kick them out(viperpictmodeoff)
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff






i think the best way for securing scottish independence is to let the whole uk vote.
ViperPict, your thread has arrived!