Unseasonal BMW Winter Tyre thread
Unseasonal BMW Winter Tyre thread
Author
Discussion

jinkster

Original Poster:

2,429 posts

187 months

Sunday 12th August 2012
quotequote all
So,

OK its a little early in the season to be talking winter tyres but they are cheap at the moment......

What winter tyres would you recommend. I've got some Hankook Icebear Run Flats 205/65/16. Will they be any good?

Car is a 320d Touring E91 (2007).

Billyray911

1,086 posts

235 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
I've been using Vredestein wintrac extremes,which have been fantastic on my E91 over the past couple of years.
I've got them mounted on a set of 18" MV3's.
Can't comment on your tyres.
However,it's a good time to start a winter tyres thread, as new (limited) stocks are released now and prices should be at their lowest.
Prices have increased greatly over the past couple of years as more people are getting wise to their benefits-especially on our vehicles!

pete

1,637 posts

315 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
Another thumbs-up for Vredstein Wintrac Xtremes here. I've got an 18" set that will be going back on my E91 335d this winter.

Pete

Animal

5,670 posts

299 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
Can they be used year-round? I don't have space to store a set of spare wheels/tyres...

Billyray911

1,086 posts

235 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
You can,but I think that due to the compound of the tyre,they may wear excessively in normal conditions as the mileages increase.I would speak to the AA or such like to see if there are any safety implications on their use all year.
I certainly wouldn't bother with 'all-weather' tyres as these are a big compromise.However,in your circumstances,they may offer some extra stability,come winter.
If you can afford it,BMW offer a purchase and storage facility that may be best for you.
http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/owner/wintertyres/0,,13...
Bizarrely,some insurance companies class the addition of none standard tyres a modification and may either not cover or charge you extra-even though they are increase safety and should therefore lower risk!

rassi

2,519 posts

282 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
Are you sure the 205/65/16 is the correct dimension for a 320d? 205/55/16 appears more appropriate but please verify with the owners manual.

bennyboydurham

1,617 posts

205 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
I was thinking about winter tyres earlier but trying to find a set that fit my 19s on the E65 is proving a potentially very expensive operation. I might look for a set of 18 inch E65 rims and get some tyres to fit those. There's a hell of a price reduction for tyres only an inch smaller!

Drek

609 posts

196 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
jinkster said:
So,

OK its a little early in the season to be talking winter tyres but they are cheap at the moment......

What winter tyres would you recommend. I've got some Hankook Icebear Run Flats 205/65/16. Will they be any good?

Car is a 320d Touring E91 (2007).
How much were these fellows?

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
jinkster said:
So,

OK its a little early in the season to be talking winter tyres but they are cheap at the moment......

What winter tyres would you recommend. I've got some Hankook Icebear Run Flats 205/65/16. Will they be any good?

Car is a 320d Touring E91 (2007).
I run icebears on my Passat and they are fine in snow, wet and when very cold. Very good wear rate too.

It's an all season tyre BTW.


jinkster

Original Poster:

2,429 posts

187 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Bought the car private and these came with the car. I am just getting prepared for the winter.

Crackie

6,386 posts

273 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
bennyboydurham said:
I was thinking about winter tyres earlier but trying to find a set that fit my 19s on the E65 is proving a potentially very expensive operation. I might look for a set of 18 inch E65 rims and get some tyres to fit those. There's a hell of a price reduction for tyres only an inch smaller!
I have some 19s on my 335i and had the same issue - I got some 17" rims from http://www.bmautosport.co.uk/showroom/index.php/e3... and fitted some Dunlop Winter Sport 3Ds. thumbup Cost less overall than 19" winter tyres.

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Animal said:
Can they be used year-round? I don't have space to store a set of spare wheels/tyres...
Vredstein Quattrac can be, and they are fantastic in Winter ( Ithink they won one aspect of the EVO winter tyre test, beating the pure winter tyres in the process).

I have mine on a spare set of 16" OEM BMW wheels (that I bought second hand on e-bay). Even though they are all-season, I only use them in the winter.


a11y_m

1,861 posts

253 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
To the folks that are running 18" winter tyres on e91's, what size rear tyres are you using? Sticking with the normal staggered size (255/35/18) or dropping to something narrower?

I'm shopping for winter tyres for my e90 at the moment - got a spare set of staggered OEM 18" alloys that I intend using, but wide 18" winter tyres are understandably thin on the ground...

gizard

2,272 posts

314 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
I sticked to staggered size on my e91 335d as let's face it the temperature is low for alot of the year but snow cover is minimal therefore I prefer to keep to the same / similar contact patch size. I have pirelli sotozeros and they have been great.

a11y_m

1,861 posts

253 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
gizard said:
I sticked to staggered size on my e91 335d as let's face it the temperature is low for alot of the year but snow cover is minimal therefore I prefer to keep to the same / similar contact patch size. I have pirelli sotozeros and they have been great.
Thanks, that's the exact rationale I have for preferring to hold out for 255/35/18 winter rears: it's the better performance in cold temps rather than outright performance in snow I'm interested in.

Saying that, lets hope I don't get "sticked" in the snow this year wink

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
gizard said:
I sticked to staggered size on my e91 335d as let's face it the temperature is low for alot of the year but snow cover is minimal therefore I prefer to keep to the same / similar contact patch size. I have pirelli sotozeros and they have been great.
Another recommendation for Pirelli Sottozeros here.

I have a set for the family car for winter and they are great (as you'd expect/hope)

IIRC, they were also fitted to a Lambo that Evo were testing in winter, so if they can keep a hard-driven 500bhp+ Lambo on the road in adverse conditions, that's good enough for me.

pete

1,637 posts

315 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
a11y_m said:
To the folks that are running 18" winter tyres on e91's, what size rear tyres are you using? Sticking with the normal staggered size (255/35/18) or dropping to something narrower?
I'm using 235/40 18s on the back, with stock sizes on the front. No issues at all with my e91 335d.

Pete

parapaul

2,828 posts

229 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
Stock staggered 18" sizes for mine.

I'm using Kumho KW27 on mine - I rate their summer tyres so thought I'd try their winters too. Quite disappointed last winter though, it was so mild that I really think normal tyres would have been fine. The one snowy day we had, I made it to work and back though, when dozens of other cars were stranded at the roadside.

a11y_m

1,861 posts

253 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
parapaul said:
Stock staggered 18" sizes for mine.

I'm using Kumho KW27 on mine - I rate their summer tyres so thought I'd try their winters too. Quite disappointed last winter though, it was so mild that I really think normal tyres would have been fine. The one snowy day we had, I made it to work and back though, when dozens of other cars were stranded at the roadside.
I used those Kumho KW27s on my Z4 the last two winters (in 225/50/16 all-round) and rate them highly. Incredibly good in snow as you'd imagine given the tread pattern, but I reckon other less extreme tyres might be better when it's simply cold and wet/dry. Saying that, I can get a set of staggered 18" Kumho's for £470 which is tempting.

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
a11y_m said:
I used those Kumho KW27s on my Z4 the last two winters (in 225/50/16 all-round) and rate them highly. Incredibly good in snow as you'd imagine given the tread pattern, but I reckon other less extreme tyres might be better when it's simply cold and wet/dry. Saying that, I can get a set of staggered 18" Kumho's for £470 which is tempting.
Yes, this.
They are a very extreme winter/snow tyre, and good value too, but the tread pattern with the large spaces between the blocks means that they make the car feel a bit loose (its not though - they grip like sh*t to a blanket - its just the tread blocks deforming that makes them feel that way)