Another Gransport Thread (sorry)
Another Gransport Thread (sorry)
Author
Discussion

bigricho

Original Poster:

167 posts

184 months

Monday 13th August 2012
quotequote all
Hi Guys,

I've just come out of an SL55 and had always liked E46 M3s, so I have been searching for them for the past couple of weeks. Unfortunately I've become disillusioned by the number of dogs out there.

I had considered a Gransport when buying the SL 6 months ago, but fell in love with the engine, noise and versatility of the SL so didn't even bother trying anything else! Browsing PH today and I've seen some stunning Gransports, It has seriously got me thinking about stretching my budget and going for one.

Obviously they are completely different cars, but does anyone have any experience of owning both? What are people's thoughts on them? and which do people think is a better ownership proposition considering and also not considering that I would be paying twice as much for the Gransport?

I've read all there is to read of Sportsmaserati and the Maserati forum, but they are obviously a little biased towards the Italian!

Thanks in advance for any helpful replies,

Rich

prg123

1,421 posts

194 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Hi,

I've no experience of a SL55 but I had a gransport MC victory...

Fantastic car, the noise is amazing, the F1 gearbox is fab In sport mode, fuel consumption can be a little high I was getting between 10-20 mpg depending. How much I thrashed it. Servicing from a main dealer can be expensive, find a good independent.

An SL55 is 'just' a Merc, a maserati is a fantastic Italian mistress, I loved every minute of owning her, ,I only got rid because my wife couldn't get on with driving it with the F1 gearbox.

It's alway an occasion driving one...... Only downside is sometimes the electrics give spurious lights on the dash, usually a battery reset sorts that.

- Pete

Pork

9,455 posts

265 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
bigricho said:
Obviously they are completely different cars, but does anyone have any experience of owning both? What are people's thoughts on them? and which do people think is a better ownership proposition considering and also not considering that I would be paying twice as much for the Gransport?
Owned both - M3 and GS, or SL and GS?

I've owned both the M3 and GS and prefer the GS. The M3 is a phenomenal car and objectively is probably a better car than the GS. However, throw in the feel of a Maserati and the fact you don't see many about at all compared to many poeple running M3's, the Maserati takes it for me.

bigricho said:
...but they are obviously a little biased towards the Italian!
With good reason! smile

Most people who actuall own modern Maserati's (3200s onwards, particularly late 4200s onwards) are very fond of them.

If you want to compare the M3 to the GS, ask away, I'll do what I can to answe questions. I've run two M3s, the last for 3 years. Had my GS for just over 1.5 years.

bigricho

Original Poster:

167 posts

184 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Pork said:
If you want to compare the M3 to the GS, ask away, I'll do what I can to answe questions. I've run two M3s, the last for 3 years. Had my GS for just over 1.5 years.
H Pork,

Thanks for the reply. I would be using the cars very frequently (I did 8000 miles in 6 months in my SL just to give you an idea). I had planned to spend much less on this purchase than I did the SL, so what I'm really asking is that given I would be paying over twice as much for the Gransport, is it twice the experience?

jamesc69

132 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Yes it may be twice the budget but remember the GS will hold its value due to scarcity of supply. Their never appear to be more than 10 or so cars for sale on PH at any one time. Demand from Oz is also keeping values up.

Buy privately, keep the miles sensible and i recon you will be only down fuel/servicing and maintenance come 2 years time.

J

Edited by jamesc69 on Tuesday 14th August 11:03


Edited by jamesc69 on Tuesday 14th August 11:04

bigricho

Original Poster:

167 posts

184 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Yes, thats a good point. I have been keeping an eye on prices for the last year or so and I was glad that I managed to get back the same amount I paid on my SL. But do you not think GS prices will eventually fall? With the GTSs pushing down the GTs? Plus the depreciation on an E46 M3 would be manageable and surely they can't drop much further?

jamesc69

132 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
bigricho said:
Yes, thats a good point. I have been keeping an eye on prices for the last year or so and I was glad that I managed to get back the same amount I paid on my SL. But do you not think GS prices will eventually fall? With the GTSs pushing down the GTs? Plus the depreciation on an E46 M3 would be manageable and surely they can't drop much further?
I think it comes down to supply and demand pure and simple. The Gransport has been one of motoring best keep secrets. But people are now in the know and are chasing very few cars.

You would have thought that E46 M3 values could not drop much further but there are so many about for sale that competition for sales will inevitably reduce values further IMHO.

J

cc8s

4,258 posts

234 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
My mate has one coming up for sale shortly. It's a fantastic car - compact, quick and exotic. Drop me a PM if you want to know more and I can point you in his direction.

lambo_xx

2,199 posts

228 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
bigricho said:
Hi Guys,

I've just come out of an SL55 and had always liked E46 M3s, so I have been searching for them for the past couple of weeks. Unfortunately I've become disillusioned by the number of dogs out there.

I had considered a Gransport when buying the SL 6 months ago, but fell in love with the engine, noise and versatility of the SL so didn't even bother trying anything else! Browsing PH today and I've seen some stunning Gransports, It has seriously got me thinking about stretching my budget and going for one.

Obviously they are completely different cars, but does anyone have any experience of owning both? What are people's thoughts on them? and which do people think is a better ownership proposition considering and also not considering that I would be paying twice as much for the Gransport?

I've read all there is to read of Sportsmaserati and the Maserati forum, but they are obviously a little biased towards the Italian!

Thanks in advance for any helpful replies,

Rich
Hi there,

I've got a Gransport (among other things) so hopefully will be able to help here.

I have never owned a BMW M3 so I'm afraid i can't comment on them. As for whether the Gransport is worth twice the money I'm not sure if any car is justifiably worth twice, 3 times the money etc.

The Gransport is a fantastic car! It is a proper 4 seater, I have had 2 6ft adults in the back before and they both commented on how much comfier and how much more room there was than my 911 Turbo. The F1 box is ok in normal mode, but it's pretty good in Sport mode (so far i have just left it in sport mode). The engine sounds brilliant, if you want it to sound absolutely insane you could fit a Larini exhaust to it cloud9

Fuel consumption isn't great but then I can't imagine it will be much worse than your SL. The 55 is a thirsty beast. Main dealer servicing and parts will be pricy but if you find a good specialist (there are lots out there) that will keep cost right down. Reliability has been pretty good and as far as I know most Modern Maseratis are.

Spec wise, that all comes down to your taste and budget. The general consensus is that the full leather interior is nicer, however the earlier (therefore cheaper cars) tended to have the half weird cloth thing. The LE spec cars had most of the options on them and are the ones to go for in my opinion.




if you yhave any specific questions to ask feel free.

Hope that helps

lambo_xx

2,199 posts

228 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
cc8s said:
My mate has one coming up for sale shortly. It's a fantastic car - compact, quick and exotic. Drop me a PM if you want to know more and I can point you in his direction.
That would be my car CC8s is speaking about. I have it up for sale just because I am running out of room and I can't really justify having it as well as my 911 Turbo as practical cars. So I have stuck it up for sale, I'm not too fussed if it doesn't sell as I'm more than happy to keep it biggrin

Let me know if it's any interest to you.

http://pistonheads.com/sales/4146308.htm


Luke.

12,052 posts

281 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Interesting topic. Is there much difference between a late 4200 and the Gransport?

Pork

9,455 posts

265 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
bigricho said:
H Pork,

Thanks for the reply. I would be using the cars very frequently (I did 8000 miles in 6 months in my SL just to give you an idea). I had planned to spend much less on this purchase than I did the SL, so what I'm really asking is that given I would be paying over twice as much for the Gransport, is it twice the experience?
hmm....tough question to answer! As James points out, you'd need to consider depreciation really, as thats the cost that will hit most.

M3s - you'd get a cracker for £15-20k.
GS - you should be able to get a nice one for mid-£20k's upwards.

I went with a GS as I was getting stung on running costs on the M3. £800 service, £1200 service etc....and I didnt see the 'value' in that. I was also only getting low to mid-20's MPG out of it.

I bought the GS as a second car, but it gets used a lot. Not daily (I dont drive daily) but the first year, I did c12k miles. Trouble free ones, too.

Cost wise, I think the M3 and the GS are reasonably comparable. The GS is a bit more expensive on maintenance, but not by much.

Buy well, use a good indipendant and hopfully you'll have some good motoring.

I really dont know if you would say its worth twice the money, but for me, it was a clear choice and once I've not yet regretted.

The performance and running costs might be broadly similar, but the ownership experience couldnt be more different. The GranSport gives more than just performance, its generally a lovely ownership experience. I've had people start conversations because of it and have poeple show an interest in cars that have never previously given two hoots.

Although there's a purchase price different,for me, its worth it.

Have you thought about a 4200? A late 4200 is very comparable to a GS and can be have for a considerable amount less without being considerably less of a car.

crostonian

2,427 posts

203 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
With regard to the effect on Gransport values by the Gran Turismo I feel that the reason the GS has hardened is that as a driving experience it is superior to the GT 4.2, however when the GTS 4.7s start to become sub £40k then I feel this will have a knock down effect on the GS, albeit only a slight one as it is a rare car that is getting rarer and will still have its fans over the GTS.

F355GTS

3,875 posts

286 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Loved my Gransport, totally reliable and tremendous fun, even managed 25mpg on a long 80mph run through France. If i had a criticism it's that for the gearchange you need it in sport but the ride in sport is harsh, if I'd have kept the car longer I'd have worked a way to separate the two and have the OK ride and sport shifts/ engine mapping thumbup

chris5150

742 posts

231 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
I am another fan of the gransport.Great cars, M3 nowhere near that special feeling for me. I think the CSL gets closer becuase of its noise factor
I think most that have owned a gransport always seem to be left with the twinkle in their eye about them when they move to something else, most have huge respect for the car, me included.
I think anybody would enjoy GS ownership

housen

2,366 posts

223 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Luke. said:
Interesting topic. Is there much difference between a late 4200 and the Gransport?
oh dear hehe

Luke.

12,052 posts

281 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
housen said:
oh dear hehe
Informative. Thanks. hehe

Pork

9,455 posts

265 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
housen said:
oh dear hehe
confused Is that not a valid question?

housen

2,366 posts

223 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Pork said:
housen said:
oh dear hehe
confused Is that not a valid question?
no just meant thats another can of worrms that may send this thread into a different direction

im no expert but i think the 4200 is a total dog compared to the Gs

apart from from the bommerang lights which are deemed as v cool

Luke.

12,052 posts

281 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
housen said:
Pork said:
housen said:
oh dear hehe
confused Is that not a valid question?
no just meant thats another can of worrms that may send this thread into a different direction

im no expert but i think the 4200 is a total dog compared to the Gs

apart from from the bommerang lights which are deemed as v cool
I think you're getting your 3200s confused with your 4200s. wink