The old favorite...Cracked Wheels.
The old favorite...Cracked Wheels.
Author
Discussion

roofer

Original Poster:

5,136 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
What do you do when your wheel cracks at 130 and rips a hole in the sidewall?




Answer? you st yourself and try to slide across 2 lanes of artics redface

And after losing total cofidence in the stwk BMW rims, you put these on



BMW 313 Replicas for a monkey, and you know what, i bet they last longer than the st Cromodora/BWW ones!

Edited by roofer on Tuesday 14th August 17:07

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
at 130 in the morning or at 130 mph?

Did you hit a pothole?


DennisCooper

1,340 posts

202 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Do you *REALLY* think that replica wheels are more robust than oem wheels?

Chances of you having this issue again are quite high!

Good luck!

Cheers, Dennis!

roofer

Original Poster:

5,136 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
monthefish said:
at 130 in the morning or at 130 mph?

Did you hit a pothole?
It was leptons which roughly converted is 70mph.whistle No pothole involved and the 3rd fractured rim i've had.

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Were you on runflats?

roofer

Original Poster:

5,136 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
DennisCooper said:
Do you *REALLY* think that replica wheels are more robust than oem wheels?

Chances of you having this issue again are quite high!

Good luck!

Cheers, Dennis!
Dennis, i've had more sets of reps in the last 10 years than i can remember, going back to a set of 5 series parallels (37's?) And do you know how many issues i've had with them? None. If i was racing round the ring every week i'd go and give 3k for some super dooper magnesium jobs. For bashing up and down motorways, i'm happy to buy a set of reps once a year, and the 313's were actually lighter than the 225'S that came off.

roofer

Original Poster:

5,136 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
monthefish said:
Were you on runflats?
I always take RF's off as soon as i buy any BMW, no exception with this one. Its been on 'normal' tyres for the last 60k miles.

DennisCooper

1,340 posts

202 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Hi Roofer

Yes, some people do indeed report no issues with replica wheels and you do seem to have had good luck in that overall !

However, by logic that replica wheels aren't made to the same higher standards, have the higher grade materials used to make them, any R&D etc it stands that they are indeed an inferior product and prone/likely to crack, bend or fail more than a quality made product.

Of course, genuine wheels, branded higher quality wheels etc can and do bend/crack, but chances are also correspondingly less.

As per above, good luck to you !

Cheers, Dennis!

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
roofer said:
and the 313's were actually lighter than the 225'S that came off.
Which ones did you buy?

I tempted to buy some, purely because they'll be (far) easier to clean...

roofer

Original Poster:

5,136 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
monthefish said:
roofer said:
and the 313's were actually lighter than the 225'S that came off.
Which ones did you buy?

I tempted to buy some, purely because they'll be (far) easier to clean...
A fella in Coventry i'll get his details tomorrow service was excellent.

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
DennisCooper said:
Hi Roofer

Yes, some people do indeed report no issues with replica wheels and you do seem to have had good luck in that overall !

However, by logic that replica wheels aren't made to the same higher standards, have the higher grade materials used to make them, any R&D etc it stands that they are indeed an inferior product and prone/likely to crack, bend or fail more than a quality made product.

Of course, genuine wheels, branded higher quality wheels etc can and do bend/crack, but chances are also correspondingly less.

As per above, good luck to you !

Cheers, Dennis!
Generally I would agree with you, but BMW Styling 225's cannot be described as the bold above.........

roofer

Original Poster:

5,136 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
DennisCooper said:
Hi Roofer



However, by logic that replica wheels aren't made to the same higher standards, have the higher grade materials used to make them, any R&D etc it stands that they are indeed an inferior product and prone/likely to crack, bend or fail more than a quality made product.



Cheers, Dennis!
Like the genuine BMW ones pictured? Or the Alpina cotton reels i had on my 335 that also cracked?

The last decent wheels BMW used were made by BBS and Mahle. Big rims and UK roads don't mix. However, like a lot of other people, i bought a car and it had these wheels on it, i also fitted the cottons expecting another level of quality. BMW has lost its way regarding quality, and i've owned them since 1985. The decline has been noticeable on every model since then.

roofer

Original Poster:

5,136 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
monthefish said:
roofer said:
and the 313's were actually lighter than the 225'S that came off.
Which ones did you buy?

I tempted to buy some, purely because they'll be (far) easier to clean...
Found him.

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/x4-19-BMW-E90-E91-E92-E4...

DennisCooper

1,340 posts

202 months

Tuesday 14th August 2012
quotequote all
Hi

As per my earlier response, some people do indeed not experience issues with lower quality wheels and others do manage to bend and crack oem and higher quality ones. It's just the chances of failure of some level is higher with lower quality wheels that's all. I've only ever put on genuine BMW Tuner brand wheels or, very high quality aftermarket brands on my cars and never had an issue, and my only time using a replica wheel, it cracked at town speeds of circa 25-30 mph - I dread to think what would've happened had I been at motorway speeds. As a result of that, and of course seeing and reading what other people experience, I regard wheels as a safety related item and thus will not compromise in that respect.

Good luck once more! I do hope they work/last well for you!

Cheers, Dennis!

James P

3,038 posts

268 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
E30M3SE said:
DennisCooper said:
Hi Roofer

Yes, some people do indeed report no issues with replica wheels and you do seem to have had good luck in that overall !

However, by logic that replica wheels aren't made to the same higher standards, have the higher grade materials used to make them, any R&D etc it stands that they are indeed an inferior product and prone/likely to crack, bend or fail more than a quality made product.

Of course, genuine wheels, branded higher quality wheels etc can and do bend/crack, but chances are also correspondingly less.

As per above, good luck to you !

Cheers, Dennis!
Generally I would agree with you, but BMW Styling 225's cannot be described as the bold above.........
Agreed, you would hope that OEM would be higher quality. The 296's seem to prove otherwise though.