Do you think there really were any yobs?
Do you think there really were any yobs?

Poll: Do you think there really were any yobs?

Total Members Polled: 74

Yes: 82%
No: 18%
Author
Discussion

Somewhatfoolish

Original Poster:

5,104 posts

217 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2188690/Ca...

A cat has been found with an elastic band tied around its leg. All very unfortunate for the poor cat, but I just don't believe that this is anything other than an accident. I assume it's been out and somehow got tangled in the thing. Yet the Daily Mail is blaming it on unspecified yobs.

Even if it does turn out that humans were involved in some way, I should imagine that it will have been one mentally ill weirdo rather than a feral gang...

jogon

2,971 posts

189 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Article said:
"An elastic band had been wrapped round his rear left leg five times and later had to be carefully cut off. " - Leg has now been amputated..

Maybe it was just the Houdini of the cat world that went tragically wrong but it does sound like someone might have done it intentionally.

So I vote 'yes'

Laurel Green

31,317 posts

263 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
jogon said:
Article said:


So I vote 'yes'
Likewise!

172ff

3,777 posts

226 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Mean while in Kent we cook are cats in the microwave:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-kent-19271076


Somewhatfoolish

Original Poster:

5,104 posts

217 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Maybe he was trying to dry it. Eight year olds are stupid and well meaning, ususally. I don't feel comfortable labelling that as intentional animal cruelty without knowing the circumstances. I am, however, very comfortable assuming the RSPCA would hype it up for publicity whatever the circumstances.

OllieC

3,816 posts

245 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
I dug up a worm once that had tied itself in a knot

whoami

13,201 posts

271 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Somewhatfoolish said:
Maybe he was trying to dry it. Eight year olds are stupid and well meaning, ususally. I don't feel comfortable labelling that as intentional animal cruelty without knowing the circumstances. I am, however, very comfortable assuming the RSPCA would hype it up for publicity whatever the circumstances.
I'm not sure whether you are being deliberately obtuse or not?.

However, your username appears appropriate.

rohrl

8,984 posts

176 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
I'm not sure whether it's "yobs" or not. How could I be from the evidence presented? Was the woman who put the cat in a wheelie bin a yob? I suppose she is but I can't help feel that the Daily Mail is not trying to conjure up the image of a middle-aged female office worker.

Somewhatfoolish

Original Poster:

5,104 posts

217 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
whoami said:
I'm not sure whether you are being deliberately obtuse or not?.

However, your username appears appropriate.
Well think about it.

Most eight year olds are well intentioned

Not many eight year olds want to hurt cats

No eight year olds have decent judgement

Both scenarios are compatible with him putting a cat in a microwave. Without further information, we just don't know. I don't think I'd have put a cat in a microwave at eight to try and dry it out (although I wouldn't have known that it would do a lot more damage then say a cooker by the way), but I could have done it when I was four.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Somewhatfoolish said:
whoami said:
I'm not sure whether you are being deliberately obtuse or not?.

However, your username appears appropriate.
Well think about it.

Most eight year olds are well intentioned

Not many eight year olds want to hurt cats

No eight year olds have decent judgement

Both scenarios are compatible with him putting a cat in a microwave. Without further information, we just don't know. I don't think I'd have put a cat in a microwave at eight to try and dry it out (although I wouldn't have known that it would do a lot more damage then say a cooker by the way), but I could have done it when I was four.
8 year old incident possibly accidental/excusable.

However I very much doubt your opening example of the elastic band being wrapped (or tied as the Northern Echo reported before the DM story) around the cats leg 5 times was by any means an accident as you suggest. If the band was wound around so tight as to cut off blood flow sufficient to destroy the amount of muscle tissue, nerve endings, blood vessels etc, for a long enough period to render the leg un-savable, you'll have to enlighten me as to how a cat could manage that by itself, especially if the band was tied not wrapped?


Pixelpeep

9,050 posts

173 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
if the child is old enough to understand what punishment is then they should be given it.

if the child is too young to go to prison send parents instead.

Pure evil - if you can intentionally cause suffering on a defensiveness animal then you should be taken from your family and shot.

makes me really REALLY angry stories like this frown


ukwill

10,289 posts

238 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Pixelpeep said:
if the child is old enough to understand what punishment is then they should be given it.

if the child is too young to go to prison send parents instead.

Pure evil - if you can intentionally cause suffering on a defensiveness animal then you should be taken from your family and shot.

makes me really REALLY angry stories like this frown
True. No one should be able to harm defensiveness animals.

Pixelpeep

9,050 posts

173 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
stupid auto correct frown


Somewhatfoolish

Original Poster:

5,104 posts

217 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Pixelpeep said:
if the child is old enough to understand what punishment is then they should be given it.

if the child is too young to go to prison send parents instead.

Pure evil - if you can intentionally cause suffering on a defensiveness animal then you should be taken from your family and shot.

makes me really REALLY angry stories like this frown
Your attitude makes me angry, it's moronic. How is sending the parents to prison going to acheive anything at all? You are the one with a primitive blood lust, which is ironic indeed!

Somewhatfoolish

Original Poster:

5,104 posts

217 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
djstevec said:
8 year old incident possibly accidental/excusable.

However I very much doubt your opening example of the elastic band being wrapped (or tied as the Northern Echo reported before the DM story) around the cats leg 5 times was by any means an accident as you suggest. If the band was wound around so tight as to cut off blood flow sufficient to destroy the amount of muscle tissue, nerve endings, blood vessels etc, for a long enough period to render the leg un-savable, you'll have to enlighten me as to how a cat could manage that by itself, especially if the band was tied not wrapped?
I've no idea. One possible situation is that it was already tied around something, and whatever it was tied around fell off. Then the cat came along and stuck its leg through somehow, and then the blood started accumulating in the base of the leg.

I am not saying that this being intentional by someone is impossible or anything close to that. I just don't believe there are great big roaming bands of animal abusing yobs.

Pixelpeep

9,050 posts

173 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Somewhatfoolish said:
Pixelpeep said:
if the child is old enough to understand what punishment is then they should be given it.

if the child is too young to go to prison send parents instead.

Pure evil - if you can intentionally cause suffering on a defensiveness animal then you should be taken from your family and shot.

makes me really REALLY angry stories like this frown
Your attitude makes me angry, it's moronic. How is sending the parents to prison going to acheive anything at all? You are the one with a primitive blood lust, which is ironic indeed!
eye for an eye. if you don't hurt it it wont hurt you.

Sending the parents to prison might teach other parents that they need to take some responsibility for their inbred angry over nothing sprogs

whoami

13,201 posts

271 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Somewhatfoolish said:
whoami said:
I'm not sure whether you are being deliberately obtuse or not?.

However, your username appears appropriate.
Well think about it.

Most eight year olds are well intentioned

Not many eight year olds want to hurt cats

No eight year olds have decent judgement

Both scenarios are compatible with him putting a cat in a microwave. Without further information, we just don't know. I don't think I'd have put a cat in a microwave at eight to try and dry it out (although I wouldn't have known that it would do a lot more damage then say a cooker by the way), but I could have done it when I was four.
Sorry, I was referring primarily to your OP.

It's highly unlikely that there is any other explanation than a "yob" having deliberately harmed the animal.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Somewhatfoolish said:
I've no idea. One possible situation is that it was already tied around something, and whatever it was tied around fell off. Then the cat came along and stuck its leg through somehow, and then the blood started accumulating in the base of the leg.

I am not saying that this being intentional by someone is impossible or anything close to that. I just don't believe there are great big roaming bands of animal abusing yobs.
I find your scenario pretty implausible, however possible as a "one in a million" chance. It doesn't change my thinking as to the cause of this incident.

Whilst in agreement with your thinking that they're aren't, "great big roaming bands of animal abusing yobs", it only takes one person to do something like this. Taking into account the number of abuse incidents, unless perpetrated by the same person, then "yobs" certainly do exist. You should maybe Google the words "German Shepherd, firecracker, duct tape, mouth", to realise human beings are capable of some very intentionally cruel acts to animals, however I would advise you to never look at the photos of the outcome.

In response to your poll, which has a very simple question, yes yobs, or yobbos as they were called I was growing up, exist, have always existed and will continue to do so.

Edited by djstevec on Wednesday 15th August 19:04

whoami

13,201 posts

271 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Somewhatfoolish said:
djstevec said:
8 year old incident possibly accidental/excusable.

However I very much doubt your opening example of the elastic band being wrapped (or tied as the Northern Echo reported before the DM story) around the cats leg 5 times was by any means an accident as you suggest. If the band was wound around so tight as to cut off blood flow sufficient to destroy the amount of muscle tissue, nerve endings, blood vessels etc, for a long enough period to render the leg un-savable, you'll have to enlighten me as to how a cat could manage that by itself, especially if the band was tied not wrapped?
One possible situation is that it was already tied around something, and whatever it was tied around fell off. Then the cat came along and stuck its leg through somehow, and then the blood started accumulating in the base of the leg.
Stop being silly now.

powerstroke

10,283 posts

191 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
rohrl said:
I'm not sure whether it's "yobs" or not. How could I be from the evidence presented? Was the woman who put the cat in a wheelie bin a yob? I suppose she is but I can't help feel that the Daily Mail is not trying to conjure up the image of a middle-aged female office worker.
Um I think you will find Yobs can be rich, poor , middle class or whatever!!!
nasty, selfish or just horrid isnt limited to the ferel underclass...