F30 320d mpg
F30 320d mpg
Author
Discussion

pauldavies85

Original Poster:

423 posts

217 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
Ive now completed around 5000 miles in my new 320d, and I have been very pleased.

How were, usual saga of mpg reality being much lower than expected, my trip that I reset at 1000 miles shows average mpg of 48. I drive in the Eco setting most of the time and rarely put my foot down.

I do have the 8 speed sport auto box, thigh was lead to believe this would for a change increas efficicency over the manual.


What sort of mpg are you guys hitting?

pauldavies85

Original Poster:

423 posts

217 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
I should also mention that most of mileage is from commuting etc which is a mixed of dual carriage way and flowing a roads, little town driving. Each journey is 15 miles plus. Car always hits full oil temperature.

14-7

6,233 posts

222 months

Wednesday 15th August 2012
quotequote all
I actually had a 320d sport from my dealer the other day whilst my 123d was in for a service. No matter how gently I drove it (eco mode) I couldn't get more than 2 mpg more than my 123d on the average mpg.

I covered just over 100 miles on normal roads/routes I would drive and wasn't doing anything different.

The 320d just felt very wheezy when going for overtakes. Quite a nice comfortable cruiser, the suspension felt a lot better in dealing with bumps and rebound but overall it felt soft and wobbly at the front end, a bit slow and dare I say it, boring?

BMW's are meant to be drivers cars but my last few Alfa's knocked the spots off them when it came to involvement in what's going on (even a 9 year old 156).

Tea Pot One

1,870 posts

259 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
FWIW on journey's such as you describe ... I used to get 42mpg on my E92 320d (177) auto ... so 48mpg sounds far more than I would have got and seems IMO a realistic improvement from the newer car. The most I ever got from my 320d was 52mpg on a dual carraigeway/motorway run of 200 miles ...


pauldavies85

Original Poster:

423 posts

217 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
It funny you mention that because I got thinking for two reasons:

1. my firend who doesnt drive conervatively at all gets similar returns on his older shape 320d coupe.

2. a patient of mine was talking about her previous generation 320ED (same as mine) though manual with smaller wheels and gets more like 65mpg.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
I used to get around 39mpg from my 320d ed auto touring, and 44ish on a run without thinking about it.
Sat at 60mph would see it hit the 60's but that rarely happened.

So 48 average is pretty good I reckon and 25% better than my old car.


Having said that, I did 100 miles in my E350cdi estate yesterday, Norwich to Cambridge centre and back, and sat with it at 72mph on cruise and saw 45mpg.


Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
Having said that, I did 100 miles in my E350cdi estate yesterday, Norwich to Cambridge centre and back, and sat with it at 72mph on cruise and saw 45mpg.
Thats a bit dissapointing, I'd hoped we were at the stage where cars like that would do 50+ in those circumstances.

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Thats a bit dissapointing, I'd hoped we were at the stage where cars like that would do 50+ in those circumstances.
Yep, I averaged 58.9 in my E92 at that speed on the way from Zagreb to Vodice (320km)

halo34

2,890 posts

230 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
If its first 5k its still bedding in, I would say too early to call it.

48 mpg on a 320d pre lci manual with 50+ on a run. Engines at 72k now.


chrisx666

808 posts

292 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
gizlaroc said:
Having said that, I did 100 miles in my E350cdi estate yesterday, Norwich to Cambridge centre and back, and sat with it at 72mph on cruise and saw 45mpg.
Thats a bit dissapointing, I'd hoped we were at the stage where cars like that would do 50+ in those circumstances.
We are, sometimes..sort of.. The 640d display showed 53mpg during a trip from Halifax to Scarborough last month. Eco-pro mode and not exactly pressing on, though the route is far from flat. Computer reset when pulling out of the drive at home and checked when parking up at the coast.

I don't bother with Eco mode any more though. The couple of mpg gain does not make up for the dulled throttle response.

There has been some progress in the industry. One of my regular commutes (same route for 10 years, and no, I do not write down every trip/fill in an anorak style but remember the headline numbers):

Golf 1.8T (150hp) 35mpg
325i E46 (192hp) 30mpg
645i (330hp) 20mpg
A6 3.0TDI (245hp 4wd) 30mpg
640d (313hp) 40mpg

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
pauldavies85 said:
Ive now completed around 5000 miles in my new 320d, and I have been very pleased.

How were, usual saga of mpg reality being much lower than expected, my trip that I reset at 1000 miles shows average mpg of 48. I drive in the Eco setting most of the time and rarely put my foot down.

I do have the 8 speed sport auto box, thigh was lead to believe this would for a change increas efficicency over the manual.


What sort of mpg are you guys hitting?
47mpg from a 318d on the Autobahn, not pushing too hard (130 km/h most of the time, up to about 160 on the derestricted parts) with a little bit of town driving. This was over 900 km in three days, on a car with 4-5kkm on the clock.

TackleburyUk

493 posts

221 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
My F30 318d has covered 3.5k now.

Never reset OBC, its showing 51.8mpg.

My joinery computer regularly shows 60-65 on my commute to work, it’s a mere 7 miles one way.

Around town I can easily get 60mpg, if I stick it in sport and nail it still shows 49.

Anything under 50 and I’m disappointed!

llewop

3,973 posts

242 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Done just over 3k in mine so far.

I've not reset the computer at all - the average is going up all the time, now just short of 56 mpg.

To start with a fair percentage of my mileage was around town, most at the moment is my commute to work, so about 60 miles each way along a mix of country roads and A road. I do leave it in eco mode most of the time but I'm not averse to pressing the loud pedal or 'making progress' as mood/circumstances allow wink


pauldavies85

Original Poster:

423 posts

217 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
So following your replies and some google searching, I decided tore set computer and drive like a granny.

I mean really slow pull away, very steady speed the lot. I just about saw 52mpg, then as soon as I kept up with the traffic a bit more, down to 47mpg. This is over a 50 mile cycle, which I know isn't that reliable but I at no point hit these banded about figures of 65mpg, or close for that matter. All was done in the Eco pro setting, which is significantly more sluggish than the other modes.

Should I see the dealer just get a system check. As said my car is the ED model too so I thought I would at least see high figures driving super conservatively.

Maybe the 8 speed auto isn't as Eco as claimed?

As the ED model is meant to have a longer final drive ration, would this still be the case if I spec'd the sport auto box?

agreen

232 posts

288 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
Afternoon,

My OBC is showing 56.7 average over the first 8500 miles in my F30 320d Sport manual. I generally drive with eco-pro enabled in urban areas and on motorway cruises then stick it in sport when on fun roads or when the traffic is light. My journeys are probably ~60% motorways/dual carriageways 30% a/b roads and 10% urban driving. Driving at about 70 on a motorway it usually does around 60mpg but I have had it up to 70mpg before (lots of lorries holding up proceedings). When driving on autobahns wink 85 seems to be the point at which the mpg tails off back into the 40mpgs.


texasjohn

3,687 posts

262 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
I think the key here is going to be auto v manual.

Derwins Revenge

316 posts

201 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
My 320d sport manages about 45 mpg these days (about 2000 miles on it), but I stick it in sport as soon as I start off, otherwise I feel like its slowly eating my soul.
When I first got it I used Eco pro more and could get about 53 round town, so good eonomy is available if you want it but you really have to drive carefully.


llewop

3,973 posts

242 months

Friday 31st August 2012
quotequote all
llewop said:
Done just over 3k in mine so far.

I've not reset the computer at all - the average is going up all the time, now just short of 56 mpg.

To start with a fair percentage of my mileage was around town, most at the moment is my commute to work, so about 60 miles each way along a mix of country roads and A road. I do leave it in eco mode most of the time but I'm not averse to pressing the loud pedal or 'making progress' as mood/circumstances allow wink
An update on my figures and comment on auto vs manual:

I've now done about 4.5k and seem to be averaging just over 60 mpg without great difficulty and enough 'loud' pedal for journeys not to get boring.

Also; bumped into a colleague who has an auto - he said he's getting 64! So perhaps the OPs does need a check-up!

Wills2

29,940 posts

206 months

Friday 31st August 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
gizlaroc said:
Having said that, I did 100 miles in my E350cdi estate yesterday, Norwich to Cambridge centre and back, and sat with it at 72mph on cruise and saw 45mpg.
Thats a bit dissapointing, I'd hoped we were at the stage where cars like that would do 50+ in those circumstances.
I think that's bloody good for a 2 tonne, 155mph, 265hp estate that will hit 60 in 6.5 secs.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Friday 31st August 2012
quotequote all
Me too. the F11 520d we had would do 47mpg doing that.