David Cameron to push through cap on care costs
David Cameron to push through cap on care costs
Author
Discussion

Fittster

Original Poster:

20,120 posts

244 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
"
The Prime Minister is preparing to announce that care home costs, which can run to hundreds of thousands of pounds, will be capped for the first time.
However, any reforms would not come into force until after the next election in 2015, meaning tens of thousands of frail and disabled people will be forced to wait for the help.

Finding an affordable system of caring for the country’s rapidly ageing population has been one of the most contentious and difficult policies confronting ministers over recent years.
Cross-party talks between Labour and the Coalition on the subject broke down earlier this year, while a previous attempt to reach consensus failed shortly before the 2010 election.

Last month, the Health Secretary, Andrew Lansley, said the government would like to place an upper limit on the amount elderly and disabled adults face paying for their care in old age.

However, he said he could not promise that money would be available to pay for the reforms, which were proposed by the economist Andrew Dilnot last year.

Mr Dilnot called for a cap of £35,000 on the care bills that adults will pay over their lifetimes. Any costs above this level would be met by the state. However, the plan would cost the Treasury an extra £1.7 billion a year"


Well it's nice to know the economy has picked up and the state has a surplus in its budget to pay for this.

muffinmenace

1,100 posts

219 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Well it's nice to know the economy has picked up and the state has a surplus in its budget to pay for this.
I think it's pretty obvious tax rates would go up to pay for the elderly, there's a lot more of them than us.

PeanutHead

7,839 posts

201 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Whenever i read articles on old people and cost to keep them, i think of a logans run scenario and how it would work in todays society.
How many 20 or 30 year olds will say they would be happy being 90+ in a care home only able to do very little for themselves.
It's about time we had a system that allows anyone who wishes to call it a day to do so, in style and with dignity.

greygoose

9,674 posts

226 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
PeanutHead said:
Whenever i read articles on old people and cost to keep them, i think of a logans run scenario and how it would work in todays society.
How many 20 or 30 year olds will say they would be happy being 90+ in a care home only able to do very little for themselves.
It's about time we had a system that allows anyone who wishes to call it a day to do so, in style and with dignity.
Very true, quality of life is far more important than longevity imo.

rich1231

17,340 posts

291 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
greygoose said:
Very true, quality of life is far more important than longevity imo.
How old are you?

muffinmenace

1,100 posts

219 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
PeanutHead said:
Whenever i read articles on old people and cost to keep them, i think of a logans run scenario and how it would work in todays society.
How many 20 or 30 year olds will say they would be happy being 90+ in a care home only able to do very little for themselves.
It's about time we had a system that allows anyone who wishes to call it a day to do so, in style and with dignity.
I think your justifications on offing yourself at 90 might be a bit different than at 30 hehe

Perhaps adopt the Suicide Booths in Futurama, just insert your house deeds into the slot to activate it.

Prince Phillip is 91 and is still up to plenty...

Murph7355

42,082 posts

287 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
With funds not being limitless I guess a cap is the least they can do. Won't stop the hand wringers coming out in force and moaning though, probably resulting in a watering down of an already weak policy.

greygoose

9,674 posts

226 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
rich1231 said:
How old are you?
A youthful 40, watched my gran waste away in a care home bored out of her mind for ten years, wouldn't be my idea of a good time (there weren't many blokes who seemed to reach very old age there though).

Countdown

49,579 posts

227 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
muffinmenace said:
Fittster said:
Well it's nice to know the economy has picked up and the state has a surplus in its budget to pay for this.
I think it's pretty obvious tax rates would go up to pay for the elderly, there's a lot more of them than us.
Or spending in other areas would go down.

The cynic in me wonders if this is because the elderly are more likely to vote Tory.

rich1231

17,340 posts

291 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
greygoose said:
A youthful 40, watched my gran waste away in a care home bored out of her mind for ten years, wouldn't be my idea of a good time (there weren't many blokes who seemed to reach very old age there though).
Watched my granddad lead an active life until 99.

greygoose

9,674 posts

226 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
rich1231 said:
greygoose said:
A youthful 40, watched my gran waste away in a care home bored out of her mind for ten years, wouldn't be my idea of a good time (there weren't many blokes who seemed to reach very old age there though).
Watched my granddad lead an active life until 99.
That's good he had a good quality of life, if there is no quality of life then euthanasia is acceptable in my opinion.

PeanutHead

7,839 posts

201 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
I think the key part i posted is this,
It's about time we had a system that allows anyone who wishes to call it a day to do so, in style and with dignity.
I'm not sujesting folks make a choice at a young age but if there was a system that allowed anyone at any age for any reason to check out, would that really be a bad thing?

muffinmenace

1,100 posts

219 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Countdown said:
Or spending in other areas would go down.

The cynic in me wonders if this is because the elderly are more likely to vote Tory.
Well, there's nothing wrong with voting Tory

I don't think it's the simple case of populist policys but doing the right thing for the population. We don't have a society that looks after it's old, they're fobbed off so it's up to the state to come up with a solution, the state would end up picking up the tab if they ran out of money anyway.

What's needed to go along with this is a longer term plan of increasing the retirement, bigger pension contributions from everyone who works and provisions for care, it just means the current lot paying twice...

Murph7355

42,082 posts

287 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Totally misread this!

Had it been a cap on the amount of state contribution, fair enough.

This just sounds like madness though (now I've read it properly).

So they've managed to make little in the way of material cuts to public spending, and are now committing the country to open ended care bills. Well done. And I thought Labour were idiots.

MickC

1,101 posts

289 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Murph7355 said:
Totally misread this!

Had it been a cap on the amount of state contribution, fair enough.

This just sounds like madness though (now I've read it properly).

So they've managed to make little in the way of material cuts to public spending, and are now committing the country to open ended care bills. Well done. And I thought Labour were idiots.
We are already committed to open ended care bills. The difference here is, people who have saved or behaved financially responsibly during their life and have some money or a home left after retirement are not peanalised to support the feckless who have saved nothing but get the same care.

I would say 35k is too low imho, 50-100k would sound more like it, although that still might mean selling the family home to fund care.

crankedup

25,764 posts

274 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
If people really cared for elderly family members perhaps they would consider direct home care, at home.
The French are so much more family orientated, the younger generations respect the elderly, rather than shove them into a 'care home'. Successive Governments wrestle with the costs of the elderly, consideration to social change is not even mentioned. U.K. = bottom line.

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
crankedup said:
If people really cared for elderly family members perhaps they would consider direct home care, at home.
The French are so much more family orientated, the younger generations respect the elderly, rather than shove them into a 'care home'. Successive Governments wrestle with the costs of the elderly, consideration to social change is not even mentioned. U.K. = bottom line.
Once in a while you post something that doesn't have me considering all manner of things from your mental well being and parentage to intelligence.

The above is about right. Why do we think that it is right to put Mum and Dad in a home when so many often it is the wrong thing to do morally and financially?

It is not likely to be the solution for all. Some will require a level of care well above that your average ‘working’ family can. Others though need little more than a look in a couple of times a day and perhaps making sure that they get a proper meal if they have trouble. Care homes are not full of droolers waiting for their turn in the wooden box and there are a lot of people in them that really would not need to be if their offspring were not so selfish and short sighted.

It isn't the solution for all, but it is the solution for many.

Murph7355

42,082 posts

287 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
MickC said:
We are already committed to open ended care bills. The difference here is, people who have saved or behaved financially responsibly during their life and have some money or a home left after retirement are not peanalised to support the feckless who have saved nothing but get the same care.

I would say 35k is too low imho, 50-100k would sound more like it, although that still might mean selling the family home to fund care.
They're not open ended really though. There are limits to the services provided by the state and I would suggest those limits will reduce over time as realisation dawns that we don't have a pot to piss in.

If you have an asset base to enable you to look after yourself, you should use it IMO. And if you're that bothered about the feckless getting the "same" treatment as you later on, sell the house now and go and blow the proceeds on hookers, drugs, booze and cars. And at least you'll have some fun stories when sat next to Waynetta in a st hole of a state provided care home...

This isn't massively different to the child benefit arguments. Universal benefits are daft. We should be minimising expenditure and encouraging people to fend for themselves (or for families to do it - am off for a sit down now as I think I just agreed with crankedup on something).

Bill Carr

2,234 posts

265 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
crankedup said:
If people really cared for elderly family members perhaps they would consider direct home care, at home.
The French are so much more family orientated, the younger generations respect the elderly, rather than shove them into a 'care home'. Successive Governments wrestle with the costs of the elderly, consideration to social change is not even mentioned. U.K. = bottom line.
I agree. I think we have a duty to our parents to look after them in their second childhood, as far as possible.

Riley Blue

23,217 posts

257 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Bill Carr said:
crankedup said:
If people really cared for elderly family members perhaps they would consider direct home care, at home.
The French are so much more family orientated, the younger generations respect the elderly, rather than shove them into a 'care home'. Successive Governments wrestle with the costs of the elderly, consideration to social change is not even mentioned. U.K. = bottom line.
I agree. I think we have a duty to our parents to look after them in their second childhood, as far as possible.
I couldn't agree more. I just spent a week with my 92 year old Dad who lives at home, alone since my Mum died almost two years ago. He has a carer in the morning, meals on wheels at lunchtime and my sister calls every evening. All he is able to do (he has heart, lung and kidney problems) is sleep and watch TV but he's in his own home, with all his belongings around him. When he needs medical care, he gets it. If he has a hospital appointment, I'll make a 400 mile round trip to take him. I swore to my Mum and Dad they would never be put into a care home and he never will. He'll come to live with us if necessary, I wouldn't dream of anything else.