Suspended sentence fails judge goes easy on him again
Suspended sentence fails judge goes easy on him again
Author
Discussion

Pesty

Original Poster:

42,655 posts

287 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all

A blundering serial thief who ransacked a flat which police had rigged with CCTV cameras and stole fake mobile phones has been jailed.
Dim Bubba Ambala, 19, was first caught raiding an apartment in his own block of flats which officers had set up with cameras in an elaborate sting operation.
But, despite being given a suspended sentence for that crime, he clearly had not learned his lesson.
Just six months later he was caught shoplifting from a high street store when he made off with three worthless display mobile phones which he thought were real.
The teenager admitted theft and was jailed for six months at Warwick Crown Court on Thursday.


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2189686/Te...

Shaolin

2,955 posts

220 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
Surely calling him Dim is against his yuman rights - however appropriate.

StuartGGray

7,703 posts

259 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
Dim by name...

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
In fairness to the court, the defendant has successfully completed his first year of studies and fully intends to continue on with the second. In jailing him for 6 months, he is able to continue with that course, whereas a longer sentence would likely preclude that from being a possibility.

If you take a common sense view;

- 12 month sentence, automatic release at 6 months, release on curfew at 3 months;

- 6 month sentence, automatic release at 3 months, release on curfew at 1.5 months;

- Difference between time in jail for each sentence, 6 weeks.

What additional protection for the public, deterrent from future offending or punishment will be achieved from the extra 6 weeks, especially if it takes the effect of removing him from the education he has established he is dedicated to?

This instance is one where the courts are displaying more sense, not less.

Pesty

Original Poster:

42,655 posts

287 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
Yes but only if it works and he commits no crimes when he is out and on his course.

So far he has faced no deterrent at all. I suspect he will be seen again by the courts

I'd have locked him up for 5 years without parole and made him take his quals inside but thats just me smile

And I'd stop automatically halving the sentences its really just spin

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Friday 17th August 2012
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
This instance is one where the courts are displaying more sense, not less.
However if we jailed him for one month but gave him 50 lashes in the public square, he could do his school work whilst suffering incredible pain for his actions thereby I suspect etching in his head the theft/consequences system....

smegmore

3,091 posts

207 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Dim Bubba... hehe

'nuff said.

Somewhatfoolish

5,104 posts

217 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
However if we jailed him for one month but gave him 50 lashes in the public square, he could do his school work whilst suffering incredible pain for his actions thereby I suspect etching in his head the theft/consequences system....
Nowithstanding the ethical problems with this, it won't work. If he's daft enough to do this sort of thing then it clearly shows he doesn't think ahead about the consequences of his actions. Therefore there will be no deterrence.

Pommygranite

14,472 posts

247 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
StuartGGray said:
Dim by name...
Erm he's called Bubba not Dim....

Mojocvh

16,837 posts

293 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Somewhatfoolish said:
Jasandjules said:
However if we jailed him for one month but gave him 50 lashes in the public square, he could do his school work whilst suffering incredible pain for his actions thereby I suspect etching in his head the theft/consequences system....
Nowithstanding the ethical problems with this, it won't work. If he's daft enough to do this sort of thing then it clearly shows he doesn't think ahead about the consequences of his actions. Therefore there will be no deterrence.
I take it you have never felt reality of corporal punishment have you? hehe

Somewhatfoolish

5,104 posts

217 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
Mojocvh said:
Somewhatfoolish said:
Jasandjules said:
However if we jailed him for one month but gave him 50 lashes in the public square, he could do his school work whilst suffering incredible pain for his actions thereby I suspect etching in his head the theft/consequences system....
Nowithstanding the ethical problems with this, it won't work. If he's daft enough to do this sort of thing then it clearly shows he doesn't think ahead about the consequences of his actions. Therefore there will be no deterrence.
I take it you have never felt reality of corporal punishment have you? hehe
only the kind i've paid good money for...

i bet i regret tyoing that in the morning

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
Pommygranite said:
StuartGGray said:
Dim by name...
Erm he's called Bubba not Dim....
Then he'll be top dog in the showers...

FarleyRusk

1,036 posts

242 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
In fairness to the court, the defendant has successfully completed his first year of studies and fully intends to continue on with the second. In jailing him for 6 months, he is able to continue with that course, whereas a longer sentence would likely preclude that from being a possibility.

If you take a common sense view;

- 12 month sentence, automatic release at 6 months, release on curfew at 3 months;

- 6 month sentence, automatic release at 3 months, release on curfew at 1.5 months;

- Difference between time in jail for each sentence, 6 weeks.

What additional protection for the public, deterrent from future offending or punishment will be achieved from the extra 6 weeks, especially if it takes the effect of removing him from the education he has established he is dedicated to?

This instance is one where the courts are displaying more sense, not less.
Erm if you take the common sense view, 12months would mean a year jail!

singlecoil

35,890 posts

277 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
A short time in jail will have pretty much the same effect on the offender as a long time, once he settles in and gets used to it then really all it's doing is costing the taxpayer lots of money. If he's going to learn a lesson from it he will learn it just as well in a few weeks as he will in a year.

Pesty

Original Poster:

42,655 posts

287 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
A short time in jail will have pretty much the same effect on the offender as a long time, once he settles in and gets used to it then really all it's doing is costing the taxpayer lots of money. If he's going to learn a lesson from it he will learn it just as well in a few weeks as he will in a year.
I really can't see that at all.


A few weeks in gaol then out he will be laughing.
A full year (5 preferably) yeah he might settle in but its a year out of his life. No GF, no going down the pub,no hanging out wid his bredren etc etc

singlecoil

35,890 posts

277 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
Pesty said:
singlecoil said:
A short time in jail will have pretty much the same effect on the offender as a long time, once he settles in and gets used to it then really all it's doing is costing the taxpayer lots of money. If he's going to learn a lesson from it he will learn it just as well in a few weeks as he will in a year.
I really can't see that at all.


A few weeks in gaol then out he will be laughing.
A full year (5 preferably) yeah he might settle in but its a year out of his life. No GF, no going down the pub,no hanging out wid his bredren etc etc
All depends on whether he's a hardened criminal or not. If he's never done time then he won't be laughing, he won't like it at all. If he's used to prison then a much longer sentence might be needed, but it's a bloody expensive business for the tax payer so it's good to see that judges are being a bit circumspect about handing out long terms.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
Pesty said:
I really can't see that at all.


A few weeks in gaol then out he will be laughing.
A full year (5 preferably) yeah he might settle in but its a year out of his life. No GF, no going down the pub,no hanging out wid his bredren etc etc
There are various reasons to send someone to prison; public protection, punishment, rehabilitation and so on. You don't just pick one out at the expense of the other reasons.

With this chap, there is evidence he intends to educate himself. If he's willing to educate himself, he's showing a willingness to live without needing to resort to theft or a life of crime. Whether he follows through with that, we don't know yet. What we do know, is if you lock him up for a long time for a minor offence, you will make it more difficult for him to become rehabilitated and to become a productive member of society upon his release.

What is the value in paying £20,000 a year to keep him in an open prison when he has shown that in the same time scale he may be able to earn £20,000 a year as a fully fledged, decent member of society?

Putting too much emphasis on the punishment element only deals with the past and does very little to improve the future.

Pesty

Original Poster:

42,655 posts

287 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
Could he not learn while in Jail?

At least while he is in there he isn't robbing anybody.

We only know what he got caught for because the flat was a trap. God know how many other flats he has robbed.

Jessicus

374 posts

177 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
I'm impressed by the use of the college course as a mitigating factor. It's a shame that it's probably rubbish.

There's a small but certainly significant number of students on most college courses who are not really interested in the course, making progress and aiming to better themselves. Their aim is to avoid real work and "hassle" from parent who want them to do a proper job. These are the students who partake of criminal behaviour - from robbery and burglary to drug offences. I see it every year - occasionally having students removed from college in handcuffs.

Let him do his course in prison. At least there he'll be able to focus on his studies!

FraserLFA

5,083 posts

205 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
The 3 store in the picture is the one in Norwich.

Just sayin'!