Chinese/Japanese dispute
Author
Discussion

Mermaid

Original Poster:

21,492 posts

202 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all

Getragdogleg

10,318 posts

214 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
World war 3.

Ought to be fun.

EDLT

15,421 posts

237 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
Getragdogleg said:
World war 3.

Ought to be fun.
Nope. Who would want to declare war on China?

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
EDLT said:
Getragdogleg said:
World war 3.

Ought to be fun.
Nope. Who would want to declare war on China?
I think the Japanese did in the past. It wasn't very nice. It's worth reading up on. Quite horrific.

Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
it'd be an interesting war....

the chinese would outnumber the japs 10,000 to 1
but, out of every 10,000 weapons the chinese made, they'd be lucky if 1 of them worked, so it'd balance out

i suggest they sort it out with a kung fu vs karate fight with plenty of comedy 'bwongggg' noises and bad dubbing

PH lurker

1,301 posts

188 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
I wonder where this will go.
coffee

Justices

3,682 posts

195 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Mermaid said:
Where will this end up?
Had to remove the link to that ghastly publication but..

It will end when every piece of land China claims to be part of China is handed over. This means any land connected to China and any land close by that China likes the look of. Too much power in the hands of a few who are very good at stirring up the brainless in the population and broadcasting it to the rest. The kinds of "protests" you see are outlawed in China, the police are on orders to stand by and let them smash Japanese-made cars and Chinese-owned businesses selling things like Japanese food. Ridiculous, yes, but it will be spun around the nation and the vast majority who aren't savvy with the ways of the world will eat it up.

I wouldn't be surprised if it the riots were timed to take attention away from the Gu KaiLai scandal.. sentence on that being announced sometime today (Monday).

uk_vette

3,336 posts

235 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
.
Mermaid said:
.
It’s getting pretty serious, and there is NO love lost between the Chinese and the Japanese.
There is a fierce dislike, especially between the older generation of say, 50 years and older to the Japanese.
Getragdogleg said:
World war 3.

Ought to be fun.
.
Don’t think so, there is a score to settle, and make no mistake, The Chinese are more than capable of dictating the schedule.
EDLT said:
Getragdogleg said:
World war 3.

Ought to be fun.
Nope. Who would want to declare war on China?
.
No country in their right mind, would consider taking on China.
I live about 10km from our local airport, and there are 98 fast jets stationed there. Mostly J 10 's and SU-30 if I am not mistaken.
Generally, all local airports have a military attachment.
They are in and out the airport every other day, generally flying in group of 2 or 3 aircraft.
All landings are parachute assisted, ie, deploy parachute to slow down when on the runway.
Derek Smith said:
EDLT said:
Getragdogleg said:
World war 3.

Ought to be fun.
.
Nope. Who would want to declare war on China?
I think the Japanese did in the past. It wasn't very nice. It's worth reading up on. Quite horrific.
.
The Rape of Nanking, 1937 read about it.
Then read about Unit 731, then still decide if there is a score to settle
I WONT link them, as I feel they are too disgusting.
Half a century of denial from the Japs, doesn't help much either.

Conian said:
it'd be an interesting war....

the Chinese would outnumber the Japs 10,000 to 1
but, out of every 10,000 weapons the Chinese made, they'd be lucky if 1 of them worked, so it'd balance out

I suggest they sort it out with a kung fu vs karate fight with plenty of comedy 'bwongggg' noises and bad dubbing
.
Well, I wouldn’t bet on the Japs, knowing what I know.
The two countries are well within general striking range for fast jets, missiles, etc.
Incidently, I believe that China now puts more funding to missiles than to replacement jets.
Chinese missiles
.
PH lurker said:
I wonder where this will go.
coffee
.
You wouldn’t want to be a Japanese.
Incidentally, the Filipinos and the Taiwanese are also claiming the Islands are their island.
.
Justices said:
Mermaid said:
Where will this end up?
Had to remove the link to that ghastly publication but..

It will end when every piece of land China claims to be part of China is handed over. This means any land connected to China and any land close by that China likes the look of. Too much power in the hands of a few who are very good at stirring up the brainless in the population and broadcasting it to the rest. The kinds of "protests" you see are outlawed in China, the police are on orders to stand by and let them smash Japanese-made cars
and Chinese-owned businesses selling things like Japanese food. Ridiculous, yes, but it will be spun around the nation and the vast majority who aren't savvy with the ways of the world will eat it up.

I wouldn't be surprised if it the riots were timed to take attention away from the Gu KaiLai scandal.. sentence on that being announced sometime today (Monday).
.
Are you crazy???"the police are on orders to stand by and let them smash Japanese-made cars"
"and Chinese-owned businesses selling things like Japanese food. "
What utter nonsense.
Now let me throw this into the equation,,,
Falkland Islands,,,,,,say no more.
The islands don’t have to be close, or “on your doorstep” for you to claim them.

Chinese Military aircraft
http://www.softwar.net/plaaf.html

And the city I live in, isn't even mentioned on that attached list.
We have the best part of 100 J 10 's and SU-30 's
And we are not even on the list, so guess what hidden delights the other bigger airports have.
Much of the military are "brushed out" on Google, as I know exactly where the airports are, but not showing on Google.
The airport I am close to is free to see on google.




.

.

.

.
And this is just our SMALL airport !!

vette







Edited by uk_vette on Monday 20th August 03:36

Rotary Madness

2,285 posts

217 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
What about the fact Russia will most likely back China, and the US + the west will back Japan. End up with another cold war situation no?

Justices

3,682 posts

195 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
What a ridiculous thing to say. Nonsense, public unrest and protests are always shutdown instantly, so why are they sitting on the sidelines watching and putting out footage for the media? Police deal with disturbances VERY swiftly here, in this case they are not doing as they would, not at all. If you honestly believe the government would allow this for anything else, you have a lot to learn about China.

The group that sailed to the islands and were deported were from HK. They wouldn't have been able to do it from China so Beijing use their people in HK to set things into motion. It's been going on for decades, read about the bombing that used to go on in HK, learn who was behind that and you'll get an idea. Beijing are masters of controlling a massive number of people and until fairly recently, it's been a relatively straightforward affair. The internet however, has allowed a lot of people to learn more and share their views, which the government have to work hard to manage.

There is phenomenal animosity towards the Japanese from the older generations in China. Understandably, and especially with the lack of acceptance from Japanese officials for all the atrocities committed during the war which the average man in the West has no idea about. With this history, it doesn't take much for people to get very angry. It's clearly not a good idea for Japan to get into any military conflict with China, but they and the other neighbouring countries cannot be seen to bow to China's demands.

uk_vette

3,336 posts

235 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Justices said:
What a ridiculous thing to say. Nonsense, public unrest and protests are always shutdown instantly, so why are they sitting on the sidelines watching and putting out footage for the media? Police deal with disturbances VERY swiftly here, in this case they are not doing as they would, not at all. If you honestly believe the government would allow this for anything else, you have a lot to learn about China.
.
Thank you Justices.
Some people have NO IDEA at all about China, and are all suckered in to what they see on TV, and read in the daily's.
.
People who have lived here for any length of time, soon realise, thee is a lot more freedom in China than what you would be led to believe.

vette

Justices

3,682 posts

195 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Being part Chinese, living in China for most of my life and working with top government officials in the tier cities on various projects, I am fully aware thanks smile

As an aside.. Commuted death sentence for Gu KaiLai. As expected.

PZR

643 posts

216 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
uk_vette said:
It’s getting pretty serious, and there is NO love lost between the Chinese and the Japanese.
There is a fierce dislike, especially between the older generation of say, 50 years and older to the Japanese.
UK_vette said:
....there is a score to settle, and make no mistake, The Chinese are more than capable of dictating the schedule.
uk_vette said:
No country in their right mind, would consider taking on China.
UK_vette said:
The Rape of Nanking, 1937 read about it.
Then read about Unit 731, then still decide if there is a score to settle
I WONT link them, as I feel they are too disgusting.
Half a century of denial from the Japs, doesn't help much either.
UK_vette said:
Well, I wouldn’t bet on the Japs, knowing what I know.
UK_vette said:
You wouldn’t want to be a Japanese.
You're coming across as though you would support any military action that China might take against "the Japs", and/(because?) 'they deserve it'.

There's "a score to settle" is there? That's exactly the kind of ill-informed sentiment that situations like this feed from.

5705

1,165 posts

183 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
So much daftness in one short thread.

No matter the history, the unsettled scores, the inevitability of victory, etc - China will not start military action. It would cost them far too much.

It's all blow-hard nonsense to rouse the rabble temporarily (in both countries).

Getragdogleg

10,318 posts

214 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
EDLT said:
Getragdogleg said:
World war 3.

Ought to be fun.
Nope. Who would want to declare war on China?
I will just clarify that my statement was made with irony, Given the tenacious attitude of both sides I can only imagine how troublessome any conflict would be.