Islington Night Life Tax
Author
Discussion

Hackney

Original Poster:

7,442 posts

239 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
Just saw this on the news. A proposed tax on venues in this one London borough because of increased anti-social behaviour / crime related to alcohol and "binge drinking"

The charge to venues will be around £4k per year and it's expected to raise around £0.5 million per annum.

The "issue" seems to be centred around Upper Steet.
Labour councillor said, "we granted a lot of licences to promote an evening economy" but they seem to think this has backfired and resulted in increased crime.

Now, if they'd stop and think for just one minute they'd realise that the perpetrators of crime are not spending their evenings in the bars of Upper Street before doing a bit of breaking and entering.

Since moving to Islington I've been a victim of two crimes:
1) stolen bike
2) flat broken into

Both of these happened during the day. The first one happened during the World Cup Final 2010 so absolutely nothing to do with the perps being in the pub.
The second was discovered when my wife returned home from work at around 6:30pm on a weekday. So again, not related to drinking in the area.

If the local govt wanted to crack down on crime or prevent it then they'd do well to stop trying to dress up their revenue raising shenanigans and start putting some more police on the streets during the day or actually sorting out the security issues in properties they're supposed to be responsible for. Absolutely ridiculous.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
Drunken bankers still count as crime if they get a fine for drunk and disorderly. They're a lot easier to clear up too. So if you have a target for clearing up crime it's best to clear up the easy things. I'm not saying it's right.

Hackney

Original Poster:

7,442 posts

239 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
Agreed, but this is just Islington, not any other London borough.
My suspicion is that most Islington crimes (including the two I've been a victim of) are perpetrated by drug users and not a result of alcohol purchased in bars (who already paid for their licence to sell alcohol)

rpguk

4,520 posts

315 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
I wonder how they'll calculate it for each venue? There are a few bars that I'd wager fuel the majority of drunken misbehaviour, seems a bit unfair if the smaller bars and restaurants have to pay £4,000 and the chain bars such as Wetherspoons, Pitcher and Piano or Browns have to pay the same.

Can't say I'm much of a fan of Upper Street as it is anyway.

Baryonyx

18,295 posts

190 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
OP, I'm guessing you don't go out in Islington, hence why you don't appreciate the crime and disorder generated by binge drinkers. It's the same anywhere there is a night time economy, and the smart thing to do is to try and recoup some of the costs of policing and licensing the whole thing from the bars and clubs that are making huge profits off it.

rpguk

4,520 posts

315 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
Are the police funded by the local authority? You'd pay near £4/pint in a lot of places on Upper Street - surely the tax take over a weekend across the bars would cover a good number of police.

wolowizard

15,137 posts

231 months

Sunday 19th August 2012
quotequote all
I am not a drinker by any stretch of the imagination but I do know most of the binge drinking is done before people have even left home, the reason is that the clubs and pubs are forced to have door staff forced to do this forced to do that which all costs. They pass on those costs to the customer and now they all pre load on tescos finest shandy before they go out.

more costs will only increase the pre-loading and increase the anti-social problem as the bottle of vodka they just all chipped in to buy must get drunk before they leave.

We need proper responsible drinking laws and a taxation system that supports responsible drinking, just adding costs to deal with a problem that could be eliminated will make it worse.

Edited by wolowizard on Sunday 19th August 23:47

otolith

69,773 posts

235 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
How about we arrest the people who are committing crime, and then take them to court and punish them?

Radical, I know.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
otolith said:
How about we arrest the people who are committing crime, and then take them to court and punish them?

Radical, I know.
Nice idea. I used to live just off Upper Street. The police in Islington were deeply unimpressive. So although a nice idea, it won't work in practice.

Hackney

Original Poster:

7,442 posts

239 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Baryonyx said:
OP, I'm guessing you don't go out in Islington, hence why you don't appreciate the crime and disorder generated by binge drinkers. It's the same anywhere there is a night time economy, and the smart thing to do is to try and recoup some of the costs of policing and licensing the whole thing from the bars and clubs that are making huge profits off it.
As I said, I live in Islington, and not far from Upper Street.
And much as I detest the beer emporium culture of certain places, Islington is by no means unique.

- What percentage of crime in Islington is commited by those spending £4 per pint in the bars of Upper Street?
- And why punish all the bars in Islington for problems supposedly caused by some

Isn't it likely that a higher proportion of crime in Islington is drug related?

TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
"A proposed tax on venues in this one London borough because of increased anti-social behaviour / crime related to alcohol and "binge drinking"


Seems fine to me, an increase in drunken crime, so charges passed onto the bars.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
See those people over there doing something illegal

We are going to stop them by punishing another group who aren't doing anything illegal

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
rpguk said:
I wonder how they'll calculate it for each venue? There are a few bars that I'd wager fuel the majority of drunken misbehaviour, seems a bit unfair if the smaller bars and restaurants have to pay £4,000 and the chain bars such as Wetherspoons, Pitcher and Piano or Browns have to pay the same.

Can't say I'm much of a fan of Upper Street as it is anyway.
One would assume they would look at the map of the areas with the most incidents and see what the bar is called.

Done very easily in York, as we have an abundance of drunken stag and hen louts late night.

turbobloke

117,577 posts

291 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
TheEnd said:
"A proposed tax on venues in this one London borough because of increased anti-social behaviour / crime related to alcohol and "binge drinking"

Seems fine to me, an increase in drunken crime, so charges passed onto the bars.
Yet the bars in Islington will already be paying more tax due to the increased turnover and bigger profits. Perhaps a better idea would be to use this existing larger tax take rather than manufacture an excuse for another count of daylight robbery on businesses which no plod will ever look into.

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
TheEnd said:
"A proposed tax on venues in this one London borough because of increased anti-social behaviour / crime related to alcohol and "binge drinking"

Seems fine to me, an increase in drunken crime, so charges passed onto the bars.
Yet the bars in Islington will already be paying more tax due to the increased turnover and bigger profits. Perhaps a better idea would be to use this existing larger tax take rather than manufacture an excuse for another count of daylight robbery on businesses which no plod will ever look into.
More often than not a lot of the ASB problems stem from certain bars and clubs allowing people to get paralytic and then throwing them out, not taking responsibility for the problems on their doorstep.

It is not the same for all bars, however it will always be the same bars with the problems.

In York and Selby we can narrow it down to 3 bars in each, out of 270.

Pickled

2,059 posts

174 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Yet another tax, on top of that tax business owners already have the pleasure of paying for the privilege of running a business from commercial premises, i.e. business rates.

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Pickled said:
Yet another tax, on top of that tax business owners already have the pleasure of paying for the privilege of running a business from commercial premises, i.e. business rates.
It is actually a fine, that the council are not allowed to spend on what they want.

It is also can be applied to as many or as few bars that are serving after 12 and causing problems.

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
See those people over there doing something illegal

We are going to stop them by punishing another group who aren't doing anything illegal but are very easy to find and make them pay up
EFA

Lazy policing to me, or simply an excuse to raise more money.

turbobloke

117,577 posts

291 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
elster said:
turbobloke said:
TheEnd said:
"A proposed tax on venues in this one London borough because of increased anti-social behaviour / crime related to alcohol and "binge drinking"

Seems fine to me, an increase in drunken crime, so charges passed onto the bars.
Yet the bars in Islington will already be paying more tax due to the increased turnover and bigger profits. Perhaps a better idea would be to use this existing larger tax take rather than manufacture an excuse for another count of daylight robbery on businesses which no plod will ever look into.
More often than not a lot of the ASB problems stem from certain bars and clubs allowing people to get paralytic and then throwing them out, not taking responsibility for the problems on their doorstep.

It is not the same for all bars, however it will always be the same bars with the problems.

In York and Selby we can narrow it down to 3 bars in each, out of 270.
Understood, but that sounds like a licensing problem not a tax problem.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Revoke the licenses of any bars or pubs that are seen serving alcohol to people that are clearly already intoxicated. The problem will be solved one way or another.