Z4 (E85) 2.0 vs 2.5 vs 3.0 - I'm suprised.
Z4 (E85) 2.0 vs 2.5 vs 3.0 - I'm suprised.
Author
Discussion

DazBock

Original Poster:

826 posts

223 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Hi All

I have been in contemplation of buying a sub £10k sportscar for a few weeks or so and having been to see a few I am now set on getting a BMW Z4 (E85).

However, having driven a few cars now I'm somewhat supirsed at my conclusions and thought I would take a minute to share them.

I have driven a 2.0, 2.5 and 3.0 car and weirdly the one I ended up liking the most in terms of driving was actually the 2.0. It felt far more agile in the corners presumably due to it being only a 4 cylinder and wasn't noticeably slower in terms of acceleration than the 2.5. The steering seemed far more direct and I had far more confidence in the bends.

Both the 2.5 and 3.0 cars had lots of low end torque and plenty of power but the understeer and ride put me off a fair bit. I also think that the 3.0 is most likely out of my budget as the ones I have seen have been a bit ropey in comparison.

I am used to driving older sportscars (like my old Spitfire) along with an s1 elise around and I guess the 2.0 felt the most similar to drive. When you combine that with the cheaper running costs and avaliability of the 2.0 it seems to me to be a good choice.

I thought I would just share my experience with you and fully expect that most of you will tell me I am insane, perhaps I'm not the only one?


Thanks


steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
I have a z4, you need 6 cylinders. Even if it's a 2.2 the noise is worth it.
4 pot sounds miserable.

DazBock

Original Poster:

826 posts

223 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
steve_bmw said:
I have a z4, you need 6 cylinders. Even if it's a 2.2 the noise is worth it.
4 pot sounds miserable.
I thought it sounded quite good actually. May need to test them all again then.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Go with your instinct Daz, not everyone likes the same qualities in a car. If the 2.0 is for you, get it bought.

Sortie 10

744 posts

283 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Whatever you do, make sure the roof works well. It looks as if I could be in for a major bill on my 50000 mile 2003 car - BMW deserve a gold medal for making the motor so inaccessible & difficult to repair/replace. Not happy at the moment...

DazBock

Original Poster:

826 posts

223 months

Tuesday 21st August 2012
quotequote all
Sortie 10 said:
Whatever you do, make sure the roof works well. It looks as if I could be in for a major bill on my 50000 mile 2003 car - BMW deserve a gold medal for making the motor so inaccessible & difficult to repair/replace. Not happy at the moment...
A friend of mine works for BMW apparently there is a company that can provide aftermarket motors. He said they fitted them the other day at work and total bill was around £270. I'll find out who it is.

Sticks.

9,726 posts

282 months

Tuesday 21st August 2012
quotequote all
Did you try the 2.0 or the 2.2? The 2.0 was only available post facelift, 2006 on and a 4 cyl; the 2.2 is 6 cyl from 04 iirc.

I remember the 2.2 got good write-ups at the time because it was perceived as more nimble, as you describe.

Handling on my 3.0 is much sharper since getting rid of rfts, so with/without rfts will affect your comparison as much as anything I'd have thought.

DazBock

Original Poster:

826 posts

223 months

Tuesday 21st August 2012
quotequote all
Sticks. said:
Did you try the 2.0 or the 2.2? The 2.0 was only available post facelift, 2006 on and a 4 cyl; the 2.2 is 6 cyl from 04 iirc.

I remember the 2.2 got good write-ups at the time because it was perceived as more nimble, as you describe.

Handling on my 3.0 is much sharper since getting rid of rfts, so with/without rfts will affect your comparison as much as anything I'd have thought.
I drove a 56 plate 2.0 4 cylinder. You could tell it was definitely a 4 cylinder because it did look a little lost in the bonney in comparison to the 2.5.



I hear what you are saying with regards the RFT's but the 2.0 had them on too, so surely if you were to remove them from that you would experience a similar increase in turning ability?


Shurv

1,024 posts

191 months

Tuesday 21st August 2012
quotequote all
All Z4's are very reliable,the odd roof motor and broken spring is about all that seems to go wrong.Go and have a look on the Porsche forum,you'll weep with the tales of big engine bills, top end rebuilds and clutches at 40,000 miles.Properly scary,and poor ,for a perceived quality German marque.The 2.0 is a great car, get yourself a nice one and you'll be very happy with it.Ditto the runflats,the ride with normal tyres is much better.

Sortie 10

744 posts

283 months

Tuesday 21st August 2012
quotequote all
DazBock said:
A friend of mine works for BMW apparently there is a company that can provide aftermarket motors. He said they fitted them the other day at work and total bill was around £270. I'll find out who it is.
Would really appreciate this - and would be prepared to travel (I'm near Bristol) if I could save a pot of cash (my local main dealer was quoting around £100 just to diagnose the fault!)

DazBock

Original Poster:

826 posts

223 months

Tuesday 21st August 2012
quotequote all
Sortie 10 said:
Would really appreciate this - and would be prepared to travel (I'm near Bristol) if I could save a pot of cash (my local main dealer was quoting around £100 just to diagnose the fault!)
My mate is service manager at a BMW dealership in Bedfordshire. He tells me the drain plugs get clogged which results in the motor being submerged and shorting out. Apparently it is a £1000 job at BMW but the parts came from a place in wembley and labour cost a few hundred. He can't remember name but he is checking it out.

blippo1984

358 posts

177 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2012
quotequote all
I have a 2.0.

Lovely car and you can afford o be pretty aggressive on price when buying too as there are quite a few hovering in that price range.

a11y_m

1,861 posts

253 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2012
quotequote all
DazBock said:
Sortie 10 said:
Would really appreciate this - and would be prepared to travel (I'm near Bristol) if I could save a pot of cash (my local main dealer was quoting around £100 just to diagnose the fault!)
My mate is service manager at a BMW dealership in Bedfordshire. He tells me the drain plugs get clogged which results in the motor being submerged and shorting out. Apparently it is a £1000 job at BMW but the parts came from a place in wembley and labour cost a few hundred. He can't remember name but he is checking it out.
Yep, that's about right. The motor's located on the passenger/left side of the car thus it's vital to keep the roof drain holes clear. Main problem on 2nd hand is obviously its impossible to know if the previous owners have done so. Seems to happen more with Z4s kept/parked outdoors due to debris (leaves, etc) blocking the drain holes. Luckily there's cheaper options than BMW, as mentioned. Been discussed in detail on www.z4-forum.com.

2.0/2.2/2.5/3.0 performance on paper is largely different, but I agree (from lots of experience) that on the road there's not as much in it as you'd expect. I had a pre-facelift 3.0 231ps and was regularly out on drives with plenty of 2.0 owners. They didn't ever really struggle...

DazBock

Original Poster:

826 posts

223 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2012
quotequote all
blippo1984 said:
I have a 2.0.

Lovely car and you can afford o be pretty aggressive on price when buying too as there are quite a few hovering in that price range.
This is the sort of thing I am looking at, shame the pictures are crap

http://pistonheads.com/sales/4152390.htm

HerrSchnell

2,352 posts

230 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2012
quotequote all
DazBock said:
My mate is service manager at a BMW dealership in Bedfordshire. He tells me the drain plugs get clogged which results in the motor being submerged and shorting out. Apparently it is a £1000 job at BMW but the parts came from a place in wembley and labour cost a few hundred. He can't remember name but he is checking it out.
The good news is it's a 15 minute job to clear the drain plugs as they're easily accessed from the wheel arch.

There's a flap at the front of each wheelarch liner, a few bolts and that's off, reach forward & up inside the flap and you'll feel the spongy rubber plug, whip it out and poke a piece of speaker cable / straightened coathanger up then flush from the top and replace plug.


mbtech01

174 posts

202 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2012
quotequote all
Everybody has there own opinion & you've goota go with what your happy with. For me i just had to go for the 3.0 Z4 (E85) as i love the smoothness of the straight 6 engines & it just purrs along ! Also to me its not a proper Bmw unless it has the straight 6 in, but then thats my opinion & thats why i bought it !

Sortie 10

744 posts

283 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2012
quotequote all
HerrSchnell said:
The good news is it's a 15 minute job to clear the drain plugs as they're easily accessed from the wheel arch.

There's a flap at the front of each wheelarch liner, a few bolts and that's off, reach forward & up inside the flap and you'll feel the spongy rubber plug, whip it out and poke a piece of speaker cable / straightened coathanger up then flush from the top and replace plug.
This could be the very reason why my motor has failed. The car runs on 18" wheels & has M-sport lowered suspension - the clearance between wheels & arches is very low and jobs of this nature (like adjusting headlights for continental driving) are a right royal PITA; will check the service manual as this should be a routine service item. Is there a way of clearing the drains from above? (you could on the MX-5, the car I traded for the Z4)

a11y_m

1,861 posts

253 months

Thursday 23rd August 2012
quotequote all
Sortie 10 said:
This could be the very reason why my motor has failed. The car runs on 18" wheels & has M-sport lowered suspension - the clearance between wheels & arches is very low and jobs of this nature (like adjusting headlights for continental driving) are a right royal PITA; will check the service manual as this should be a routine service item. Is there a way of clearing the drains from above? (you could on the MX-5, the car I traded for the Z4)
Get yourself on z4-forum and have a search - there's some guides on there I think. I believe you still need to access the bottom of the drain, but it's made easier by jacking up the rear of the car. I was able to drain them with 18"s and Eibach Pro springs (another 15mm lower than M-Sport) although removing the wheels does make it far easier.

illmonkey

19,842 posts

229 months

Thursday 23rd August 2012
quotequote all
Don't forget to alter the noise generator. It makes a massive difference in noise, especially at full chat.

a11y_m

1,861 posts

253 months

Thursday 23rd August 2012
quotequote all
illmonkey said:
Don't forget to alter the noise generator. It makes a massive difference in noise, especially at full chat.
Not in the 2.0/2.2 it doesn't - they don't have it. Not sure if the 2.5 does either, but the 3.0 does as standard. In the end I'd completely removed one piece of foam and half of the other bit - lovely smile