Riots last year...what powers should the police have?
Discussion
I'm just watching the programme about the riots last year, and some of the footage of what the rioters did, and the level of violence towards the police is truly shocking.
So, if it ever happens again, what should the police be allowed to do? Could they deploy batton rounds, or could they use other tactics such as CS gas or some other form of crowd control. To be honest, watching it, I feel they should be allowed to deploy real firearms, but in reality, I guess that probably would not help.
So, if it ever happens again, what should the police be allowed to do? Could they deploy batton rounds, or could they use other tactics such as CS gas or some other form of crowd control. To be honest, watching it, I feel they should be allowed to deploy real firearms, but in reality, I guess that probably would not help.
2011 - Riots in Assam, Meghalaya, Northeast India, 4 dead.[152][153]
2011 - Riots in Arusha, Tanzania, 2 dead and nine people injured.[154]
2011 - Riots in Algeria, 2 dead and four hundred people injured in riots linked to food price increases and unemployment.[155]
2011 - Riots in Tunisia, at least 219 killed.[156]
2011 - Riots in Jos, Nigeria, more than 30 people dead.[157][158]
2011 - Riots in Tirana, Albania, 3 killed, 17 policemen and soldiers were injured, including three seriously, along with 22 civilians.[159]
2011 - Riots in Lebanon, following the fall of Saad Hariri's government.[160]
2011 - Riots in Egypt, at least 846 killed.[161]
2011 - Riots in Tafawa Balewa, Nigeria, 4 killed.[162]
2011 - Prison riot in Sao Luis, Brazil, 6 dead.[163]
2011 - Religious riot in Banten, Indonesia, at least 6 killed.[164]
2011 - Riots in Manama, Bahrain, at least 10 killed, 92 civilians, 50 security forces injured.[165][166][167]
2011 - Riots in Sulaimaniya, Iraqi Kurdistan, two killed.[168]
2011 - Riots in Al Hoceima, Morroco, 5 killed.[169]
2011 - Riots in Libya, at least 24 people killed.[170]
2011 - Riots in Iraq, at least 13 killed.[171]
2011 - Riots in Yemen, 24 killed.[172][173]
2011 - Riots in Tunis, Tunisia, 3 killed.[174]
2011 - Miners riot in Peru, at least 2 killed.[175]
2011 - Riots in Cairo, Egypt, between Muslims and Christians, at least 13 people died and 140 were injured.[176]
2011 - Riot in Kissidougou, Guinea, at least 3 dead.[177]
2011 - Prison riot in Tikrit, Iraq, 2 dead, 14 wounded.[178]
2011 - Riots in Syria, at least 60 killed.[179][180][181]
2011 - Riots in Sana'a, Yemen, 42 people had died and at least 300 were injured according to doctors.[182]
2011 - Prison Riot in Hyderabad, Pakistan, 7 dead.[183]
2011 - Riot in London, around 250 thousand people, initially a small protest.[184]
2011 - Riots in Nigeria, at least 70 people have been killed.[185]
2011 - Riots in Mazar-e Sharif and Kandahar, Afghanistan, at least 13 people have been killed.[186][187]
2011 - Riots in Jessore, Bangladesh, 1 dead and at least 30 others injured.[188]
2011 - Riots in Cairo, Egypt, 2 killed and at least 15 wounded.[189]
2011 - Prison riot in Rumieh prison, Lebanon, 2 dead.[190]
2011 - Riot in Parwan province, Afghanistan, 1 killed.[191]
2011 - Riots in Uganda, at least 3 killed.[192]
2011 - Riots in Yemen, more than 100 people have died in two months of protests.[193]
2011 - Riots in Jaitapur, Maharashtra, India, 1 killed, more than 50 injured.[194]
2011 - Riots in Diyarbakir, Turkey, 1 killed.[195]
2011 - Riots in Dakar, Senegal.[196]
2011 - Riots in Tyre, Lebanon, 2 killed.[197]
2011 - Riots in Mansa, Luapula Province, Zambia, 3 people were burned to death.[198]
2011 - Riots in Nigeria, at least 500 killed in post-election rioting.[199][200]
2011 - Riots in Kampala, Uganda, at least 5 dead and 100 injured.[201][202]
2011 - Riots in Cairo, Egypt, between Muslims and Christians, 12 dead.[203]
2011 - Riots in Hesarak District, Nangarhar province, Afghanistan, 1 killed, 3 wounded.[204]
2011 - Riots on Israel's borders, at least 12 killed and dozens injured.[205][206]
2011 - Riots in West Bengal, India, at least 8 people killed in post-election violence.[207]
2011 - Riots in Taloqan, Takhar province, Afghanistan, at least 12 killed and 80 injured.[208][209]
2011 - Riots in Tbilisi, Georgia, 2 killed, 20 injured.[210]
2011 - Riots in Choucha refugee camp, Tunisia, at least 2 killed.[211]
2011 - Riots in Sri Lanka, 1 killed, at least 200 wounded.[212]
2011 - Riots in Greater Noida, Uttar Pradesh, India, 4 killed.[213][214]
2011 - Riots in Metlaoui, Tunisia, 3 dead and 90 wounded.[215]
2011 - Riots in Mogadishu, Somalia, 2 killed.[216]
2011 - Riots in El Rodeo I prison, Caracas, Venezuela, 19 killed.[217]
2011 - Riots in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada after the Vancouver Canucks lost to the Boston Bruins in the Stanley Cup.[218]
2011 - Riots in Tripoli, Lebanon, at least 4 killed and at least 48 people wounded.[219][220]
2011 - Riots, three separate outbreaks in June and July, Northern Ireland, United Kingdom, over 300 injured.[221][222]
2011 - Riots in Huancavelica, Peru, 3 killed and more than 30 injured.[223]
2011 - Riots in Guwahati, Assam, India, 2 killed and at least 30 injured.[224][225]
2011 - Riots in Juliaca, Puno Region, Peru, at least 5 killed and 30 wounded.[226]
2011 - Riots in Dadaab, Kenya, 2 killed and 13 injured.[227]
2011 - Riots in Karachi, Pakistan, at least 114 killed, including violence a week prior.[228][229]
2011 - Riots in Ganjam, Orissa, India, at least 2 killed.[230][231]
2011 - Riot in Karaganda, Kazakhstan, at least 7 killed in a prison riot.[232]
2011 - Riot in Nuevo Laredo, Mexico, 7 killed in a prison riot.[233]
2011 - Riot in Hotan, China, 4 killed.[234]
2011 - Riots in Homs, Syria, at least 30 killed in sectarian violence.[235]
2011 - Riots in Sidi Bouzid, Tunisia, 1 killed.[236]
2011 - Riots in Malawi, at least 18 killed.[237]
2011 - Riots in Ciudad Juarez, Mexico, 17 people killed in a prison riot.[238]
2011 - Riots in Papua, Indonesia, 18 killed in rioting between rival clans.[239][240]
2011 - Riots in Qalad District, Zabul province, Afghanistan, at least 4 killed.[241]
2011 - Riots in Pimpri-Chinchwad, India, 3 killed.[242]
2011 - Riots in London which spread to other cities in England, over a hundred injured and 5 killed.[243][244][245][246]
2011 - Riots in Mogadishu, Somalia, at least 10 killed.[247]
2011 - Riots in Chile, scores of demonstrators and police injured, 1 killed.[248]
2011 - Riots in Hakkari province, Turkey, 1 killed.[249]
2011 - Riots in Jos, Nigeria, at least 22 killed.[250]
2011 - Riots in Sbeitla, Tunisia, 4 injured, 1 teenage girl killed.[251]
2011 - Riots in Cairo, Egypt, 3 killed and more than 1000 injured in anti-Israel protests.[252]
2011 - Riots in Ambon, Indonesia, 5 dead and 80 injured in clashes between Christians and Muslims.[253][254]
2011 - Riots in Paramakudi, Tamil Nadu, India, 7 killed.[255]
2011 - Riots in Ujjain, India, 2 killed and 16 injured in a religious riot.[256]
2011 - Riots in Bharatpur, Rajasthan, India, at least 9 killed, over a dozen injured.[257]
2011 - Riots in Nablus, West Bank, 1 killed.[258]
2011 - Riots in Katunitsa, Bulgaria, 2 dead, at least 6 injured in ethnic clashes.[259][260]
2011 - Riots in Dakhla, Western Sahara, Morroco, 7 killed, at least 20 injured.[261]
2011 - Riots in Conakry, Guinea, at least 4 killed.[262][263]
2011 - Riots in Cairo, Egypt, at least 24 killed.[264][265]
2011 - Riots in Darrang district, Assam, India, 4 killed.[266]
2011 - Riots in Papua, Indonesia, 1 killed, 5 injured.[267]
2011 - Riots in Athens, Greece, 1 died of heart attack, 16 injured.[268]
2011 - Riots in Monrovia, Liberia, at least 1 killed and several others wounded.[269]
2011 - Riots in Nicaragua, at least 4 people killed in post-election violence and 46 officers have been injured.[270]
2011 - Riots in Damietta, Egypt, 1 killed and at least 11 injured.[271]
2011 - Riots in Cairo, Egypt, 33 killed.[272]
2011 - Riots in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of the Congo, at least 1 dead.[273]
2011 - Riots in Karachi, Pakistan, at least 2 killed and 8 injured.[274]
2011 - Riots in Zakho, Iraq, at least 30 injured.[275]
2011 - Riots in Canete, Peru, at least 1 killed and 20 injured.[276]
2011 - Riots in Nabi Saleh, West Bank, 1 killed.[277]
2011 - Riot in Jagatsinghpur district, Orissa, India, at least 1 killed and 2 injured.[278]
2011 - Riots in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of the Congo, 6 killed.[279]
2011 - Riots in Zhanaozen, Kazakhstan, at least 11 people killed and 86 injured.[280]
2011 - Riots in Cairo, Egypt, at least 13 people killed and hundreds injured.[281][282]
2011 - Riots in Bima, West Nusa Tenggara, Indonesia, at least 2 people were killed and 8 wounded.[283]
Dixie68 said:
Am I'm missing the significance of the above long list of riots?
Water cannons with a dye. Anyone trying to claim the dole while covered in the dye gets feck all & has to help clean up & repair. Or snipers, I'm happy with snipers too.
He's trying to say we are under our quota of riot deaths and falling behind in the world wide tables.Water cannons with a dye. Anyone trying to claim the dole while covered in the dye gets feck all & has to help clean up & repair. Or snipers, I'm happy with snipers too.
TheEnd said:
Dixie68 said:
Am I'm missing the significance of the above long list of riots?
Water cannons with a dye. Anyone trying to claim the dole while covered in the dye gets feck all & has to help clean up & repair. Or snipers, I'm happy with snipers too.
He's trying to say we are under our quota of riot deaths and falling behind in the world wide tables.Water cannons with a dye. Anyone trying to claim the dole while covered in the dye gets feck all & has to help clean up & repair. Or snipers, I'm happy with snipers too.
There were riots, stealing and assault on people and property. And some people died!
Baton rounds should have been a first choice option, real hurty, stingy, nasty, ouch I'm dead type rounds the next option.
In my opinion of course...
The level of violence towards the police was ridiculous. I'm all for meet violence with violence in such situations.
As usual health and safety plus I guess some European unwanted rights will have come into play.
was also trying to work out why most police seemed to have round shields instead of the full length shield. And used tactics from the roman rule book
Minus the gladius of course.
Massive restraint shown by police unfortunately.
As usual health and safety plus I guess some European unwanted rights will have come into play.
was also trying to work out why most police seemed to have round shields instead of the full length shield. And used tactics from the roman rule book
Minus the gladius of course.
Massive restraint shown by police unfortunately.
I got the feeling that if force was used and the Police charged the rioters, the media opinion the next day would have been very anti Police for doing so. On the first day it almost felt that the Police should just stand there and just say' oh well, let the poor things have their day of rioting'.
I'm pretty sure a lot of the media would have been all over pictures of anyone getting hit by Police in riot gear, and we would have had to sit and listen to people who were just caught up in it and totally innocent, about how the nasty Police pushed them around and kept them in one area.
I thought there was quite a big shift in opinion on days 3 and 4 of 'OK, that's enough, now go in and kick the crap out of these rioters'. For me, that needs to happen on day one and show that if you try you luck the next day, that's what is going to happen.
I don't get the big deal about using water canons either. The assertion that it is OK to use in Northern Ireland, but we in England are above that and it wouldn't be fair, is rather lost on me. Hose'em down.
I'm pretty sure a lot of the media would have been all over pictures of anyone getting hit by Police in riot gear, and we would have had to sit and listen to people who were just caught up in it and totally innocent, about how the nasty Police pushed them around and kept them in one area.
I thought there was quite a big shift in opinion on days 3 and 4 of 'OK, that's enough, now go in and kick the crap out of these rioters'. For me, that needs to happen on day one and show that if you try you luck the next day, that's what is going to happen.
I don't get the big deal about using water canons either. The assertion that it is OK to use in Northern Ireland, but we in England are above that and it wouldn't be fair, is rather lost on me. Hose'em down.
Mr_B said:
I got the feeling that if force was used and the Police charged the rioters, the media opinion the next day would have been very anti Police for doing so. On the first day it almost felt that the Police should just stand there and just say' oh well, let the poor things have their day of rioting'.
I'm pretty sure a lot of the media would have been all over pictures of anyone getting hit by Police in riot gear, and we would have had to sit and listen to people who were just caught up in it and totally innocent, about how the nasty Police pushed them around and kept them in one area.
I thought there was quite a big shift in opinion on days 3 and 4 of 'OK, that's enough, now go in and kick the crap out of these rioters'. For me, that needs to happen on day one and show that if you try you luck the next day, that's what is going to happen.
I don't get the big deal about using water canons either. The assertion that it is OK to use in Northern Ireland, but we in England are above that and it wouldn't be fair, is rather lost on me. Hose'em down.
MMMmmmmmI'm pretty sure a lot of the media would have been all over pictures of anyone getting hit by Police in riot gear, and we would have had to sit and listen to people who were just caught up in it and totally innocent, about how the nasty Police pushed them around and kept them in one area.
I thought there was quite a big shift in opinion on days 3 and 4 of 'OK, that's enough, now go in and kick the crap out of these rioters'. For me, that needs to happen on day one and show that if you try you luck the next day, that's what is going to happen.
I don't get the big deal about using water canons either. The assertion that it is OK to use in Northern Ireland, but we in England are above that and it wouldn't be fair, is rather lost on me. Hose'em down.
How about we let the police shoot anyone seen buying a copy of the daily mail?
Stun guns are a good idea.
Though live rounds would be fine with me too, I probably wouldn't, when push came to shove, want to be the guy who mowed down a group of teenagers, even if they were raising hell, nor would I want to have to deal with the inevitable resentment that came from that over the following months and years.
Stun gun, then when they wake up being part of a chain gang who have to clean up the mess they made. Then face court and tougher prison sentences.
Though live rounds would be fine with me too, I probably wouldn't, when push came to shove, want to be the guy who mowed down a group of teenagers, even if they were raising hell, nor would I want to have to deal with the inevitable resentment that came from that over the following months and years.
Stun gun, then when they wake up being part of a chain gang who have to clean up the mess they made. Then face court and tougher prison sentences.
The law in this country regarding what the police can do in such situations is very complex. If water cannon is used in somebody is insured then the police, or probably a police officer, will be liable. Historically the response of police in escalation of violence has been to protect the individual officer. My experience is that this worked very well and changed casualty rates amongst the police dramatically.
I went on one demo where we set out with 56 on board the coach had returned with 26 ('just over half' according to the superintendent in charge). Two years later I was involved in an equally violent demonstration (riot) but this time with shields. The only injuries were back pain from carrying the heavy shields for so long.
As time goes by the law is changed as to what police officers can and cannot do in such situations. I went in with a snatch squad to rescue a couple of police officers who were being beaten up by demonstrators some way into the mob. All we did was to use our short shields to matter how way through. Nowadays that would be frowned upon.
The response of police to changing demands has been to reinvent kettling. Now it would appear that some of the people who were kettled wanted to go to Laura Ashley to buy some strange wallpaper site looks as if that response will soon be banned.
The law in this country prohibits in practice responses such as water cannon. The police might be told to use it but it is quite a powerful weapon. Think back to its deployments in Northern Ireland I do remember films of people being knocked off their feet, crashed into walls and rolled along the ground by the force of the jet. Yet we have recently seen a police officer being prosecuted for what was in essence little more than a push the demonstrator.
The change in the law to allow water cannons does not change the fundamental basis of policing. Any response must be reasonable and if an innocent party, or rather party who cannot be proven to be part of the riot, is injured when the person pulling the trigger, or whatever device sets off the water cannon is liable.
Due to the massive cuts in response strength it is unlikely that, should similar riots occur in the near future, the police could respond with anything like the numbers they did last year. I can see soldiers being deployed in public order incidents in this country.
This is a recipe for disaster. That is not to be critical of soldiers of course, they are trained to respond differently. Whilst their performance might not be quite as bad as police officers being deployed to perform their role in Afghanistan, I can see a considerable number of injuries being suffered by demonstrators.
Police are criticised for being reactive but in point of fact, or rather point of law, that is their only option.
I went on one demo where we set out with 56 on board the coach had returned with 26 ('just over half' according to the superintendent in charge). Two years later I was involved in an equally violent demonstration (riot) but this time with shields. The only injuries were back pain from carrying the heavy shields for so long.
As time goes by the law is changed as to what police officers can and cannot do in such situations. I went in with a snatch squad to rescue a couple of police officers who were being beaten up by demonstrators some way into the mob. All we did was to use our short shields to matter how way through. Nowadays that would be frowned upon.
The response of police to changing demands has been to reinvent kettling. Now it would appear that some of the people who were kettled wanted to go to Laura Ashley to buy some strange wallpaper site looks as if that response will soon be banned.
The law in this country prohibits in practice responses such as water cannon. The police might be told to use it but it is quite a powerful weapon. Think back to its deployments in Northern Ireland I do remember films of people being knocked off their feet, crashed into walls and rolled along the ground by the force of the jet. Yet we have recently seen a police officer being prosecuted for what was in essence little more than a push the demonstrator.
The change in the law to allow water cannons does not change the fundamental basis of policing. Any response must be reasonable and if an innocent party, or rather party who cannot be proven to be part of the riot, is injured when the person pulling the trigger, or whatever device sets off the water cannon is liable.
Due to the massive cuts in response strength it is unlikely that, should similar riots occur in the near future, the police could respond with anything like the numbers they did last year. I can see soldiers being deployed in public order incidents in this country.
This is a recipe for disaster. That is not to be critical of soldiers of course, they are trained to respond differently. Whilst their performance might not be quite as bad as police officers being deployed to perform their role in Afghanistan, I can see a considerable number of injuries being suffered by demonstrators.
Police are criticised for being reactive but in point of fact, or rather point of law, that is their only option.
Derek Smith said:
Due to the massive cuts in response strength it is unlikely that, should similar riots occur in the near future, the police could respond with anything like the numbers they did last year. I can see soldiers being deployed in public order incidents in this country.
This is a recipe for disaster. That is not to be critical of soldiers of course, they are trained to respond differently. Whilst their performance might not be quite as bad as police officers being deployed to perform their role in Afghanistan, I can see a considerable number of injuries being suffered by demonstrators.
I look forward to such an eventThis is a recipe for disaster. That is not to be critical of soldiers of course, they are trained to respond differently. Whilst their performance might not be quite as bad as police officers being deployed to perform their role in Afghanistan, I can see a considerable number of injuries being suffered by demonstrators.
Derek Smith said:
The law in this country regarding what the police can do in such situations is very complex. If water cannon is used in somebody is insured then the police, or probably a police officer, will be liable.
Then we need a political seachange, followed by a law change, making the scrotes liable and in particular liable to receive lengthy periods of stripey daylight after, as somebody sensibly suggested, being made to clean up their own mess - which is after all what a responsible grown up would do, though a sensible person wouldn't wreck a cityscape in the first place. Nothing wrong with teaching various motley anarchists, communists and revolting students a lesson.Police warning to disperse, no response, final warning, no response, get stuck in.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



