was it right for the sun to have published pictures Harry?
Poll: was it right for the sun to have published pictures Harry?
Total Members Polled: 337
Discussion
ehonda said:
No. Not because the royal family asked them not to, but because it's not in the public interest and it's a private thing that happened in a private place.
They're scum and I hope they go out of business simply for making me agree with Prescott this morning.
well said. I agree entirely, even about prescott!They're scum and I hope they go out of business simply for making me agree with Prescott this morning.
whoami said:
The pictures were already all over the web.
This.If the photos were not available online, and The Sun had the only copies then I think it would have been wrong to publish them.
But on the basis that they were already all over the internet I think it was right that they carried them too, since our press is free.
The difference is whether they were releasing them/breaking the story, or not. They were not, so I don't think it was wrong of them to republish something which was already so widely available.
They claim it is a "freedom of the press" issue. I call "b
ks". They wanted to get onto the salacious bandwagon at the earliest opportunity - as is their normal modus operandi.
They could have continued not to publish the pictures but stated clearly that they were adopting that stance due to editorial decision making and not due to any outside pressure.
But Murdoch's ethos runs through his empire like Brighton through a stick of Brighton Rock.
ks". They wanted to get onto the salacious bandwagon at the earliest opportunity - as is their normal modus operandi.They could have continued not to publish the pictures but stated clearly that they were adopting that stance due to editorial decision making and not due to any outside pressure.
But Murdoch's ethos runs through his empire like Brighton through a stick of Brighton Rock.
mrmr96 said:
This.
If the photos were not available online, and The Sun had the only copies then I think it would have been wrong to publish them.
But on the basis that they were already all over the internet I think it was right that they carried them too, since our press is free.
The difference is whether they were releasing them/breaking the story, or not. They were not, so I don't think it was wrong of them to republish something which was already so widely available.
I take the opposite tack. The only reason they've published them is to beat their chest about the freedom of the press. It's not news since it was widely published days ago, and the Sun had already told the country that Harry had been pictured naked in a hotel room. So all this is is posturing and titillation. If the photos were not available online, and The Sun had the only copies then I think it would have been wrong to publish them.
But on the basis that they were already all over the internet I think it was right that they carried them too, since our press is free.
The difference is whether they were releasing them/breaking the story, or not. They were not, so I don't think it was wrong of them to republish something which was already so widely available.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



