NHS works well and provides an ok service shock
Discussion
Our eldest has had a scratch on her leg go septic. I couldn't be arsed to drive into town to see our usual GP and didn't want to call out a locum, so I took her to the drop-in centre at our local NHS GP practice where my wife has them down as NHS patients for simple day-to-day stuff.
I was expecting queues out of the door, crimean war field-hospital standards of cleanliness and equipment and a doctor who, when we finally did see him/her would be a 19yr-oldwith qualifications of questionable foriegn origin and a grasp of English limited to asking for directions to the beach.
The building was clean, well equipped and modern, there were 3 people in the queue in front of us and, less than 20 minutes after arriving, we were being seen by a charming and very competent GP.
Why do people moan about the state of the NHS?
I was expecting queues out of the door, crimean war field-hospital standards of cleanliness and equipment and a doctor who, when we finally did see him/her would be a 19yr-oldwith qualifications of questionable foriegn origin and a grasp of English limited to asking for directions to the beach.
The building was clean, well equipped and modern, there were 3 people in the queue in front of us and, less than 20 minutes after arriving, we were being seen by a charming and very competent GP.
Why do people moan about the state of the NHS?
ClaphamGT3 said:
Why do people moan about the state of the NHS?
Because your experience isn't typical?To get an appointment with our GP means ringing at 8.00am and having your phone on redial for up to 40 minutes, then depending upon which GP you get your treatment will vary between excellent and barely adequate. I've also had a cut turn septic and 6 weeks later it still looks like crap, despite being described 3 different types of antibiotics (on a suck it and see basis) and seeing 3 different GPs.
RYH64E said:
To get an appointment with our GP means ringing at 8.00am and having your phone on redial for up to 40 minutes, then depending upon which GP you get your treatment will vary between excellent and barely adequate.
^^^^ This, very much this.... An ex work colleague's wife is a practice manager locally, (not my surgery though). They were instructed by higher authorities, in no uncertain terms, that this action of people having to ring up continuously at 8 am onwards and being put in the queue was against guidelines and would be clamped down on. They are also obliged to keep a % of appointments clear for those who want to book an appointment 2 or 3 days in the future.
That surgery has a large number of non-English people (shall we say), and those patients know this guideline/rule VERY well indeed.
Needless to say, these rules have buggar all effect on my local surgery. I have mentioned this to them and they say “they are only guidelines”.
So one lot get b
ked, but another lot don’t. Hmmm…..bucksmanuk said:
RYH64E said:
To get an appointment with our GP means ringing at 8.00am and having your phone on redial for up to 40 minutes, then depending upon which GP you get your treatment will vary between excellent and barely adequate.
^^^^ This, very much this.... An ex work colleague's wife is a practice manager locally, (not my surgery though). They were instructed by higher authorities, in no uncertain terms, that this action of people having to ring up continuously at 8 am onwards and being put in the queue was against guidelines and would be clamped down on. They are also obliged to keep a % of appointments clear for those who want to book an appointment 2 or 3 days in the future.
That surgery has a large number of non-English people (shall we say), and those patients know this guideline/rule VERY well indeed.
Needless to say, these rules have buggar all effect on my local surgery. I have mentioned this to them and they say “they are only guidelines”.
So one lot get b
ked, but another lot don’t. Hmmm…..pokethepope said:
I've only had good experiences, so thats puts us at two-all in this thread, who's going next?
I've been receiving great treatment from various NHS organisations in Somerset (particularly Musgrove Park) over the last few years, as has my OH. Bar one cock-up in Surrey, we haven't experienced truly terrible service in the last 10 years or so.I know that others aren't so lucky; my mother and grandmother absolutely hate their local GPs and the trust they deal with in NW Kent (might have gone bankrupt recently...)
ClaphamGT3 said:
I was expecting queues out of the door, crimean war field-hospital standards of cleanliness and equipment and a doctor who, when we finally did see him/her would be a 19yr-oldwith qualifications of questionable foriegn origin and a grasp of English limited to asking for directions to the beach..
.......
Why do people moan about the state of the NHS?
Because myths are perpetuated by malevolent rumour-mongering, if your preconceptions are anything to go by........
Why do people moan about the state of the NHS?
TheHeretic said:
Could be worse. You could be sat in the waiting room, filling out forms, handing over credit card details, or hoping that your insurance will cover it. The NHS is superb.
The only other place where I've had a better experience with state-provided healthcare was when we lived in Moscow, where we never bothered to use our health insurance because the local poly-clinic was so good (and free at the point of consumption on production of our residency permit)TheHeretic said:
Could be worse. You could be sat in the waiting room, filling out forms, handing over credit card details, or hoping that your insurance will cover it. The NHS is superb.
This.It's usually good. Even when it's bad you're probably better off than in the vast majority of places around the world.
ClaphamGT3 said:
Our eldest has had a scratch on her leg go septic. I couldn't be arsed to drive into town to see our usual GP and didn't want to call out a locum, so I took her to the drop-in centre at our local NHS GP practice where my wife has them down as NHS patients for simple day-to-day stuff.
You didn't even need to be registered there to use it - they have to be open to everyone.GP led drop in centres are quite a recent thing. Most of them are run directly by the local NHS PCT.
TheHeretic said:
Could be worse. You could be sat in the waiting room, filling out forms, handing over credit card details, or hoping that your insurance will cover it. The NHS is superb.
I am not saying that the NHS is always bad, far from it, but from reading the OP's post it would seem that there are no problems with the NHS, which isn't true.As far as cost is concerned, my old mum need a hip operation earlier this year and was in a lot of pain, the NHS waiting list was 6-12 months so my siblings and I paid upwards of £11k for her to have the operation in a private hospital (waiting list 2-3 days), sometimes even free service isn't worth it.
RYH64E said:
I am not saying that the NHS is always bad, far from it, but from reading the OP's post it would seem that there are no problems with the NHS, which isn't true.
I think his post is somewhat tonque-in-cheek, as it would seem he normally uses a private GP.It's a bit like taking a single journey on a park-and-ride bus and then declaring that all public transport is marvelous.
vonuber said:
I've been in the hands of the NHS now for getting on two years. Been bloody fantastic.
You would hope so, given that it has cost UKP400 billion to run it during those 2 years. My personal experience of the NHS has been less satisfactory than yours. Luck of the draw I suppose.TheHeretic said:
Could be worse. You could be sat in the waiting room, filling out forms, handing over credit card details, or hoping that your insurance will cover it. The NHS is superb.
Not really a big problem. In Switzerland you carry your insurance card in y our wallet and you just get seen to- if it's emergency they always see you first. The only time I've had to fill out forms was moving to a new doctors surgery when they wanted to see that I had cover! To be honest it took just the same amount of time raw registering at the local uk gp surgery.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



