3 children dead and man missing after canoe capsize.
3 children dead and man missing after canoe capsize.
Author
Discussion

croyde

Original Poster:

26,550 posts

261 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
Apologies if this has been talked about before but I have done a search.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-highlands-is...

Really bloody tragic plus the kids had life jackets on. Does it not strike you as strange that one dad made it to the shore with one daughter getting there before him whilst the other daughter was found face down in the water.

I just can't imagine what went on, that a capsize in calm waters could go so wrong. A lot of panic perhaps and the locals say that there are fast currents so maybe everyone was separated. Bloody awful.

I capsized a dinghy with my then 7 year old son in the sea off a Greek island. We had buoyancy jackets on but not the full ones. No problem I thought as I can right the boat again plus there were safety boats within minutes.

I did not account for my boy's absolute panic. He was terrified and struggling and there was no way I could leave him so that I could right the boat. Thing is the more he panicked the more I could feel the onset of it in me.

Thankfully the safety boat was quick but it felt like forever.

RIP to the kiddies and the dad frown

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

229 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
croyde said:
Apologies if this has been talked about before but I have done a search.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-highlands-is...

Really bloody tragic plus the kids had life jackets on. Does it not strike you as strange that one dad made it to the shore with one daughter getting there before him whilst the other daughter was found face down in the water.

I just can't imagine what went on, that a capsize in calm waters could go so wrong. A lot of panic perhaps and the locals say that there are fast currents so maybe everyone was separated. Bloody awful.

I capsized a dinghy with my then 7 year old son in the sea off a Greek island. We had buoyancy jackets on but not the full ones. No problem I thought as I can right the boat again plus there were safety boats within minutes.

I did not account for my boy's absolute panic. He was terrified and struggling and there was no way I could leave him so that I could right the boat. Thing is the more he panicked the more I could feel the onset of it in me.

Thankfully the safety boat was quick but it felt like forever.

RIP to the kiddies and the dad frown
My wife pointed this out this morning as we've just bought a kayak and it plugs into her fear of taking it out with my three year old. My thoughts were I wonder if they were actually wearing life jackets and not PFDs?

Very very sad story though nonetheless.

Eric Mc

125,971 posts

296 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
I wonder how familar they were with these types of canoes? The man from the Coastguard they interviewed on TV last night seemed to think they were inherently unsttable in the water and therefore required skill and experience to use properly.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
Strikes me as an awful lot of people to pack into a canoe - they would have been very low in the water I imagine. Terrible incident nonetheless.

croyde

Original Poster:

26,550 posts

261 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
I took my 3 kids and my niece on the Norfolk Broads on a 42 ft cruiser and I was terrified enough. I made them wear the life jackets all the time. I found the whole experience pretty wearisome and definitely now need a holiday for myself.

I originally was going to hire a dinghy as an extra but was too scared for the children's sake, even though they can all swim apart from the youngest.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
davepoth said:
Strikes me as an awful lot of people to pack into a canoe - they would have been very low in the water I imagine. Terrible incident nonetheless.
Same here, although they are pretty big. I'd imagine they'd be pretty unstable with that many in it, possibly moving about in waves on the loch.

Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
I think that it was reported somewhere that they were wearing buoyancy aids rather than true lifejackets so, whilst they were kept afloat, their heads were not kept above water.

Really very tragic.

hyperblue

2,921 posts

211 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
croyde said:
I capsized a dinghy with my then 7 year old son in the sea off a Greek island. We had buoyancy jackets on but not the full ones. No problem I thought as I can right the boat again plus there were safety boats within minutes.
Dinghy's have built in buoyancy. The report on the news last night showed the boat (open canoe type thing) and they don't have their own buoyancy. If capsized, I imagine it would be difficult to right and would be very unstable whilst you bailed out the water.
croyde said:
I capsized a dinghy with my then 7 year old son in the sea off a Greek island. We had buoyancy jackets on but not the full ones. No problem I thought as I can right the boat again plus there were safety boats within minutes.

I did not account for my boy's absolute panic. He was terrified and struggling and there was no way I could leave him so that I could right the boat. Thing is the more he panicked the more I could feel the onset of it in me.
When I was a sailing instructor, it was pretty much lesson #1 to take the kids out and do a controlled capsize, so they know what to expect.

Edited by hyperblue on Tuesday 28th August 16:03

Jamie VTS

1,238 posts

178 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
hyperblue said:
Dinghy's have built in buoyancy. The report on the news last night showed the boat (open canoe type thing) and they don't have their own buoyancy. If capsized, I imagine it would be difficult to right and would be very unstable whilst you bailed out the water.
Yep, pretty much impossible to self rescue a canadian canoe in the situation they would have been in, if you have another boat still afloat you can use it to haul the capsized boat up and empty it etc..

Lots of things they did (going by the news reports) were wrong;The conditions were not appropriate, Buoyancy aids should be used for people who can swim confidently (NOT a 3 year old) as have to keep yourself upright in the water, if you use a life jacket they have more buoyancy in one of the chambers so they will turn you the correct way up in the water and even keep your head above the water if you are unconcious. I also read somewhere that they were over 500m from shore thats nearly double the limit most manufacturers place on recreational boats (300m is the recommended distance)

It is a real tragedy, but unfortunately they wont be the last people to die because they didnt take the correct steps to prevent something like this happening. frown

Edited by Jamie VTS on Tuesday 28th August 16:12

jhfozzy

1,345 posts

221 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
Haven't seen the craft used yet, but it was described as a "canadian type canoe", these (should) have inflatable airbags front and rear as bouyancy in case the worst happens. Please ignore my brother P*****g himself at us capsizing.



Once flooded they are quite stable as the water damps the rocking movements but they are quite difficult to empty and bail out as they hold a lot of water.



I'd be really surprised and quite horrified to be honest if they did have six in a standard Canadian. This is ours three-up and it was unstable-ish with just three.


Chrisw666

22,655 posts

230 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
It's hard to be critical of the adults involves when something so tragic happens, however there are four things that probably combined to cause this event, the younger children should have been wearing buoyancy aids that have neck pieces (like a life jacket but without the need to inflate), the boat was almost certainly overloaded and with young children on board will have been less stable, the (supposed) inexperience of the adults meant they didn't have a plan b, once the boat capsized the shock for the children will have been an immense cause of panic and without the benefit of experience or another boat the adults would have struggled to do anything effectively and the children will have been very hard to manage.

It is very sad but as has been said it isn't the first and won't be the last event of the type.

frown

croyde

Original Poster:

26,550 posts

261 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
In response to above I did send my boy on a RYA course and he has now done a few and can happily right a capsized Laser.

ninja-lewis

5,507 posts

221 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
There's also the water temperature. It might be warm enough to paddle in the shallow waters on beach but if you go out a few metres where it starts getting deeper the water temperature drops rapidly. They were at the mouth of sea loch in The Minch, which is essentially the North Atlantic - even at this time of year, the water temperature is going to feel icy.

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Daily Mail claiming they were only wearing boyancy aids and not life jackets. No system in the vests to keep the kids upright

Chrisw666

22,655 posts

230 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Puggit said:
Daily Mail claiming they were only wearing boyancy aids and not life jackets. No system in the vests to keep the kids upright
That would only be an issue if they were unconscious/stuck at sea for a long time or if they weren't correctly fitted. The buoyancy aids will keep you upright if you understand that you need to relax in it and not try to swim in a panic, but for small children they also need to be fastened very tightly to avoid them riding up the child's body and over their face.

Buoyancy aids are the standard piece of safety kit used in canoes and kayaks everywhere, and every piece of safety advice I've ever taken on the subject has always advised staying away from life jackets. The Daily Mail is wrong to imply that the act of not using life jackets is relevant.


croyde

Original Poster:

26,550 posts

261 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
I fell out of my Laser in choppy seas and as the boat carried on without me the safety lookout would not have noticed that I was in trouble. Even with a buoyancy aid I was not happy after just 10 mins of being alone in the water. Must have been terrifying for those kids.

Luckily, in my case, another Laser picked me up and dropped me off by my boat.

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

229 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Chrisw666 said:
Puggit said:
Daily Mail claiming they were only wearing boyancy aids and not life jackets. No system in the vests to keep the kids upright
That would only be an issue if they were unconscious/stuck at sea for a long time or if they weren't correctly fitted. The buoyancy aids will keep you upright if you understand that you need to relax in it and not try to swim in a panic, but for small children they also need to be fastened very tightly to avoid them riding up the child's body and over their face.

Buoyancy aids are the standard piece of safety kit used in canoes and kayaks everywhere, and every piece of safety advice I've ever taken on the subject has always advised staying away from life jackets. The Daily Mail is wrong to imply that the act of not using life jackets is relevant.
Kid's ages were 5,5 and 2. At those ages a life jacket is more appropriate IMO. A cold sea lock at that age will give them zero chance of not panicking. My 3 year old is very very confident in the cold pool, and can swim a little. Dump him in the sea and he would be flappling like a humming bird.

We've just come back from a beach holiday in N Wales with a few other families and my three man kayak was used every day. The rule I imposed if people wanted to borrow it, even in calm water, was 1 child per adult when in the boat and that a life-jacket needed to be worn any kids who couldn't swim or were nervous in the water. The reason, I've seen adults get into difficulties in a swimming pool when out of their depth and trying to keep a child affloat.

Chrisw666

22,655 posts

230 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
rhinochopig said:
Kid's ages were 5,5 and 2. At those ages a life jacket is more appropriate IMO. A cold sea lock at that age will give them zero chance of not panicking. My 3 year old is very very confident in the cold pool, and can swim a little. Dump him in the sea and he would be flappling like a humming bird.

We've just come back from a beach holiday in N Wales with a few other families and my three man kayak was used every day. The rule I imposed if people wanted to borrow it, even in calm water, was 1 child per adult when in the boat and that a life-jacket needed to be worn any kids who couldn't swim or were nervous in the water. The reason, I've seen adults get into difficulties in a swimming pool when out of their depth and trying to keep a child affloat.
While I defended the use of buoyancy aids if we have physically small children canoeing (usually under about 9 years old) we use a buoyancy aid that is like this



meaning for children it does the same job as a life jacket will (over a shorter time-scale) but without the danger of it failing to inflate. Fitting is also hugely important.

hyperblue

2,921 posts

211 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Not all life jackets are the "inflating" type, they may just be foam as per the above post, however they are designed to keep an unconscious person afloat and facing upwards, to prevent drowning. A buoyancy aid is just worn for additional buoyancy to help keep a conscious person afloat (i.e. you don't need to keep swimming to stay afloat) and will typically not support the head or keep an unconscious person facing upwards.

Edited by hyperblue on Wednesday 29th August 10:05

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

229 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Chrisw666 said:
While I defended the use of buoyancy aids if we have physically small children canoeing (usually under about 9 years old) we use a buoyancy aid that is like this



meaning for children it does the same job as a life jacket will (over a shorter time-scale) but without the danger of it failing to inflate. Fitting is also hugely important.
That is a life-jacket isn't it. LJs can be foam or inflating. The key different between a PFD and a LJ is that a LJ will keep an unconcious person head out of the water, whereas a PFD will only keep them afloat in either head in or head out orientation.