BBC break rules on payments to Diana Abbott
Discussion
Do not read this if you are easily annoyed as you will burst with rage
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19423658
The rest of us can have a giggle at the beeb having its fingers wrapped
It would be nice if she had to return the payments but this won't happen
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19423658
The rest of us can have a giggle at the beeb having its fingers wrapped
It would be nice if she had to return the payments but this won't happen
Intersting. I heard this earlier (on the BBC) and I'm probably going to go against the usual PH crowd on this as I don't have a kneejerk black and white view that she appears on the show as a Labour politican representing her party but as a political commentator albeit one clearly supportive of the Labour Party. Similarly I don't see Michael Portillo as solely representing the Conservative Party (although I understand the distinction that she remained an MP).
I appreciate many won't see a distinction but I watch that show as political commentary rather than as Andrew Neil interviewing two representatives. Regardless, the Trust doesn't agree and has ruled.
A bit more ammo for the Mail and the regulars on here to throw at the BBC. All is well with the world.
I appreciate many won't see a distinction but I watch that show as political commentary rather than as Andrew Neil interviewing two representatives. Regardless, the Trust doesn't agree and has ruled.
A bit more ammo for the Mail and the regulars on here to throw at the BBC. All is well with the world.
Where can I claim my "disturbance fee" for having to live in an environment where the BBC broadcast out raw, biased sewage on national networks? Granted, I don't have to watch it, but I do have to live with the noise of their ill-formed opinions, echoing out of the empty heads of voters and, owrse still, consequences of their idiotic ideals.
thinfourth2 said:
Do not read this if you are easily annoyed as you will burst with rage
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19423658
The rest of us can have a giggle at the beeb having its fingers wrapped
It would be nice if she had to return the payments but this won't happen
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19423658
The rest of us can have a giggle at the beeb having its fingers wrapped
It would be nice if she had to return the payments but this won't happen
I don't think they should have paid her...... primarily because as a panelist on This Week, she was inept.
Alan Johnson is far better at it than DA ever was.
But in principle, I don't have a problem with any MP being paid if they're prepared to discuss the week's political events in the way they do on This Week - Perhaps ask them to do it for free the first time, and if they turn it into a Party Political Broadcast (as some have tried to do in the past) then simply don't ask them back - if they do a good job, they're paid from then on.
Alan Johnson is far better at it than DA ever was.
But in principle, I don't have a problem with any MP being paid if they're prepared to discuss the week's political events in the way they do on This Week - Perhaps ask them to do it for free the first time, and if they turn it into a Party Political Broadcast (as some have tried to do in the past) then simply don't ask them back - if they do a good job, they're paid from then on.
I dislike the stupid, lardy, racist, race card weilding woman as much as the next man, but I cannot see anything wrong with paying someone to be on a show like This Week.
Both Abbott and Portillo regularily strayed from the party line and seemed to be only representing themselves.
Appearences on "Question Time" are a completely different matter.
Don
--
Both Abbott and Portillo regularily strayed from the party line and seemed to be only representing themselves.
Appearences on "Question Time" are a completely different matter.
Don
--
JDRoest said:
don4l said:
I dislike the stupid, lardy, racist, race card weilding woman as much as the next man, but I cannot see anything wrong with paying someone to be on a show like This Week.
So....you would be comfortable if Cameron was paid by Newsnight to appear on it?JDRoest said:
don4l said:
I dislike the stupid, lardy, racist, race card weilding woman as much as the next man, but I cannot see anything wrong with paying someone to be on a show like This Week.
So....you would be comfortable if Cameron was paid by Newsnight to appear on it?You cut out the bit where I said
"Both Abbott and Portillo regularily strayed from the party line and seemed to be only representing themselves.
Appearences on "Question Time" are a completely different matter.
Newsnight appearances would be very similiar to Question Time."
Have you watched "This Week"?
Don
--
Edited by don4l on Thursday 30th August 13:54
I have never, ever seen Abbott spelt Abutt, was this perchance a Freudian slip?
On the flip side, it seems that the BBC Trust is doing a reasonable job of monitoring standards and output on the BBC. I have never felt that Abutt (sic) was representing the views of the Labour Party and that part of the appeal of this programme is that the main players engage in a less partisan debate.
On the flip side, it seems that the BBC Trust is doing a reasonable job of monitoring standards and output on the BBC. I have never felt that Abutt (sic) was representing the views of the Labour Party and that part of the appeal of this programme is that the main players engage in a less partisan debate.
I can't see a problem either. It's a bit rich that Lord Laird complained about Abbott being paid by The BBC. He is not unaccustomed to filling his pockets either. In 2008/09 he became the most expensive peer in the House of Lords, claiming more than £73,000 in expenses and allowances.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



