Government announces fuel tax cut
Discussion
French Government, that is. Keep in mind their diesel (the last time I looked) was £1.15 a litre anyway.
http://uk.reuters.com/article/2012/08/28/uk-france...
http://www.france24.com/en/20120830-germany-round-...
Bit of an odd article that second one. Strange comments in it
The measure in France is only for three months but still has to make you laugh.
http://uk.reuters.com/article/2012/08/28/uk-france...
http://www.france24.com/en/20120830-germany-round-...
Bit of an odd article that second one. Strange comments in it
article said:
France’s Socialist government has come under a broadside of criticism in Germany for artificially lowering the cost of petrol and diesel at the pump.
Bringing the price down closer to what the product actually costs is 'artifically lowering' now is it?German Government Chap said:
Lowering the cost of fuel is not the government’s job
But raising it is?The measure in France is only for three months but still has to make you laugh.
muffinmenace said:
Marf said:
Who the fig are Germany to tell anyone not to reduce fuel duty.
Because it increases demand on oil, which is something we want to lower as a continent muffinmenace said:
Because it increases demand on oil, which is something we want to lower as a continent
Only politicians think it's as simple as that. Higher fuel tax doesn't decrease demand for oil, it just makes the population potless so they can't afford to buy it. They actually demand it quite a bit 
Marf said:
muffinmenace said:
Marf said:
Who the fig are Germany to tell anyone not to reduce fuel duty.
Because it increases demand on oil, which is something we want to lower as a continent Beyond that, who is speaking on behalf of a whole continent here? When were we all asked what we want? I'd hazard a guess the answer would be less government rip-offs particularly in terms of fuel duty.
With no sign of peak oil the only 'want' is a mythical one from eurocrats pushing their own daft policies.
martin84 said:
article said:
France’s Socialist government has come under a broadside of criticism in Germany for artificially lowering the cost of petrol and diesel at the pump.
I'm very sad for France - this whole crock of s
t is going to be upended on them just as soon as Hollande provokes the bond markets far enough. I gues Germany must be pissed of that, daft and pomous as Napoleon III was, his replacement has put clear distance between the countries and ultimately risks the security of their largest and most important EU ally.turbobloke said:
Your translation is closest.
Beyond that, who is speaking on behalf of a whole continent here? When were we all asked what we want? I'd hazard a guess the answer would be less government rip-offs particularly in terms of fuel duty.
With no sign of peak oil the only 'want' is a mythical one from eurocrats pushing their own daft policies.
I'm not going to argue that a significant amount of revenue isn't raised from taxation because it is, I'm not going to argue that I think fuel costs are high and is starting to impact on the economy with the stagnation of leisure. Beyond that, who is speaking on behalf of a whole continent here? When were we all asked what we want? I'd hazard a guess the answer would be less government rip-offs particularly in terms of fuel duty.
With no sign of peak oil the only 'want' is a mythical one from eurocrats pushing their own daft policies.
This is about a shift on long term governments ethoses that we need to reduce demand for oil. This is done by having it heavily taxed above inflation, it's not very nice as a user of V-Power. I can see it makes us stronger in the long run by not implementing populist polices that only help in the short term (I wouldn't expect any less from a self proclaimed Socialist). Keeping it up keeps us striving to be more efficient from transport to industry which will keep us a more power continent in the years to come.
Fuel tax is a political tool, not an environmental one. If our "leaders" really believed the CO2 story, they'd have to take much more harsh action to reduce our consumption (and therefore emissions). As it is, they make noises about raising tax to encourage efficiency and lower emissions, while actually keeping it balanced at a level to maximise revenue while minimising the likelihood of mass behaviour change (as that would reduce revenue drastically).
Governments don't want us to use less fuel, it's a massive cash cow for them.
Their conviction that they need the income is far stronger than their conviction that the CO2 emissions are harmful to the environment.
Governments don't want us to use less fuel, it's a massive cash cow for them.
Their conviction that they need the income is far stronger than their conviction that the CO2 emissions are harmful to the environment.
muffinmenace said:
I really don't know where to start, which bit is b
ks?
Most of it, really. Fuel tax is not a mechanism for reducing oil demand, it's a mechanism for raising Government revenue and any Government which claims otherwise is lying. If it were a mechanism for reducing oil demand then surely Government would like its fuel tax revenue to be 0 in an ideal world. In the UK we were told for years fuel tax is to save polar bears and discourage usage, now we get told the real reason they can't cut it is because the Government needs the money.
ks?I would argue there is a limit to how far the economic stick can take you, raising taxes will decrease usage to a certain point but after that point it'll just harm your economy and do more harm than good. I believe we've reached that tipping point in the UK. In 2010 the UK fuel industry shifted over 1 billion litres less than just two years previously, which should be good news but it's not because the Government then lose money and in their infinite wisdom raise tax to chase lost revenue, there is a curve to these things. The Government are now chasing revenue down instead of up to the point where we'll eventually just have one motorist remaining driving round a deserted wasteland paying £20k a litre
The key to everything economic is movement, movement of money, movement of goods, movement of everything. High fuel tax limits movement in more ways than one, it limits the transport of goods, the scope of where one can commute to work and it limits the cash in the publics pocket which prevents it from circulating and promoting growth. The more the Government taxes at source - the less the economy has to move around and make more.
Europe as a continent has far lower emissions and fuel usage than China and the United States but those two are also the 5th and 3rd biggest producers of oil, they have a clear interest in people buying it. If we all stopped using oil then that's most Texans out of a job, likewise those in Colorado wouldn't be too impressed by a worldwide mining ban. Europe is a continent which uses energy but - Russia apart - makes precious little, the biggest oil producer in Europe aside from Russia is Norway with the UK coming in third. Its easy for Europes politicians to spout anti-oil rhetoric when it's not our economies which depend on the production of the stuff. Solutions to things have never been caused by Government taxation, discouraging fuel usage has got us to a point where carmakers make more economical models than they used to but if high taxes limit economic movement then those engineering businesses will struggle to make more solutions.
martin84 said:
Most of it, really. Fuel tax is not a mechanism for reducing oil demand, it's a mechanism for raising Government revenue and any Government which claims otherwise is lying.
It is a mechanism for reducing consumption, if it wasn't taxed we'd become wasteful with it, you don't want something so critical to the working of your economy being wasted to the point of exhaustion. It's desirable for a steady price, enabling the economy to have time to react to changes, our high tax actually cushion us from oil prices rises compared to America which has seen it's prices double in three years.
High fuel prices are not good, nor is low good, it's a balancing act, a balancing act that has to be steady and predictable. I'm sure you could compare oil price stability with economic growth and instability with economic woe.
http://www.transportenvironment.org/sites/te/files...
More efficiency give us a stronger economy
ewenm said:
Fuel tax is a political tool, not an environmental one. If our "leaders" really believed the CO2 story, they'd have to take much more harsh action to reduce our consumption (and therefore emissions). As it is, they make noises about raising tax to encourage efficiency and lower emissions, while actually keeping it balanced at a level to maximise revenue while minimising the likelihood of mass behaviour change (as that would reduce revenue drastically).
Governments don't want us to use less fuel, it's a massive cash cow for them.
Their conviction that they need the income is far stronger than their conviction that the CO2 emissions are harmful to the environment.
Governments don't want us to use less fuel, it's a massive cash cow for them.
Their conviction that they need the income is far stronger than their conviction that the CO2 emissions are harmful to the environment.
martin84 said:
If it were a mechanism for reducing oil demand then surely Government would like its fuel tax revenue to be 0 in an ideal world. In the UK we were told for years fuel tax is to save polar bears and discourage usage, now we get told the real reason they can't cut it is because the Government needs the money.
I'm not arguing environmental points, purely economic.
muffinmenace said:
if it wasn't taxed we'd become wasteful with it, you don't want something so critical to the working of your economy being wasted to the point of exhaustion
So I take it you're advocating banning Formula One and Nascar then?muffinmenace said:
our high tax actually cushion us from oil prices rises compared to America which has seen it's prices double in three years
Another urban legend. We're not cushioned from anything, we're just more accustomed to financial arse rape that a little bit more of it is neither here nor there.I'd have thought the Germans would have been pleased with the French given they've spent years hedging themselves against high-cost energy through subsidisation and application of taxation. Has it been the right move? We'll know in 10 years, they're playing a strategy for long-term growth.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


