The return of workfare?
Author
Discussion

Countdown

Original Poster:

49,587 posts

227 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Govt suggesting people do a certain amount of work before being entitled to benefits.

Firstly -about time.

Secondly - why stop there? There are plenty of "public service" jobs that could be done in exchange for benefits payments. Street cleaning/litter picking/ painting & maintaining communal areas / domestic assistants in hospitals.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/jobs/9504796/En...

Apologies if repost.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Countdown said:
Secondly - why stop there? There are plenty of "public service" jobs that could be done in exchange for benefits payments. Street cleaning/litter picking/ painting & maintaining communal areas / domestic assistants in hospitals..
Why stop there?

Pay a street cleaner to clean the street results in a clean street

Pay a doleite to clean the street results in a stolen brush, a bigger pile of rubbish and a dirty street as well as an unemployed street sweeper


Pay a painter to paint results in something painted

Pay a doleite to paint results in graffiti, and paint everywhere as well as an unemployed painter



My father was involved with a project which involved maintaining some grounds where they got some community service folk in and they cost more in damage theft then it would of to of hired professional gardeners.

Don't force these people to work as it costs more then paying someone who wants to work

Countdown

Original Poster:

49,587 posts

227 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
At the moment a lot of council "stuff" isn't being done because councils are cutting back.

The council / public sector is paying twice over ; once to a street cleaner to clean the streets and once to the welfare recipient.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Well bin the street cleaner and have two on the dole

As making the doley clean the streets won't result in clean streets

Countdown

Original Poster:

49,587 posts

227 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Might do if you threaten to stop his benefits? wink

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Countdown said:
why stop there? There are plenty of "public service" jobs that could be done in exchange for benefits payments. Street cleaning/litter picking/ painting & maintaining communal areas / domestic assistants in hospitals.
Presumably all the employees in the jobs you mention there will therefore be sacked, due to benefit claimants doing their jobs for free. So someone who was a street cleaner will end up unemployed and probably back out on the street cleaning it as he used to but only for benefit money instead. Well done rolleyes

If you want people to do these jobs then employ them to do it. This 'policy' makes it sound like there is work out there to be done, so let's actually get people into those jobs. Get them off the benefits, give them an actual job at a legal wage. Why should councils get their cleaning and painting done for free when private businesses don't? Why should public services be exempt from paying for labour? Why should my taxes go to providing local authorities with free workers because they don't want to employ them themselves?

What other groups of people do you want to force onto the dole by getting the unemployed to do their work for £50 a week? Bus driver? City trader? Car salesman? Taxi driver? Computer engineer? Should unemployed engineers be forced to repair BA planes for benefit money? You tell me where it ends.

What job do you do by the way? How would you feel if the Government offered your company the use of every JSA claimant to do your job free of charge to your employer?

Apologies for not joining in the round of 'what else can we get the benefit claimant to do?' but I really don't think you or the Government have thought this through.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Why should councils get their cleaning and painting done for free when private businesses don't? Why should public services be exempt from paying for labour? Why should my taxes go to providing local authorities with free workers because they don't want to employ them themselves?
You've excelled yourself there.


I take the other points about putting people out of work, but why people on scruffy council estates can't be put to work tidying them up, I have no idea. They might even take pride in the places if they were smartened up.

Funk

27,820 posts

240 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
martin84 said:
Why should councils get their cleaning and painting done for free when private businesses don't? Why should public services be exempt from paying for labour? Why should my taxes go to providing local authorities with free workers because they don't want to employ them themselves?
You've excelled yourself there.


I take the other points about putting people out of work, but why people on scruffy council estates can't be put to work tidying them up, I have no idea. They might even take pride in the places if they were smartened up.
Read his other posts; he never fails to underwhelm me.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
You've excelled yourself there.


I take the other points about putting people out of work, but why people on scruffy council estates can't be put to work tidying them up, I have no idea. They might even take pride in the places if they were smartened up.
I wasn't talking about council estates. Council's control more than just housing estates. By 'public service' work we're talking about cleaning the streets, tending the public gardens, flower baskets, painting road markings and all sorts of other things.

My main criticism of the previous scheme the Government tried was how it was set up to provide low paying employers with free staff at my expense. Remember the case of the student (with a history degree) who arranged voluntary work in the museum but was forced to go to Poundland? That's proof it's not about 'giving people experience' it's about giving companies free staff to get them to sponsor the program.

Personally I think Poundland should pay for Poundlands staff, not the taxpayer.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Countdown said:
Might do if you threaten to stop his benefits? wink
Excellent idea

Lets employ someone to watch them and before you know it you have a more expensive system then employing a street sweeper

The idea of forcing the unemployable to work is basically flawed as they are unemployable

crankedup

25,764 posts

274 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
martin84 said:
Why should councils get their cleaning and painting done for free when private businesses don't? Why should public services be exempt from paying for labour? Why should my taxes go to providing local authorities with free workers because they don't want to employ them themselves?
You've excelled yourself there.


I take the other points about putting people out of work, but why people on scruffy council estates can't be put to work tidying them up, I have no idea. They might even take pride in the places if they were smartened up.
Then why should those on the out of work benefits only work on council estates? I want my grass verge cut more than twice each year, just because its not on council estate you exclude my area for the 'makeover'. In an equal Society its not so easy is it.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
, but why people on scruffy council estates can't be put to work tidying them up, I have no idea. They might even take pride in the places if they were smartened up.
One would say if they are unemployed then why haven't they tidied it up themselves?

Are they too busy watching the telly to move the old sofa off the lawn

Mobile Chicane

22,031 posts

243 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Grayling's barking up the wrong tree. The problem needs to be stopped 'at source'.

End the provision of local authority funded housing for new single mothers from say, 1 January 2014, and there's half the problem solved, right there.

Terminator X

21,025 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Countdown said:
Might do if you threaten to stop his benefits? wink
Lol do you really think the end result = no payments?! The govt will not get away with making (even dossers) pennileness (sp?) ...

TX.

crankedup

25,764 posts

274 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
We should shove a broom into the hands of out of work bankers, if not the hands then elsewhere perhaps.

crankedup

25,764 posts

274 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Deva Link said:
You've excelled yourself there.


I take the other points about putting people out of work, but why people on scruffy council estates can't be put to work tidying them up, I have no idea. They might even take pride in the places if they were smartened up.
I wasn't talking about council estates. Council's control more than just housing estates. By 'public service' work we're talking about cleaning the streets, tending the public gardens, flower baskets, painting road markings and all sorts of other things.

My main criticism of the previous scheme the Government tried was how it was set up to provide low paying employers with free staff at my expense. Remember the case of the student (with a history degree) who arranged voluntary work in the museum but was forced to go to Poundland? That's proof it's not about 'giving people experience' it's about giving companies free staff to get them to sponsor the program.

Personally I think Poundland should pay for Poundlands staff, not the taxpayer.
Thats not a debating point, no way will anyone come back to you with a response, far too much truth and common sense in that statement. It sums up what has been going wrong in this Government since it took office, ideas tried out before thinking through.

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Countdown said:
why stop there? There are plenty of "public service" jobs that could be done in exchange for benefits payments. Street cleaning/litter picking/ painting & maintaining communal areas / domestic assistants in hospitals.
Presumably all the employees in the jobs you mention there will therefore be sacked, due to benefit claimants doing their jobs for free. So someone who was a street cleaner will end up unemployed and probably back out on the street cleaning it as he used to but only for benefit money instead. Well done rolleyes

If you want people to do these jobs then employ them to do it. This 'policy' makes it sound like there is work out there to be done, so let's actually get people into those jobs. Get them off the benefits, give them an actual job at a legal wage. Why should councils get their cleaning and painting done for free when private businesses don't? Why should public services be exempt from paying for labour? Why should my taxes go to providing local authorities with free workers because they don't want to employ them themselves?

What other groups of people do you want to force onto the dole by getting the unemployed to do their work for £50 a week? Bus driver? City trader? Car salesman? Taxi driver? Computer engineer? Should unemployed engineers be forced to repair BA planes for benefit money? You tell me where it ends.

What job do you do by the way? How would you feel if the Government offered your company the use of every JSA claimant to do your job free of charge to your employer?

Apologies for not joining in the round of 'what else can we get the benefit claimant to do?' but I really don't think you or the Government have thought this through.
Hmmm. I don't usually mind your posts, like others do but you show a total lack of understanding with this one.

Suffice it to say that there are all sorts of jobs that aren't absolutely essential, but would have benefit, that aren't being done by anyone.

See where this is going?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
I can never tell on these threads if people are asking for a return to forced slavery or mass starvation of the underclass.

Of course stopping someones benefits ALWAYS ends up with said slackers

a) finding work
b) NEVER committing a crime (and going to a taxpayer funded prison).
c) Somehow surviving on fresh air and changing their ways (and those of their children).

And it most certainly NEVER ends up with the underclass going on an orgy of riot and destruction or some form of civil disobedience.

Of course G4S can handle the admin of the said underclass in doing these "free" tasks. Which is nice.


scdan4

1,299 posts

191 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
I've flirted with unemployment from time to time.

Although you can fill a certain amount of time with job searching, there are lags and responses take time.

Overwhelmingly, I was bored. I am not content to watch Jeremy Kyle with a few litres of cheap cider and some bensons. You try to fill the day - cleaning, cooking, gardening etc, but after a time everything is clean, there is more baked than you could possibly eat and the garden is immaculate. (I would like to point out that I managed from my own resources, and did not claim JSA or similar whilst not working)

I would have loved somewhere i could go to get a days work for a minimal amount of money in an easy in - easy out type arrangement. Paint this, scrub this, clean this, pick up litter here. 8 to 10 hours, 15 to 20 quid of your jobseekers - do this 3 times a week leaving plenty of time (4 days a week!) for job seeking. I cannot fathom why people have an objection to this - walk round your local town, there will be places you can improve.

It would get you out the house, keep you active, fit and interacting with others. I would also hope that if it is time spent improving your local environment then it might make you take more care of it, proud of it and involved in it rather than abusing it and then blaming the cahhnncil because everythings crap.

Think how nice your town could be if all those extra things were done. Doesn't have to displace anyone currently employed, doesn't have to be "unfair", can perhaps do an awful lot of good to you and your community.

Personally I would have loved it and would hope and encourage its introduction.

WhoseGeneration

4,090 posts

238 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
scdan4 said:
I've flirted with unemployment from time to time.

Although you can fill a certain amount of time with job searching, there are lags and responses take time.

Overwhelmingly, I was bored. I am not content to watch Jeremy Kyle with a few litres of cheap cider and some bensons. You try to fill the day - cleaning, cooking, gardening etc, but after a time everything is clean, there is more baked than you could possibly eat and the garden is immaculate. (I would like to point out that I managed from my own resources, and did not claim JSA or similar whilst not working)

I would have loved somewhere i could go to get a days work for a minimal amount of money in an easy in - easy out type arrangement. Paint this, scrub this, clean this, pick up litter here. 8 to 10 hours, 15 to 20 quid of your jobseekers - do this 3 times a week leaving plenty of time (4 days a week!) for job seeking. I cannot fathom why people have an objection to this - walk round your local town, there will be places you can improve.

It would get you out the house, keep you active, fit and interacting with others. I would also hope that if it is time spent improving your local environment then it might make you take more care of it, proud of it and involved in it rather than abusing it and then blaming the cahhnncil because everythings crap.

Think how nice your town could be if all those extra things were done. Doesn't have to displace anyone currently employed, doesn't have to be "unfair", can perhaps do an awful lot of good to you and your community.

Personally I would have loved it and would hope and encourage its introduction.
Now, who can argue with this post?