Anyone else had a problem with plastic thermostat housings..
Anyone else had a problem with plastic thermostat housings..
Author
Discussion

HustleRussell

Original Poster:

26,710 posts

191 months

Friday 31st August 2012
quotequote all
...on the M50 engine? I fitted a replacement from euro car parts when fitting a thermostat because the old one looked manky and the rubber seal looked past it, I also noticed it'd been fitted with sealant so was probably due a replacement.
The aftermarket one I bought is next to useless, I fitted it using the recommended torque and it leaked just under a litre between tankfulls- so I took it off and tried again. Went a little tighter and used a smear of sealant. It's now losing coolant at about a litre per 10 miles! Perhaps I cracked it when re-fitting.
Anyway, has anyone else had this? presumably the solution is an OEM BMW replacement housing?

rumple

15,439 posts

182 months

Friday 31st August 2012
quotequote all
HustleRussell said:
...on the M50 engine? I fitted a replacement from euro car parts when fitting a thermostat because the old one looked manky and the rubber seal looked past it, I also noticed it'd been fitted with sealant so was probably due a replacement.
The aftermarket one I bought is next to useless, I fitted it using the recommended torque and it leaked just under a litre between tankfulls- so I took it off and tried again. Went a little tighter and used a smear of sealant. It's now losing coolant at about a litre per 10 miles! Perhaps I cracked it when re-fitting.
Anyway, has anyone else had this? presumably the solution is an OEM BMW replacement housing?
No i never had that, if i were you id source a metal one off ebay, much better solution, also when i did my 328 one years ago i got a plastic one OEM and it was pretty reasonble priced.

HustleRussell

Original Poster:

26,710 posts

191 months

Friday 31st August 2012
quotequote all
I looked into this, but I've read mixed opinions on whether the aluminium ones are any good... They're a fair bit more money I'm sure. I think I'll stick to OEM this time, I just wondered if anyone shares my theory that cheap nasty aftermarket ones are trouble.

TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Friday 31st August 2012
quotequote all
Can you see the leak at the thermostat housing?

The older alloy ones were better as the plastic ones do tend to crack on tightening. Usually it is pretty obvious and a big chunk snaps off.

The old alloy ones had a complete paper gasket, the newer ones just have the inner rubber bit.

I'd bead it with some RTV/silicone to make sure.