Do BMW owners not bother servicing their cars?
Discussion
OK, provokative title, I apologise. But...
I'm looking for an E90/91 330i* - need a car <5y.o. and with 4 doors for work (also for our new baby), and I've never been a hot-hatch person...so the 330 ticks a lot of boxes.
However, over the last 5-6 weeks I've phoned up about 6 different cars, of which I've been to see one and a good friend has seen a second. And ALL 6 have a big gap between oil changes. No, not 18k or 2 years, we're talking 28-30k and/or 33-36 months! Checked with BMW UK and with a few dealerships, and have got a consistent message "no sir, that's outside of our servicing schedule".
Most vendors have been claiming "full service history" because there's a stamp in that large gap, despite the tick under said stamp saying 'brake fluid' (and been verified by a call to the dealer). Another seemed proud that "he wasn't a car person", and wasn't bothered by 3 services in >70k miles.
Am I missing something here?
And is 30k actually sensible in one of these (On an N53: Injectors, coils, etc.
)?
Finally, is there ANY hope of getting a BMW-backed warranty (the Mondial one) on one of these cars, even if I should be putting away the barge-pole I'm currently wielding at the thought of 30k on the same oil
Thanks all,
M.
* Driven a 330d and am impressed overall, but the engine doesn't do it for me. So no suggestions to try a -d, please.
I'm looking for an E90/91 330i* - need a car <5y.o. and with 4 doors for work (also for our new baby), and I've never been a hot-hatch person...so the 330 ticks a lot of boxes.
However, over the last 5-6 weeks I've phoned up about 6 different cars, of which I've been to see one and a good friend has seen a second. And ALL 6 have a big gap between oil changes. No, not 18k or 2 years, we're talking 28-30k and/or 33-36 months! Checked with BMW UK and with a few dealerships, and have got a consistent message "no sir, that's outside of our servicing schedule".
Most vendors have been claiming "full service history" because there's a stamp in that large gap, despite the tick under said stamp saying 'brake fluid' (and been verified by a call to the dealer). Another seemed proud that "he wasn't a car person", and wasn't bothered by 3 services in >70k miles.
Am I missing something here?
And is 30k actually sensible in one of these (On an N53: Injectors, coils, etc.

)?Finally, is there ANY hope of getting a BMW-backed warranty (the Mondial one) on one of these cars, even if I should be putting away the barge-pole I'm currently wielding at the thought of 30k on the same oil

Thanks all,
M.
* Driven a 330d and am impressed overall, but the engine doesn't do it for me. So no suggestions to try a -d, please.
My mates got an E36 323 that hadn't been serviced at all in 3 years/30k when he got it. It was fine after an oil change and full service. But then it's an older less complicated car and cost £700, still a lovely car though. Personally if I was spending that much money service history would be my priority. Modern BMW's are set to variable servicing. No set time, just when the light comes on, and that's anything from 10-25k I've heard. I don't think any damage will be really done if it's done 30k on the same oil but as you say it won't help with warranty issues. My 528 get's one every 12-18 months/10-12k.
havoc said:
No, not 18k or 2 years, we're talking 28-30k and/or 33-36 months! Checked with BMW UK and with a few dealerships, and have got a consistent message "no sir, that's outside of our servicing schedule".
On mine X3 3d, The first service on mine was done at around 20.6k (about a year), but still indicated it had over 2K to go - the current service is indicated in 200 miles, it has done 21K in 21 months.From the way the service indicator goes down, I think cold starts probably drops the figure more than distance, so I think 28K if done in a year could possibly be within service indicator levels.
Roofer - me too. Regardless of oil quality, it's a small cost to keep the engine as good as possible.
Blippo - think I agree with you, but when someone pays £30k+ for a new car (OK, probably £4k down and £400 a month, then chopping before the balloon payment*), why the **** do they not spend another couple of hundred a year SERVICING THE BLOODY THING?!?
Jimmy - if it was all in one year I'd think M-way miles and have some sympathy, but the last two (both currently for sale, both blue):-
- the 21k mile car, reg 1-March-08, had it's first oil service 14 Dec-10 at 14k. 2yrs 9mths on the original oil?!?
- the 44k mile car (Dec-07 reg) had the first oil service in July-09 @ 16k and then an alleged service in Dec-11 (still >2 years) @ ~36k, which on inspection turns out to be brake fluid only! (The car's had the brake fluid done twice and the engine oil once!!!
)
I also went to see a very nice LCI Touring which hadn't had a service for 27 months and 21k miles, also advertised with 'full history'...this one I could probably have lived with if I knew I could put a BMW warranty on it (was told at the time no, now being told something different by BMW CS, which pisses me off as it was a decent car and not TOO over-priced).
* That's why they don't bother - it's disposable to them, and it's never 'their car', only something to show-off in. By the time there's a problem it'll be someone else's. I imagine Audi's and Merc's have the same...
Blippo - think I agree with you, but when someone pays £30k+ for a new car (OK, probably £4k down and £400 a month, then chopping before the balloon payment*), why the **** do they not spend another couple of hundred a year SERVICING THE BLOODY THING?!?
Jimmy - if it was all in one year I'd think M-way miles and have some sympathy, but the last two (both currently for sale, both blue):-
- the 21k mile car, reg 1-March-08, had it's first oil service 14 Dec-10 at 14k. 2yrs 9mths on the original oil?!?
- the 44k mile car (Dec-07 reg) had the first oil service in July-09 @ 16k and then an alleged service in Dec-11 (still >2 years) @ ~36k, which on inspection turns out to be brake fluid only! (The car's had the brake fluid done twice and the engine oil once!!!

)I also went to see a very nice LCI Touring which hadn't had a service for 27 months and 21k miles, also advertised with 'full history'...this one I could probably have lived with if I knew I could put a BMW warranty on it (was told at the time no, now being told something different by BMW CS, which pisses me off as it was a decent car and not TOO over-priced).
* That's why they don't bother - it's disposable to them, and it's never 'their car', only something to show-off in. By the time there's a problem it'll be someone else's. I imagine Audi's and Merc's have the same...
Back in June I brought a 330i touring. I also had the same 'problem' you’re going through. How could people not be servicing their cars... I think it comes down to the BMW on-board computer service system (or whatever its call). I brought my 330i and immediately did an oil change and some other items even thought it had an oil change earlier this year.
The computer came up saying 13,000 miles until the next service... it still does 2,000 miles later! We have done some long summer holiday trips on M-roads. I'll still be doing a yearly change.
If I brought a new car and had it for 4 years knowing this to be the case I would only do as the computer said and some BMW seem to allow the owner to do almost 30 months before oil changes.
Good luck with the hunt.
The computer came up saying 13,000 miles until the next service... it still does 2,000 miles later! We have done some long summer holiday trips on M-roads. I'll still be doing a yearly change.
If I brought a new car and had it for 4 years knowing this to be the case I would only do as the computer said and some BMW seem to allow the owner to do almost 30 months before oil changes.
Good luck with the hunt.
It's not just BMW's, it's everything. Owners just don't care anymore and if the car's on the drip, they care even less. I once took a five year old E60 525d in p/ex that was so rough it had to be cleaned up and auctioned. It was pissing oil out everywhere, brakes down to the metal, horrible car.
As good as AUC can be, I would still give thought to buying privately from someone who's had the car for a few years and taken care of it.
As good as AUC can be, I would still give thought to buying privately from someone who's had the car for a few years and taken care of it.
havoc said:
I guess the question is 'are modern oils that good?'. If so, I'm being old fashioned and worrying too much.
Modern oils are very good. But, they have to hold all the shyte from combustion and the filter can't take all of it. I've seen oil drained from cars after 15'000 miles and it's horrid. The filter looks like a chocolate cake and they can indeed collapse - I've seen them make a pitiful whining noise from the filter housing where the collapsed bit is trying to block the oil feed.Longlife oil/servicing is b
ks. It doesn't cost much to change the oil and filter every 7-8000 miles.iSore said:
It doesn't cost much to change the oil and filter every 7-8000 miles.
The parts are not too expensive, but the overall cost depends if you're able to do it yourself or if you rely on a mechanic who needs paying.We all know the saying "a little knowledge can be dangerous" and a botched attempt at an oil/filter change by an incompetent home mechanic could do much more harm than good.
Obviously all PHer's could do an oil change one handed in the dark with no tools, but some car's are owned by people who are not PHers.
When I got my E39, I changed the oil, reset the service lights (as well as doing other things, but this is about oil !), and away we went.
My previous E34's had told me they required an oil change at approx 9 - 10,000 miles.
I'm a high mileage chap, so this could be 10 weeks or so for me.
The E39 went to 19,000 before it needed a change, the filter was starting to collapse ,(I use oem filters), and the oil was rank, really really rank.
Mine doesn't use a drop between services.
Since then I've changed it at 10,000 regardless.
So I for one don't think much of newer service schedules, it's ok I guess for those that can afford new cars, and only drive them under warranty, but I feel if you want the nasa mileages these cars should be capable of, you need to ignore what BMW salesmen tell you.
BMW techies will quietly advise you change it at 10,000.
My previous E34's had told me they required an oil change at approx 9 - 10,000 miles.
I'm a high mileage chap, so this could be 10 weeks or so for me.
The E39 went to 19,000 before it needed a change, the filter was starting to collapse ,(I use oem filters), and the oil was rank, really really rank.
Mine doesn't use a drop between services.
Since then I've changed it at 10,000 regardless.
So I for one don't think much of newer service schedules, it's ok I guess for those that can afford new cars, and only drive them under warranty, but I feel if you want the nasa mileages these cars should be capable of, you need to ignore what BMW salesmen tell you.
BMW techies will quietly advise you change it at 10,000.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


