Secret royal veto powers over new laws
Discussion
http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/aug/31/secret-ro...
It's not often that I read The Guardian, but I saw this story linked from Google News and was intrigued. Apparently senior royals have to be consulted before legislation is introduced to ensure it does not harm their private interests, even subjects like the apprenticeships bill had to be approved because it potentially affected the royal household in their capacity as an employer.
I thought that the royals role was now largely symbolic, I'm not sure that I'm happy with Charles having the power of veto.
It's not often that I read The Guardian, but I saw this story linked from Google News and was intrigued. Apparently senior royals have to be consulted before legislation is introduced to ensure it does not harm their private interests, even subjects like the apprenticeships bill had to be approved because it potentially affected the royal household in their capacity as an employer.
I thought that the royals role was now largely symbolic, I'm not sure that I'm happy with Charles having the power of veto.
RYH64E said:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/aug/31/secret-ro...
It's not often that I read The Guardian, but I saw this story linked from Google News and was intrigued. Apparently senior royals have to be consulted before legislation is introduced to ensure it does not harm their private interests, even subjects like the apprenticeships bill had to be approved because it potentially affected the royal household in their capacity as an employer.
I thought that the royals role was now largely symbolic, I'm not sure that I'm happy with Charles having the power of veto.
they've always had it. It's not often that I read The Guardian, but I saw this story linked from Google News and was intrigued. Apparently senior royals have to be consulted before legislation is introduced to ensure it does not harm their private interests, even subjects like the apprenticeships bill had to be approved because it potentially affected the royal household in their capacity as an employer.
I thought that the royals role was now largely symbolic, I'm not sure that I'm happy with Charles having the power of veto.
not sure i'm happy with any prime minister of the last 50 years having unchecked power.
The Royals are the head of state, they are less likely to be completely self serving than a president. The veto is there to provide a final check and balance, in the same way the army swear allegiance to the Monarch not the government, imagine what would have happened if Oswald Mosely had gained power prior to the second world war.
UnderTheRadar said:
Is the OP referring to "Royal assent", which is far from secret?
I'm no constitutional expert but I believe that Royal Assent is a formal signing off of legislation, whereas the article refers to consultation and involvement in the process of forming legislation, with the power of veto if they believe it affects their private interests.The hereditary system seems to be good at putting people who would not have been involved with law and legislation in the loop, people who are in politics and lawmaking on purpose tend to be of a certain character and seem to in it for a gain, that gain can be financial, or influencial. Both if your name is T.Blair.
A non elected person who's Great great Grandfather was the original title holder is is a good check and balance system for someone who wants to be there as they are less likely to have as many vested interests and such a drive to climb up the power ladder.
A non elected person who's Great great Grandfather was the original title holder is is a good check and balance system for someone who wants to be there as they are less likely to have as many vested interests and such a drive to climb up the power ladder.
Getragdogleg said:
The hereditary system seems to be good at putting people who would not have been involved with law and legislation in the loop, people who are in politics and lawmaking on purpose tend to be of a certain character and seem to in it for a gain, that gain can be financial, or influencial. Both if your name is T.Blair.
A non elected person who's Great great Grandfather was the original title holder is is a good check and balance system for someone who wants to be there as they are less likely to have as many vested interests and such a drive to climb up the power ladder.
Charles has a lot of vested interests, I see no reason why he should be consulted and have powers of amendment and veto in any behind the scenes legislative process.A non elected person who's Great great Grandfather was the original title holder is is a good check and balance system for someone who wants to be there as they are less likely to have as many vested interests and such a drive to climb up the power ladder.
Getragdogleg said:
The hereditary system seems to be good at putting people who would not have been involved with law and legislation in the loop, people who are in politics and lawmaking on purpose tend to be of a certain character and seem to in it for a gain, that gain can be financial, or influencial. Both if your name is T.Blair.
A non elected person who's Great great Grandfather was the original title holder is is a good check and balance system for someone who wants to be there as they are less likely to have as many vested interests and such a drive to climb up the power ladder.
Precisely I suspect the reason the MPs are wary of the none elected house of lords is that there is little that can be done to get them in line. It also means that some in the lords had jobs in the real world not Uni, Party job, researcher, then local politics or back bench position till they climb the party ladder i.e. career politician.A non elected person who's Great great Grandfather was the original title holder is is a good check and balance system for someone who wants to be there as they are less likely to have as many vested interests and such a drive to climb up the power ladder.
RYH64E said:
Getragdogleg said:
The hereditary system seems to be good at putting people who would not have been involved with law and legislation in the loop, people who are in politics and lawmaking on purpose tend to be of a certain character and seem to in it for a gain, that gain can be financial, or influencial. Both if your name is T.Blair.
A non elected person who's Great great Grandfather was the original title holder is is a good check and balance system for someone who wants to be there as they are less likely to have as many vested interests and such a drive to climb up the power ladder.
Charles has a lot of vested interests, I see no reason why he should be consulted and have powers of amendment and veto in any behind the scenes legislative process.A non elected person who's Great great Grandfather was the original title holder is is a good check and balance system for someone who wants to be there as they are less likely to have as many vested interests and such a drive to climb up the power ladder.
k they please.While the Commons is in this astonishing disarray and the representitives are b
d chancers the majority of the nation worry their silly little heads with celebrity jungle X factor on ice talent shows. It is so broken that right now I don't care if the queen dips her oar in to the process or Charles has a hand in deciding something, by the time it reaches them it will have been profited on a thousand times by the very people who are supposed to represent us.
Caulkhead said:
Constitutional monarchy.
Look it up OP.
Look it up OP.
Wiki said:
Most constitutional monarchies employ a parliamentary system in which the monarch may have strictly ceremonial duties or may have reserve powers, depending on the constitution.
In Britain, the Glorious Revolution of 1688 led to a constitutional monarchy restricted by laws such as the Bill of Rights 1689 and the Act of Settlement 1701, although limits on the power of the monarch ('a limited monarchy') are much older than that (see Magna Carta). With the Hanoverian accession in Britain onwards, monarchs saw their powers pass further to their ministers, and Royal neutrality in politics became cemented from around the start of the reign of Queen Victoria (though she had her personal favorites) and enlargements to the franchise. Today, the role is by convention effectively ceremonial.[1] Instead, the British Parliament and the Government - chiefly in the office of Prime Minister - exercise their powers under 'Royal (or Crown) Prerogative': on behalf of the Monarch and through powers still formally possessed by the Monarch.
The most significant family of constitutional monarchies in the world today are the sixteen Commonwealth realms under Elizabeth II.[7] Unlike some of their continental European counterparts, the Monarch and her Governors-General in the Commonwealth realms hold significant "reserve" or "prerogative" powers, to be wielded in times of extreme emergency or constitutional crises usually to uphold parliamentary government.
The article linked in the OP doesn't refer to exercising power in times of extreme emergency, or merely symbolic approval of legislation, rather the power to amend or veto any routine legislation that can conceivably affect their private interests, even such mundane issues as the apprenticeships bill.In Britain, the Glorious Revolution of 1688 led to a constitutional monarchy restricted by laws such as the Bill of Rights 1689 and the Act of Settlement 1701, although limits on the power of the monarch ('a limited monarchy') are much older than that (see Magna Carta). With the Hanoverian accession in Britain onwards, monarchs saw their powers pass further to their ministers, and Royal neutrality in politics became cemented from around the start of the reign of Queen Victoria (though she had her personal favorites) and enlargements to the franchise. Today, the role is by convention effectively ceremonial.[1] Instead, the British Parliament and the Government - chiefly in the office of Prime Minister - exercise their powers under 'Royal (or Crown) Prerogative': on behalf of the Monarch and through powers still formally possessed by the Monarch.
The most significant family of constitutional monarchies in the world today are the sixteen Commonwealth realms under Elizabeth II.[7] Unlike some of their continental European counterparts, the Monarch and her Governors-General in the Commonwealth realms hold significant "reserve" or "prerogative" powers, to be wielded in times of extreme emergency or constitutional crises usually to uphold parliamentary government.
edited to add: Apparently it isn't just the monarch who has these powers, they also extend to the Duchy of Cornwall.
Edited by RYH64E on Saturday 1st September 21:14
RYH64E said:
Caulkhead said:
Constitutional monarchy.
Look it up OP.
Look it up OP.
Wiki said:
Most constitutional monarchies employ a parliamentary system in which the monarch may have strictly ceremonial duties or may have reserve powers, depending on the constitution.
In Britain, the Glorious Revolution of 1688 led to a constitutional monarchy restricted by laws such as the Bill of Rights 1689 and the Act of Settlement 1701, although limits on the power of the monarch ('a limited monarchy') are much older than that (see Magna Carta). With the Hanoverian accession in Britain onwards, monarchs saw their powers pass further to their ministers, and Royal neutrality in politics became cemented from around the start of the reign of Queen Victoria (though she had her personal favorites) and enlargements to the franchise. Today, the role is by convention effectively ceremonial.[1] Instead, the British Parliament and the Government - chiefly in the office of Prime Minister - exercise their powers under 'Royal (or Crown) Prerogative': on behalf of the Monarch and through powers still formally possessed by the Monarch.
The most significant family of constitutional monarchies in the world today are the sixteen Commonwealth realms under Elizabeth II.[7] Unlike some of their continental European counterparts, the Monarch and her Governors-General in the Commonwealth realms hold significant "reserve" or "prerogative" powers, to be wielded in times of extreme emergency or constitutional crises usually to uphold parliamentary government.
The article linked in the OP doesn't refer to exercising power in times of extreme emergency, or merely symbolic approval of legislation, rather the power to amend or veto any routine legislation that can conceivably affect their private interests, even such mundane issues as the apprenticeships bill.In Britain, the Glorious Revolution of 1688 led to a constitutional monarchy restricted by laws such as the Bill of Rights 1689 and the Act of Settlement 1701, although limits on the power of the monarch ('a limited monarchy') are much older than that (see Magna Carta). With the Hanoverian accession in Britain onwards, monarchs saw their powers pass further to their ministers, and Royal neutrality in politics became cemented from around the start of the reign of Queen Victoria (though she had her personal favorites) and enlargements to the franchise. Today, the role is by convention effectively ceremonial.[1] Instead, the British Parliament and the Government - chiefly in the office of Prime Minister - exercise their powers under 'Royal (or Crown) Prerogative': on behalf of the Monarch and through powers still formally possessed by the Monarch.
The most significant family of constitutional monarchies in the world today are the sixteen Commonwealth realms under Elizabeth II.[7] Unlike some of their continental European counterparts, the Monarch and her Governors-General in the Commonwealth realms hold significant "reserve" or "prerogative" powers, to be wielded in times of extreme emergency or constitutional crises usually to uphold parliamentary government.
edited to add: Apparently it isn't just the monarch who has these powers, they also extend to the Duchy of Cornwall.
Edited by RYH64E on Saturday 1st September 21:14
The government belongs to the monarch. The monarch chooses to allow her government to make laws whilst she reserves the right to veto or influence them.
The article is typical Grauniad, as are the comments and unsurprisingly they are unable to quote an example where this power has been used.
Caulkhead said:
"Instead, the British Parliament and the Government - chiefly in the office of Prime Minister - exercise their powers under 'Royal (or Crown) Prerogative': on behalf of the Monarch and through powers still formally possessed by the Monarch."
The government belongs to the monarch. The monarch chooses to allow her government to make laws whilst she reserves the right to veto or influence them.
The article is typical Grauniad, as are the comments and unsurprisingly they are unable to quote an example where this power has been used.
You missed the part that said 'Today, the role is by convention effectively ceremonial'.The government belongs to the monarch. The monarch chooses to allow her government to make laws whilst she reserves the right to veto or influence them.
The article is typical Grauniad, as are the comments and unsurprisingly they are unable to quote an example where this power has been used.
And what about the Duchy of Cornwall? Unless I've missed some breaking news, Charles isn't yet the monarch.
According to the quoted article the power of amendment or veto only applies to legislation that affects their private interests, so not really the same thing as withholding royal assent or 'allowing her government to make laws whilst she reserves the right to veto or influence them', apparently it's only those laws that affect their private interests (in any obscure or conceivable way).
I just went back and read the comments section, f
k me there are some clueless folk out there, seriously, did they honestly think the monarchy exists as a little old lady, her husband and family in a few big houses that we pay for ? Perhaps they might cut a few ribbons and what not once in a while.
As for the idiots calling for a "republic" and "an elected head of state", yes, that will be much better...Put a power hungry sucession of career politicians in the top job, what could possibly go wrong ?
The last thing I want is more power given to
s like Blair.
k me there are some clueless folk out there, seriously, did they honestly think the monarchy exists as a little old lady, her husband and family in a few big houses that we pay for ? Perhaps they might cut a few ribbons and what not once in a while.As for the idiots calling for a "republic" and "an elected head of state", yes, that will be much better...Put a power hungry sucession of career politicians in the top job, what could possibly go wrong ?
The last thing I want is more power given to
s like Blair.Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




