Tutu wants Blair & Bush tried over Iraq
Discussion
Pulls out of leadership summit because he refuses to share a platform with Blair. Good on him.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19454562
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19454562
Justices said:
Pulls out of leadership summit because he refuses to share a platform with Blair. Good on him.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19454562
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19454562
Comment said:
Tutu is spot on. I could never understand how Blair could get away with all his lies, starting/supporting an illegal war then make himself millions on the US speaking circuit or giving leadership talks. The man is a disgrace.
Blair's type have always made use of a well-oiled brassneck. He'll slime away with a statue instead of facing a trial.http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19454562
" It's now almost certain that the war was illegal because it breached the United Nations Charter provisions.”
Sir Geoffrey Bindman, Human Rights Lawyer.

" It's now almost certain that the war was illegal because it breached the United Nations Charter provisions.”
Sir Geoffrey Bindman, Human Rights Lawyer.

Mojocvh said:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19454562
" It's now almost certain that the war was illegal because it breached the United Nations Charter provisions.”
Sir Geoffrey Bindman, Human Rights Lawyer.

Well, crack on with arresting the slimey piece of turd then and let's have the Court decide his Guilt or Innocence. Can we still execute him either way though??! " It's now almost certain that the war was illegal because it breached the United Nations Charter provisions.”
Sir Geoffrey Bindman, Human Rights Lawyer.

Mojocvh said:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19454562
" It's now almost certain that the war was illegal because it breached the United Nations Charter provisions.”
Sir Geoffrey Bindman, Human Rights Lawyer.

Cherie Blair is a leading human rights lawyer too, remember..." It's now almost certain that the war was illegal because it breached the United Nations Charter provisions.”
Sir Geoffrey Bindman, Human Rights Lawyer.

williamp said:
PeanutHead said:
williamp said:
Cherie Blair is a leading human rights lawyer too, remember...
Don't she have habit of defending little s
ts and getting them off?THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS AN ILLEGAL WAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jesus H f
king Chist weeping on a cross.
How hard a damn concept is this for morons to get? Just because a lawyer flaps his mouth the bloody concept doesnt mean it actually exists.
There are no legal wars or illegal wars, there is just war. If you want to invade anywhere then you do and nobody outside of a defending military force has the power to stop you. Similarly the only ppl who have the power and authority to hold you to account are a stronger military force.
The best you can hope for are conventions such as the Geneva Convention, but even that is breached as and when it is deemend neccessary. And before anybody even starts to quote the Just War and casus belli claptrap at me, please dont, I probably know the theory better than you do.
A Sovereign state goes to war when it wants, why it wants and how it wants. What the UN says or thinks on the matter is irrelevent.
Jesus H f
king Chist weeping on a cross.How hard a damn concept is this for morons to get? Just because a lawyer flaps his mouth the bloody concept doesnt mean it actually exists.
There are no legal wars or illegal wars, there is just war. If you want to invade anywhere then you do and nobody outside of a defending military force has the power to stop you. Similarly the only ppl who have the power and authority to hold you to account are a stronger military force.
The best you can hope for are conventions such as the Geneva Convention, but even that is breached as and when it is deemend neccessary. And before anybody even starts to quote the Just War and casus belli claptrap at me, please dont, I probably know the theory better than you do.
A Sovereign state goes to war when it wants, why it wants and how it wants. What the UN says or thinks on the matter is irrelevent.
DJRC said:
I probably know the theory better than you do.
That's great, give yourself a pat on the back.DJRC said:
A Sovereign state goes to war when it wants, why it wants and how it wants. What the UN says or thinks on the matter is irrelevent.
Ours is a democracy. We signed-up to the UN. TB ignored the law in addition to what his voters wanted and pressed ahead with the killing. He should be tried for his criminal actions. Fakkin ell DJRC there's got to be some semblance of international law as it would be a bloody free for all if there wasn't a collective rule book. As you say there was nothing to stop the military might of the U.S but that didn't make their intentions righteous. If opposing military force can't stop it then maybe if the threat of getting strung up by ones neck was a little more real then the will of dominant nations to act with impunity may be diminished.
castex said:
DJRC said:
I probably know the theory better than you do.
That's great, give yourself a pat on the back.DJRC said:
A Sovereign state goes to war when it wants, why it wants and how it wants. What the UN says or thinks on the matter is irrelevent.
Ours is a democracy. We signed-up to the UN. TB ignored the law in addition to what his voters wanted and pressed ahead with the killing. He should be tried for his criminal actions. You dont live in a democracy, you live in a referential democracy and the 2 are very different things. Have you got any idea how many unpopular wars PMs have taken Britain into??? We all signed upto the League of Nations aswell and we all threw that in the bin when it didnt suit us. The UN is just the same. To be ignored when convenient, to be used when it is convenient. A Sovereign State is subservient to no higher authority, that is the whole point of the Sovereign bit. Once you accept you are accountable to a higher authority then you are no longer Sovereign and in the matter of war the highest authority anybody in Britain is accountable to is HMQ. For Blair or any other PM to go on trial for their actions with regards to the country being at war it would need to be authorised by the Queen, and for them to be put on trial under the auspices of the UN it would need for her to delegate that authority to the UN.
At such a time of that happening, it would be a singularly unique event in British history and it would cause a constitutional crisis of clusterf
k proportions. We get agitated enough at the transfer of Sovereign powers for what, relative to this, are very minor issues.If you lived in Switzerland however, then yes you could use the Direct Democracy system they have in order to bring a motion that the PM be brought up on charges before the highest court in the land, so long as you gathered enough supports. But you dont, so you cant.
DJRC said:
There is no law! What do you not understand here? The PM decided to go to war. End of. Protests on the streets are irrelevent unless they are enough to force the PM from office, they didnt, ergo they are irrelevent. The country does not vote to go to war, that authority rests with the Executive.
You dont live in a democracy, you live in a referential democracy and the 2 are very different things. Have you got any idea how many unpopular wars PMs have taken Britain into??? We all signed upto the League of Nations aswell and we all threw that in the bin when it didnt suit us. The UN is just the same. To be ignored when convenient, to be used when it is convenient. A Sovereign State is subservient to no higher authority, that is the whole point of the Sovereign bit. Once you accept you are accountable to a higher authority then you are no longer Sovereign and in the matter of war the highest authority anybody in Britain is accountable to is HMQ. For Blair or any other PM to go on trial for their actions with regards to the country being at war it would need to be authorised by the Queen, and for them to be put on trial under the auspices of the UN it would need for her to delegate that authority to the UN.
At such a time of that happening, it would be a singularly unique event in British history and it would cause a constitutional crisis of clusterf
k proportions. We get agitated enough at the transfer of Sovereign powers for what, relative to this, are very minor issues.
If you lived in Switzerland however, then yes you could use the Direct Democracy system they have in order to bring a motion that the PM be brought up on charges before the highest court in the land, so long as you gathered enough supports. But you dont, so you cant.
You're right of course. Nice one. You dont live in a democracy, you live in a referential democracy and the 2 are very different things. Have you got any idea how many unpopular wars PMs have taken Britain into??? We all signed upto the League of Nations aswell and we all threw that in the bin when it didnt suit us. The UN is just the same. To be ignored when convenient, to be used when it is convenient. A Sovereign State is subservient to no higher authority, that is the whole point of the Sovereign bit. Once you accept you are accountable to a higher authority then you are no longer Sovereign and in the matter of war the highest authority anybody in Britain is accountable to is HMQ. For Blair or any other PM to go on trial for their actions with regards to the country being at war it would need to be authorised by the Queen, and for them to be put on trial under the auspices of the UN it would need for her to delegate that authority to the UN.
At such a time of that happening, it would be a singularly unique event in British history and it would cause a constitutional crisis of clusterf
k proportions. We get agitated enough at the transfer of Sovereign powers for what, relative to this, are very minor issues.If you lived in Switzerland however, then yes you could use the Direct Democracy system they have in order to bring a motion that the PM be brought up on charges before the highest court in the land, so long as you gathered enough supports. But you dont, so you cant.
/pats DJRC on the back.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




