A serious man
Author
Discussion

Crook

Original Poster:

8,118 posts

255 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
If you haven't but you think you might because you like the Coen's other films, don't, just don't.

Matt..

4,035 posts

220 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
I thought it was good smile Well worth a watch.

hesnotthemessiah

2,121 posts

235 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
Matt.. said:
I thought it was good smile Well worth a watch.
Me too!

Crook

Original Poster:

8,118 posts

255 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
Please can you explain why?
I found it boring and frustrating. I gave it the benefit of the doubt but gave up just before the 2nd Rabbi.
What am I missing? How is it funny watching a put- upon spineless man deal with his life falling apart?

hesnotthemessiah

2,121 posts

235 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
I enjoyed it's quirkiness. I enjoyed the insight into aspects of religion (as it's something I don't get). I especially enjoyed the rampant MILF, pot smoking neighbour but I wasn't a fan of the (now ubiquitous) sad ending (from the Coen Bros).

Although, I was not a fan of their remake of True Grit, it seemed to me they just did it just to give it a sad ending. (But I guess that's for another thread).

whoami

13,201 posts

271 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
hesnotthemessiah said:
Matt.. said:
I thought it was good smile Well worth a watch.
Me too!
And me.

vrsmxtb

2,003 posts

187 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
I'm with crook - LOVE the Coens 80s and 90s films, but the recent stuff has been patchy. I really wanted to like A serious Man, but the Jewish culture in-jokes were just too niche and it just seemed a really cruel joke on the character. Usually the comedy in their films outweighs the character's trials but the comedy was too specific to lighten the tone for me.

Crook

Original Poster:

8,118 posts

255 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
hesnotthemessiah said:
I enjoyed it's quirkiness. I enjoyed the insight into aspects of religion (as it's something I don't get). I especially enjoyed the rampant MILF, pot smoking neighbour but I wasn't a fan of the (now ubiquitous) sad ending (from the Coen Bros).

Although, I was not a fan of their remake of True Grit, it seemed to me they just did it just to give it a sad ending. (But I guess that's for another thread).
Now, I didn't feel it was particularly quirky at all really. Maybe I should have watched all of it but I just couldn't get that far which is unusual as I tend to watch a film to the end regardless but this film just tried my patience. I have no real interest in the Jewish faith or their religious idiosyncrasies. There were pointless resolvable situations which provided no humour, I don't know, it obviously wasn't for me.

Looking at reviews on IMDB it appears to be a 7-8 stars or a 1-2 stars by reviewer hence my interest in what you got from it.

GhostDriver

879 posts

223 months

Tuesday 4th September 2012
quotequote all
Love this film too.

Its not just entertainment. Its the way the characters interact with themselves. The results of their actions, their posturing, the philosophies of the Rabbis. Thought it was excellent.

If you want that 90s Coen Black humour type film, watch Burn After Reading. Thats a recent one, that's very much like the oldies.

Steamer

14,201 posts

244 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
I liked it. Not my favorite Coen Bros film - probably benefits from a second viewing.

vdubbin

2,176 posts

228 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
I didn't get it, but then again I'm just a goy…

RDMcG

20,920 posts

238 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
I thought it was superb. The scene where he is in the senior Rabbi's office was side splitting.

D1ngd0ng

1,014 posts

196 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
I also didn't get it but my brother who was sat next to me found it hilarious.

Did chuckle at the ending though. And the neighbor was spiffing.