sunny tyres on E46
sunny tyres on E46
Author
Discussion

rumple

Original Poster:

15,445 posts

182 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
As title, in this last week I've seen 2 330ci's with sunny tyres on and a unbadged ci with them on, in all 3 cases they were new all round, are these tyres any good ( I suspect not ) or is it just a sign of the times, the one 330 ci was the best example I've ever seen condition wise, made mine look rough, and mines nice, would those tyre be a deal breaker for you.....brand new sunnys all round.

illmonkey

19,842 posts

229 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
The general consensus is if the owner can't afford good rubber, the one thing that keeps you on the road, they won't spend money to get them fixed correctly.

rumple

Original Poster:

15,445 posts

182 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
illmonkey said:
The general consensus is if the owner can't afford good rubber, the one thing that keeps you on the road, they won't spend money to get them fixed correctly.
Now I was hoping you'd say, rumple these tyres cost 50 snots
a corner and are as good as ps2's being as I need new back tyres, seriously though, if you found an immaculate car with these tyres on, fitted by the dealer, would you walk.

illmonkey

19,842 posts

229 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
rumple said:
illmonkey said:
The general consensus is if the owner can't afford good rubber, the one thing that keeps you on the road, they won't spend money to get them fixed correctly.
Now I was hoping you'd say, rumple these tyres cost 50 ants a corner and are as good as ps2's being as I need new back tyres, seriously though, if you found an immaculate car with these tyres on, fitted by the dealer, would you walk.
No. I'd probably swap them soon after buying the car, and I'd haggle on the price knowing that.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
rumple said:
Now I was hoping you'd say, rumple these tyres cost 50 snots
a corner and are as good as ps2's being as I need new back tyres, seriously though, if you found an immaculate car with these tyres on, fitted by the dealer, would you walk.
If there was evidence of good service history then bad tyres wouldn't put me off. Loads of people properly care for their cars but haven't a clue about tyres. My mates Ford is in lovely condition and he really looks after it well, genuine Ford parts and serviced twice a year, all four tyres are different brands of used budgets though. Budgets on a BMW is asking for trouble IMO.

Edited by sparks_E39 on Monday 3rd September 10:36

CypherP

4,459 posts

223 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Its the difference between spending twice as much but having a better quality tyre that lasts longer, and going for the cheap option but affords limited grip and will likely wear quicker.

I guess the general cost of living has a knock on effect with some people's motoring, so I don't blame them for wanting to save a little money. I replaced all 4 on my 325 a couple of months back with Falkens 452s, and although I don't dispute they're a good tyre, they're just not as good as the Michelins that they replaced.

mike325112

1,074 posts

215 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
After a bad experience on some Hankooks that were dreadful, I'm never putting anything other than Pilot Sports on again.

mmm-five

12,400 posts

315 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Sometimes it's simply that the seller assumes a buyer would like to see new tyres on the car (of whatever make) rather than a pair of PS2s with the canvas showing wink

happychap

545 posts

179 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
My 325 had Sunnys on the rear, slightest bit of damp and the back end stepped out. Fortunetly picked up an urepairable punture in one of them, changed them for Falkerns 452, much improved.

mini1380cc

2,949 posts

202 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
My 330ci came with new Sunny tyres which I suspect were just put on by the dealer to help sell the car. They are shockingly bad in the wet, yet very grippy in the dry.

The only reason i haven't replaced them yet is I might change wheel and tyre at the same time.

rumple

Original Poster:

15,445 posts

182 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
mini1380cc said:
My 330ci came with new Sunny tyres which I suspect were just put on by the dealer to help sell the car. They are shockingly bad in the wet, yet very grippy in the dry.

The only reason i haven't replaced them yet is I might change wheel and tyre at the same time.
Interesting, I started this thread as a bit of cheap tyre bashing, but if they make the car arse end happy I'm seriously thinking of sticking a pair on the back, not to save money but to make the car more entertaining.

blippo1984

358 posts

177 months

Tuesday 4th September 2012
quotequote all
Generally then if a pilot sportbis 9 out of 10, where doesva Falken come? Purely on overall performance

mini1380cc

2,949 posts

202 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
I had the Falken 452's on my mr2 Turbo and they were very good for the price.

If the Sunny's were a 5/10 then the 452's would maybe be a 8/10.

dr_gn

16,992 posts

215 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
Just how reckless a driver do you have to be for cheap tyres to be a danger to yourself or other road users? I've had cheap tyres of my previous cars and my 330i Sport came with them on the rear. Never had the slightest issue. With DSC and ABS on the BMW it's even more unlikely to have an accident at any sane speed.

If someone is potentially going to have an accident under these circumstances (ie driving like a tt), they'll eventually have it irrespective of tyre manufacturer IMO.

mmm-five

12,400 posts

315 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
dr_gn said:
If someone is potentially going to have an accident under these circumstances (ie driving like a tt), they'll eventually have it irrespective of tyre manufacturer IMO.
What if it's someone else driving like a tt and you have to make an emergency manouevre to avoid the accident.

That 10-20% difference in response, braking performance, lateral grip, etc. might make the difference between bent car/bent body or not!

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
What if it's someone else driving like a tt and you have to make an emergency manouevre to avoid the accident.

That 10-20% difference in response, braking performance, lateral grip, etc. might make the difference between bent car/bent body or not!
This.

the_kato

411 posts

218 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
I put a pair of Sunny's on the back of my 320 sport a few months ago as I was a bit short of funds and needed a pair of tyres

In the dry they are fine but as soon as it rains the back of the car is all over the place. Will be changing them for proper tyres as soon as

dr_gn

16,992 posts

215 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
dr_gn said:
If someone is potentially going to have an accident under these circumstances (ie driving like a tt), they'll eventually have it irrespective of tyre manufacturer IMO.
What if it's someone else driving like a tt and you have to make an emergency manouevre to avoid the accident.

That 10-20% difference in response, braking performance, lateral grip, etc. might make the difference between bent car/bent body or not!
The only time I've ever lost control of a car in 25 years of driving was on sheet ice on a randomly untreated road in a housing estate. Only studded tyres would have prevented that. On the other hand some people I drive with seem to have 'moments' during almost every trip.

I tend to assume that all other road users are insane. I also have nightmares about a child running out from between parked cars...so I drive accordingly.

mmm-five

12,400 posts

315 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
dr_gn said:
The only time I've ever lost control of a car in 25 years of driving was on sheet ice on a randomly untreated road in a housing estate. Only studded tyres would have prevented that. On the other hand some people I drive with seem to have 'moments' during almost every trip.

I tend to assume that all other road users are insane. I also have nightmares about a child running out from between parked cars...so I drive accordingly.
It's not about LOSING control, it's about having the ability to MAINTAIN control when something unexpected happens or someone else losing control and coming into you.

You can watch out for children all you want, but if the driver next to you decides to share the exact same location in space-time, then I'd expect you to attempt to do something to avoid/mitigate the other driver's actions.

It's also about having the knowledge that you can drive safely within the speed limit, with good margin for error should the conditions change.

dr_gn

16,992 posts

215 months

Friday 7th September 2012
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
dr_gn said:
The only time I've ever lost control of a car in 25 years of driving was on sheet ice on a randomly untreated road in a housing estate. Only studded tyres would have prevented that. On the other hand some people I drive with seem to have 'moments' during almost every trip.

I tend to assume that all other road users are insane. I also have nightmares about a child running out from between parked cars...so I drive accordingly.
It's not about LOSING control, it's about having the ability to MAINTAIN control when something unexpected happens or someone else losing control and coming into you.

You can watch out for children all you want, but if the driver next to you decides to share the exact same location in space-time, then I'd expect you to attempt to do something to avoid/mitigate the other driver's actions.

It's also about having the knowledge that you can drive safely within the speed limit, with good margin for error should the conditions change.
I realise that, but surely it's simply about appreciating the limitations of your car (or whatever defines that, for example tyre quality). Taken to the extreme, you could say *only* drive a car with the very softest/most expensive tyre, or stay at home. Likewise don't drive unless your car has the agility of a Lotus 7.

There's no way I'd drive my E-type like I drive my 330i, or conversely like I'd drive my MGB. They are all different cars with very different limitations irrespective of tyre quality.

IMO it's simple a case of appreciating and driving to those new limitations as defined by less grippy tyres.