Ed Balls impersonates Nick Clegg
Ed Balls impersonates Nick Clegg
Author
Discussion

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
Apparently tomorrows Independent has an interview with Ed Balls - in similar vein to recent interviews Clegg and Cameron have had with the Guardian and Mail - in which he calls for the 'mansion tax' and declares he's planning a 'proper' wealth tax should Labour return to power.

Is this just Labour trying to make sure the Tory reshuffle doesn't take up the entire weeks political news or is Balls 'courting' Vince Cable in preperation for a possible Lib-Lab coalition? There's been rumblings of Cable taking over the Lib Dems when Clegg is finally forced out.

ETA: Balls is such a . That is all.

Gargamel

16,427 posts

292 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
Balls is single handedly trying to ensure the Labour remain un electable. Wealth Tax? Remember the labour party think wealth starts above £37,000

speedy_thrills

7,979 posts

274 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
Seems high if the thing someone on here about the median full time income being £24k is correct. £37k would put you in the top 10th percentile (though you need to be mindful of regional variation as in London the median salary is about the same level).

Labour will have quite a few Lib-Dem seats anyway if current polling is any indication of voting intention. Too late for them to hedge their bets now.

pacman1

7,324 posts

224 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
Guam said:
These guys just dont get it, no matter how much tax they raise to squander it will never be enough. They wont be happy until everyone but them is living in penury and the state gets back every pound you ever earned in your lifetime, the Tories are proving no different in this.

This kind of stuff is laughable, its time they seriously focused on the expenditure side of the equation.
Spot on. yes

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
Guam said:
This kind of stuff is laughable, its time they seriously focused on the expenditure side of the equation.
That's very unfair, and you know it.

The Labour party are VERY focused on the expenditure side frown

dave stew

1,502 posts

198 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
Although Labour is not that in favour here in PH land, there is still a vast UK demographic that will always vote for them.

There are the traditional, manual job (or no job) voters, but don't forget the educated Guardian brigade who dominate the public sector.

Let's face it - after Brown's dreadful last year of incompetence in office, the expectation was that the Conservatives would have walked it. They didn't.

Don't think that Labour won't get back in. It's a very real possibility.

Be afraid, be very afraid.

Or open your subscription Guardian and cheer!

Digga

48,636 posts

314 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
dave stew said:
Although Labour is not that in favour here in PH land, there is still a vast UK demographic that will always vote for them.
That's true, but more of the country is blue and Labour only really succeeded after extensive gerrymandering.

Anyway, that old tax-n-spend chestnut is so last century. The Eeyorezone are about to demonstrate why.

RYH64E

7,960 posts

275 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
Gargamel said:
Balls is single handedly trying to ensure the Labour remain un electable. Wealth Tax? Remember the labour party think wealth starts above £37,000
I think that they will distinguish between wealth and income, another attack on those prudent folks who have savings and/or assets.

mattviatura

2,996 posts

231 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
dave stew said:
Although Labour is not that in favour here in PH land, there is still a vast UK demographic that will always vote for them.

There are the traditional, manual job (or no job) voters, but don't forget the educated Guardian brigade who dominate the public sector.

Let's face it - after Brown's dreadful last year of incompetence in office, the expectation was that the Conservatives would have walked it. They didn't.

Don't think that Labour won't get back in. It's a very real possibility.
I would say it's a cert.

Put simply the left shouts louder, unless the tories can come up with something along the lines of the Saatchi 'Labour isn't working' campaign they've no chance.

Having said that the Conservative party isn't exactly appealing anymore.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
Democracy will always result in the masses voting for the party that promises them the most (PH loves its child benefit and the Olympics, it's not just chav who love a freebie).

The only force that's ever going to constrain state spending is the bond market and while we are buying our own bonds that won't even act as a brake.

catso

16,576 posts

298 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
Balls is a cock...

crankedup

25,764 posts

274 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
mattviatura said:
dave stew said:
Although Labour is not that in favour here in PH land, there is still a vast UK demographic that will always vote for them.

There are the traditional, manual job (or no job) voters, but don't forget the educated Guardian brigade who dominate the public sector.

Let's face it - after Brown's dreadful last year of incompetence in office, the expectation was that the Conservatives would have walked it. They didn't.

Don't think that Labour won't get back in. It's a very real possibility.
I would say it's a cert.

Put simply the left shouts louder, unless the tories can come up with something along the lines of the Saatchi 'Labour isn't working' campaign they've no chance.

Having said that the Conservative party isn't exactly appealing anymore.
Don't see a brilliant advertising slogan cutting the mustard, most of the Electorate are to clued up to be sucked into that. Also the risk of insulting the Electorates intellect is high. Remember the battle ground is middle England, those at the top will remain loyal to Conservatives and those at other end to Labour (broadly). As middle England are being hammered right now its difficult to see how the Tories can turn around another term in Office.

turbobloke

117,583 posts

291 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
crankedup said:
most of the Electorate are too clued up
If they were, there would never be another Labour government.

As there will never be a LibDem government no more needs to be said.

speedy_thrills

7,979 posts

274 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
The Conservatives still have time on their side but not on any model of reduced spending or taxation. It was a pipe dream anyway when you looked at the figures.

An aggressive but temporary economic development plan with a “make the rich pay” theme might just sneak them past on reduced unemployment and an artificial bump in lower middle and professional working class prosperity (essentially where they really need to win votes). Perhaps one of the first could be housing projects as housing debt is often singled out as quite a drag on the economy.

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
RYH64E said:
I think that they will distinguish between wealth and income, another attack on those prudent folks who have savings and/or assets.
Yes I think that's the idea. Despite spending weeks banging on about the 50p tax rate, Labour are actually shifting to favouring taxing wealth rather than income. Thats why they - like the Lib Dems - want a flat levy on expensive properties because unlike your earnings, you can't hide your house. Quite how they'd administer such a thing I'm not sure. For instance who gets to decide if its worth £2million or not? You can bring three different estate agents round and receive three different opinions.

Digga said:
That's true, but more of the country is blue and Labour only really succeeded after extensive gerrymandering.
Arguing whether the country is more blue/red is pointless because I think the most important demographic are the 40 odd percent who don't vote at election time. A huge chunk of voters believe it doesn't matter who they vote for because they're all the same, they don't know or care about politics and don't believe Government impacts anything anyway. The 2010 results do show that almost 64% of people who voted, didn't vote for the Conservatives. Almost 55% of voters voted for a left-wing party. Aside from 2005, recent elections seem to show you need 40% or more of the popular vote to win a majority.

RYH64E

7,960 posts

275 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
RYH64E said:
I think that they will distinguish between wealth and income, another attack on those prudent folks who have savings and/or assets.
Yes I think that's the idea. Despite spending weeks banging on about the 50p tax rate, Labour are actually shifting to favouring taxing wealth rather than income. Thats why they - like the Lib Dems - want a flat levy on expensive properties because unlike your earnings, you can't hide your house. Quite how they'd administer such a thing I'm not sure. For instance who gets to decide if its worth £2million or not? You can bring three different estate agents round and receive three different opinions.
I can't see that working out well for them, if some old dear is living in an expensive house but has no liquid assets how is she going to afford the tax? Many people have assets but no cash, and it isn't always easy or cheap to sell up.

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
RYH64E said:
I can't see that working out well for them, if some old dear is living in an expensive house but has no liquid assets how is she going to afford the tax? Many people have assets but no cash, and it isn't always easy or cheap to sell up.
It'd be even harder to sell up if that house attracted a major levy. Who would want to buy it?

Over the last decade or so, property has appreciated in value at breakneck speed, it's entirely reasonable to assume someone may have moved in/inherited the home when it was worth far less. I think this is what put the brakes on the 'mansion tax' in the first place. This was put to Jacqui Smith in a TV interview recently and she replied she doubts theres many little old ladies in expensive homes who couldnt afford to pay a wealth tax.

Surely whether they can afford it or not is beside the point? That mentality sounds like the Government should take everything you don't need.

RYH64E

7,960 posts

275 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
It'd be even harder to sell up if that house attracted a major levy. Who would want to buy it?

Over the last decade or so, property has appreciated in value at breakneck speed, it's entirely reasonable to assume someone may have moved in/inherited the home when it was worth far less. I think this is what put the brakes on the 'mansion tax' in the first place. This was put to Jacqui Smith in a TV interview recently and she replied she doubts theres many little old ladies in expensive homes who couldnt afford to pay a wealth tax.

Surely whether they can afford it or not is beside the point? That mentality sounds like the Government should take everything you don't need.
The policy is to redistribute wealth from hard working, prudent, responsible citizens to the feckless, irresponsible layabouts - who unfortunately get a vote and form a large part of the Labour core vote. How about removing the right to vote from the long term unemployed? That should see Labour out of power for the forseeable future.

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Thursday 6th September 2012
quotequote all
RYH64E said:
The policy is to redistribute wealth from hard working, prudent, responsible citizens to the feckless, irresponsible layabouts - who unfortunately get a vote and form a large part of the Labour core vote. How about removing the right to vote from the long term unemployed? That should see Labour out of power for the forseeable future.
I think you may run into some constitutional and democratic principle issues with that one my friend. wink

I disagree though, what erks me about certain peoples support for 'the rich to pay more' is knowledge that no matter how much the Government takes from the rich, they won't give any of it to me. So why should I care? Labour want the rich to pay down the deficit, which would be fine if the deficit wasn't a year-on-year issue. The countries billionaires could pay the deficit off this year - but what about next year when we spend it all again?