another annoying "what car" thread
another annoying "what car" thread
Author
Discussion

arollingstone

Original Poster:

107 posts

175 months

Saturday 8th September 2012
quotequote all
been chatting with my father today and both my parents need new cars. current cars are a Jag x-type, and a BMW 3 series touring, and I've been told my suggestions aren't helpful frown so we need the help of the PH masses biggrin

Car 1, for my father - must be a comfortable GT car, sporty, capable of easily doing 30K a year (and therefore not too horrendous on fuel) budget = £10,000

Car 2, for my mother - must be 4 wheel drive, must be able to tow a horse trailer, ideally diesel, ideally SUV, take dogs, 40MPG+, budget = £10,000

Both cars have to be good marques i.e. no dacia dusters please.

couple of things they both said, they don't want anything Asian, unless is a Mitsubishi shogun sort for the mother. Father has decided he defiantly does not want a porsche.

Also, the budgets have to stay fairly even, 10k a piece, rather than say 15k for one, 5k for the other if you see what i mean.

All suggestions appreciated!

AndyT77

1,755 posts

189 months

Saturday 8th September 2012
quotequote all
What were your suggestions?

Papa Hotel

12,760 posts

209 months

Saturday 8th September 2012
quotequote all
Discovery and, err... a 3 Series Touring.

Zwolf

25,867 posts

233 months

Saturday 8th September 2012
quotequote all
arollingstone said:
Car 1, for my father - must be a comfortable GT car, sporty, capable of easily doing 30K a year (and therefore not too horrendous on fuel) budget = £10,000
2006 BMW 330d SE with 97k miles.



Private seller, £9,995

arollingstone said:
Car 2, for my mother - must be 4 wheel drive, must be able to tow a horse trailer, ideally diesel, ideally SUV, take dogs, 40MPG+, budget = £10,000
2004 Volvo XC90 D5 SE with 73k miles.



Private seller, £9,800

The latter won't average 40mpg+, but at 30k mpa the former will exceed it sufficiently without much trouble. As "not too horrendous" to me is ~30mpg, then the overall fuel bill for both of them should be acceptable.

Chilliman

12,354 posts

188 months

Saturday 8th September 2012
quotequote all
Land/Range Rover and an XJR (post 2004)