Planet Oceans on a small wrist: 37.5mm vs 42mm
Planet Oceans on a small wrist: 37.5mm vs 42mm
Author
Discussion

MG-FIDO

Original Poster:

454 posts

268 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all

Dear All,

I've been a big fan of Omegas since being gifted my father's Seamaster as my 18th birthday present back in 2004.






Despite loving the watch and wearing it as much as possible, I've long lusted after a diver. After considering a range from Sea-Dwellers, through to vintage Omega 300s I'm leaning towards looking for a Planet Ocean when I (hopefully) graduate from 9 years of University next year.

So, having spent too much time over summer looking at wrist shots and weighing up the 2500 vs 8500 debate I thought I'd go to the local dealers and see whether either of them would fit my puny 6.5" wrist and here's the evidence:

First the 42mm PO 8500-




And then out of desperation, the "ladies'" version, the 37.5mm PO-





As you might expect, after years wearing my 33-34mm watch, even the 37.5mm PO felt like a large watch and I was shocked at the heft of the 42mm; it really did look like a big lump of admittedly very attractive metal when I put it on.

My girlfriend felt the 42mm was too big, and there does seem to be a little overhang looking at the picture, whether this was how I'd draped the watch over my wrist or not I don't know, but it certainly looked far bigger on me than I'd expected at first.

Anyway, your opinions would be much appreciated. I'm not too worried about going for the "ladies'" option, but I've known a few people regret going for smaller sizes in the past and had also quite fancied the original 2500 PO (I know I should try to find one to try on) and they don't come in the 37.5mm size.

Thanks in advance!

bennyboydurham

1,617 posts

205 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
The PO is a chunky watch. It's never going to blend into your wrist like an older classic watch or Patek Phillippe. It's definitely a 'statement' watch, although not as much as something like a SeaDweller or a Breitling Bentley, which really does feel like walking around with Big Ben on your wrist.

I'd go for the bigger one. It certainly doesn't look daft from the pics and I wear the older Quantum of Solace special edition model and after the first few hours of wearing it I could barely feel it was on. It's amazing how quickly you get used to wearing a big watch. Either way, it's a good choice and you'll be very happy with it. It's all the watch you'll ever need.

Jaged

3,598 posts

225 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
I have 46 PO 8500 with the display back.

It is big and heavy that is it's style, at first I thought it was going to be too big but after a few months of wearing it I have just got so used to it.

I also have a 46 SuperOcean Heritage which is not quite as heavy and I hardly notice that in comparison.

So much so I swap wrists often on both, just to "feel" them more!

A friend of mine who wears a Rolex Sub, loves the PO and often comments about how good it looks.
He never mentions how big it is though!

So my advice is go big only IF you like the look as you will get used to its weight.


alfaman

6,416 posts

265 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
The 42mm does look big on you TBH - the smaller one looks more balanced and doesn't look as if you are wearing your dads watch smile

My wrists are similar size to yours - 42mm 'chunky' style watches are usually too big for my wrists - and the weight starts to grate after a while (just my 2p worth)

DukeDickson

5,079 posts

244 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
Personally I think the 42 looks fine & the ladies version would be a mistake. A diver should look/be more chunky on the wrist than an older, more dressy thing. However, at the same time, you should go with what you're comfortable with.

Does it need to be an Omega & a PO? Almost seems to me that you might be better served with something else - an older Submariner/Sea Dweller at that price point, a different Omega or alternative.


Tony Starks

2,411 posts

243 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
I have a slightly bigger wrist than you (by about 5mm lol) and have a 47mm Getat homage and a 50mm Casio trek and they fit and feel really well, no-ones ever point and said they look to big. As has been said, a few hours of wearing and you for get they're on.

raptor600

1,356 posts

177 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
If I were you get the smaller one definitely. It fits you better, as simple as that.

The big one is too big and you are right, looks like it "hangs over" your wrist.

The small one looks awesome though. smile

SSBB

698 posts

187 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
MG-FIDO said:
First the 42mm PO 8500-




Thanks in advance!
Well, from a distance the 42mm doesn't look half bad. It's big yeah, but not excessive. However in the close up it just looks massive. Possibly because of the camera angle? Bordeline I would say, but big watches are the fashion these days.

P.S. 9 years in Uni! What the heck were you studying?!

ROB_GTR

1,819 posts

256 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
If thats what your heart is set on go for the smaller 'ladies' version as the mens 'full size' looks way too big.
Have you ever looked at the speedmaster reduced size? very nice looking and much more slim than the PO and would suite your wrist much better.

It would save you a few quid too!

Pic of mine....

Omega speedy reduced size



Hoofy

80,186 posts

313 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
The 42mm one does look too big as the lugs hang over your wrists. One trick you could try is to wear it looser so it flops about a lot more so you can't see how big it is compared to your wrist without holding it in place. This might be uncomfortable to wear, though, if you intend to wear it while doing some kind of active sport. The ladies one sits much better BUT if you intend to sell it, I think the resale value will be more than proportionally less, IYSWIM!

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
Just to throw in an alternative, have you looked at Ball watches? They may not have the Omega name on the dial or the 8500 movement inside but they do make very well made, solid diver style watches in a 40mm case size, the lugs are also curved to such an extent that they make a great fit around the wrist - here's a shot of my old Hydrocarbon (7 1/4" wrist)



Or how about the older 2500 version of the PO? Same case diameter as the 8500 but not as tall, I tried one on yonks back and it didn't look or feel like a 42mm watch.

ETA that I'd choose the 42mm over the ladies version, the ladies watch looks like what it is smile


Edited by CardShark on Sunday 9th September 12:20

MG-FIDO

Original Poster:

454 posts

268 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies guys! It seems the responses are as torn as I am.

I'm not bothered about the weight of the watch, but i do think the 42 looks a fraction too big, shame they don't make a 40mm! I think I'll have to have another look at some point nearer the time and I'd certainly like to see if the lower profile 2500 looked any better (not sure it will though as it seems the lug to lug length is my problem).

As for considering other options, I really admire older rolexes, but very much like the looks of the PO and the slightly less flashy Omega image. I know they're not always popular here, but I also quite liked the Christopher Ward C60, I just think the PO's more likely to be something I'd enjoy wearing long term. As for the Speedmaster suggestion, great shout and something I'd like to consider one day, but I've been bitten by the diver bug, it's just a case of making sure I find the right one!

Oh an SSBB- I've been studying medicine, I just went a very long way around it involving a degree in Economic History and a "pre-med" year to make up for not having A level Chemistry.

Hoofy

80,186 posts

313 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
Try a Rolex Explorer 1 or a simple Oyster.

SlimJim16v

8,235 posts

174 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
The 42mm looks too big on you, the 37.5mm looks OK. I am considering this option myself, as I also have a 6.5" wrist. I did try the 36mm and 42mm Seamaster, one too big the other too small.

Forget all those people who say they have a '5" wrist and wear 60mm watches', they don't see all the people sniggering behind their backs.

raptor600

1,356 posts

177 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
MG-FIDO said:
Thanks for the replies guys! It seems the responses are as torn as I am.
The smaller one looks great! It is a no brainer - just get it bought! wink

SlimJim16v

8,235 posts

174 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
I haven't seen the small one, but some have said it's out of proportion? It's quite thick but smaller.

I have a midsize Seiko diver at 37mm wide by 15mm fat, but I think it looks OK. Maybe people are laughing at me behind my back wink

jonny70

1,280 posts

189 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
I would get the Older Planet Ocean model , as its thinner , the new model is too thick. I have a 6.5 inch wrist and the old model PO wears fine.

tcant

308 posts

242 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
The first photo of the 42mm looks too big for you but the second photo of the same watch looks OK. It's probably the close up which distorts its true size. You will soon get used to the bigger size and I think you will regret buying the 37.5mm and the fact that it is a womans watch will always play on your mind!

Just because a watch is 42mm don't let it put you off, it is all down to the bezel size and the depth of the lugs. Each one will wear differently on you. I have small wrists and I have a bezel less 40mm watch which looks massive on me, I also have a 45mm diver with wide bezel and short lugs which looks perfect. Try some other models for size, you will know when you get the right one.

nitsypee

154 posts

235 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
I think the smaller one looks a much better fit on you - and I think that's the most important thing. I'll bet when you wore it you didn't think "oh, that looks too small".

If they named it a "mid-size" rather than a "ladies'", then it wouldn't be a problem! (I wear a 1990s men's Breitling Colt, with a 38mm diameter. Funny how sizes have ballooned since then.)

Tiggsy

10,261 posts

283 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Its not the wrist...it's the body. I have skinny wrists but on a large frame...I can wear anything.

If your dinky (just like your wrist!) it will look to big....If you're 6ft5, 16st and ripped you could wear a wall clock on a 5" wrist and get away with it.