Seadweller, no box, no papers what kind of price?
Seadweller, no box, no papers what kind of price?
Author
Discussion

ellroy

Original Poster:

7,858 posts

256 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
The title says it all. I've seen one for sale in York at £3750 and was wondering if that's the right kind of money. Not sure of the vintage, but looks pretty much unmarked at first glance.

Slobberchops

3,641 posts

232 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
What ?

BrabusMog

21,824 posts

217 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
A model/make might help smile

ellroy

Original Poster:

7,858 posts

256 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
Sorry chaps, blasted iPhone, Seadweller.

Slobberchops

3,641 posts

232 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
Sounds dear but I am no expert? Is it a reputable seller?

daveenty

2,385 posts

241 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
Seems dear to me as well,especially with no box or papers.

If it's the 16600 then £3,500 maximum I'd have thought, with full set.

digger_R

1,809 posts

237 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
For an extra few hundred notes you should be able to get one with box and papers from a private sale. IMO the saving isn't significant enough to buy without in this case.

ellroy

Original Poster:

7,858 posts

256 months

Sunday 9th September 2012
quotequote all
You're all echoing what I thought.

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
No box no papers, like buying a car without a V5 for me. Wouldnt touch a quality watch without purchase information .

andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
daveenty said:
If it's the 16600 then £3,500 maximum I'd have thought, with full set.
A full set 16600 in good condition from a dealer - Add £500 to £1,000 to that.

AlexWF

127 posts

173 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
sone said:
No box no papers, like buying a car without a V5 for me. Wouldnt touch a quality watch without purchase information .
No box or papers has an effect on the value of a pre-owned watch, naturally, but is not the same as a car without a V5.

As watches are no "registered" like cars, all the papers would tell you is the name of the dealer who sold it new and on what date. With a Rolex though the serial number tells you when the watch was produced so you can age it pretty accurately anyway.

So the papers will cost you, and sit in the box.

Plus, when it comes to re-sale, anyone that tells you they won't buy it due to lack of papers is trying to buy it cheap off you. You will have bought it at a lower price, and will sell at a lower price but it's all relative.

Finally, if you buy a watch with no papers from a reputable dealer they will provide you some sort of valuation/certification to go with it.

andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
AlexWF said:
sone said:
No box no papers, like buying a car without a V5 for me. Wouldnt touch a quality watch without purchase information .
No box or papers has an effect on the value of a pre-owned watch, naturally, but is not the same as a car without a V5.

As watches are no "registered" like cars, all the papers would tell you is the name of the dealer who sold it new and on what date. With a Rolex though the serial number tells you when the watch was produced so you can age it pretty accurately anyway.

So the papers will cost you, and sit in the box.

Plus, when it comes to re-sale, anyone that tells you they won't buy it due to lack of papers is trying to buy it cheap off you. You will have bought it at a lower price, and will sell at a lower price but it's all relative.

Finally, if you buy a watch with no papers from a reputable dealer they will provide you some sort of valuation/certification to go with it.
No box & papers is the norm for older / vintage watches. Christ knows how much more my 1665 Sea Dweller would be worth with it's original box & papers + £1k, + £2k, + more?

AlexWF

127 posts

173 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
andy tims said:
AlexWF said:
sone said:
No box no papers, like buying a car without a V5 for me. Wouldnt touch a quality watch without purchase information .
No box or papers has an effect on the value of a pre-owned watch, naturally, but is not the same as a car without a V5.

As watches are no "registered" like cars, all the papers would tell you is the name of the dealer who sold it new and on what date. With a Rolex though the serial number tells you when the watch was produced so you can age it pretty accurately anyway.

So the papers will cost you, and sit in the box.

Plus, when it comes to re-sale, anyone that tells you they won't buy it due to lack of papers is trying to buy it cheap off you. You will have bought it at a lower price, and will sell at a lower price but it's all relative.

Finally, if you buy a watch with no papers from a reputable dealer they will provide you some sort of valuation/certification to go with it.
No box & papers is the norm for older / vintage watches. Christ knows how much more my 1665 Sea Dweller would be worth with it's original box & papers + £1k, + £2k, + more?
Exactly. Ultimately, there is no right or wrong answer here in terms of whether a watch should be bought with box and papers or not. It really comes down to the budget and attitude of the buyer. Plus of course some due diligence of the seller.

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
I suppose what I should have said with regard papers and boxes is that for me I wouldn't buy without them. Realistically it's a personal thing that I like to have everything in place. The V5 comment was obviously not the right sort of comparison.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
It really depends on the piece. The last Rolex that I bought came without box or papers of any sort and I didnt pay any less for it.

When watches reach a certain age their having the correct and original box and papers becomes less and less likely. For many models now Id say that having a full set adds to their value considerably (with the usual value being for a bare watch), but these watches are the exception, rather than the norm.

Vvroom

1,170 posts

221 months

Monday 10th September 2012
quotequote all
AlexWF makes a good point that the papers just sit in the box, and the box, if mine are anything to go by, sits in the safe. Are they important? To me: yes. But on an older watch, condition is more important. On a newer watch, I'd have serious reservations about how well it has been looked after if the previous owner hadn't bothered to keep his eye on the box and papers.

Tino

1,948 posts

314 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Vvroom said:
AlexWF makes a good point that the papers just sit in the box, and the box, if mine are anything to go by, sits in the safe. Are they important? To me: yes. But on an older watch, condition is more important. On a newer watch, I'd have serious reservations about how well it has been looked after if the previous owner hadn't bothered to keep his eye on the box and papers.
But surely as the watch becomes older, the value of the box/papers would also increase, so a £400 difference now may make a much larger difference in the future.
Granted, it won't cause an issue selling it, as people will happily save thousands, but at this stage, the price difference is too small to consider without.

Vvroom

1,170 posts

221 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Tino said:
... but at this stage, the price difference is too small to consider without.
I'd agree at the price OP quoted.

But if the watch was c£3k now without B+P and it looked in good shape, I think I would probably go for it. Yes, its resale value in 10yrs time might be compromised, but you've not paid full whack for it to begin with. Also, it's a superb watch that will give many years of pleasure: may be tough to part with and so resale may never come into it.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
The correct period box is seldom difficult to find, nor is it expensive. 'Papers' can easily be substituted with a service guarantee.

Id prefer original box and papers, but it isnt as important as people would have you believe and a lot of 'full set' watches were a bare watch not too long ago, after all.

huytonman

341 posts

225 months

Friday 14th September 2012
quotequote all
3k maximum but if it needs a service (which will cost you £400'ish but may be more now from Rolex) I would'nt be jumping to buy this when there are others out there for £3.5-£4k with papers. I've happily bought rolex's without papers, especially the divers which in older models would have been worn by guys who didnt think about things like boxes and papers (my 1665 has no papers and i didnt expect it to have) but as in all cases just make certain that its what it pertains to be...fakes fakes fakes everywhere!