E39 Head gasket replacement or new engine?
Discussion
The good news. I'm fortunate enough to have been given an E39 528 for nowt. The bad news. It's showing all the symptoms of a head gasket failure.
I've been reading around and it seems like there is a very high chance that the head is cracked. It seems to be a more common failure than the gasket itself. Although I intend to any repair work myself, sorting out a cracked head would obviously involve a machine shop. In fact even if the head wasn't cracked it may need a skim. All this is leading me to wonder if it's worth me just getting a complete engine instead. In some ways it seems an easier job and might actually work out cheaper.
Am I talking sense?
Assuming it's new engine time, are there any 2.8 engines I need to avoid? I know about Nikasil but more worried about any incompatibilities from other models. It's a 1997 528 auto.
I've been reading around and it seems like there is a very high chance that the head is cracked. It seems to be a more common failure than the gasket itself. Although I intend to any repair work myself, sorting out a cracked head would obviously involve a machine shop. In fact even if the head wasn't cracked it may need a skim. All this is leading me to wonder if it's worth me just getting a complete engine instead. In some ways it seems an easier job and might actually work out cheaper.
Am I talking sense?
Assuming it's new engine time, are there any 2.8 engines I need to avoid? I know about Nikasil but more worried about any incompatibilities from other models. It's a 1997 528 auto.
Yep, it seems like I'd have to be quite lucky to avoid spending a bit of cash on the head itself and of course a gasket kit cost a bit as well.
Have an option on a bare engine (pretty much just block and head by the sound of it) for £200. It's done some miles but have seen a video (for what that's worth! ) of it running and it sounds like it sounds sweet enough. Seems like a no brainer at the moment but I am tempted to pay a little more for a guaranteed engine.
Have an option on a bare engine (pretty much just block and head by the sound of it) for £200. It's done some miles but have seen a video (for what that's worth! ) of it running and it sounds like it sounds sweet enough. Seems like a no brainer at the moment but I am tempted to pay a little more for a guaranteed engine.
Ok, I think decision is more or less made on this one though I'm going to wait until I've actually seen the car at the weekend before purchasing another engine. Partly because I'd like to be certain there aren't any other major expenses before I get in deep.
Question though. This is a 1997 528 auto. I guess that means single Vanos? Does that mean I need to source a replacement engine from any pre 99 328, 528, 728 or Z3 or is there more to it than that?
I know the current engine has had steel liners done but obviously if I put in a new engine I need to check that one too.
Question though. This is a 1997 528 auto. I guess that means single Vanos? Does that mean I need to source a replacement engine from any pre 99 328, 528, 728 or Z3 or is there more to it than that?
I know the current engine has had steel liners done but obviously if I put in a new engine I need to check that one too.
It depends what it's doing. Does it automatically start to overheat after a set period of driving, or just do it now and then? Is it really boiling its tits off and leaking steamy coolant everywhere? These engines use plastic impeller water pumps and if it's still on the original (quite likely) and it's shagged, that's your overheating issue.
M52 heads are quite prone to cracking and they're not really repairable. You can buy a single vanos 2.8 engine for not a lot these days - £250 should get one - and you won't be getting a used head, bolts, gasket and a precautionary head skim for much less. There is also a danger of the threads in the block pulling out on the second of the two 90 degree turns.
Are you going to smoke this around yourself or punt it on when fixed? I assume it's the former as a 1997 528i isn't worth a lot now. If that's the case, I'd look at the water pump, drill a couple of holes in the thermostat outer ring and pour a bottle of K Seal down the top hose. It's far from a permanent solution but it may well persuade the car to behave itself, and all for a lot less $$$$ and aggro than swapping engines.
M52 heads are quite prone to cracking and they're not really repairable. You can buy a single vanos 2.8 engine for not a lot these days - £250 should get one - and you won't be getting a used head, bolts, gasket and a precautionary head skim for much less. There is also a danger of the threads in the block pulling out on the second of the two 90 degree turns.
Are you going to smoke this around yourself or punt it on when fixed? I assume it's the former as a 1997 528i isn't worth a lot now. If that's the case, I'd look at the water pump, drill a couple of holes in the thermostat outer ring and pour a bottle of K Seal down the top hose. It's far from a permanent solution but it may well persuade the car to behave itself, and all for a lot less $$$$ and aggro than swapping engines.
replacement engine time, buy a scrapper with a good engine I.e mot failure and swap it over, the thing is with the headgasket is, the alloy block can sink from around the steel liners, also the headbolt threads are prone to stripping on retightening, a steel block 325 would do it if you really fancied building one, depending on the age of the E39, {important because of the position of the cranksensor, simplest is to swap lumps, replace the waterpump whilst your at it.
iSore said:
It depends what it's doing. Does it automatically start to overheat after a set period of driving, or just do it now and then? Is it really boiling its tits off and leaking steamy coolant everywhere? These engines use plastic impeller water pumps and if it's still on the original (quite likely) and it's shagged, that's your overheating issue.
M52 heads are quite prone to cracking and they're not really repairable. You can buy a single vanos 2.8 engine for not a lot these days - £250 should get one - and you won't be getting a used head, bolts, gasket and a precautionary head skim for much less. There is also a danger of the threads in the block pulling out on the second of the two 90 degree turns.
Are you going to smoke this around yourself or punt it on when fixed? I assume it's the former as a 1997 528i isn't worth a lot now. If that's the case, I'd look at the water pump, drill a couple of holes in the thermostat outer ring and pour a bottle of K Seal down the top hose. It's far from a permanent solution but it may well persuade the car to behave itself, and all for a lot less $$$$ and aggro than swapping engines.
Cheers for such a comprehensive reply. The car is my father's. He's had it from new. I don't know the full story but from what I gather, the car overheated. He pulled over, coolant tank boiling away good and proper. He let it all cool off, topped things up and tried to get the car a couple of miles home. It overheated again and before he could safely pull over it also flashed up low oil pressure light briefly. He said the engine was a bit tickety at idle but sounded fine when moving. Sounds like the overheating has cooked the head gasket good and proper. Oil leaked into water or cylinders or sludged up the oil enough that top end was a bit starved would be my guess. If it was just a water issue, I'd try K-seal but it sounds like I'd be wasting my time. Sound properly goosed to me, but interested to know if anybody thinks differently. Possibly worth a shot at £8 a bottle. M52 heads are quite prone to cracking and they're not really repairable. You can buy a single vanos 2.8 engine for not a lot these days - £250 should get one - and you won't be getting a used head, bolts, gasket and a precautionary head skim for much less. There is also a danger of the threads in the block pulling out on the second of the two 90 degree turns.
Are you going to smoke this around yourself or punt it on when fixed? I assume it's the former as a 1997 528i isn't worth a lot now. If that's the case, I'd look at the water pump, drill a couple of holes in the thermostat outer ring and pour a bottle of K Seal down the top hose. It's far from a permanent solution but it may well persuade the car to behave itself, and all for a lot less $$$$ and aggro than swapping engines.
On that subject though I would want to give the cooling system a thorough going over. Chances are that the overheating was caused by dodgy water pump. I'd replace that regardless but worth checking there is nothing else playing up.
All the horror stories of head gasket replacements on these are really steering me down the total engine swap route. I have a decent workshop at my disposal and should have plenty of time to do it.
In terms of usage, I'll smoke it around as you say, probably sell my 330 as it's a bit tight on rear space in the back now I have a nipper. The 528 is a lovely car, been pampered all of it's life (still has full BMW service history at 15 years old!), and has a great spec. Best of all, I know it's history and how it's been driven and looked after. Would be a shame to let it die but I do know it probably needs a couple of rear bushes as well and a couple of rust bits sorted. The way I'm viewing this is that given the car is free, for £500 or so I could have a very tidy E39. Worst case, I break it and split the proceeds with my father.
TheEnd said:
You might need to swap sumps, but otherwise, you could take an engine from pretty much any 2.8 of that era.
Keep an eye out for the M52TU which is the double vanos which is the post 9/98 -ish engine, so no E46s, but e36, and early e38/39's will do.
Excellent, cheers. I figure that as long as the block and head are fundamentally the same, I can always swap bits around, the sump being a good example. Keep an eye out for the M52TU which is the double vanos which is the post 9/98 -ish engine, so no E46s, but e36, and early e38/39's will do.
helix402 said:
The heads and blocks on these are prone to warp if overheated.
Yep, that's a worry. As is stripping the threads when re-torquing the head down assuming the threads haven't been pulled already from overheating. Just sounds like a bog can of worms that could be neatly circumnavigating by a wholesale engine swap. It also means I get spare a nice straight six as garage decoration!Well, before you do anything, have a look at the water pump. If it's knackered, fit another one, refill with water (don't waste anti freeze just yet!) and see how it is. I always refill the cooling system via the top hose with it disconnected from the rad, take time to add water slowly and it's okay. It's worth also checkiung the thermostat in a pan of water on the stove - make sure it opens up okay. For the purposes of making it easier to bleed up, you can drill a 3mm hole in the outer ring, refitting the stat with the hole at the top.
You may be lucky!
You may be lucky!
iSore said:
Well, before you do anything, have a look at the water pump. If it's knackered, fit another one, refill with water (don't waste anti freeze just yet!) and see how it is. I always refill the cooling system via the top hose with it disconnected from the rad, take time to add water slowly and it's okay. It's worth also checkiung the thermostat in a pan of water on the stove - make sure it opens up okay. For the purposes of making it easier to bleed up, you can drill a 3mm hole in the outer ring, refitting the stat with the hole at the top.
You may be lucky!
Cheers, somehow missed this reply until now. Got the car on Saturday and managed to get a chance to give it a thorough going over last night. First impression is that I may be lucky. There is no obvious tell tale sign of head gasket failure. The coolant doesn't bubble with the engine running. There is no sign of oil in the header tank. No sign of mayo on the oil cap, though it was a bit grotty. No mayo on the dipstick.You may be lucky!
I topped up the oil (a bit low) and water (very low) and ran the car up to temperature. No dodgy smoke out the back, engine sounds pretty sweet. Low coolant warning is illuminated but I've been told that this has been dodgy for while, sounds like the sensor needs cleaning or replacing.
The engine settled at the middle of the gauge for a couple of minutes and then eventually started to creep up at which point I switched it off.
Plan now is to do a bit of remedial work to get the car mobile. I'm tempted to get some k-seal in there just in case but worried whether this can have any downsides?
I'll also replace the water pump and possibly the thermostat (like the sound of the drilled hole mod for bleeding) and check that the fan is working as it should.
After that, it's fingers crossed time. I could take it for a sniffer test but want to get it mobile first.
The only niggling doubt that I have is that my father reported an oil warning light (he thinks pressure) the first time it overheated and it sounded rattly at tick over. Doesn't sound great but fingers crossed.
I would avoid the K-Seal, having seen the mess inside an engine afterwards,
The rattlyness when it overheated could just have been the oil overheating.
Does the fan come on when it's creeping over temp? If its a viscous fan you should hear more noise from it and feel more of a draught from it as the coupling engages.
Check for leaks around the radiator and tanks.
The rattlyness when it overheated could just have been the oil overheating.
Does the fan come on when it's creeping over temp? If its a viscous fan you should hear more noise from it and feel more of a draught from it as the coupling engages.
Check for leaks around the radiator and tanks.
buggalugs said:
I would avoid the K-Seal, having seen the mess inside an engine afterwards,
The rattlyness when it overheated could just have been the oil overheating.
Does the fan come on when it's creeping over temp? If its a viscous fan you should hear more noise from it and feel more of a draught from it as the coupling engages.
Check for leaks around the radiator and tanks.
Cheers, I'll give k-seal a miss for now then.The rattlyness when it overheated could just have been the oil overheating.
Does the fan come on when it's creeping over temp? If its a viscous fan you should hear more noise from it and feel more of a draught from it as the coupling engages.
Check for leaks around the radiator and tanks.
No sign of leaks anywhere. Will check fan tomorrow.
Well, a brief update. I tried bleeding the car at lunchtime in case I had an air lock. I either got an awful lot of air out the system or else the engine is consuming water at a hell of a rate. I must have put 4 litres or so in.
The good news. The car ran rock steady in the middle of the temp gauge. I still think there may be air in the system though as the heater was a bit erratic for a while. I'm hoping that is all it is.
So, last thing, I've read quite a few methods for bleeding the system but most are a bit vague. Anybody got a decent guide?
The good news. The car ran rock steady in the middle of the temp gauge. I still think there may be air in the system though as the heater was a bit erratic for a while. I'm hoping that is all it is.
So, last thing, I've read quite a few methods for bleeding the system but most are a bit vague. Anybody got a decent guide?
I know the Euro-Spec M52s are aluminum blocks... But from my experience with them,...
Bleeding these cars is a real PITA at times, even using the bleeder screw at the expansion tank. We used to jack the front end up to force the air to the top but even then it wasn't foolproof. Oftentimes an airlock would cause overheating before we could even get the damned thermostat open to run the heater! 4L wouldn't shock me at all, you had an air leak, if the head gasket or head was sucking in that much coolant you'd have had smoke coming out the tailpipe like a steam locomotive OR you'd have hydro locked the engine or had a massive leak that I assure you, you'd have noticed!
Being a 97 and a single VANOS M52 you should not have an electronic thermostat so there goes that idea. As far as head gaskets go, I never saw one fail on an M52B28 but the S52 3.2s in the US M3s used to burn through the firing ring between 5 and 6 cylinders, but those are basically M52s anyhow. All of our single VANOS M52s were iron block engines though.
If the car does start to act up once it's fixed, Plan on replacing the long block if she's an aluminum block. Once these get really hot you have to remember... Aluminum block + aluminum head + steel head studs = really really bad. The differing rates of thermal expansion mean that the head studs strip out the now slightly warped block, so the fix is to time-sert the block, resurface the block and head and THEN hope that the damn thing holds.
Not worth the trouble when you can get a good long block cheap enough. But if it does act up a quick leak-down compression test will prove its sick.
Bleeding these cars is a real PITA at times, even using the bleeder screw at the expansion tank. We used to jack the front end up to force the air to the top but even then it wasn't foolproof. Oftentimes an airlock would cause overheating before we could even get the damned thermostat open to run the heater! 4L wouldn't shock me at all, you had an air leak, if the head gasket or head was sucking in that much coolant you'd have had smoke coming out the tailpipe like a steam locomotive OR you'd have hydro locked the engine or had a massive leak that I assure you, you'd have noticed!
Being a 97 and a single VANOS M52 you should not have an electronic thermostat so there goes that idea. As far as head gaskets go, I never saw one fail on an M52B28 but the S52 3.2s in the US M3s used to burn through the firing ring between 5 and 6 cylinders, but those are basically M52s anyhow. All of our single VANOS M52s were iron block engines though.
If the car does start to act up once it's fixed, Plan on replacing the long block if she's an aluminum block. Once these get really hot you have to remember... Aluminum block + aluminum head + steel head studs = really really bad. The differing rates of thermal expansion mean that the head studs strip out the now slightly warped block, so the fix is to time-sert the block, resurface the block and head and THEN hope that the damn thing holds.
Not worth the trouble when you can get a good long block cheap enough. But if it does act up a quick leak-down compression test will prove its sick.
Captain Cadillac said:
I know the Euro-Spec M52s are aluminum blocks... But from my experience with them,...
Bleeding these cars is a real PITA at times, even using the bleeder screw at the expansion tank. We used to jack the front end up to force the air to the top but even then it wasn't foolproof. Oftentimes an airlock would cause overheating before we could even get the damned thermostat open to run the heater! 4L wouldn't shock me at all, you had an air leak, if the head gasket or head was sucking in that much coolant you'd have had smoke coming out the tailpipe like a steam locomotive OR you'd have hydro locked the engine or had a massive leak that I assure you, you'd have noticed!
Being a 97 and a single VANOS M52 you should not have an electronic thermostat so there goes that idea. As far as head gaskets go, I never saw one fail on an M52B28 but the S52 3.2s in the US M3s used to burn through the firing ring between 5 and 6 cylinders, but those are basically M52s anyhow. All of our single VANOS M52s were iron block engines though.
If the car does start to act up once it's fixed, Plan on replacing the long block if she's an aluminum block. Once these get really hot you have to remember... Aluminum block + aluminum head + steel head studs = really really bad. The differing rates of thermal expansion mean that the head studs strip out the now slightly warped block, so the fix is to time-sert the block, resurface the block and head and THEN hope that the damn thing holds.
Not worth the trouble when you can get a good long block cheap enough. But if it does act up a quick leak-down compression test will prove its sick.
Huge thank you for such a detailed reply. Not had a chance to look at it further since my last post but should get some time on it over the weekend. Bleeding these cars is a real PITA at times, even using the bleeder screw at the expansion tank. We used to jack the front end up to force the air to the top but even then it wasn't foolproof. Oftentimes an airlock would cause overheating before we could even get the damned thermostat open to run the heater! 4L wouldn't shock me at all, you had an air leak, if the head gasket or head was sucking in that much coolant you'd have had smoke coming out the tailpipe like a steam locomotive OR you'd have hydro locked the engine or had a massive leak that I assure you, you'd have noticed!
Being a 97 and a single VANOS M52 you should not have an electronic thermostat so there goes that idea. As far as head gaskets go, I never saw one fail on an M52B28 but the S52 3.2s in the US M3s used to burn through the firing ring between 5 and 6 cylinders, but those are basically M52s anyhow. All of our single VANOS M52s were iron block engines though.
If the car does start to act up once it's fixed, Plan on replacing the long block if she's an aluminum block. Once these get really hot you have to remember... Aluminum block + aluminum head + steel head studs = really really bad. The differing rates of thermal expansion mean that the head studs strip out the now slightly warped block, so the fix is to time-sert the block, resurface the block and head and THEN hope that the damn thing holds.
Not worth the trouble when you can get a good long block cheap enough. But if it does act up a quick leak-down compression test will prove its sick.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



