What do I need to know when buying an E60/E61 520d?
What do I need to know when buying an E60/E61 520d?
Author
Discussion

mackay45

Original Poster:

832 posts

202 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Hi all

I am sure this has been done before but I am struggling to find anything, if there are threads to cover my queries then please feel free to just send a link!

My dad is looking to replace the family car - it will do around 20k miles p.a., trips to France etc. etc. so needs to be big but also pretty economical. I was originally thinking of a 320d Touring but after seeing one I think a 5 series might be more suitable (3 series seemed to lack headroom and boot space). Will be an M-Sport (prefer the looks) and either be Saloon or Touring, in manual guise.

Please can someone guide me as to what iterations of the 520d are out there? I noticed on the BMW AUC website that the newer ones have higher mpg figures. Given the mileage the car will be covering I'll be suggesting we disregard mileage to a certain extent on purchase and just try and buy as new as possible (budget around 15k).

I understand these cars are on condition based servicing. Please can someone give a rough estimate as to what this might mean in terms of costs for a typical year? I appreciate it will fluctuate but a benchmark figure would be useful. I was thinking a set of 4 tyres a year on average but have no idea how many visits to the dealer will be required.

We'll be looking to keep it under BMW warranty as long as possible so main dealer only for the servicing I suppose.

Any advice appreciated! Things to look out for on the cars, what can be asked for from the dealers on purchase etc.

jackbauer

35 posts

203 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
I owned a 2009 e60 530i. The 5 series had a facelift in 2007 - referred to as LCI.
This will be the better option if you opt for that. Less CO2, more mpg, newer iDrive (plus cosmetic changes such as LED rear lights...which sounds like you might not be too fussed about)

For 15k, you can easily pick up a circa 2008/9 520d with around 50k on the clock and a handsome list of optional extras. I would particularly look out for media package, visibility package (or xenons) and cruise control with active breaking which i think you will find handy in motorway drives to france or wherever.

good choice the 5 series, especially when you factor in the added bonus of thieves being able to nick it from under your nose in 3 minutes smile

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Edited by jackbauer on Tuesday 11th September 23:04

eastsider

1,102 posts

254 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Manual 520d? Will be hard to find and not much fun to drive IMHO. 520d is primarily an economy driven choice, with just about acceptable performance. Its not a rocketship so why stir your own gears? Most buyers don't want to, company drivers doing big mileages wanting easy life. Majority you find for sale will be auto.

If you really want a manual (fair play) then I'd suggest looking at 530d.

cerb4.5lee

45,342 posts

211 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
eastsider said:
Manual 520d? Will be hard to find and not much fun to drive IMHO. 520d is primarily an economy driven choice, with just about acceptable performance. Its not a rocketship so why stir your own gears? Most buyers don't want to, company drivers doing big mileages wanting easy life. Majority you find for sale will be auto.

If you really want a manual (fair play) then I'd suggest looking at 530d.
I agree with this, i have a e61 520d m sport with a manual box & i agree it only just has acceptable performance, i would never buy a 4 pot diesel again, if & when i swap mine it will most likely be a 530d with an auto as that gearbox suits the torque.

They are a great drive with lovely steering & you can just munch miles easily in nice comfort, but the 4 pot diesel ruins the car totally, steer clear of that engine & there is only a little difference in economy compared to the 3.0d engine.

Great car / poor engine the 520d! & i like to call it the 520dull!

Max M4X WW

5,031 posts

213 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
All this 520d bating makes me laugh, my company car is an Octavia with 100bhp. It does 0-60 3 seconds slower than a 520d.

I know which I'd rather have, the Octavia is just about adequate so I'm sure the 520d would fine if you were not expecting massive performance?

cerb4.5lee

45,342 posts

211 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Max M4X WW said:
All this 520d bating makes me laugh, my company car is an Octavia with 100bhp. It does 0-60 3 seconds slower than a 520d.

I know which I'd rather have, the Octavia is just about adequate so I'm sure the 520d would fine if you were not expecting massive performance?
I just drive it for economy now & accept the lack of go, BMW`s performance figures for the 520d are almost as way off the mark as their economy figures, drive a manual 520d & you will see what i mean.

I have drove both a mondeo 2.0 tdci & renault 1.9 dci & the get up & go they have in comparsion is amazing, the 5 series is just too heavy for that engine, trust me i am not making it up. smile

mackay45

Original Poster:

832 posts

202 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Thanks chaps, some good food for thought so far. Good to know the LCI the name for the facelift etc.

The reason for a the 2L and the manual box is that the car will be doing a lot of motorway mileage so whilst I'm sure that I personally would prefer the 3L, my parents care for performance less so than me - I'm working on it but they don't share the Pistonheads mindset just yet!

If this is an unappealing combination to most that is something worth considering though as whilst I don't expect it will be replaced for a while we need to remember that trade in price might take a hit as a result.

As long as the 2L provides 'acceptable' performance when we test drive it I think that will be the one we go for. If it means a few more toys/less mileage as well I think it will be even harder to persuade my parents that the lower mpg of the 3L is worthwhile.

Can anyone give a rough indication of a real world mpg comparison of the 520d vs the 530d? Assuming both LCI.

A boring main concern for a thread I realise but I think performance is probably fourth on the priorities list here after economy, reliability and comfort!

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
I asked a similar question a while back

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Still loving my E61 and I would say that my particular iteration (525d MSport Manual) is the ideal combination of performance and economy. On a steady run from Leeds -> Huddersfield and back recently it did 48mpg - that's a properly hilly route too and I wasn't driving for economy or anything. It also has a useful amount of poke from the 3.0 engine - I would be disappointed with anything less.

It's averaging 40mpg around town btw.

If you will be usng the car on the Mway a lot then I can't see that an auto will use significantly more fuel really. Once an auto is up to speed then it's pretty much on a par with a manual.

As long as nothing goes wrong with it then I can see this being really quite a cheap (relatively) car to run. The condition based servicing tells me I don't really need to touch it for 18months (for an oil change) but I will probably do an interim change in 6-9 months for a bit of peice of mind.

LCI info
http://5series.net/information/2008_LCI_Detailed_C...

As has been mentioned make sure you get the adaptive xenons (they are awesome) and pro nav as a minimum. Anything else is just fluff - very cool useful fluff mind, in fact the dynamic cruise would be very useful.

Edited by dave_s13 on Wednesday 12th September 15:37

halo34

2,890 posts

230 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Nothing wrong with the four pot or BMWs performance figures either.

Whilst most of us would prefer (prefer being the operative word) a straight six and it is frankly more suited to the 5 than the 4 pot - its not a bad unit at all.

Like others I find it amusing that it gets such a bashing when in comparison to other cars I have driven it was absolutely fine. To say its as slow as some are making out is way off the mark IMHO.

I would recommend the LCI as well and 15k is a decent budget to get something with a nice spec.

The only reason I didn't get one over the 320d in the end was finding a manual which I prefer to the auto. I test drove an auto with two big adults in the car with me and other than a rattly start up making you think "oh god" we all found it to be decent enough, I wasn't thinking give me more power!



cerb4.5lee

45,342 posts

211 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
halo34 said:
Nothing wrong with the four pot or BMWs performance figures either.

Whilst most of us would prefer (prefer being the operative word) a straight six and it is frankly more suited to the 5 than the 4 pot - its not a bad unit at all.

Like others I find it amusing that it gets such a bashing when in comparison to other cars I have driven it was absolutely fine. To say its as slow as some are making out is way off the mark IMHO.

I would recommend the LCI as well and 15k is a decent budget to get something with a nice spec.

The only reason I didn't get one over the 320d in the end was finding a manual which I prefer to the auto. I test drove an auto with two big adults in the car with me and other than a rattly start up making you think "oh god" we all found it to be decent enough, I wasn't thinking give me more power!
The 4 pot diesel engine works fine in the 3 series, my brother in law has a e92 320d coupe & when he took me out in it i was impressed with the performance, but its gutless in the 5 series because of the added weight.

halo34

2,890 posts

230 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
The 4 pot diesel engine works fine in the 3 series, my brother in law has a e92 320d coupe & when he took me out in it i was impressed with the performance, but its gutless in the 5 series because of the added weight.
You are entitled to your opinion - I have driven both.

cerb4.5lee

45,342 posts

211 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
halo34 said:
cerb4.5lee said:
The 4 pot diesel engine works fine in the 3 series, my brother in law has a e92 320d coupe & when he took me out in it i was impressed with the performance, but its gutless in the 5 series because of the added weight.
You are entitled to your opinion - I have driven both.
I think i must have a duffer of an engine in mine then, because everytime i slate mine most people say that the performance is acceptable or its my expectations that are too high because of what cars i am used to driving.

I love the car just hate the engine, i even told the BMW dealer that i bought it from that they should be ashamed as a company for putting such a underpowered engine in such a big car, i think the car must work better for a company buyer not a family owner like me! smile

mackay45

Original Poster:

832 posts

202 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Test drive on Saturday so I'll let you know how we get on! 08 plate - 520d manual. smile

cerb4.5lee

45,342 posts

211 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
mackay45 said:
Test drive on Saturday so I'll let you know how we get on! 08 plate - 520d manual. smile
Good luck with your test drive, i think you will love the feel of the car & the steering they really do drive lovely smile

Keep us updated on your thoughts, cheers

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
Good luck with your test drive, i think you will love the feel of the car & the steering they really do drive lovely smile

Keep us updated on your thoughts, cheers
Have you thought about getting yours remapped??

cerb4.5lee

45,342 posts

211 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
dave_s13 said:
cerb4.5lee said:
Good luck with your test drive, i think you will love the feel of the car & the steering they really do drive lovely smile

Keep us updated on your thoughts, cheers
Have you thought about getting yours remapped??
Dave, its a good shout & i have thought about it because i love everything else about the car just sometimes wish it had a little more grunt, i think it could be the way forward for me thanks. smile

mackay45

Original Poster:

832 posts

202 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
mackay45 said:
Test drive on Saturday so I'll let you know how we get on! 08 plate - 520d manual. smile
Good luck with your test drive, i think you will love the feel of the car & the steering they really do drive lovely smile

Keep us updated on your thoughts, cheers
Well the test drive went well! As I think I indicated above, I had only intended for the test drive to be used for the purposes of giving an idea of whether we liked the 520d, as opposed to being a test drive with the idea of an immediate purchase in mind.

To cut a long story short a purchase was made. My parents liked the car so went for it. It is a June 2008 car, 44k miles, 1 owner from new, deep sea blue paint with a cream leather/wood interior (I'm not a massive fan of the interior but it looked better in real life than I was expecting). Seems to have loads of options:

BMW Assist
BMW Assist online portal
CD changer
Enhanced Bluetooth telephone functionality
Headlight wash
Leather interior
Light Poplar wood trim. high-gloss
Metallic paint
Navigation System Business
Through-loading system
Visibility package

Alarm system (Thatcham 1)
M Sport Package
Floor mats. velour
First Aid Kit & Triangle
Rear-view mirror. auto dimming
Smokers package
Park Distance Control (PDC). front and r
Cruise control with brake function

The options bar on the AUC website was full - can anyone confirm if the car is fully loaded or are there options missing?

Collection is Friday - only thing really that they are sorting before then is a badly repaired (bad colour match) stonechip on the bonnet so nothing major.

I know they are taking your money so maybe this should be expected, but I was impressed with the professionalism/courteousness of all of the staff we dealt with during the search (from 3 different BMW dealerships in the past few weeks). They are a better bunch than most of the car traders I have come across before which was a nice surprise!

Will post some photos when it arrives - thanks to everyone that has contributed, much appreciated!

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
mackay45 said:
Well the test drive went well! As I think I indicated above, I had only intended for the test drive to be used for the purposes of giving an idea of whether we liked the 520d, as opposed to being a test drive with the idea of an immediate purchase in mind.

To cut a long story short a purchase was made. My parents liked the car so went for it. It is a June 2008 car, 44k miles, 1 owner from new, deep sea blue paint with a cream leather/wood interior (I'm not a massive fan of the interior but it looked better in real life than I was expecting). Seems to have loads of options:

BMW Assist
BMW Assist online portal
CD changer
Enhanced Bluetooth telephone functionality
Headlight wash
Leather interior
Light Poplar wood trim. high-gloss
Metallic paint
Navigation System Business
Through-loading system
Visibility package

Alarm system (Thatcham 1)
M Sport Package
Floor mats. velour
First Aid Kit & Triangle
Rear-view mirror. auto dimming
Smokers package
Park Distance Control (PDC). front and r
Cruise control with brake function

The options bar on the AUC website was full - can anyone confirm if the car is fully loaded or are there options missing?

Collection is Friday - only thing really that they are sorting before then is a badly repaired (bad colour match) stonechip on the bonnet so nothing major.

I know they are taking your money so maybe this should be expected, but I was impressed with the professionalism/courteousness of all of the staff we dealt with during the search (from 3 different BMW dealerships in the past few weeks). They are a better bunch than most of the car traders I have come across before which was a nice surprise!

Will post some photos when it arrives - thanks to everyone that has contributed, much appreciated!
- Pro Nav
- Adaptive Xenons
- Upgraded Hi-fi
- Adaptive radar cruise
- Fancy suspension
- USB/Ipod connectivity
- DAB radio
- HUD
- Soft close doors
- Auto close boot
- Comfort seats
- Auto fold mirrors
- Exterior puddle lights

They are the ones I can remember off the top of my head. If you look through the instruction manual there's load of functions with the dreaded asterix next to them*

  • i.e. you haven't got it!!

mackay45

Original Poster:

832 posts

202 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
Cool cheers mate - coming from Fords I'm sure it will still have more options than we know what to do with!

mackay45

Original Poster:

832 posts

202 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
A quick snap on purchase:



A quick snap en route to the Sunday Service - was going past the dealership anyway so stopped to show my brother what we had bought, and got a quick picture while parked up (can just about see the 5 series in the background!):